In a mexican standoff

you have to be absolutely braindead to think Revolver was better
the game was short as fuck, the controls are sluggish even for the time
the only good thing about it where the story and Bullet time (and that has been improved in Redemption dont even @ me)

Red

Considering John got shot to shit and lived for a few seconds and Arthur got taken out by a bad cough I'd say John.
The fag at the top would probably fall into a ravine on his way there.

need i remind you assholes that Arthur outpaced a fucking Lion lunging at him?

Attached: Dt4oS_8X4AEuk7A.jpg (1200x670, 174K)

Ocelot would get shot in the middle of his monologue

yeah after arthur had been dead a long ass time

OLD

Considering how shit the controls are in RDR2, both Red and John are better shots. Arthur can't even shoot straight without dead eye.

John had the most op dead eye out of the three

and the OP pic has 1911 John when he was about Arthurs age

Arthur endured a lot of shit during most of the game. Remember when the O'Driscoll captured him or Guarma, or his final stand.

Lions are big targets.

ahem...

Attached: colton-white.jpg (210x240, 20K)

Probably the best side mission in the game.

Red Harlow was without a doubt the fastest gun in all of the red deads.

Attached: EC284D0C-671B-4710-AA9A-B8C1C2563F1B.jpg (785x644, 51K)

>fabricates a story of coming out on top against all 3 of them at once
Heh.

Attached: gns.jpg (220x281, 26K)

Colton is too OP. He is western Punisher.

Red is literally a legend

A Mexican.

It's Red. Unlike the other two he's a mythic figure in the universe.

and fast as fuck reaction wise

This game was fucking great and I can't believe we haven't gotten anything since.

Attached: Vincent.png (800x689, 408K)

this game was too good to be true
i didnt expect this quality after The Cartel
youtube.com/watch?v=YyQrcpNIIdU

Arthur was literally suffocating in his final moments and he still beat the ever loving shit out of Micah. Arthur Morgan is an undisputed fucking badass. Even more than John.

the one with the least input lag

Red actually exists in the RDR universe
hes mentioned several times by travellers and so are Revolver locations

it was surely a pleasant surprise
I thought it was just going to be a weird mexican call of duty game (a common mistake that you probably hear many times regarding this series) but it was a pleasant and sweet game

*throws a vial of acid at you*

Attached: erron black.jpg (1920x1080, 272K)

Both characters are cucks and refuse to nail whores. Some "outlaws" they are lmao

Arthur is pretty old, I don't think his reflexes are as good as the other 2

>Portrayed as a badass assassin that gets shit done.
>Jobs the entire series.
Truly the worst of all cowboys.

>his name is king

Attached: 1541257351093.jpg (298x439, 89K)

Arthur's supposed to be the best gunman in the gang. Also, when you play as John in the epilogue the shooting turns to ass compared to when you played as Arthur.

>arthur dies
>lose all your weapons
>john's aim is shaky as fuck
wew lad, better start up NG+ immediately.

damn that powerstance

>Arthur dies
>lose Buell
FUCK YOOOOOUUUUU GIVE HIM BACK

Attached: db4.jpg (495x362, 17K)

>post game is practically entirely new RDR game
wew

That's because Rockstar tried to be cute instead of letting us keep our horses and play as one character
Bad game design.

It'd time to close The Book of Van Der Linne gang and open up a new tale with a new Red Dead title. I want my peak 1870's Spaghetti Wild West goddamnit.

i still want a game set in Landon Rickets younger years

we all know the answer

Attached: Rdr_ricketts_in_chuparosa.jpg (1280x720, 168K)

>micah
Micah missed a ton of shots with John standing right in front of him in American Venom
Arthur=John>Dutch>Micah>the rest

Hey, at least he killed many jobbers like Kobra and Hsu Hao

(ocelot) revolver ocelot would all three of them niggas

Red Harlow

My name's Red, and all I see is Yellah!

John would never shoot Arthur.

They both developed oneitis, and if Arthur hadn't been dying, he would probably have been fucking Mary all day.

Attached: 🔫🐆.png (518x483, 170K)

I think the appeal of Revolver is that you can just pop it in and play it through for one afternoon.

