Why are echo ideas so fucking retarded?

I'm not memeing here. Every single thread on this topic, whenever on this site or other sites, always have the worst of the worst ideas for echo fighters. I always see shit like:
>DURRRRRRRRR BALZIKEN FOR CAPTURN FALCURN ECHO!!!!!111 :D
>you noe who wuld make a good game and watch echo fightere? PAPURR MARIO CUZ THERR BOFF FWATTTTTTTTTTT.
>BABY MARIO BORS WOULD MAKE GOOD ICE CLIMBAR ECHA BECAUSE IT'S A TWO IN ONE HIRE ME NINTY111
And of course when you tell them that echo fighters have to be from the exact same series they say shit like
>HEHEHE GANONDURF WAS THE FIRST ECHO FIGHTERE HAHAHAHA
I fucking hate this shit so much why do people do this

Attached: 1493413221418.jpg (640x628, 40K)

take it to /smash/

why Dr Mario isn't a echo fighter?

They gotta pander to melee players somehow.

I smell some mighty projection in this post

Because he's too mechanically different.

Goddamn. Stupid fucking frog poster.

Echo fighters were supposed to be characters like Lucina and Dark Pit who are nearly exactly the same as the original, so Dr. Mario is too different from normal Mario... but then Sakurai went and made Ken an echo fighter despite having many differences from Ryu so who the fuck knows why half of these characters aren't echoes.

Who would you have as a reasonable echo fighter?

Attached: dry.jpg (1280x720, 96K)

wouldn't dry bowser fit more as an alt than an echo desu?

Dumb fucking frogposter

Metal Sonic. Ms. Pacman. Zach Fair. Ravio.

Doctor Mario has way more differences than ken

>Metal Sonic
how are you such a mouth breather you think Metal could be an echo?

He absolutely could be
>but he does other things too!
so does Chrom

>so does Chrom
Chrom just recycles Ikes other moves he's a double echo
What characters moves would you steal to make Metal then?

yeah?

Attached: 729E2BDD-F5B4-42D7-B942-77CC176A0430.jpg (450x700, 71K)

Sonic but replace one of the extraneous spindashes with Samus missles and maybe homing attack with charge shot. Final smash can be that dumb shit from Sonic Heroes.

>metal is more than just a doppelgänger! he does other things!
join the club

Attached: 4BED0254-FA21-4182-ABA2-0CE2FD440D53.png (250x432, 91K)

but... he is Mario.

Did you have a point to make?

But he isn't an echo

He's still not on the level of difference that Doc is.

dr mario and mario have the exact same amount of differences as ken and ryu. the melee clones just weren’t grandfathered into the echo title like Lucina and Dark Pit were for no reason other than it would fuck with marth to have 3 echos

>different speed
>variance in the properties of specials
>different tilts aerials and throws
>different play styles
hmmm. i’m think they’re the same.

Big Boss,Funky Kong and maybe Shadow the Edgehog are the only Echos I want

Does Ryu have a fucking water faucet instead of a tatsu?

>dr mario and mario have the exact same amount of differences as ken and ryu
Nah

so when chrom takes ike’s aether he remains an echo but when doc gets his tornado back from luigi its fine?

I want ravio in smash but what character would he be an echo of? Toon or Young Link?

He's right for once, you're the retard here.

Dr. Mario and Mario play nothing alike. Nothing about their play styles are similar.