If Melee was indeed the last Smash game as Sakurai planned, would you have been satisfied with this roster?

If Melee was indeed the last Smash game as Sakurai planned, would you have been satisfied with this roster?

Attached: Melee Roster.png (384x275, 249K)

No because melee was broken and half those characters would've been non-viable.

Hell no.

Needs Banjo & Joanna since Rare released two Nintendo games that year

Replace Isaac with Villager from Animal Crossing
Replace Anna with Saki from Advance Wars
Replace Snake with Captain Falcon

The actual Melee roster is better

very

Nice try Issac fag

Eevee's a really shit pick but that's pretty solid overall.

>No Rare anything, not even just Banjo
Based retard

No, because Smash was about Nintendo All-Stars back then. Many of those characters are neither Nintendo nor All-Stars.

>Terra
>Not based Bartz

Attached: CMuta21VAAAJ2Nl.jpg (769x1000, 116K)

> Isaac
Too new retards

> Implying Ness, Dr. Mario Captain Falcon, Marth, Roy and Pichu are All-Stars
Neck yourself

>Only one SEGA rep

Where's Captain Falcon?

Anna's a poor choice.Tiki would be my personal pick.

>Terra and Chrono
>over Cloud
Okay retard

>Cloud
>over Kain

>Anna
>In Melee
At this point the series, she had only run shops and bookmarked the player's game.

If another unique FE character were in Melee, it would be Sigurd, Leif, or another Akaneia character.

FF6 & Chrono Trigger are the most acclaimed RPGs ever, and were Nintendo exclusives at the time. FF7 is Sony shit & doesn't belong in Smash

This roster is overall great, but i would cut Sheik and add meta knight

Animal Crossing was way too recent at that point to get a rep.

>FF7 is Sony shit & doesn't belong in Smash
Obviously Nintendo doesn't think so.
>FF6 & Chrono Trigger are the most acclaimed RPGs ever
Being "acclaimed" isn't a metric.

Nintendo wanted Terra but Cloud was more iconic so Sakurai added him