You can't just do that in Redemption 1 since it's 25 hours of main story and sure as hell don't in 2 since it's 70 hours just for the main missions.

Arthur is the best shot of all three, even after John has been trained by Landon Ricketts Arthur would still win.
He wouldn't shoot John though, he'd dive in front of Red's bullet to protect John if he had to.

Attached: MovieBlobThumbsUp.png (310x470, 137K)

>tfw you can't take lions pelt to make a coat with a lion mane collar

Attached: Arthur_Leave_Conversation.jpg (285x337, 29K)

Nice attempt at damage control but you see Mary before getting sick. Rockstar made Arthur a cuck. Accept it.

Wasn't a new game teased around RDR2's release?

me

>Lose all your weapons
That doesn't happen user

Attached: 1534854274717.jpg (1280x720, 152K)

Red could actually shoot at superhuman speeds, but most of Yea Forums didn't even play his game, so of course they will vote on John.

Get fucked, Revolver has better atmosphere, more fun gameplay, and better music. yeah I fucking said it

>yeah I fucking said it
Wow watch out for this guy. First time an unpopular opinion has ever been posted on this board

Based.

Attached: gun.jpg (500x280, 58K)

Based

Pretty sure you have to buy everything aside from the standard revolver back, famalam.

Attached: .jpg (696x1040, 144K)

*blocks your path*

Attached: _-Samurai-Western-PS2-_.jpg (533x800, 51K)

You only get into a Mexican standoff if you are hesitant to shoot. Confirmed onions trio.

Fucking CIA stole his powerstance

Attached: Trigun.png (704x528, 444K)

me

>Hello yes i'd like to sell this rare Elite Arabian only ever found in the wild, what's your price
48 dollars sir
>Excuse me but this horse has literally the best stats in the game not to mention-
48 dollars sir
>But sir you must understand this horse is the only one of it's kind across four different states-
48 dollars sir
>But sir-
forty
eight
dollars
sir

Arthur needs to remember to cock his single action pistols.

this, but the truth hurts so get that dumb jap shit out of this thread,

I just beat the first call of juarez not too long ago and absolutely loved it, especially reverend rey he really sold the game for me. I'm glad I got all the other games on the sale

Attached: steamuserimages-a.akamaihd.net.jpg (1024x819, 147K)

it's clearly zan

JOHNNY NOOOOOOO MORE

Attached: JOHNNY NOOOO MORE.jpg (800x975, 112K)

red killed injuns and superhumans
the other 2 didn't
I vote for red

Mcree to be desu.

I remember Bound in Blood being pretty fun

Retard and pleb

how many of you fucking zoomers even know who the top character is

>old means it isn't known

Red fucking Harlow.
anyone who says otherwise is a zoomer who didnt play Revolver on the ps2.

Attached: 220px-Red_Dead_Revolver_Coverart.jpg (220x271, 25K)

You really don't, you keep all the guns Arthur had.

yes, generally

When the fuck has there ever been a hand to hand Mexican stand-off you fucking dingaling

you inherit all of Arthur's guns and you get John's cattleman on top of it

>there are no Mexican standoffs in red dead redemption 2/online
>there's battle royale instead
How can a game be so out of touch

I mean the tradeoff there is that he's one of the most OP characters online so you take what you can get

me

For me, RDR1 > RDRevolver > RDR2.
That said, Red would take down Arthur and John both before they'd cleared leather.

Attached: 1373068574401.jpg (480x535, 104K)

FUCKING

based

It's okay because red is half injun himself

John killed a shit load of Indians at the end of RDR1 though

Redemption 1 has no twin revolvers, therefore it sucks.

Jerry miculek cosplaying as mario.

>tfw have Dead Eye Level 1
>it's fucking great
>get Level 2 and 3
>it's fucking shit
Why?

>the controls are sluggish even for the time
Imagine saying this and acting like RDR2 is any better. It’s like you guys just ignore that RDR2 has some of the most sluggish controls of any game made in years.

If anything it tries too hard to stay relevant with the kids to its own detriment.

That's okay, though, because it was intentional.