Left or right, which one is the superior game Yea Forums?

Left or right, which one is the superior game Yea Forums?
strawpoll.me/18342429

Attached: mosaic9006c10835f93cd932ec4f1e24e9117b22a38e49.jpg (615x310, 93K)

RDR1 easily:
>amazing spaghetti western atmosphere
>music in the overworld is really good and not just sparse piano notes
>getting 100% is actually fun with the challenges and outfits and not just an overdose of koroks and shrines
>horses are fast as fuck and fun to ride and not just auto pathing bored like in BotW

Breath of the Wild easy:
>far more enemy variety
>far more environmental diversity
>deeper combat mechanics
>actual fucking level design
>actual fucking bosses
>better physics

The only thing Red Dead has over Breath of the Wild is story telling and writing. That's it.

RDR1 if you play games for the Story & characters, otherwise BOTW blows it out of the water

rdr because fuck nintenbros

I barely see anyone talking about RDR2 anymore, so BotW wins by default (I don't think it's that great either)

>nintenbros
fuck the mods are trannies. wont let me insult these faggots

Of those two, easily Breath of the Wild.
>if you play games for the Story & characters
The retards who unironically do that are all quarantined to the JRPG threads.

This is about RDR1, not 2

Mexico and West Elizabeth were way cooler environments than the boring green fields in BotW. Who gives a shit if there's more diversity, death mountain, the desert and the jungle were all pretty meh anyway. RDR's map is more cohesive and comfy