What is the greatest MMORPG of all time?

The only thing that could make the list more accurate is if there were something below 'shit tier' to put XIV in.

>GW1 in shit tier
>GW2 in okay tier
bait

MMOs are pretty much always shit. I have nostalgia for Runescape but I realize it's not actually a good game, and I just didn't like WoW even though I played it around the same age.

I guess the best one is one with actually good real-time combat like Dragon's Dogma Online, but that game still has its problems, and you need a VPN and a pretty barebones translation patch to even play it outside of Nippon.

I miss my ls

Attached: 1458447549737.jpg (693x492, 100K)

Alright fuckos, be honest with me. Where does my precious, beaten-by-EA baby place?

Attached: 823572638.jpg (570x346, 40K)

Where's runescape?

Attached: download (1).jpg (197x256, 4K)

>not even including Runescape
This list is shit tier

OSRS Shaggy-blanco tier

up in elder god tier
OSRS, that is

>no FFXI or OG Everquest
>WoW in top tier
OP confirmed for casual.

after playing vermintide and warhammer total war I want there to be a good warhammer mmo so bad, but then I remember this game being just kinda meh

Attached: 1546224912541.png (900x1200, 407K)

Star Trek online
>shit tier
Fuck off WoW babby.

I love the Star Trek universe but good god the gameplay on STO. It's autoshoot with 3 classes.

>mid tier
ESO

fuck no.
1 expansion
2 paid Dungeon packs
1 paid Zone pack
tons of cashshop bs

>VANILLA
>FUCKING VANILLA WOW
WotLK was the best expansion, only BC fags would deny this. Also
>FFXIV
>shit tier
Neck yourself, please.

Attached: 1549598787845.png (500x500, 99K)

WILDSTAR

>all these pve babby themepark games

Zoomers lmao

Imagine being this much of a casual that you think WOTLK and FF14 are good games

The best MMOs are FFXI followed by Guild Wars (pre nightfall) followed by World of Warcraft the burning crusade

*Ahem*

Attached: 235729386.png (341x206, 100K)

Where do we put the patrician’s MMORPG, lads?

Attached: D4DEB3F1-F087-44FD-8F9B-CBD295CA35A4.jpg (413x232, 63K)

OP is a child because he has Wizard 101 on the list at all. Be it ironically or otherwise.

I don't know anything about that guy other than that he's an eceleb, but he has good taste for wanting FFXI back Yes, I know it is still around and run by a skeleton crew, but the game itself is a fucking wasteland at this point.

>wowshitter
yikes

Shit tier.

I'm sad I missed this game when it was live.

I played Wizard101 when it came out. I was 10. I'm a graduate student now sooo...

The secret world was a great experience for as long as you don't run out of content
The endgame was pretty bad but it had a lot of very fun and creative quest and a really cool story to get immersed into
Also the boss mechanics were really cool and every boss felt different, especially in nightlmare

>someone unironically defending The Secret World
what

Attached: 1557289420900.jpg (750x1071, 416K)

That's the worst zoomer tierlist I've ever seen

>No Ultima
>No OSRS
Shit list.

>calling people casual
>plays MMO
Imagine being this much of a nigger faggot.

Defend it from what ? It had issues, but it also had a lot of very enjoyable content. I don't give a fuck if you couldn't appreciate it, go collect your bear asses.

Better question, what's an MMO you wish could be revived/remade?
I miss Warhammer Online and I wish it hadn't been so fucking mishandled.

>EQ2
>DDO
>Lineage
>Zoomer
Sooo you're just a little zoom who's trying to look big for the older kids. You realize you don't have a username and karma score on reddit right? You're not getting any upboats and gold

Attached: 064.gif (326x281, 171K)

Woah, ninja is based??
Secret world is fantastic if you don't have ADHD and can read. Otherwise you're going to spend all your time looking up puzzle solutions and meta builds.

Mabinogi just got a server merge and holy shit I thought this game was dead and I'm on the server that didn't get merged.

Attached: 1540962297791.png (1352x705, 2.24M)

>Better question, what's an MMO you wish could be revived/remade?

Lord of the Rings Online. It needs a modern polish and a buy-to-play or subscription model, not pay-to-win. Middle Earth is too cool of a world to be represented by LotRO even if it's good.

>wow anywhere other than absolute garbage tier

Lineage 2 was miles better.

damn, fpbp
;_;
>up to Aht Uhrgan
>le 75 cap maymay
higher level skills is what made PUP awesome, and fuck RDM being best healer because MP refresh was so powerful

lotro has great world building and ambience, but it has the worst kind of tab combat and crafting is a complete joke

WoW is and always has been absolute shit tier garbage

drop dead

>No EQ1
>No Asheron's Call
>No UO
>No T4C
Complete fucking zoomercore games, don't even @ me kid if all you got is your insecurity and projection

EQ1 or Shadowbane. I would argue EQ1 personally.

>No EQ1
>No Asheron's Call
>No UO
>No T4C
Why would anyone play those when WoW was out

Attached: GarfieldCharacter.jpg (1024x1595, 218K)

Shadowbane is way too clunky

they're all better games without exception

>tfw Age of Conan 1-20
Was there a bigger bait and switch?

Lol no ultima online? Dumb fuck

OSRS should be God tier
Runescape 3 in mid tier, the quests are fun still

>the secret world
>shit tier
fuck you faggot i liked it, mid tier at least
also
>no EVE
better put that shit right next to WoW classic or you're a fucking retard

Attached: cartoon-jameson-2135.jpg (400x300, 32K)

If you didn't play this gem during its golden years you might as well kill yourself right now.

