This is literally the greatest game ever made.
Decades of countless attempts in the industry to be taken seriously have lead to this.
The peak, the sky, the limit.
The ultimate proof that video games can be considered art.
Where do even go from here?
Post your top 10 best games & rate other peoples list's
The entire red dead online community would hack you to pieces for praising an unfinished game.
RDO is nothing like RDR2
witcher was better
and witcher wasn't the greatest either
want to find out the greatest game ever?
5 you's
Why is this game art?
Nightmare mode: Only bring up things that are unique to video games.
>The masks/bandanas are useless
>Robbing/stealing isn't lucrative, even robbing trains are barely worth your guaranteed bounty because of said masks not working
>no high stakes gambling
>huge but massively empty world that would be suited to a comfy survival way of playing in post game, hunting for food is too easy and there's no other dangers so it's boring
>story gets thrown into the trash in chapter 4
>challenges are tedious and in a nonsensical order, with random difficulty placements rather than gradual increase
could've been better
It is poor form to release a good single player experience and capitulate with the absolute worst online mode possible.
The online was supposed to be an immersive, interactive freeroam journey that would keep the game alive for at least a decade.
Not content empty, griefer's paradise and fortnite PvP while everyone anxiously waits for the next big disappointing update.
Definitely proof that videogames have surpassed film.
Would be great if they added a mode where you actually have to eat, sleep and increase your stats to survive. There are many systems in the game but they don't add meaningful depth.
>campsite doesn't set up wherever you want it to
>camp is the most useless safehouse system I have ever seen, and it doesn't even add up to anything at the end when you lose it
>so many locked doors despite not so many buildings
>broken interact prompt won't allow me to buy newspapers
>NPCs get shit scared or overly aggressive for no reason
>stealth kill a lawman, the entire lawforce automatically knows
>walk in the general direction of a lawman and become wanted
>change clothes, get haircut, wear mask, still get recognised
>honour system is the most retarded addition to the game, I can murder an entire town and become honourable just by feeding my horse.
>autoaim
>after a certain mission I get minted and lose the need to actually explore and play the game in order to buy things
>"mission failed" every time I stray off the designated railed fetch missions
Could have been much much better, frankly it's highly overrated.
>The masks/bandanas are useless
They let do whatever the fuck you want and never get a bounty as long as lawmen don't see you doing it. It's not supposed to be god mode.
>NPCs get shit scared or overly aggressive for no reason
Happens to my gf all the time when she plays. Just don't act like a sperg in-game and you can avoid this.
1. Heroes of Might and Magic III
2. The Elder Scrolls 3 Morrowind
3. The Elder Scrolls 4 Oblivion
4. Fallout 1/2
5. Pajama Sam games
6. Aracnum of steamworks and magic obscura
7. Minecraft (unironically)
8. Undertale (probably a shit game, but I have a personal connection to it)
9. GTA San Andreas/Vice City
10. -
I didn't think i was going to like this game at first but it ended up being one of my favourite games this gen.
"the peak" lel such low standards.
And yet it was utter garbage, one of the worst games I've ever played.
>Story is a scripted shit
>Camp life is shit
>Missions are boring
>Little to no freedom in open world
>No good story outside the main quest
>Autoaim
>Snakebite, horse died, are the only "random" events
The only good part of this game for me is riding your horse across huge a beatifull world. But fucking game woun't let me buy cool rifle, cuz i need to get fuckin AIDs to get to the plot point where i will be able to buy this gun. This game is mediocre at best, Rocstar needs to let players get creative, insted of cinematic story.
Not on PC or Nintendo so it's bad, and you can't acknowledge how good it is.
Why videogame very good and not very not good?
based ResetEra
Lmao at all these people that haven't played the game
how the fuck do you do a story without scripting? Are you retarded?
Witcher 3 main game is worse than RDR 2.
Witcher 3 expansions are better, yeah.
No I think that's you
It's not on PC so really it might as well not exist
I implaying that there is no freedom in story.
>third person open world cover shooter
>greatest game ever made
maybe if you're an amerimutt
I get you're baiting, but do rockstar fans just not value gameplay at all? Their games all have substandard gameplay and roughly 20% or more of the playtime is just driving or riding to objectives.
>This is literally the greatest game ever made.
