Strawpoll Time: What's the most overrated game of all time?

What praise BotW doesn't get in the story department TLoU does, and viceversa on the gameplay part. The difference being if you ignore retards online BotW is a good enough game while TLoU is mediocre at best yet people hailed it and Infinite as examples of videogames as art back in 2013, which couldn't be further from what makes games different from movies ie gameplay, not fucking "muh emotional" cutscenes. Far, FAR more people jumped on Druckmann's dick

It has a 97 & Journalists constantly circlejerk it as the best Rockstar game now

It's honestly bizarre just how much TLOU got overrated. I'm convinced at this point it was only because it was a PS3 exclusive. It was a generic as fuck third person shooter with a generic as fuck zombie story and setting. It just reeks of a hackjob story from a Hollywood reject that went to games since no one wanted to make a movie of his shit script.

Agreed, Witcher 3 is a good example. Critics originally rated it appropriately with it's 91 Metascore, but then later once Reddit & E-Celebs started circlejerking it they had no choice to overrate it for the sake of pandering to the hivemind.

> TLOU that low
> OOT receiving any votes
> Halo has no votes
Zoomers are pathetic

Bump

B-u-m-p

Bump

Bu-mp

Bump, Halo is 2nd now

Voted for Halo 2, the most overrated series I've ever played, and the most overrated installment.

OoT is the only correct answer

Voted for FF7. The amount of people who said that shit was amazing blew my mind.

Okami

Ocarina of Time and Chrono Trigger, two mediocre grames always hailed as the best of all time.

Nice job outing yourself zoomers

>no TW3
lmao

Witcher 3 is appropriately rated.

Formerly it was TLOU but Rockstar beat Naughty Dog at being pretentious pile of garbage with an exaggerated sense of their own self worth with RDR2.

RDR2 is the complete opposite of pretentious.

the fact that people consider Ocarina to still be the BEST game of all time despite 2 decades worth of games being released since it came out makes it overrated. great in its time and a classic to be sure but better games have come out since

It's underrated.

All of this is wrong, also Skyrim is literally garbage so by default it’s the most overrated. You don’t know what Overrated even means

BotW easily. it's more of a game than RDR2 but has a way more rabid fanbase

Wow the thread having RDR as the image doesn't sway anyone at all, you're a fucking retard OP. I voted for shit of the wild.

Rockstarfags are some of the most obnoxious faggots on the planet. If you don't pretend every game they shit out is masterpiece they call you mad and claim you didn't play it or are a "zoomer" who has a short attention span.

Skyrim is kino.

Attached: YYZ Drum Solo.webm (1122x648, 572K)

>a 20 year old game that aged like milk is still widely considered to be the GOAT
>i-its underrated
>brings up Skyrim out of nowhere
rent free

I know, I've experienced it first hand after giving the game some rough criticism. But I experienced WAY worse when I did the same to BotW.

It's pretty blatantly obvious who the seething pcfags and nintendies are who couldn't play the absolute masterpiece that was RDR2, it felt like a futuristic game. BOTW feels like it should have been on PS2 15 years ago

Where is fallout new vegas?

>it's more of a game than RDR2
Wrong.

>are a "zoomer" who has a short attention span.
But this is 100% true.

Attached: RDR2 gunplay.webm (1280x720, 2.62M)

RDR2 is fucking dogshit. Even more so then GTA5 at launch.

It actually only shows how biased and nostalgia driven all nintendo drones are. OOT is complete dogshit, not even playable if you take the rose glasses off. And no it's not considered the greatest game of all time.

>rdr2 first
it's time for another chill run.

Attached: 2.jpg (650x366, 56K)

> It aged bad
> Never explains why it’s bad aside from vague criticism & buzzwords that wouldn’t tell anyone who didn’t play it why it’s a poorly designed game
Every time

New Vegas is underrated.

Cope nintendie

> PC drones turn it into a console war thread because of how much OOT makes them seethe
That’s how you know it’s a masterpiece

This looks awful. The ai is fucking retarded just running in again and again and instantly dying.

>Wrong
I disagree. Good game, but not a masterpiece

Tendies on suicide watch.

>Literally just described BOTW
Check and mate autist

Attached: 1234567.jpg (680x622, 72K)

>but not a masterpiece
That's where you're wrong.

Attached: RDR2 gunplay 3.webm (1280x720, 2.85M)

Is this the part where we spam cope cringe seethe based redpilled have sex and incel over and over again ad nasum?
Fucking hate reruns.

Nice mental gymnastics, it's not even a good game, if it wasn't called Zelda it would have gotten 6/10s across the board and nobody would have talked about it, its so overrated simply because its zelda and fanboys like you are pure cancer who will eat dog shit and say its caviar

>your subjective opinion is wrong
That's not how it works. Let me guess, you're a falseflagger?

