It didn't suck, its just that you realized the game sucked and didn't want to admit it

nah this game's atmosphere is top notch and i barely played it last year

>Replying to bait

>burgers
>good for anything other than FPS games
hilarious

No, i've gone back to playing 3 on a ps2 emulator right after trying that collection.
It did suck, the most noticeable thing was that they managed to scramble a bunch of sound effects around for some reason.

I'm sensing a lot of negative energy in this thread, let's just chill and rationalize this out. Sure they removed the fog and added some comic sans but it's pretty much the same experience.

play silent hill 2 (on pc with mods to make it pretty)

Attached: HotJames.png (379x607, 224K)

>and nothing was resolved, the end.

I like his art, but Remina was his only really solid story.

They changed the voice acting, which is a pretty big deal in a game where the characters and performances are absolutely central to the experience

...

I sense a lotta faggotry in this post. Maybe you should actually play the game on PS2 instead of watching it on youtube

Attached: 1469923122829.gif (625x626, 1.16M)

I played it on PC with a PS2 emulator, don't bully. I'm still sensing mixed vibes in this thread, let's not get feisty here. Sure they misplaced some sound effects and maybe the new voice acting isn't quite as good as it could be, but it's pretty much the same experience.

It sucked. It sucked worse than the originals, and they sucked.
Silent Hill 2 could make a serious run at the most overrated game ever made.

>implying SH was ever known for quality voice acting

Is this your way of starting SH thread? with a terrible fucking bait?

Not even gonna continue this. Fuck your thread

Attached: 1554569631231.jpg (693x490, 75K)

I didn't say he could write or finish a story, but it least he has the visual panache to inspire fear.

they changed the music, textures, misplaced sound effects and much more it's hardly just comic sans and fog

Pleb=filtered

>it didn’t suck, you just realized the game sucked
WOAH DUDE

Attached: mfw.jpg (200x297, 27K)

You're the real pleb for not realizing how inferior it is to the material it rips off.

true,bro.
only SH 4 and maybe 1 are any good,

More like they are only good at making Horror games

I only played because i'm a dirty trophy whore and i never touch them again.
Is it true that this remaster was the one they chose to port to the xbone instead of the much superior xbox originals? that must suck.

Silent hill 2 is inferior to any western horror game made in the last ten years.

Outlast completely btfos it and amnesia makes silent hill its bitch each night.

You know I'm right.

Silent hill isn't scary compared to modern games but the subject matter in the game is extremely unique still.

No, those are just abysmal remasters of great games because Konami are incompetent fucks.

xbox BC isn't porting, it's mostly software emulation.
original XBOX BC is second class compared to 360 that's likely why they did the HD collection first.

I like the games a lot, but SH1 was the only truly scary one for me because the sequels just reuse the exact same tricks in scaring you.

amnesia is a fine game, not as good as penumbra and not as good as silent hill
outlast is trash

Outlast 2 was a decent horror game, I really liked the idea of using the microphone to listen for enemies around you when you didn't have the juice for nightvision
The first one was pretty generic though

Attached: blood.png (1920x1080, 1.21M)

I love junji ito but I cannot stand faggots like you who literally ONLY read Junji ito horror mangas

im some group online and they literally never read any other horror other than junji ito

kys

Silent Hill 2’s genius doesn’t lie in making you jump out of your seat. You like the most basal style of horror probably because those are the only horror games that you ever actually played. Nothing wrong with it, but you won’t convince anyone that SH2 was bad. You just out yourself as someone who doesn’t know much about the horror genre.

I don't think that's quite the case. I think SH2 inspires dread more than fear, it has a much more melancholic tone that drags one down more than it tenses one up. Meanwhile, SH3 does a lot to emphasize sensory abrasion with very striking visual designs and audio cues, it's a much more aggressive game than SH2. SH1 is straight up the scariest though because it does the most to put the player in actual peril rather than playing things up symbolically and aesthetically.

Suggestions?

Whistleblower was a substantial improvement on the first game. Never did play the second one.

>not as good as penumbra
Finally, a fellow intellectual

People always try to dumb this down into 1 or 2 complaints but the fact is EVERYTHING is wrong. You cannot play this game for more than 15 seconds without something being completely fucking broken.

Attached: Maria_eyes.png (322x225, 121K)

Ehh, I didn't find 3 scary at all really - more just tense. They start dropping you right into rooms swarming with enemies, and after this happens a few times the fear is dulled a little, since the rooms full of monsters is all the game will probably throw at you. The one clever thing 3 did IMO was the bit with Stanley Coleman in the hospital, and how he lures you over to his room, which I ended up skipping since I was so creeped out by him. I liked the game in general but it was just too bog standard SH, nothing quite stood out except for the new characters.

You're pretty wrong. Amnesia wasn't that good and Outlast was bad.

Attached: Untitled.png (277x411, 54K)

Did you ever play Penumbra Necrologue? It's free on steam and I've heard some good things about it, though it's just an amnesia mod apparently.

That's fair, 3 attempts a different kind of horror altogether and horror is inherently a bit of a "different strokes for different folks" prospect. What scares one person could leave another completely unaffected and vice versa. It's one of the main reasons the genre is so niche, there is no catch all, definitive formula that scares EVERYONE.

zoom zoom

Nah, I've been in my metroidvania/RTS phase, so it completely flew by me. I'll check it out.

>collection
>no sh1 or 4

the voice acting was memorable and fit the game, everybody just acts like a weirdo

Fuck off Hullet

>blaming Hulett for KCET fuckups
cringe bro.