Not really
>>story gets thrown into the trash in chapter 4
It hat some of its best moments in chapter 5 and 6. It's the epilogue that feels padded out.
but the best part of the story is in ch 5 and 6
fucking hell, this board has some god awful taste
The game's story mode is amazing, but like most of Rockstar's game the multiplayer was shit.
>I get you're baiting, but do rockstar fans just not value gameplay at all?
Yep. That is rockstar userbase all right. Remember how everybody was praising Max Payne 3 for having the "best gunplay ever"? When it was a broken shitty game with well over four hours of cutscenes in an eight hour campaign and most basic mechanics were completely broken?
"Best gunplay ever" actually meant "It REALLY looks like a movie!" Rockstar fans are the biggest fucking casuals and normies in the world. Which would be fine: there are always going to be the biggest market in the universe, and someone will have to pander to them. What absolutely FASCINATES me is how they somehow deluded themselves into thinking they are a hardcore crowd, and not casuals that make fucking Naughty Dog fans like really hardcore dudes.
Dang, you didn't have to kill em. But I feel the same way honestly.
And this is how fucking delusional consolebabies are. To think some fucked up storygame garbage with shit controls and bad gameplay is the "greatest game ever made" is so delusional that the only recourse would be to ban this fucking idiot from playing videogames for the rest of his life.
>greatest game ever made
Can't take a bath in the bath at beecher's hope
Nope, no way.
I agree on the no danger part. Playing as john with zero good karma and even then bounty hunters barely show up. Half the time I gotta sleep or else it's just me roaming the map for 20 mins. Even with fucking cougars I barely encounter them. I wish they would have areas with an outbreak of dangerous animals or gangs. Like all of Roanoke forest can have Murfree hideouts scattered throughout after certain periods of time pass or something just to add more or a challenge to the game combat wise.
Kinda defeats the purpose. I dont care if a regular civilian sees me or not cause they cant do shit. Lawmen should be able to recognize me instantly with a mask. I understand they wanted that realism shit with recognizing your clothes and horse and shit, but c'mon now.
>Having a nice gamer gf
I'm jealous, I cant play games around my girl in peace for shit.
Rockstar looks at Hollywood (and more recently, Netflix) the same way Michal Bay looks at explosions and women.
>trying to fit in the list
now show your real top 10 list zoomer
Aside from RDO being... unfinished. Everything from the single player was pretty much perfect (except for how slow you move in the camps.)
If bandanas made you completely immune to bounties why the fuck would the system even be in place?
>I dont care if a regular civilian sees me or not cause they cant do shit.
Except report you to the cops, which adds to your bounty. The purpose of the mask is to prevent unnecessary bounties, it's not god mode for killing sprees.
>crying because you need progress to buy better weapons
filthy casual
In all honesty youd be surprised how much ppl forget to put that shit on. Unless the game tells you, most folks just bust in a place and go stupid, a bandana should be your fail safe for trying to do a robbery right. I'm not saying it should be God hack, but atleast maybe there should be a 50/50 if they recognize you or not rather than straight up as soon as they see you.
nah
>The purpose of the mask is to prevent unnecessary bounties, it's not god mode for killing sprees.
mate, on most missions where we do some illegal shit i pre-emptively put on the mask and it gets removed in the cut-scene, whereupon arthur then slaughters an entire town's population of young able-bodied men
>Yea Forums now defends this insanely cinematic game with some of the worst movement ever and bland third person shooter mechanics
This board is fucking dead.
>overreacting about minor flaws in an insanely ambitious game
Seems like business as usual
>genuinely awful movement
>minor flaw
not even him, but get fucking real
>gameplay is a minor flaw
1. Minecraft
2. Call Of duty BO2
3. Destiny 1
4. Destiny 2
5. Skyrim
6. Battlefield 1
7. Overwatch
8. MK 11
9. GTA V
10. and Ironically fortnite
This game has the worst replay value ever
The gameplay (the main focus of a video game) is fucking terrible.
The input lag is dreadful
My thumb is numb from being forced to mash the button to go at a decent speed
The weight mechanics are just fucking stupid
The shooting is the same cookie cutter shit we've been getting out of a 3rd person shooter for the past 2 console gens
i'd unironically agree if not for the:
>shitty crime/bounty system
>cops with mental powers
>kill a SINGLE cop in the middle of nowhere and you get INSANT bounty
>cops know its Arthur through full facemasks
>civilian AI witnessing crimes through walls
>witnesses constantly spawning outta nowhere after you commit a crime
>shitty epilogue not letting your play as Arthur after ending
>not letting Arthur go to New Austin
>bank robberies only in specific missions
Yea Forums has a weird collection of fanboys who act like this is the best game ever. Everyone else has moved on from this disappointing game
>Yea Forums has a weird collection of fanboys who act like this is the best game ever.
