It is high time for Smash Bros to trim the fat

nintendo

>no DQ hero
>no Roy
>Little Mac

I would not buy the game if that was the roster.

>infinitesimal

Attached: brenlit.png (211x239, 5K)

>nintendo
nintendo?

Replace Boo with Waluigi and this is a genuinely good roster of characters that "deserve" it.
Also add DQ hero.

sorry english is hard

remove bayo sonic banjo & ice climbers

fuck off back to 9gag

>7 mario reps
>Robin
Cringed pretty hard famalama desu

Attached: 1544435279595.jpg (1002x983, 130K)

who do you want to get in so bad that you unironically care about the smash 6 rooster

>infinitesimal amount of characters
Good idea

Attached: infinitesimal.png (22x23, 1K)

NINTENDOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Hire

>cutfags have no taste
Suprising

Bayonetta is pretty much Nintendo's thing now

I have the magical ability to tell who your waifu is based soley on the fact that you didn't feel the need to remove them.

Attached: 1558432192706.png (2000x3000, 2.19M)

Finally, I've always wanted to play as M

where's /ourguy/?

Attached: wahhhh.gif (228x152, 3.07M)

> cuts Pac-Man and Megaman
> keeps the 2 least relevant 3rd parties
Amazing how easily you can fuck up each time, cutfags.

>no mega man
dropped

>trim the fat
>leaves Rosalina
>adds a Mario character
>leaves Charizard
>leaves Shulk

I wouldn't agree that being published by Nintendo grants her a spot. Might as well throw in Shovel Knight if that's a justification.

don't even play mega man. feels wrong without him.

keep simon too.

Ties with Nintendo takes precedence over everything else

Fixed that for you bro

Attached: smash 6 draft.png (1536x1254, 2.71M)

"Ties to Nintendo" is just abstract enough for you to use it to justify whatever poor choices you want

If I wanted to add whatever poor choice I wanted then Shadow and Lanky Kong would be there
I could not care less about Bayonetta, it just makes the most sense

Imagine the utter shitfest this board would become if this actually happened.

Hi Latin American friend, I can tell you’re on your phone XD

>removing any of the original 12
you're a fag and I'm glad you're not in charge of Smash

Bayonetta has a grand total of 2 games and only got in because all the big time picks were saved for Ultimate. She is easily one of the first candidates for the chopping block you maximum retard.

Jigglypuff's playstyle is gigacancer he's doing us all a favor

take a shower

Way to many cut K Rool Diddy Boo Peach Rosalina Mewtwo Mets Knight Ridley Ness and all third party

>Master Chief
>Not Doomguy
Fucking change it right now or get the fuck out

What's the difference?

>keeping banjo
based
>removing any of the original 12
>only one newcomer
>bayonetta
nevermind

>infinitesimal
brainlet

I'm not sure if I want this bait to be completely ignored, or get a thousand replies telling you to fucking die.

?

the beauty is that they can play the game they want right now because of Ultimates unlock system.

I refuse to believe there are people out there who unironically want a smaller roster. The level of retardation and bitterness would be astronomical to reach that point.

Does Master Chief ties with Nintendo then?

did you use photoshop for this or this their a website for these roster edits?

>trim the fat
>keeps Bayonetta
>adds a Boo

>Cutfags STILL seething

Oh god, you’re reawakening the beast

What if Smash 6 pulls an EVERYONE IS HERE twice in a row, and cutfags got BTFO’d again? Oh my god, I’m cumming just thinking about it

>keep bayo kick ryu

Attached: 1548474797450.gif (360x273, 143K)

do you really think people want the next smash to have less content? Of course not. But you gotta understand that they aren’t going to do smash 4 during all the life (ultimate was a still a semi-port) and they wouldn’t reuse the same assest always. They gotta cut content, like they did in brawl. Or you will get the next smash in 5 years of development if you want all back

I hope Smash 6 flops because you didn't have the decency to bring back Ryu

not bad for a 36 character roster

What reason would they drop Pit? Kid Icarus had a game more recently than Mother or F-Zero have.

