Left or right

This

Sadly new doom will keep the generic weapons.

nudoom has too many weapons
why is there a railgun, a machinegun and why do you get the chaingun at the end of the game
if you're going about trimming the fat why do you need a shotgun when a super shotgun exists

Right by far, the only thing Painkiller has going for it is the interesting weapons the rest of the game is shit. Biggest issue is simplistic enemies with dumb as rocks AI and few attacks that dont work with the fast movement the player can do. Bosses are terrible too. Doom on the other hand actually does something decent with the style and makes mobile aggressive enemies that actively chase you down and have melee and ranges attacks they alternate between, along with a variety of ranged attacks none of which are hitscan. Painkiller could have benefitted from dropping its enemy variety and focusing on just a few solid enemy types.

>Why is there 2 shotguns in a game well known for having 2 shotguns

Are you retarded?

At least the original Doom's shotgun could be used at longer ranges. nuDoom's regular shotgun is just as weak and ineffective at range as any modern FPS shotgun.

>just because the old game made a mistake we should continue that

Your whore mother made a mistake but we continue you.

neither
max payne

painkiller feel like a shittier serious sam

This, nu doom has nothing that's close to being as cool as the stake gun.
And I'll take Painkiller's quake lite bunny hops over Doom's conslow shit anytime.

All three

Attached: 1511319140798.png (1500x1333, 1.72M)