Attached: tibia.jpg (1024x712, 162K)

OSRS

Attached: hudon btfo.png (518x846, 237K)

ESO, no question. It's the perfect balance of simplicity and complexity while remaining fun.

Fixed that shit chart for you OP.

Attached: 1540137683969.png (1420x1684, 1.88M)

Early 2000's Graal Online.

Attached: 1446705077308.png (1432x844, 238K)

Ultima Online.

Please kill yourself, ESO is basically a solo game with how ZoS treats it and the end game balance is fucking awful.
>Dragonknights really the only good tanks with some Warden OT and NB MT meme builds thrown in.
>Templar/Warden so supremely ahead of the other healers.
>Weapons determine playstyle more than class so everything plays the same across a given role.
>90% of the sets are useless
>1 raid a year if that
>Most builds use 3-5 of the same skills across the board and ultimates are even worse in terms of balance.
ESO is for solo players which shouldn't be your target audience in a fucking MMORPG.

This. The only problem with non theme park MMOs is they're usually a grind. Much of the game ends up being devising a procedure for max output and gains, and waiting while that happens.

Runescape circa 2006-2010
OSRS is good but not the same heights

Attached: vinicius-bortoletto-fishing.jpg (1546x2000, 647K)

Tibia

Dying had severe consequences, pvp was global except in player owned houses and temples and depots, there were guild wars that drained the server's economy and resources and it was intense as fuck.

DAoC and GW

Your scheme is obvious, WoWFag.
>make list
>put nostalgia game at the top
>put game currently beating WoW at the bottom
>throw in some other random games just to try and disguise your intention

Your tricks wont get past me.

pay armor or hunted

Damn bro, can't really disagree with that. Stam Necro has been pretty fun though and playing in a guild over solo is a lot better because the PVP/Dungeons can get intense. I'm just dying for a new ES game honestly and this has been a good filler until then.

>WOW BFA
>okay tier
good god user, did you fall and hit your head?
3 would be god tier if they actually pushed out more quests and weren't relentless shilling p2w shit to get the whales to open their wallets
and they wonder why osrs has 4 times the people

>Forgetting elder god tier Club Penguin
Repent boomer

Attached: 1531419796063.jpg (900x1020, 154K)

>no Dofus
Shit list

Pre-RE Ragnarok Online

I've never been one for MMOs but Secret World really did it for me.

Pre Big-Bang Maplestory.

Attached: maxresdefault.jpg (1280x720, 188K)

WoWfags are a massive embarrassment to this board.

I just assumed it was an average representation for retail post-vanilla
It's the only way it makes sense

Where are my DAoC chads

>GOD TIER
pre cata wow
eve online
OSRS
star wars galaxies
final fantasy 11
>GOOD TIER
elder scrolls online
guild wars
final fantasy 14
black desert online
city of heros
ultima online
>OKAY TIER
rift
the secret world
everquest 2
wow post cata
lord of the rings online
star trek online
warhammer online
>SHIT TIER
the old republic
DC universe online
TERA
aion
age of conan

Attached: Consider-The-Following.jpg (718x718, 69K)

EvE: Online

>everyone forgetting Wildstar

reeeeeee

Attached: 1559695289236 (1).webm (960x540, 2.48M)

If it was such a good MMO then why did it shut down?

Attached: 711.png (172x211, 32K)

I remember my mom not buying me a sub so I'd have to go collect hearts every time I logged in. good times.

replace eve online with tibia and ur list is doable

>That list

Animals like you should be thrown in a cage

Attached: 1554229525842.jpg (641x481, 50K)

Ultima.

is the game even worth getting into now? i really wanna try out runefencer and geomancer.

>Secret World Legends
I WILL NEVER NOT BE MAD

Attached: 1413584700072.gif (203x199, 222K)

Pirates of the Caribbean Online

Now? hell no, I already said the game is a fucking wasteland. Unless you have 3+ other friends to play with, don't bother.

>Everquest 2 included but not EQ1
EQ2 was trash and EQ1 is literally top 3 of all time
>No Ultima Online
IMMEDIATELY invalidated post. This list is actually funny and if you're not trolling you should unironically kys.

Because WoW literally wasn't out yet when UO and EQ1 were big you fucking retard?

Sooo... you are literally a child.

How is DQX?

Attached: 1535936778825.png (680x549, 22K)

>no ragnarok online in good tier
>no EVE in god tier if you have autism

>the lore and stories are fantastic
that would mean something if this were an rpg thread

>What is the greatest MMORPG of all time?
>the greatest MMORPG of all time?
>greatest MMORPG of all time?
>MMORPG
>RPG

It was always trash from the very start, people only even gave a single fuck because of the girl in your webm and the game came out and her model was way off what the preview was, which wasn't even anything special in the first place

take your porn bait game and go

eve

Attached: EVE Online.gif (350x184, 1.96M)

man where i can get a fucking guide

City of Heroes. Villains was great too

Any of u fags played neverwinter i rly liked it till the newest mod killed it.

it's almost as if they're different genres with similar names but vastly dissimilar expectations

Friends are your guide

The wiki was great until they changed it, now its hard to find shit on that site and have to type out anything you're looking for.

>what are subgenres

>Guild Wars 2 better than the original
Bait.

>lotro
>d&do
Shit taste.

this