>get shot 700 times
>lose .0005% of your health
>shoot enemy in the leg
>they die instantly

Why is it rated M when it's so easy toddlers could play it?

Attached: 1555775356546.png (1080x823, 380K)

You actually need to cope bud, it's all right

Attached: kek.png (500x376, 247K)

>opinions are subjective

Attached: 1372357.png (484x465, 125K)

OoT is underrated, whether you like it or not.

i don't even think its bad just that its aged poorly which is objectively true considering there have been 2 decades of technological improvements since its release. you can say the same of a lot of games including ones much newer than OoT and will happen to most games as technology progresses

Hahahaha get fucked OP stuipid fag, tried to rig the thread with OP image but SHITTER of the wild still number one by miles

Opinions are subjective, no amount of spamming buzzwords will change the fact that only 1% of the internet shares your opinion

yeah

>most overrated game of all time is underrated
Okay, nitnendo drones are like the zoomers they make fun of
>MY FIRST CONSOLE EXPERIENCE WAS BEST OKAY AND IT STILL IS TODAY!!!!!

Attached: (you).png (644x800, 15K)

>Opinions are subjective and unquantifiable
>BUT HURRRRRRR I KNOW THAT 99% OF THE PLANET AGREES WITH ME BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT OTHER NINTENDO DRONES SAY HAHA!

Attached: 6789.png (494x468, 282K)

>using a skyrim VR webm
fucking retarded

I only used RDR2 for clickbait purposes, if i used another game then nobody would actually post in this thread
> Wojak poster
Opinion invalidated

how fucking mentally stunted do you have to be to get upset over anonymous video games opinions online? what makes a seemingly HUMAN being fight for free on behalf of corporations?

>dark souls not on the list
Why am I not surprised

> Still spamming console war buzzwords as if that will somehow make him right or change anyone’s opinion

>Im hiding from your statement because i am triggered by wojak images
you know where to go back to

>Still doing absolutely nothing but sucking long and hard on nintendo cock to the point of deluding yourself that a clunky piece of shit game from 20 years ago is still good

Attached: chinese.jpg (500x750, 143K)

>Dark Souls
>Overrated
Have a (You).

Attached: Arrival at Anor Londo.webm (640x360, 2.85M)

> Hiding somehow because of a couple comments from internet neckbeard contrarians when this the same board that named OoT the GOAT a few months ago
LOL

not him, but every big classic should be on the list. it's automatically a contender due to critical acclaim and popularity

Where's Undertale?

Double negative, he's saying he knows that DS deserved all the praise it got. He's not surprised that it's not on the list, he doesn't think it should be on there. Unless he's a retard and doesn't understand double negatives.

>BUT A SMALL PORTION OF NINTENDOGAF VOTED WITH NO WAY OF KNOWING HOW MANY VOTES WERE MANIPULATED
Confirmed absolutely autistic.

Attached: 121e43.png (396x526, 341K)

dumbass OP should've made a thread where we all put things on the list first

I could completely see a seething incel nitnendo fan rigging the poll in a rage because his preconeved notion that everyone agreed with him that oot was the best game was shattered. OOT is a fucking meme game.

> Implying RNG can be rigged

Popularity has nothing to do with how a game is rated.

So true it hurts.

>OOT is the best game of all time because I was 6 at the time and hadn't played any of the far superior PC RPGs and Adventure games available at the time.
OOT is the original Fortnite just so all the zoomers know what's happening here.

Attached: zoom.gif (478x350, 84K)

I strongly disagree, popularity can create bias

Final fantasy vii is the best game ever made and the best game it is possible to make.

Why do you think polls can't be rigged it happens every fucking thread they are posted in, it's so easy

>game

Attached: FinalMovieVII.png (418x596, 248K)

That is the most hilarious thing I've ever heard a nitnendo defender say, nitnendo games ONLY get good ratings because of popularity bias. Nitnendo has meme status with pop culture because it was an early console industry player.

>Bringing up Nintendo out of nowhere
Absolutely obsessed.

jesus fucking christ you're a retarded faggot

>LOOOOOK GUYS HAHAHAHAHAHA! I POSTED IT AGAIN!!!!

Attached: you.jpg (852x480, 35K)

Skyrim didn't age bad, it was always shit.

>seething asspained replies but
>oh no no we're not nitnendo cock suckers
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA dumb faggots

Attached: 21345.jpg (1200x900, 307K)

Theres been a recent resurgence of hate towards it for some reason. Some people "blame" it for causing shooters to start focusing more on linear level design and setpieces. On the /vr/ Doom thread there are a handful of complete autists who constantly spam how Half Life is an overrated piece of shit and that games like Goldeneye and System Shock were better.

