Prove me wrong

Because Roy was in melee and people screech over cuts

Roy should definitely be in. Good taste OP.

>roy in should be in
entire list discarded

Keep em all, nobody deserves to leave

I stopped playing Pokemon after HG/SS but Greninja is cool. Also SHIT TIER taste for putting Pac-Man and Mr. Game & Watch in "no one cares".

Lucario should be in his own separate tier called Actively Makes Smash Worse

>Incineroar and Greninja should be in because they'are Pokemon starter, aka Pokemon with big visibility and well liked by a lot of people and should at least be in "some people care" tier
>Roy, Marth and Ike on the other hand are pretty much only still revelant because of Smash, if anything they should get the DQ Hero treatment and become alts of one single characters
>ZSS is only here for the waifubait
>Sheik is not revelant and should be replaced by Impa
>Literally nobody care about ROB except its mains and same for the Ice climbers

Here you go OP. You tier list is shit and biased.

Attached: q56d5qs.png (908x908, 278K)

Honestly I could point to most of this just being your understandable opinions until you get to Cloud being a should be in.

what's with all the roy hate all of a sudden?

Attached: 1497717091503.jpg (400x400, 74K)

I know right? You will never see this hate for Lucina who is much worse.

It's as much proof as you gave.

>you will never see this hate for Lucina
It's right there in the fucking OP

In what world is he a good addition but Robin not? Don't say Melee.

Lucina was actually in a game before Smash.

It is because he is an easy target. He was cut once so people will argue hard to cut him again. To these people they insist people only like Roy for the memes and not legitimate reasons. The attitudes they hold for Roy though will not be held to characters in similar positions. It is a bizzare hatred.

Explain to me why Roy and Ike should be in.

Regardless of this one thread, Lucina typically gets less hate.

Lucina is a cute girl.
That's about it.

>Dark Samus, character from literal best game of all time Metroid Prime shouldn't be in

okay nigger

I don't hate Roy per say, but you're out of youe fucking mind if you think he deserves a spot more than Robin.

cry some more

Attached: C9ovnRsXoAApdRy.jpg (631x536, 55K)

fixed
I might be slightly biased against Miis.

Attached: smash importance tiers.png (797x719, 603K)

>Greninja and Robin shouldn't be in but fucking Roy should because "muh nostalgia"
>the only characters in "no one cares" that actually belong there are Rosalina, WFT and Bowser Jr.

>Clone of Marth
>Wasn't in Brawl
>Only features in a single game
>His game never saw an official western release
>His game isn't very good or even important to the series
>Roy isn't popular outside Smash, ranks as one of the worst lords in the series
>Flat and uninteresting as a character

Really the only Fire Emblem character I'd say deserves to be in there is Marth and only by sake of being the OG and representing the franchise. Fire Emblem is not a franchise that deserves much representation. I'd say 1 or 2 slots total and there are way more deserving characters. Hell his father Eliwood would make more sense than Roy given that he comes from the first game released in the west and even he's not that popular being the worst lord in his own game.

So really Roy's a garbage pick and always has been.

Roy hate has always been a thing, user.
Mostly because Royfags are some of the most obnoxious Smashfags around.

Roy is literally only popular because of his appearance in Melee as "dat cool fire sword guy XD"
I guarantee you that a vast majority of Royfags have never played his game.
I have. He's not even as bad a character as most FEfags will pretend he is, but at the end of the day he's still a boring Marth clone in terms of personality from a game with some questionable design choices.

>ZSS
>Palutena
>Bowser Jr
>Sheik
>Bayo
>Fucking Corrin
>Appreciated

Attached: 4qs65v465qs4dh4.gif (400x206, 1.76M)

If I had to reduce the FE reps down to two fighters I'd go with Marth and Robin myself sorry Ikefags.
Robin just brings too many iconic Fire Emblem concepts and mechanics with him (magic, item durability, his position as a tactician), he's probably the best representation FE has ever had in Smash outside of the og Lord himself, and I struggle to think of a better non-Marth FE rep aside from Anna.

>Implying that the most popular character in the Fire Emblem series shouldn't be in

Attached: C-RhZYNW0AQvZMi (1).png (1000x904, 545K)

Would "Shit but it could be worse (see: the below tier)" be a better tier name?

Attached: 20181213_171044.png (960x534, 420K)

how about everyone should be in and you should stop being a whiny faggot, OP

>Most popular FE character
>Game sold so poorly that it almost killed the series
Explain this Ikefags.

Attached: fe lords.png (1022x422, 321K)

Just rename the tier into "Characters that don't HAVE to be in" and fuse it with the "Chopping block" tier. They're pretty much the same with a none biased view.

We shouldn't judge people based on the mistakes of their ancestors

smash is fucking trash, go back to your general

Nah, I think there is a pretty clear divide between characters like Corrin who kind of don't really deserve to be in but at least bring something to the table, and Roy who brings absolutely nothing by being in Smash aside from appeasing some autist's double standards.

Remove all Fire Emblem characters period. Shit series that never drew a dime. Fuck them all.

I don't hate Roy, but I don't know how someone can make a chart like that and somehow place him in the "should be in" tier, when he's just a bland clone of Marth, and is 100% culturally irrelevant outside of bandwagoneers who just cling on to him because he was "marth but with fire" in melee when everyone was 13.

Hey fuck you, I care about Meta Knight

>Toon Link
I care enough that I wouldn't have bought the game if he was cut

Fuck off fatty.

Attached: hle3aysa7wk11.jpg (2048x1591, 204K)

Then you should probably at least move Greninja, Incineroar and Maybe PPlant from one tier, since they fit your Corrin description.

>His game isn't very good or even important to the series
This isn't the time or place to discuss this but I just had to stop by and tell you that you're wrong. FE6 is one of the best games in the series to play at its higher difficulty as a ranked run.

I don't care about any of them, I just play the game because it's fun.

There's a ton of changes I would make to this too, like half of the characters in your second tier don't belong there and by putting them in the fourth tier for some reason you are actually implying that Inkling and Villager are more iconic than Simon and Ryu, which is retarded on its face

Not to mention a lot of them are pretty similar. At least with the Pokémon they got lots of different moves and a wide range of body shapes so I can get why they have so many reps. But fire emblem fighters just all look the same.

Joker shouldnt be in. Belmonts should.

Miis are fun man, piss off

>implying that Inkling and Villager are more iconic than Simon and Ryu
Which is true.

Everyone is saying Roy is a Marth clone, but he doesn't feel like a Marth clone. He's more like a Mario/Luigi than a Dark Pit/Pit

Fuck off joker nigger. Roy belongs, Joker does not.

Dumb faggots. Roy and Marth are the only FEs that should be in

>Half of the characters that shouldn't be in are echoes
Who gives a shit? They don't even have to take up space on the screen if you don't want them to

I care about both dedede and meta knight, but if they cut meta-knight for waddle dee (generic) or dark matter, I could understand.

cutfags are mentally ill

Attached: Banjo and Kazooie.png (500x500, 232K)

prove me wrong

Attached: FACTS.png (1020x856, 538K)

Roy started the trend of unwanted Fire Emblem promo rep and should be axed for that reason alone.