Nice list also you should check out P5. It's pretty good.
ITT: You can only play as characters whose game you've beaten
Juan Foster
Oliver Rodriguez
bumpf
Alexander Roberts
Just go back or kys on the way out either one is fine
Hunter White
worked
Jayden Robinson
What about characters that don’t have their own game like daisy and piranha plant?
Dylan Bell
My mains are up there so it's all good.
Aaron Kelly
Hunter Turner
>never played a single Metroid game
>never finished a link to the past and a link between worlds
>never finished a toon link game, but I got to the final boss in spirit tracks
>awakening is the only FE game I’ve beaten
>you can’t finish animal crossing unless you’re a liar or a time traveler
Jaxon Thomas
You really haven't finished a single Mario game?
Jeremiah Perry
Dark Samus - I never finished Prime 2 or 3
Ness - I never played Earthbound
Captain Falcon - F-Zero is fucking hard, never beat any of them but played everything besides GBA
Ice Climbers - Is there even an end to this game? I rarely make it to level 3 anyway
Sheik - I'm gonna get crucified but N64 Zelda is fucking slow and boring if you didn't grow up with it and I was too busy playing Mario 64 to notice this.
Dr. Mario - I love Dr. Mario 64 but I can't beat it for the life of me. I suck.
All Fire Emblem - I played Shadow Dragon DS a fair way through, I played a touch of Awakening and the Wii game and got fucking bored.
Kid Icarus - First one made me mad, new one hurt my hands.
Lucas - Never touched Mother 3
Villager/Isabelle - I paid off the biggest house in New Leaf, I guess that's a win?
Little Mac - Punch Out is too hardcore for me, never managed to knock out Tyson
Shulk - Xenoblade is on my list, I'll get to it someday I'm sure
Cloud - FF7 is not for me, takes forever to get going, too much random battles wasting my time. Just no.
Joker - No PS4
Hero - Not a big RPG guy but 11 looks neat, maybe some day.
Miis - They count as smash characters, I beat Smash 4's challenge board, I'm counting it.
G&W/Wii Fit - Not sure how you "win" these but I played them before so they get yellow.