Because this place is filled to the brim with retarded rockstarfags who pretend every game they put out is masterpiece and anyone who disagrees is someone who didn't play it or seething nintendofag or pcfag.
The story is really fucking bad. The game play is not as bad as Yea Forums makes it out to be. Somehow Arthur is still a fantastic protagonist because (((they))) remembered they had to make a believable protagonist before he died. Online a shit, SP expansion with more Arthur when?
Yea Forums has a weird collection of seething, vocal haters. The idea that people who enjoy the game are the minority is beyond hilarious.
Everyone except you, OP
It's a slog.
It's ugly (no, being realistic doesn't make it beautiful you mong).
Gameplay is shit.
>shitty epilogue not letting your play as Arthur after ending
Bitch he's fucking dead. They didn't even let you play as John with cheat codes back in RDR1.
Sadie ruined too many missions for me, awful character
good thing its a videogame retard
Yeah, they should've given us machine guns and drones and shit too. It's just a video game after all, so who cares
Lol shut the fuck up, nobody bought RDR2 for the MP and the only thing wrong with it anyway is the limited lobby mode, but the actual PvP stuff is perfect. Only zoomers hate it because r* hasn't fleshed out the shark card model so there isn't as much stuff to buy with mommy's cc
Incel detected
based
>The idea that people who enjoy the game are the minority is beyond hilarious.
You are the minority. People played this game and quickly moved on. Everyone saw how shitty and boring the gameplay was and sees no reason to play it again or keep coming back. The only people who still care about this game are the diehard rockstar fanboys who desperately want to keep it alive. It’s the most irrelevant highly acclaimed AAA game of the decade.
lol it's more like the schizo can't stand that people like the game
Yeah, most of/v/ hates it because r* hasn't put out a version that runs on mom's gateway yet
those of you hating on rdr2, uncharted, botw, and every other big budget amazing game. if youre wondering why youre sexless virgins its this. you dont like things normal people like while insulting them. mhw isnt a casual game, dark souls 1 isnt even a good game but progressivly became okay. so go tug it to some isabelle porn(thats super super weird btw even by shut in standards) and hating the world when the problems lie with you and your refusal, not inability, refusal to fix them.
fanboyism and liking the game are two very different things
lol cope I can find a lot of unflattering incel pics no problem
I don’t even think the world is that good, it honestly feels empty as fuck, even the “random events” just feel soulless and staged. Roaming around after going into an area once is totally pointless, you may as well just fast travel everywhere. This has the deadest post game of any open world game ever. People hate th character change not just because they miss Arthur but it becomes apparent the world is so fucking lifeless when the story is over.
>isabelle porn(thats super super weird btw
Pure post
I know, sweaty
Not in any order
MGS3
Tony Hawk Underground 2 Remix
Persona 4
MGS 2
FFX
Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance
Advanced Wars Dual Strike
The Witcher 3
RDR2
FE7
Bad
Just accept this game has faded into irrelevance. Stop making stupid threads like this every day to keep it alive.
Seethe harder incel
whatever you say, incel
But it hasn't
If the survival mechanics actually had any depth, the arguments that the fans make about its quality would be justified. Instead, it’s a game with horrendous gameplay with dumb realism elements that add nothing due to how basic they are, with some of the worst mission design in games. The shooting sucks. This game is a bad sim and a bad shooter.
>sacrifice gameplay for story
>story isn't even that good
Yes, it has. Nobody gives a shit about this game other than some desperate posters on Yea Forums making threads like this trying to keep it alive. The gaming world has moved on from this boring game. If the game was still relevant you guys wouldn’t have to make these dumb threads every day bragging about its greatness. There’s nothing left to talk about because the game just sucks
On second thought take out the Witcher 3 and replace it with Megaman Battle network 3: Blue because the Witcher 3 dragged on a little too much near the end whereas BN3 was fun the whole way through
>Bank robberies only on specific missions
This was by far my biggest letdown you get one bank robbery the entire game since the San Denis one is more of a shooting gallery. I was fucking pissed I couldn't just hit banks and have a big unscripted shoot out whenever I felt like it
lol cope
was it autism?
