>Sequel A: Structurally identical to the first game but focuses on refinement, if you wanted more of the same (but better) then this is for you, the only real flaw is it’s lack of originality
>Sequel B: Takes the game in a different direction while trying many new things, doesn’t necessarily get all of them right but stands unique from the previous game and ultimately provides a unique experience
Anytime a sequel does A, I always end up liking the first game more. At least with B, it could end up outdoing the original.
Benjamin Smith
A if I liked the first game, B if I didn't.
Eli Murphy
A
Liam Rogers
Most of the greatest games of all time are A
Jaxon Ross
Don't ever bring this up in front of me again.
I fucking hate Final Fantasy. Starting from XIII it has been nothing but disappointment after utter disappointment with Square Enix telling us "this new one is going to be SO good it will BLOW YOUR MIND"
yeah fuckin' right Square Enix... You can only lie to me so many fucking times before I've had enough
Zachary Wilson
Sequel A: Super Mario Galaxy 2 Ocarina of Time Twilight Princess Metal Gear Solid 2 Dark Souls 3 Resident Evil 2
Sequel B: Super Mario Sunshine Majora’s Mask Breath of the Wild Metal Gear Solid 3 Sekiro Resident Evil 4
Alexander Stewart
B followed by A for third/fourth game for perfect mix
Brayden Green
Sequel B.
Thomas Carter
You'll eventually have to accept that the Final Fantasy franchise will end up just like the Simpsons. In the end, there will be more bad games than good ones.
Jackson Bailey
Why not save A for true sequels and B for spinoffs or games set in the same setting?
Oliver Turner
B. It's why I like the Xenoblade series so much. Each game feels fresh and unique and tries new things, some of which works, some of which doesn't, but it doesn't really matter because you can be sure the next game will be different.
Aaron Jenkins
B is why Paper Mario and Chibi Robo are now dead so I will take A
Samuel Young
Definately A. B is just the devs shitting ont eh original product.
Leo Ross
A every time.
Jose Lopez
Sequel B is almost always the better option because then you have two worthwhile games instead of one that's just a better version of the other.
Oliver Hall
A has the possible outcome of just being inferior to it's predecessor despite looking better. if it's a sequel it has to introduce new shit and have a different plot, if all that sucks it could completely break what made the first game good.
David Barnes
Which one is portal 2?
Kayden Rivera
Sequel A usually results in the best entry in the series, so I'm going with that.
I’d say A. It introduces a lot of new mechanics but it’s still the same base idea. You could introduce the new puzzle gimmicks in the first and they wouldn’t have felt particularly out of place.