>adding only king boo of all things
>rosalina still there
>1/3 of the roster are mario characters
>keeping bayonetta over any of the pre-dlc smash 4 characters (minus ryu)
>robin is still there
>pokemon trainer is just gone again

Attached: stupid enough.jpg (512x384, 32K)

>King Boo
Justify this

>astral chain
sounds rad but it aint gonna happen

mariowiki.com/Luigi's_Mansion_(series)

I unironically agree with the idea, but not exactly with the example you've provided.

I think Ultimate having every Smash character ever is a great send-off, and allows for a soft reset going forward. I think a lot of characters would (and should) be replaced with more "relevant" characters. The roster may even shrink a bit. I don't want the roster to continuously
get bigger and bigger and bigger like in .

In fact, I would be fine if Ultimate was the last Smash game because of how complete everything feels. But Smash makes too much money, so I know that won't end up happening. So I think the best way for the series to continue is by taking one step back, and another step forward in a different direction.

IC is great

>No Pac-Man

I guess this is my problem with Smash's direction. A lot of the cool additions that were my favorite were retro and weird characters, and now everyone just wants only the popular 3rd party characters. I guess smash is just done for people like me.

>main character of the game that started fire emblem
>and the main character of the game that saved fire emblem
sounds fine to me

get rid of ridley or make him bettter.

>Cutting Mega Man

Attached: 20190510_171704.png (664x412, 437K)

>trims the fat
>adds king boo for literally no reason at all
yup, this guy's a retard

add charizard and banjo to it and it's perfect

Attached: trimmed roster.png (799x392, 793K)

If you were trimming the fat, Kirby wouldn't still have three characters, and Little Mac wouldn't be there at all.

OP That's basically everyone I fucking need.
Save for G&W in Boo's slot.

Attached: 2s0Z845.jpg (571x424, 29K)

Just cut all of the echo fighters and psuedo-echoes like Roy/Lucas/Wolf.

>implying Isabelle is gonna be cut
jokes on you OP, if anything she´s gonna replace the villager

Attached: pftthahaha.jpg (192x171, 15K)

still stuck in AT hell

>Marth and Roy instead of Marth and Ike

Attached: 0eEoQ2Xd_400x400.jpg (400x400, 45K)

Posting the based Sega roster

Attached: Screenshot_2018-11-11-19-40-03.png (800x480, 330K)

OP's a punk bitch
What SNK character should be in Smash

Attached: snk in smash.png (3500x1250, 1.08M)

You'd have a point a few months ago, but her role being de-emphasized in New Horizons solidifies her as the face of New Leaf and associated spinoffs rather than the new main mascot of the entire series.

You know, this has me thinking. What the hell ARE they going to do for the next Smash? They obviously will never top Ultimate in terms of sheer scope, so what kind of roster will we have? Obviously it can't be like Op's because it will bomb for being horrible, but there will obviously be enough cuts that the roster will likely be smaller. What could they possibly do to make up for the inevitably worse roster? They'd have to take the series in a different direction, but how? Focus on competitive? Focused on story? Or will they be working on the next Smash for the next 10 years so they can actually top themselves again. Or will Smash be true to it's English name and it will really be the last one?

Attached: 2e1.jpg (640x550, 79K)

>pay money to get less
Why? I would just stick to Ultimate in that case.

Here's your roster bro
Really, anyone but Mario is just bloat at this point.
Don't pretend that you need more than Mario. Everyone loves Mario.

Attached: justmario.png (82x81, 15K)

There we go

Attached: 6tzhjrdf41411.png (2534x1425, 3.19M)

They will likely rework old characters and possibly bring back custom specials. Call it Smash Revolution or somesuch thing.

>no Yakuza
>12 sonic characters
>7 puyo characters

>New Horizons is all about Nook again
Thank fucking god

Attached: 1556353416062.gif (500x333, 129K)

Nah Smash bros roster is fine as it is, but Smash 6 will certainly be missing people since it was really hard to bring Cloud in again for Ultimate.

>Make a story mode that isn't shit
>Add a less fighting centered multiplayer mode with online ( Like Kirby's City Trial, or Smash Run, or something else. A good twist on the franchise that can keep more people going )
>Adjust a few things here & there in terms of mechanic to further incentivise approaching & diversify the options to do so ( I think proper aerial momentum & less commited dash dancing could do the trick )

Smash 6 should straight up just be a spinoff like Smash vs. Capcom or something.