Why are fans of this game so fucking autistic? RDR1 didn’t have a bunch of people trying to convince you the game was a masterpiece all the time.
Try playing the game lol
But you can have big unscripted shootouts in the bank bro
Nice try OP, maybe someone actually saw this shit in the catalog and didn't realize you were falseflagging.
Prove me wrong
Lol, you’re just embarrassed because you know it’s true.
absolutely obsessed. are you a falseflagger?
>The gunplay is shi-
>absolutely obsessed
Because the first game was genuinely liked and seen as a fun game and got awards. RDR2 just got a bunch of paid reviews and hardly any awards because it’s simply not as good.
what the fuck are you trying to imply? are you retarded? you've been spamming the thread non-stop, replying to every single person that said something negative
I bet you actually hate the game
>act autistic when sitting on something
>get called out
>l-lol fanboy
that was fucking terrible
quality control your posts you dumb phoneposter
also where did I shit on anything? I mentioned the movement is bad, I actually quite like the game
>was forgotten literally after 2 months of its release
>retards now have to justify a dead game by making threads on Yea Forums how great it is and how ripped off they dont feel
lmao
Not in order
1.GTA:SA
2.Halo 3
3.Metal Slug X
4.RDR2
5.Metroid Zero Mission
6.Pokemon Emerald
7.Sonic CD
8.Super Mario 64
9.Persona 3
Shit can't think of a 10th game.
You like the game even though you want it to play like fortnite, curious
Pretty good
It's an online game with fucking auto-aim, you cancerous retard.
>Metal Slug X
only good game on your list, play more games retard
Oh shit, I how could I forget REmake? I'm in a RE thread right fucking now.
what the fuck are you talking about? I want tight movement, that's it
Anyone else have played this game to the absolute limit?
I'm so burned out I can barely play 20 mins without feeling nauseous.
Was a 9.9/10 before that though.
Post your games, so that we call your taste shit.
Like any console shooter.
1. Jet Set Radio
2. Fallout 2
3. Simpsons Hit n' Run
4. THPS2
5. Virtua Tennis 2
6. Gran Turismo 2
6. Gran Turismo 4
8. Metal Slug X
9. Morrowind
10. MGS2
you think im stupid or something? you will call them shit regardless
Nier Automata
Red Dead Redemption 2
Dragon's Dogma
Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2
Baldur's Gate 2
Dragon Quest XI
What is actually good? I have never seen anyone actually describe it. They just call you a zoomer if you dare to say it’s not that good to play. You can’t even say it makes for a good simulator because it’s extremely shallow in that regard.
>Metal Slug X
only good game, play more games retard
0 good games, play more games retard
yeah i forgot Final Fantasy IX
Why that dragon quest? There are so many better ones like V
There's a pretty big difference between auto-aim and aim assist, but okay dumbass. Keep making excusing for appalling game design.
So you admit that your taste is shit.
Pretty fucking patrician
nice meme pal
here, have 5(6) more
11. Armored Core Last Raven
12. Apocalypse
12. Kerbal Space Program
14. Microsoft Flight Sim 2004
15. Soul Calibur 1
15. SC2
I don't like 5's monster recruitment system. I could've included 4 and 7 as I like both very much too.
But you can't Rob it which is fucking gay as fuck
You could easily play it without on kbm so I fail to see how it's a problem with the game design.
RDR2 is overrated garbage.
Fair enough.
We're talking RDO. You can turn it off yourself, but everybody else still has it on which puts you at a ridiculously huge disadvantage. I mean, you cant even really have proper shootouts in the game because of it, all you do is just pop in and out of cover because even being on a horse at top speed is a death sentence.
Yes but it's still not bad game design
>first person shooter
>doesn't require you to aim
You are very, very, very dumb.
Even most console TPS games have better aiming than RDR2. The aiming in this game is unbelievably awful.
>it's not bad game design
>the aiming in this game is unbelievably awful
Retard alert!
It's more of a console problem than a game design problem though, and it doesn't remove aim entirely, that's that autism we were talking about
I’m not the other guy
Most console games don’t have aiming as bad as RDR2
Git gud.
I don't know maybe you just suck
>ai rushes in
>gets shot
>not even 10 seconds later another one rushes in and gets shot
on top of the gunplay being shit the ai is fucking retarded
????
