What features was RDR2 lacking?

I liked it , but I tink these ideas would have helped, seeing as we wanted most of it anyway

>Random robbery events like in 1, with cowboys shooting up the town. As is theres hardly any shootouts in towns without missions
>Bring gang members with us
You mean to tell me we have 20+ gang members but I have to rob trains myself? It was pure lazyness not add in the ability to travel with John, Sean, or the others
>Tap based melee blocking as opposed to "hurr hold down this button"
Mindnumbingly easy, ffxv tier shit. At least its animated nicely
>Patrons should actually matter in bars
I'm tired of seeing the same 5 people gambling at the same table, I want to be NPCs to be able to sit down at any table in saloons to gamble with various games not exclusive to poker, so you never know what you'll be doing or at what table and who with
>More gun duels
They added the ability to challenge people to duels by slowly pressing in R2 but it only equates to murder and the law always gets involved.
>Prostitutes
Why cut them out all the sudden? 2019 too progressive for you anymore rockstar?

For a game with a lot of attention to detail, it seems like they really forced a few aspects to be too linear and it really suffers from it.
Hopefully RDR3 will have improvements if it happens

Attached: Red_Dead_Redemption_II.jpg (284x350, 26K)

Let us take the train ride and look out the window. I’m amazed they didn’t have this considering they were so focused on immersion

one word
replayability

At least you can hitch rides at any wagon, thats pretty fuckin comfy

You think these production values and quality of life critiques are bad? Cyberpunk world won't even come close to having these kind of interactions, yet it won't be called out for it.

I dunno, I still think the game has tons and tons of replayability, its just lacking. I've already beat it 3 times now and none of my playthroughs have been similar outside of the story.
I recommend disabling the hud 100% after the first playthrough and it will force you into fun situations you missed before

Um the game has prostitutes.... Arthur just doesn't engage with them because of mary and eliza

Yes, it will be called out for it. And I love the current state of RDR2, I'm just autistic and cant enjoy things without noticing what they lack

How long does E3 go on for and is rockstar doing a thing? I want to know if this is coming to pc already

Let us control the horse with just the analog stick and steering with the camera. Tired of tapping/holding X

Thats a pretty dumb way of justifying is considering Michael and Franklin of GTA 5 both had love interests too but we had the ability. This was R* trying not to anger its now super mainstream audience, and thats terrible.

You really mean to tell me an arthur that slept with whores and talked down on himself after doesn't 100% fit his character?

there are only two endings and the epilogue has one, which is also a total slog to play through. at least GTAV made up for it's shitty story in fun but there isn't much reason to play everyday because it's so limited

I think e3 ends on the 13 and probably not, we might hear about gta6 next year

I would like to see cooking expanded. Let us cook stews and stuff at our own camp

You can, you just gallop at 75% speed. You tap to go to 100, but yes you can do what you said. Just dont be such a zoomer and spur your horse constantly, I reserve sprinting my horse for shootouts

You can tell they were going to but it got cut, theres 2 kinds of campfires and you can only cook seasoned meats on the fire with a griddle. I would have loved stew pots and baking

No cars to steal

No, theres 4 endings. One you knife fight micah and he kills you, One you knife fight micah and you kick his ass leaving him scarred. One you fist fight micah and you equally fuck eachother up. One you fight micah and he canoes your ass with a pistol

You had me going there.

Tbh I would have FUCKING LOVED a funny stranger mission you get smashed in a bar and jump in a random prototype model t that forces you to swerve like GTA 5 drunk driving while you escape lawmen on foot and arthur has no idea what the fuck hes driving until he crashes

I mean arthur had his son and spouse killed which he never got over plus obviously had a more personal connection to mary to the point of trying to change for her and leaving the gang showing more commitment. Dunno why you're trying to compare micheal and franklin's situation when they were vastly different.

if rockstar added a feature where I could discard unwanted guns l would go back and play this shit forever.

As it stands now, cinematic mode sucks. We should be able to just set it to normal third person view, or to rotate the camera any way we want. This should should have been patched months ago.

more freedom
less walk and talk
actual survival mechanics

I don't think I've ever seen a western where a man doesn't lose his family and end up sleeping with prostitutes, even Wyatt Earp. It doesn't fit the setting or situation. IMO I think it was taken out