>No Kiryu

Attached: DjOsBRjXsAAL69L.jpg (1200x900, 387K)

Fixed it for you bro

Attached: Fighters_Megamix_Character_Select (1).png (704x448, 76K)

I would like to see a Nintendo vs. SEGA game with Virtua Fighter gameplay.

There's not going to be a Smash 6.

It's just going to be expansion packs for Ultimate now and the game getting ported to Nintendo's next system.

>Yeah bro, just cut like ten or twenty characters and add literally nothing. Perfect roster.

Smashfags are the only ones who do this. Fans of other fighting games like Mortal Kombat are shedding tears every day that some irrelevant fuck like Rain isn't in.

little E.Gadd head. But then peeps would see that and the calls for him to be an actual fighter would get annoying

thats a pretty good fucking roster

They already add plant knowing they ran out of characters. So people will start demanding popular enemies or mob characters. The hype will still remain until smash 7.

>3 pokemon gen1 rep
>8 mario rep
>luigi still in
>falcon still in
>robin still in

>"Luigi still in"

Attached: Yami-s-shocked-yami-yugi-24125343-640-429.jpg (640x429, 35K)

Chief better

They didn't do as good a job animating the intensity of this scene as they managed to capture in this single still image.

Yah call it "Super MARIO Bros."

Dark Pit, fucking WHY how is that not number 1 on your list of cuts?

if luigi is in, why isn't roy in?

Because he takes literally zero dev time.
The amount of time it would take to delete Dark Pit is probably pretty close to the amount of time it would take to leave him in.

What's that from and what's the context

>comparing Roy to motherfucking Luigi as if they're even remotely on the same plane of relevancy / popularity / how much they deserve to be in Smash

Attached: 1539515920549.jpg (310x326, 39K)

Attached: 1535557623946.png (1115x606, 206K)

Why did ness get removed? All of the original smash bros characters will always be in till the end of time.

Fuck me I didn't even notice him what the hell.

He is below Kirby

if they're making a new game, they still have to remake him. They don't have to "delete" him if they decide not to include him, they just spend 0 work time on him

the fuck? where is jigglypuff?

also fuck cutfags, here's Smash 6

Attached: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate DX.png (720x550, 820K)

but you didn't notice puff missing

You just take Pit's model and color it black and make him scowl a little.
It takes like zero effort.

Uh eheh. Actually, deleting a character could take 1 to several minutes, where as leaving him would take no time whatsoever.

Attached: tumblr_n0hwt0yx4U1qiasnio1_500.gif (500x249, 159K)

Cutfags are mentally ill.

No I didn't. I kinda skimmed the roster and assumed she was there because I saw Kirby and he is the same shape. But at the same time, while she shouldn't be cut, she's not that important. She was actually planned to be cut for one of the games but sakurai decided he wanted to keep the veterans. Also she was easily creatable from Kirby.

different graphic effect on his moves, different properties on his arrows. So then you have to do the same for kirby's copy ability, palutena/snake codec or whatever.You have to add him in classic mode, you have to record the announcer. does dark pit have different sfx too? This is greater work than not doing any work(which would be the case if he's not included in the next title)

cutfags are the worst in all of rosterfaggotry and will be btfo again

Fucking terrible. Why do morons think we need to be exposed to their awful fucking opinions.

You trim all that third party shit and leave Bayo over fucking Pac-man or Simon? Get the fuck out

>cutfags
You are worse than the fucking steve posters

Cutfags are a plague but I'll play your game anyway

Attached: 1547243130409.png (1920x1080, 2.37M)

nnoooooooooOOOOOOOOOOO! MARIO IS NOT GONNA BE IN SMASHHHH AAAAAAAAAA LET ME TELL U WHYYYYYYY

Attached: grlrrglprlhpglhprglh.jpg (645x729, 88K)

You act like they remake the game entirely for every sequel. Dark Pit's properties and sound effects already exist, my dude. He even has the same announcer clip from Smash 4 in Ultimate.