It was a good experience but I have zero motivation to play it again since beating it. There is no player choice / rpg system, the gameplay is casual as fuck, the world is empty beyond the story missions, and the multiplayer sucks. If I could have rented this instead of buy, I would've.
>The gameplay is casual as fuc-
>PvP is full of battle royale
>zoomers hate it
Kid...
Why would anyone want RDR1 with the shitty controls and movement of 2?
Open-world story driven games are all like this
zoomers are the only people who give a shit about multiplayer in a single player game to begin with
she was great until a shopping trip turned her into a tryhard feminist wet-dream. The part where she killed at least 1 armed O'Driscoll with a knife was just so retarded. I don't understand why they had to go so overboard with her. At the very least, have her GRADUALLY become a badass, not this "welp, went on a shopping trip. Now I'm female rambo" bullshit. I'm fine with strong female characters but she was a caricature.
no im pretty sure the weekend of rape did that
this. bonnie blows her out of the water
Not him, but not really. I have replayed the GTAs and RDR1 several times and will probably do so again. RDR2, on the otherhand, is just not the kind of game I would ever want to replay. There is just nothing satisfying about playing it.
Go get raped and tell me how badass you become. She was doing chores with the gang, not training, not going on robberies, not killing anybody, not doing jack fucking shit but cooking and laundry but the shopping trip and killing a couple dudes all of a sudden put her on the same level as, if not even higher than the rest that had been doing it for their entire lives since childhood. That is fucking retarded. It is lazy and pandering. If by the end of the game they had developed her into this bad ass it'd be different, but no. They didn't.
a weekend of getting raped turns you into rambo?
>every gang member murders at least 20 people a day with total impunity until the sad cutscene where they lose their plot armor
perfect realism
>woman knifes one guy
UNREALISTIC! FEMOIDS CAN'T STRONG! FEMINISM OUT OF MY GAMES REEEEEE
I'm on my third playthrough now. I don't see why you single out RDR2 given it's everything good about open world games except more
>what a woman can't be strong that's ridiculous
what took the cake for me is how she was all alone again the fucking army of rival bounty hunters as if she was some wild west legend
Unironically the first game to truly feel like a film. And there's a whole open world game in there besides the virtual movie shit
>gets called out on his retarded "argument"
>immediately strawmans
predictable
That's how the game works. You have an invincible partner and you shoot waves of braindead cannon fodder.
Or people who 100% the single player.
Meanwhile
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
These are consistent names in the red dead community. And check the comments.
youtube.com
Skip to 4:50. I was wrong. She killed THREE armed with guns while all she had was a knife. Retarded. You're dumb for thinking that's not ridiculous. The other gang members have been shooting people for their entire lives while the people they kill are bumpkins and lawmen that probably only shoot their guns maybe twice in their entire careers. Sadie is a rape victim, therefore she can kill 3 men armed with guns while all she has is a hunting knife? lol ok
RDO seriously got worse? I played it when it came out and it was a dumpster fire.
when it comes to gameplay, yes. but I'm talking about the story. dutch has gang rivalries and uses his own gang for war with them, while sadie just chills around on her own for years while completely alone
FEMOID KILL 3??!?!? FEMOID KILL 3????@!?@?!!?
It has the worst movement of any open world game ever. Slogging my way through it once is enough. Something as simple as walking up to a second floor in a building shouldn’t feel so slow and shitty. Even the smallest actions in this game feel elongated and sluggish. The “gamefeel” is the worst ever for open world. Doesn’t even have the pleasure of a game like GTA of driving around, but even compared to elder scrolls or Witcher, the movement is garbage.
I'm just saying I'm sure I'm not the only one who really enjoyed Sadie's plot
I like RDR2, but the people saying that this has better gameplay than RDR1 are fucking delusional.
>horseriding isn't nearly as fast or as smooth, stamina is harder to maintain
>gunfights are a clunky mess with bad aim and a finnicky cover system
>teleporting lawmen and witnesses
>Arthur turns into a slow 80 year old man while at camp
>awful fast travel system that only goes one way
>RNG pelts
>hold buttons to watch Arthur slowly loot bodies, raid cabinets, etc.
>sometimes the game literally doesn't respond to your button inputs if it interferes with a scripted setpiece
Pretend one of the gang members trained her to have plot armor in secret, then
that's not what you're saying at all, I would never have a problem with that
>the red dead community
that is extremely stupid
Cringe.
