Is there any game that shows communism working?

Is there any game that shows communism working?

Attached: communism_worker_flag_mini.jpg (1920x1358, 252K)

games aren't allowed to be unrealistic anymore

Don’t starve
Fallout3

probably closest thing would be something like a heavily restricted minecraft rp server

rust

tropico

That's a strasserist you illiterate leftist tard.

red alert

Ironically most/all cooperative multiplayer games.

Communism describes a state whereby man has been educated on the objectively rational way to behave and behaves in that way, so the state withers away as people no longer need to be coerced into behaving certain ways because, as inherently rational creatures, they do the rational thing.

Cooperative multiplayer servers self-select for people who have the same objectives and the rules of the game impose a form of abstract rationality that requires them to behave in certain ways. So long as everyone is getting along and working together, you could be said to be witnessing communism.

>but what about when the admin needs to ban someone
That's where it breaks down.

Marx's idea that there is an objectively best way to live and that everyone will agree to live like that seems retarded to us now, but you've gotta remember that he was writing in the 1800s in the middle of the Enlightenment. He was far from alone in believing that rationality would solve all problems. Even today, pluralism isn't popular.

oh he based

based and redpilled

Papers, Please.

well TF2 had it's day of communism and traders are still mad about it

that's well and good until you realise people aren't ants

So a communist is a libertarian. Of course, perfect observation, makes absolute sense.

now this is a quality shitpost

How is it communism if you had to pay for the keys?

Attached: 1564437709168.gif (220x152, 31K)

star trek games

Libertarians unceremoniously "liberated" a lot of ideas from the left.

Probably not.

In order for it to be communism, the game would need
>To be free
>Have no micro transactions
>Have to reward all players evenly
>Reward all players evenly regardless of how much they help, how skilled the are, or even how much they play

>No state
>Communism
Then who will make sure everyone is evenly provided?

>making profit off of hats and trash that doesn't matter
TF2 was classic american libertarianism

games are the only place communism does work

>He was far from alone in believing that rationality would solve all problems
But you'd have to be really naive to believe that everyone is going to act rationally all the time.

>communism
>rent

It would have to remove the ranking system as well because it's a symbol of hierarchy.

In Marxism (and possibly before Marx?) communism is a government-less end state of human development.

>Then who will make sure everyone is evenly provided?
The people that have a unanimous ideology based on egalitarianism

The only difference between a libertarian and a communist is that the former continues the thought process, while the latter stops right before explaining the dirty stuff.

Both of them don't have the slightest clue about economics, too.

>Then who will make sure everyone is evenly provided?
Commune leaders I assume.

>Then who will make sure everyone is evenly provided?
That's not part of communism.

You're benefiting from 150 years of cumulative modernist critique of the Enlightenment when you say that, user.

Besides, "everyone believed that rationality would solve all problems" is a caricature of the Enlightenment anyway. The point was only that Marx wasn't unique in this 'naive' belief, so don't start piling shit on him for it any more than you would pile shit on the Enlightenment in general.

You can easy say that communism was working great in that game just like in real life.

What's stopping an alpha from trying to get the 1up over somebody else if theres no order to make sure everyone stays equal?

>No state
>Communism
>Then who will make sure everyone is evenly provided?
Woah woah woah buddy, that's socialism. Us communists don't believe in logistics and absolute reality.

stick to vidia retard

His own rationality that sees that behaving in that way would not be consistent with the objective rationality of the communist system.

pretty much any RTS or god game where you as the player have complete and total control over your population

Stick to your fantasy books. What the fuck are you even implying?

>Communism
>Rational

like alot of commuists youre too innocent for your own good

racing games. You get handouts like everyone else for doing fucking nothing and just like real communism conditioned workers to do shit job, anyone playing non sim racing games is a shit driver.

by having 5 keys I got from trading years ago when they were around 10 refs, never used them to open some of the crates I had lying around till the bug happend. The unusuals were meh but I managed to make enough cash to pre-order Doom Eternal

If you disagree with the fundamental assumptions of the theory then I'd suggest you critique them directly instead of asking questions that you should already know the answer to.

Red planet

This is objectively correct, especially of orthodox Marxism. The State would supposedly dissapear, as workers would be able to work out for themselves of how to properly distribute labour, goods and services.

The big thing is that attempts to create the ideal Communism envisioned by Marx, has never been totally achieved-- Communists blame the fact that the global capitalist economy was never dismantled, and non-Communists will typically blame Marxist theory and thought as inherently wrong, and/or evil.

Victoria 2, potentially.