I would say Meta Knight, Rosalina, Mewtwo, and King Boo are your only flab/replacement fodder. There's even a case for Isabelle to completely replace Villager, actually. Simon, Ryu, and Pit would make for good swap-ins, but you can also make a solid case for Jigglypuff, Mega Man and Pac-Man.
>Robin as the other FE character
I actually get this pick because it's a totally different character while also giving FE that sweet second rep. Doesn't tread the "Anime Swordsman" ground of the other guys, and I approve.
Grats OP, I think this is a really solid diet roster.

t. someone who loves the glut of characters we have now

all the weird additions give smash soul
cutfag rosters are always godawful and souless because they only keep the bare essentials

>No Mega Man or Pac-Man
>Keeping Bayo instead of Ryu

>everyone leaving 3rd party characters

only sonic has a real chance of coming back, he's almost nintendo by now

snake was gone and will be gone again, the same for banjo and square enix

Here's your cutfag roster, bro.

Attached: smash64roster.jpg (1280x720, 142K)

I think Smash should be a game for ALL STARS characters that had a real impact on gaming history. That means:

>No fire emblem characters
>No Rosalina
>No Animal Crossing bullshit
>No Xenoblade
>No Bayonetta

This could free space for real heroes like Bomberman, Megaman X, the Chosen Undead, Geralt, etc

Perfect

we all know nintendo will never kill smash, the thing is, do you think sakurai will stay? do you feel like smash can be the same without him?

are you ok with a reset? what would you improve or rework?

>Only Sonic has a chance
>Despite the fact that Capcom, Konami, and Atlus have shown a great willingness to cooperate with Sakurai

Attached: Danganronpa_2_Chiaki_Nanami_Closing_Argument_Sprite_(2).png (268x303, 72K)

More Pokemans then?

if you cut the Ice Climbers, the single most unique character in all of fighting games, than you have no idea what smash is all about

Attached: IC.png (1057x1200, 1.66M)

Remove Luigi and Puff.

Maybe even Fox, Falcon, and Ness, fucking irrelevant.

>This could free space for real heroes
Smash does not have a maximum capacity.

Attached: 1555755961771.jpg (1155x840, 88K)

>Land Wario
Christ, you would think you people would fucking give up by now.

>infinitesimal
I don't think you know what that words means

>Wanting less content
Can someone please explain this autism to me because I genuinely don't understand it

Attached: 1560050867287.png (192x192, 73K)

ACNL is the one of the 3DS best sellers and PC is also the 3rd highest grossing Nintendo mobile game
AC is a mainstay Nintendo franchise just like Mario and Zelda

This is what the reboot will look like, at least in term of veterans.
>Muh Falcon! Muh Ness! Muh original 12!
If we have a reboot, it would mean another producer is making it, and the only reason Jiggly, Sheik and the others are still there is because of him.
>Muh third-party characters!
Three is more than enough. While at it, keep the more iconic.
>T-Too many Mario and Pokemon characters!
Literally the two most popular Nintendo franchises.

Attached: RosterReboot.png (576x165, 201K)

If there are fewer characters, that means more content actually, such as more gamemodes, more collectibles, more balance, maybe even more moves per character since you have a smaller roster

>No Xenoblade
Fuck right off with that shit. Shulk and Monolithsoft earned that.

Attached: 1536893271064.jpg (824x626, 43K)

>no Banjo
it's shit

>cutting the ice climbers when no other character like them exists in any game ever

Replace Boo for Jigglypuff, Banjo for Megaman, K. Rook for Mr. Game and Watch and is good.

Ultimate will kill the Smash series. No way will they top it unless EVERYONE IS BACK!

literally perfect minimalist roster

>cutting a super popular and recognizable mario character for western swordsman literally whos
cutfags are a special breed of autism

I really hope they cut Ness, Captain Falcon, and Jigglypuff just to see all the of goddamn salt

>Bomberman, Megaman X, the Chosen Undead, Geralt, etc
I thought you said all stars?