Skyrim is one of the best games ever made.

Attached: Skyrim Finisher.webm (1024x576, 2.09M)

Sure thing Todd, don't let anyone tell you otherwise

look at the fucking post you replied to, it has nothing to do with nintendo. we were talking about dark souls and you embarrassed yourself, why do you act like this?

Cope more
> Over 150,000 votes with at least 200 games
> People were complaining that it was too difficult to vote for the games they liked & how they had to filter through other people's shit games
> Each game recieved at least 1,000 votes
> Completely RNG, you cannot simply select or downvote games you want like Strawpoll
> Two games are randomly selected & you have to pick which one you like the most, if you're lucky you might get the same three times in a row
> One thread had to stay up for 14 hours simply to get 50,000 votes
> The games with the highest percentage of Yes votes to No votes are rated the highest, not whichever was voted on the most
Literally impossible to rig, but sure continue coping to suit your own personal conspiracies & contrarianism

I loved goldeneye as a kid but it aged like milk being stored in direct sunlight

Wow the meme game everyone has heard of won because there was so many games in there they just gave up looking, what a surprise

Classic
>The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
>Super Mario Bros 3
>Super Metroid
>Metroid Prime
>Tetris
>Super Mario Galaxy 2
>Final Fantasy VI
>Super Mario Odyssey
>Resident Evil 4
>Portal
>Chrono Trigger
>Half-Life 2
>The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
>Half-Life
>Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
>The Last of Us
>Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

Just Okay
>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
>Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
>The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
>Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
>Bioshock
>Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
>Halo 2
>Portal 2
>Super Mario Bros
>Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Overrated Garbage
>SoulCalibur
>Grand Theft Auto IV
>Super Mario 64
>Grand Theft Auto V
>Red Dead Redemption 2
>Final Fantasy VII
>Tekken 3
>Metal Gear Solid
>Halo: Combat Evolved
>Grand Theft Auto III
>Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
>The Legend of Zelda: A Link To The Past
>GoldenEye 007
>Perfect Dark
>The Legend of Zelda:
>Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
>Red Dead Redemption
>The World Ends With You
>Street Fighter 2

Attached: 1448385486052.gif (450x253, 1.75M)

Yup, I'm thinking this post is based.

>classic game section is 99% overrated as fuck clunky poorly dated nintendo nostalgia literally unplayable trash
This is how you know you are biased, your opinion is trash and and completely based on nostalgia alone, you shouldn't try and influence others

>No hollow knight
what kind of fucking list is this?!

>ALL THE BEST GAMES ARE OVERRATED AND ALL THE OVERRATED GAMES ARE CLASSICS AND I POSTED AN IMAGE OF A KEKOLD NOW GIVE ME REPLIES!!!!!!!

Attached: 548.png (455x467, 624K)

Obsessed.

Hollow Knight is underrated, brainlet.

Attached: Radiance 2.webm (640x360, 2.63M)

> Nostalgia, Nintendo Drones, Wojaks, Zoomer, Boomer, Trash Opinion
If you use any of these you are a massive faggot, who simply cries about popular games & dismiss anyone with an opposing opinion for confirmation bias

>melee oriented game with contact damage
I enjoyed it but some design decisions were lazy

NieR: Automata was first place at one time, not a fucking argument. But sure continue seething & relying on buzzwords and wojaks.

>It just reeks of a hackjob story from a Hollywood reject that went to games since no one wanted to make a movie of his shit script.
This is the most true thing I have read about TLOU. Naughty Dog in general feels like this anyway but TLOU really takes the cake since it was at the tail end of the zombie craze. The story is the only noteworthy thing about it since everything else is just generic zombie survival shit and the story isn't even that good. It just gets jerked off by people because it makes them feel like that really old meme
>I only play mature games for mature gamers such as myself
except unironically.

Fucking this. That game is only good when compared to other games in that franchise.

It's not even the best Fallout, though.

>TLoU and CoD 4 as classics
>Portal 2 below Portal 1
>Uncharted game not being garbage
>Halo CE below 2
>Super Mario 64 below Galaxy and Odyssey
>Chaos Theory as just okay
>GTA III as garbage
>Vice City as garbage
>Red Dead 1 as garbage
6/10 made me reply

Attached: Mild_Disgust.jpg (282x353, 16K)

Yes it is, Fallout 2 fans are brainlets who refuse to acknowledge that the game being 2d and clunky makes it dogshit. Nobody cares to slog through 100 of pure dogshit gameplay for some poorly voice acted dialogue that would never be considered good in real literature just because you liked the characters
Also yes you did get more choice, because the game was shit and such little effort needed to go into crafting variable scenarios. New Vegas is the best fallout GAME, if you want F02 level of character choices in 2019 then just stick to tabletop roleplaying