>the people saying that this has better gameplay than RDR1 are fucking delusional.
Imagine honestly thinking this
>when arthur writes in his diary of she's more fierce and scary than some of the guys
come the fuck on
What's with the quote, retard?
Reminder that Arthur is so close to death that he's ended by a fistfight, but it doesn't bother you that he can run, jump, brawl, and shoot dozens of people at a time
I'M FUCKING SEETHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HOW CAN HSE KILL 3? AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH IT'S NOT FAIR BROS
That actually doesn't bother me. You can be fierce and scary without being literally able to kill three armed men with guns using a knife. Her personality is fine for her situation and background. Her actions and invincibility is obvious feminist pandering. If she would have died from her stab would that would have at least wrapped it up in a believable way but she's just this Wild West Terminator JUST BECAUSE she was raped? It's hilarious and the only part about the writing that bothered me. As if one person shoe-horned it in at the last minute or something.
Dutch's gang members are so skilled that they can fight an actual war against actual soldiers, but they can't train others to be like them. That would be stupid.
Why does the fact that men are far stronger than women on average bother you?
They updated it in spring and it turned into fallout 76.
Then they took their time to fix all the issues, the content they released got burned through in less than 3 days and everyone's been waiting ever since for an actually substantial update that will add real content to the game. Meanwhile they drip feed 2 pieces of shitty looking clothing every 2 weeks that costs an arm and a leg, while the game is slowly spiralling into more bugs and issues with framerate, glitches, cheaters and so on and so forth. The game is now in limbo and the summer update could not come any sooner, it almost seems like they have abandoned the game.
>on average
they should just drop the multiplayer and make singleplayer expansions. All I would want out of the multiplayer would be to walk around RPing and playing poker anyway.
They won't. Microtransactions are much more lucrative and they'll try to revive the online before making a singleplayer DLC. Rockstar has moved to the live service bullshit instead of releasing a finished game.
no, I meant pretending like shit happened would be stupid
RDR2 follows the Rockstar formula well, which is fine, but imagine if the western frontier they made was actually dangerous and intimidating to traverse. I thought it was going to be from the snowy opening and survival mechanics but it wasnt. Also, the story was clearly written for the high honor path and playing low honor just makes Arthur seem bipolar in his actions. He syeals and kills but feels really guilty and wants to renounce it! Rockstar made so many interesting factions, itd be awesome if we could alaign withany of them or even choose to side with Dutch or the Feds in the end. Wouldve added alot of replayability.
Super Metroid
Pokemon Blue
Metal Warriors
Marvel vs. Capcom 2
Diablo
Silent Hill
F-Zero GX
Deus Ex
Chrono Cross
Demon's Souls
that makes me so sad. Undead nightmare was literally my favorite DLC out of any game, ever. It was the best zombie game i've ever played. I want a dlc where you hunt werewolves, vampires and shit in a wild west setting.
Even LA Noire was more playable
Come up with an actual rebuttal or get the fuck out of my face, zoomer.
1. SMITE
2. Fallout New Vegas
3. RDR1/2
4. Mount & Blade
5. Zone of the Enders 2
6. Area 51
7. Shining Force 1/2
8. Red Faction Guerrilla
9. Saints Row 2
10. Natural Selection 2
It would break their totally super realistic simulator vibe.
No what they're going to do is release this stupid overdue update, which will either make or break the game. If it brings players back consistently then they will make more updates. If it flops they will abandon the online all together and probably make a singleplayer mexico DLC.
Maybe try to argue why that would be delusional first?
I did. Read the entire post, you illiterate mong.
it being a "realistic simulator" is what would make it so good. It would go so well with the hunting mechanics already. Have you not seen all the supernatural shit already in the game? including fucking aliens? lol like, it's not that outlandish. Hunting things like vampires, werewolves and wendigos would make some sense. They could just "it was a dream" it again.
maybe come up with actual arguments ;)
So then you've got nothing. Next.
Despite what would be good, they're still publicly sticking to live service till further motice.
Nobody said you can't like 1 more, but you just blast out a bunch of silly opinions and call anyone who disagrees with you wrong, it's kind of endearing.