He meant characters from games he likes

MC is a soi version of Doomguy

charizard is immensely popular and shulk is the origin of a major nintendo IP series that's ongoing, they're not going anywhere. Rosalina isn't safe. I don't know why king boo was added

>robin
otherwise ok. would cut metaknight though

Attached: Lol.jpg (500x400, 33K)

>if there is less content, it means more content actually

>any cuts would feel bad without some sort of justification or philosophy
>if you use a straightforward philosophy of relevancy and popularity, there would be very few newcomers (as seen in many of the rosters in this thread), which would feel boring
>but the game would feel like a direct downgrade if there were cuts but few newcomers
Therefore, there needs to be some sort of unique concept behind the next game.
I propose "Heroes vs. Villains" with this roster
>Includes all of the must-have heroes
>Provides a justification for adding villains who otherwise might not make the cut, which thereby justifies a reasonable amount of newcomers (Kamek, Black Shadow, Tom Nook, DJ Octavio, Meowth, Porky)
>Preserves fan-favorite choices like Ridley and K. Rool
>Provides reasonable justification for not including prominent supporting characters to focus dev time on other issues
>Base roster is the N64 roster and their corresponding villains
>Unlockable characters are a mix of the unlockable N64 characters and franchises that weren't around back then
>Focus on referencing the N64 cast preserves series staples like Captain Falcon
>The Pokemon reps are like Pokemon Trainer but with only two Pokemon each

Attached: Heroes vs Villains.png (288x440, 180K)

This roster sucks dick.

Thanks for the constructive criticism, user

the problem with this, is that it doesn't feel like smash bros. the IP has become so MUGEN-esque you can really make a new theme out of it. Smash has become official MUGEN and nothing is gonna change that.

you might as wall call your proposal "Nintendo Clash" or something.

less time spent making one thing means more time available to make another

how is this hard you fucking moron

Would these faggots make for a decent multi-character fighter? i.e. Ice Climbers.

Who else would fit?

Attached: dasd.jpg (562x600, 70K)

Actually better than what the game really has, seems Nintendo-focused enough and not 20 gay anime sword emo fags that make Sakurai's gay pepe hard

Why do stinkies unironically want a trash character like Crash who appears in nothing but overrated trash games with awful hitzones, platforming, level design and characters?

Most of the anime sword faggots people complain about are from Nintendo you tool.

>remove several pokemon for Sword and Sheild to make better gameplay
>all it ends up being is Masuda is a cutfag.
look dude, just porting the characters from the previous games just works better than cutting characters, cutting content doesn't equal quality control. we don't need another sword and shield.

Attached: ▄█▀ █▬█ █ █ █ █ █ █ ▀█▀.jpg (125x125, 4K)

You're welcome.

I know, what is your point?

Are you low IQ?

>seems Nintendo-focused enough
>Wants to cut out characters that are from Nintendo because they happen to have two traits.
The bitching about generic anime swordsman is so fucking petty.

despite the anime swordsman trope in the game, Smash without a doubt will always have Marth, he's been planned for smash since the very beginning for smash 64, he's not going away even if they do reboot the series (which they will not)

Attached: Full_Attack_Marth.png (1684x1920, 471K)

>All of these mspaint smash bros rosters with the "perfect fighters fanfiction"
>Villager is never cut
Feels good ACfags

Attached: 1508902481556.gif (300x300, 1.25M)

well yeah, animal crossing is iconic

Attached: villager ssbm.jpg (2000x1000, 425K)

everything ok, but king boo is a bad pick

>Franchise started in early 2000s
>Only four main titles / two spin offs
>Release once every ~3-7years
>Daily life simulation genre instead of action / platformer like Nintendo's audience
>On the same level as Mario and Zelda with fans
I'm just happy about this franchise and how it's grown from "that one translated title a year later" to possible worldwide switch release

>Cut G&W
>add King Boo
Nigga you retarded

Get that Snoy shit out of my Sega game.

Attached: segasmash.png (1902x1074, 2.27M)

Nope

One Punch Man. Garou is surrounded by a fuckton of heroes, and uses the kid's hero manual to learn their abilities in a pinch to avoid getting destroyed

where's persona?

GIVE ME CHIE

>Fatlus characters

I'd like a couple extra characters but this list is actually really good. I'd prefer they shrink the list and flesh out the characters more. Luigi deserves a full mansion moveset, ganondorf deserves his own moveset too.