>Commune leaders
that's a form of hierarchy

>communists
>innocent
he was just explaining the ideology, retard

>be American
>get shot

Only if you think the left included classical liberalism.

>tfw no genocidal communism sim

Attached: community_image_1425843041.png (288x288, 125K)

Civilization IV and up. Not sure about III and before, but Communism is an amazing government regime all around. Apart from that you have Stellaris with insect aliens and I think fungus too.

Attached: 1509852209204.png (2400x1350, 513K)

itll never work because humans are naturally competitive the ideology expects everyone to be beta

worker and resources : soviet republic

extremely realistic. Game is coded like it was paid by Gorbatchev and runs like a ukrainian nuclear power plant. 10/10 realism

Why don't communists just set up their own communistic societies within capitalist ones? If the system works so well, surely it would out compete?

CAPITALISM
>*Is allowed to be a useless NEET with autismbux in liberal society powered by capitalism*
IS
>*consumes porn, media produced and socially accepted in liberal society powered by capitalism*
A
>*does drugs, an activity that is mostly socially accepted and even there are lobbies fighting for its legalization, all in a liberal society powered by capitalism*
SHITTY
>*is allowed to sleep around, thanks to the erosion of conservative values caused by the sexual revolution, fueled by capitalism*รง
SYSTEM
>*is a faggot/tranny or part of some alternate communities such as furries, whose lifestyles are mostly accepted thanks to the acceptance of the LGBT, whose liberal values are pushed by capitalism, not to mention that some capitalists are LGBT themselves*


>F-FUCKING PORKY BOOTLICKER!!!!

Sorry to break it to you, user, but your entire being is a product of a capitalist society. In the case that another soviet/nazi regime rises up, you'll be first to go the gulags or end in the gas chambers.

Now, go play video games, watch the latest Marvel movie or browse your social media, all in the comfy bubble created by the system you despise yet allows you to live, my dear son of the corporations!

Attached: a88.jpg (500x514, 145K)

it's called Tropico, retard

But he directly disagreed with the communist rationale of "a multitude of people will act in a certain way so that any kind of law enforcement won't be necessary".

But you knew that and tried the usual subversion tactic of diluting the topic being discussed. Literal rat ideology

Dwarf Fortress

Communists have been explaining the "dirty stuff" ever since they started becoming political active, even during Marx's own lifetime.
All of those manuals on revolution, ever single piece of literature put out by any planned economies all consist of just part of the over body of the communist thought process. It's pretty unfair to handwave all of that away, especially when the core of Libertarian literature quite literally consists of fantasy books like Atlas Shrugged

I think the idea is culture and thought is supposed to have drifted by that point. It would be like a peasant in the middle ages saying "Hey, why don't we just get rid of the king?" Nobody would listen or tolerate it.

>it works
>family starves to death or get sick of no heat

Why are you telling me why communism is bad? You don't have to follow an ideology to talk about it, user. I am not a communist.

not even close you rude crude bag of pre-chewed food dude

>lol back then nobody knew that bad people existed
There's a difference between thinking people should be rational and thinking that everyone is rational.

>But he directly disagreed with the communist rationale of "a multitude of people will act in a certain way so that any kind of law enforcement won't be necessary".
Yes, but that rationale logically follows from the assumption that people are inherently rational and from the contention that the communist theory is the objectively rational way to live.

If you accept those two facts then the conclusion becomes inevitable. So why did he disagree with the conclusion as if it stood alone? The answer is because he, like you, is a brainlet.

right down to the leaders going crazy from not getting what they want and executing a bunch of people for attempting to sell socks

>capitalist society made your entire being
Workers and people made and provided all of those goods and services, you fucking smoothbrain. They existed before capitalism, and will continue to exist after capitalism

Attached: DP-28 Apron.png (1417x2244, 1006K)

Nope. The dirty things they discuss relate to CREATING the way for communism. For them, once a society becomes communist, there will be no discussion of rights and wrongs, and the enforcement of those scenarios, because utopia.

I'm no cummunism expert but the USSR didn't have rent for sure. I think.

>thinking that everyone is rational.
Like I said, it's a caricature of Enlightenment belief. People need to be educated on how to be rational first.

Every WW2 game.

cool, im not one either, just having a convo

He said communism is irrational exactly because the communist rationale we are discussing, which I also mentioned, is irrational.

You can't even bullshit your way out of this very direct discussion. So much for commie rethoric.

Frostpunk

they already do

Attached: 302298857_08794745e1_o.jpg (1600x1065, 387K)

interesting take but it would take years to eliminate the culture