Honestly this. I have not touched the game since Saint Denis. Game was interesting in the beginning, has some good moments. But largely it's pretty boring.
the sense of realism in the gameplay(having to store guns in your saddle, waiting for hair to grow so you can style it, cleaning guns so they work better, etc) draws you in and makes you feel more like the story is taking place in a grounded, real world. You embody Arthur in a way that you only could in a video game and that makes you have a real attachment to his character. Also the fact that he dies of TB at the end no matter what you do is more impactful because its a game. Gamers are used to being able to put in extra effort to get a good ending. But just like how Arthur was powerless to stop a situation which was out of his control, so were we the players. RDR2 plays on gaming conventions to make its story more effective in ways that most games do not.
You can shit talk the game
you can complain about it being cinematic trash
you can complain about the overgenerous auto-aim.
But it is INDISPUTABLE FACT that Arthur Morgan's antagonise dialogue has some of the funniest lines and reactions in the history of vidya. He's an absolute cunt to everyone and it makes me sad that I can't do the same to people in real life. youtube.com
Arthur is a nice guy who bends over backwards for everyone in the gang though
1:35 holy shit that was fucking hilarious.
>women are too weak to use a knife
For sure, they should have just railroaded the player into high honour to be honest, I think they only kept the system cause it was in RDR, one of my gripes with the game is that cutscene and mission Arthur is a troubled but super nice guy. It was really jarring to play the debt collecting mission where you get TB and he just beats the guy for no reason when up to that point he'd not really did much bad shit.
The final Strauss missions and kicking him out of the camp were absolute Kino though. The people shiting on RDR2 are like those neckbeards saying too ugly wouldn't bang to 9/10 girls, just bitter entitled people with unrealistic expectations. The game wasn't perfect sure but it was at least a good game.
The subplot with Strauss and Arthur's TB feels really tonally weird, like the game is suddenly shifting into a morality play. It meshes awkwardly with the bang bang shooty plot.
Even men, whom are stronger than women, can't kill 3 men armed with guns using only a knife.
Which game are you talking about? I'm talking about the one where you kill probably over 100 trained soldiers and blow up a battleship with four dudes and a mortar.
It's a video game
Its amazing that this sentiment is getting posted on Yea Forums these days. I remember before RDR2 even came out everyone was afraid the singleplayer would be unfinished garbage due to R* focusing on the MP component. Now that the game is out people are upset that the MP is unfinished. Pretty interesting.
It's not an rpg you fucking moron
she got the jump on em I guess
The Legend of Zelda A Link to the Past
Fallout New Vegas
Monster Hunter Generations Ultimate
The Binding of Isaac Rebirth
Bloodborne
The Witcher 3
Super Mario RPG
Final Fantasy VII
Persona 4 Golden
Mass Effect 2
>murder and rob innocents by the hundreds
>starts crying because of loan sharking
it was retarded and so are you for not making an argument
go whine about it on waypoint lmao
I don’t even think the single player feels finished. Why does chapter 1 have multiple dialogue options and different options for the missions, while this very rarely shows up in the rest of the game? Why is Valentine so much more interactive than the other towns? It also reeks of cut content like homes that were probably meant to be purchased at some point. To me all these things stuck out like a sore thumb.
>Rockstar why aren't there any house invasions in chapter 1 wtfffffff
What's so mindblowing about having a well rounded game on release?
It's amazing how low standards have fallen that literally any gimmick is proclaimed a masterpiece.
>noo don't criticize my favorite game!
good little corporate drone
>mfw mods will fix this when it comes to pc
>mfw snoys will never EVER play the perfected version
Go back to games focused on fun and unique mechanics
By the time it comes to pc I'll be dead
nothing about your "criticism" is even remotely insightful. R* game with ludonarrative dissonance? you don't say...
You have less than a year to live? Stop wasting your precious remaining moments on Yea Forums
>The ultimate proof that video games can be considered art.
this makes me think the game is probably shit and I won't enjoy it
Yeah lets pretend like there's not tons of that shit in RDR2 already
Less than a year before it gets delayed.
Never ever ever
what I said was my own opinion and criticism, I don't give a fuck if it doesn't match your arbitrary standard. all you're doing is posting selfies and "no u r wrong"
you feel personally attacked because you love daddy corporation
Being a sucker will only make shit worse. Expect forced microtransactions in singleplayer.
But apparently you do as you're trying to paint this game as some massive failure or whatever
Despite the fact that R8 already blew away expectations with the SP content they already released, okay.
when? fucking quote me, please
I liked the game very much, but I had several problems with it
you immediately made a strawman when you realized how defensive you are
you realize the game is on xbox too right
how old are you and what is the nature of your disability?