I mean, there's literally zero reason to. AC is easily one of Nintendo's biggest franchises now

Nobody WANTS it but we all know it's going to happen in the next Smash game. It's not very likely that they will be able to pull of Ultimate again. I would also venture a guess that the next game is going to see a new director take control, some rather drastic changes, and will be built from the ground up, effectively serving as a reboot of the franchise, making Ultimate the swan song to Sakurai's Smash. As such, they'll need to start over with a paired down roster to build upon with later entries. I don't know what they could change but I would expect something equivalent to going from MonHun XX to World.

Cutfags are mentally ill. Who the fuck would buy this?

I'd trim pokemon down even more, but I'm also the type of fag to be okay with three DK reps. Bring Megaman back, add Dillon, and maybe Spring.

Actually I'm gonna rescind that, get rid of King boo (what the fuck is that supposed to be a joke?) and add my main back in and I'd buy it with extreme caution only if literally everyone says its fun.

>It is high time
Sakurai literally said Ultimate will be the last time they'll have every character in the roster

Attached: 1558974628503.png (489x531, 497K)

CHOSE YOU MEMES

Attached: th (5).jpg (474x355, 15K)

>source: my tiny peepee

>no Yakuza
SEGA's best IP right now?

based except for misusing infinitesimal.

>tetrominoes
kek don't forget the pong paddles and goku

Do people really think that Sakurai is going to half the size of the roster? Yeah there will be cuts next game, but a majority of the characters will stay (excluding 3rd parties because who knows). I expect the next game to have around the same as Ultimate before DLC or end of Smash 4 in size. Some characters will leave and others will be added. No one likes cuts.

Blessed realistic anticutfag.

Imagine being this stupid.

Master Chief is 1000x more recognisable than Doomguy.

Still too many Fire Emblem characters.

>one fourth of the roster is Mario
I'd rarher have Fire Emblem characters

>cuts Fire Emblem down from 5 to 2
>removes Kid Icarus entirely
>keeps Donkey Kong at 3
>Keeps kirby at 3
>keeps pokemon at 3
>increases mario to 8
Like I know casuals in Yea Forums love super heavies, but come on.

Who's absolutely positively safe from being cut?

The original 12(in theory)
Peach/Daisy
Bowser
Marth/Lucina
Zelda
Ganondorf
Falco
Game and Watch
Sonic
Rosalina
Dedede
Metaknight
Pit/Dark Pit
Palutena
Charizard
Wario
Lucario
Villager
Isabelle

Mewtwo, K. Rool, Inkling and Olimar

Sonic is the only 3rd party rep who for sure is a smash main stay at this point. Everyone else is up in the air.
>tfw banjo legitimately has a higher chance of coming back than Cloud despite being a direct competitor rep

Attached: Sonic rgf.gif (427x239, 1.61M)

Eh not really. But at this point, think its fair to say the next game will probably be a huge clean up on the roster. Full updates for everyone and trimming off those whose fame is dead. Could also mean no 3rd parties from the start.

Only counters I really see to this is that Nintendo (or at least the devs) really doesn't like to milk DLC like other fighers do.

I though I put inkling. not sure how I left them out.

Attached: Young link and woomy.png (1920x1080, 1.54M)

Needs more shillmon. I'd sooner believe CF getting dropped than 0 new pokemon.

>the next Smash is just the original 12 but the game is rebooted as a 3D Arena Brawler

Attached: 1536199929826.jpg (500x538, 41K)

>5 characters
>2 stages (1 battlefield and 1 final destination)
>Melee graphics & physics

Cutfags perfect smash bros game

Jg

pocket camp is also the 3rd nintendo mobile game out of 3

I honestly doubt many people would buy the next smash game if it cut the roster down that much, even if it has good mechanics. Although many more people have come to respect smash as a competitive fighting game in recent years, the majority of people who buy it still buy it for the fan-service and content-filled party game aspects. I think it wouldn’t be profitable to release a new smash game with a roster that small unless 90% of it is new characters. Otherwise why would non-competitive players want to play it rather than the correct version that has more than twice as much content?

>no megaman
>no simon
>no richter
>no pac-man
>but bayo instead

Attached: 1550354005353.png (999x867, 759K)

Terry, then you can add Kyo next game or something

Attached: Terry-with-ukee.gif (67x151, 18K)