Almost everything intended to make the game immersive actually has the opposite effect, where the game feels annoying and clunky instead. The more it tries to be realistic, the less immersive it gets
Not in my opinion
Blew away?
Most people would say it did well.
why aren't the enemies shooting back? lol
> git gud
> uses the magic slo mo auto lock on technique to shoot someone in the ankle
> doesn't have an argument so he *ironically* acts like he's retarded
Typical tranny.
you made a strawman when you call people who speak in favor of the games drones lol cope harder
and you're still seething over a character in a video game (esp. one with as much bitterness as in Sadie's heart) acting with super human strength.
>FF7
>Ikaruga
>Panzer Dragoon Saga
>FF8
>Chrono Cross
>Radiant Silvergun
>Sonic 3 and Knuckles
>Alien Solider
>Ace Combat 4
>Dark Cloud 2
>Plays like absolute garbage
lol stick to fortnite?
>no u
I called you a drone because you defended the game without any arguments like a little dog
or maybe you just put up a dumb argument lmao
at least I put one up, unlike you
holy fucking shit you've been going non-stop for 4 hours
I put up tons, you just get butthurt when people start disagreeing with you.
No worse than previous rockstar games. In fact it is their most playable game to date with the smoothest controls
It's a generation defining game, whether you like it or not. Nintendo fags and people upset it's not available on PC will dispute this but they're in denial.
And you've been posting these threads for months.
Even GTAV?
Literally the most forgettable AAA title this gen
>no u
please direct me to your argument. you posted a brainlet wojak and "cope", that's it
I'm not OP you dumb fuck, stop deflecting
get a life lmao, fucking loser
read the thread.
Not quite but nice try. What do you conisider a 10/10 from this gen? And please don't say fucking Nier Automata.
No, that honor belongs to some snoy exclusive
see, you can't do it
Sunset Overdrive
God of War? Spider man? Bloodborne? All are and will be more fondly remembered than RDR2
But I already did
Witcher is a kid’s game and it’s nowhere as mature as RDR is.
okay kid
the only people mad at this are incels and subhumans because they cant see tiddies and there's no hookers
Maybe bloodborne but again you're in denial if you think God of War or Spider-Man will make history like RDR2. Spider-Man is a wonky Arkham game for christ sakes.
It will be more fondly remembered whether you like it or not. It’s still more relevant than RDR2.
now this is cope
then please direct me to said argument. I've already read our chain of replies and there's nothing there
Keep crying bitch.
lol you first
Just read the thread and reply to one of my posts where I did :)
I love how you sit and wait the full minute until can post again, you're beyond obsessed. how fucked is your life? how did it come to this?
Im just on my lunch break in a thread talking about a game I like, I can't complain all things considered
>this coping
you've been going for fucking hours. do something with your life, you're a lonely freak
Based L2 + R2 simulator 2k18
Pick a game that has actual gameplay pleb
that's a nice selfie, loser
It's a better FPS alone than anything that came out on PC that year
>that's a nice selfie, loser
“Game”
It aims your gun for you, it rides your horse for you, every movement is absurdly sluggish to the point of ruining any enjoyment, the missions are all “go to place and shüt people”, and the only good thing about this game is it’s plot.
Go fuck yourself.
damn kid didn't stand a chance
that's not saying much, what's your point? you ARE an idort, right?
This
touche
HA
GOTEM
lol stick to fortnite
>resorted to just quoting my posts
I really got to you
having a bit of a mental breakdown are we
...
ZOOM ZOOM
he really is, just see he's been doing this ALL day, I cannot imagine how miserable he is
>games need to be taken seriously
>this game proves games are art
>adult video game
If you think games were art from the very beginning then you truly didn’t love this hobby
1 persona 3 FES
2 devil survivor overclocked
3 rising revengence
4 snake eater
5 the world ends with you
6 titanfall 2
7 halo 3
8 Minecraft
9 fallout new Vegas
10 devil may cry 5
These aren’t in any order
That’s pretty based
This is a joke
>pokemon
All Rockstar games play like garbage my guy.
This but without a semblance of irony
How will Rockstarfags ever recover?
from an amazing, generation defining game?
RDR 2 is a masterpiece-- more akin to a novel than a film-- but of course, zoom zooms are too A.D.D'd out to appreciate it. SAD!