Is STILL the best sonic game ever made

It's not better than any of the games that came before it aside from the game gear ones (and even then, I'd rather play Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine over SA2). It's also not better than most of the ones that came after it.

Attached: Sonic 2D wins.png (942x526, 1.1M)

>t.projared
>t.pedophile

Attached: 1545969378147.png (491x494, 209K)

i preferred SA1 more. The fun parts of that game weren't held hostage by shitty mech scenes and treasure hunting with a busted radar for padding.

I played Sa2 first when i was a kid and when i tried 1 i was shocked that i could do all of sonics levels in one go, then i get to play remixed versions of them with a character with unique movement options (tails), and superior treasure hunting with knuckles.

But i feel Sa2 had a much "cooler' vibe. Also the chao garden was great. I first only played the chao garden casually, but there was alot of depth if you were into breeding and optimization.

Yet i feel Sa1 has better music, more variety in the aesthetics, and just a more faithful recreation of the classic formula in 3d. It delivers on the brand promise of speed and platforming as the core of the game, with the other stuff just being accessories, as opposed to the main course.

Because Sega doesn't know what to do with sonic nor what made the adventure games cool. Yeah the story was B tier but they had their charm.

Well yeah. That's why I said "it's not even better", implying that it isn't a high standard

How many Japanese are left in the development of sonic games and story?

SA1 has
>better level design
>better music
And most importantly
>a better controlling Sonic

It's not even a competition, niggers only praise 2 because muh epic shounen plot and the expanded Chao garden features.
Get fucked.

This.

SA2 is very flawed in basically everything aside from music, story and coolness. There are games that did a lot better, like Generations having better gameplay, Runners having better music, Forces did alternate characters better...

But SA2 still has the best story and coolness and that elevates the experience. It feels like a complete package instead of a level pack with excuse plot and nostalgia.

I like Generations, Colors, SA1, Forces more in terms of pure gameplay, but I respect SA2 so much. Even Spark the Electric Jester 2 did 3D Sonic gameplay better than SA2. But SA2 simply is epic.

Attached: 1495768327493.jpg (605x340, 28K)

wheres the hee hee in your shitty game?

Attached: SONIC.jpg (800x1140, 211K)

that's its only issue, but the level design mostly makes up for it

SA2's plot is nonsense

>To get into space, Sonic and co for some reason break into Eggman's base and use a rocket that was there the whole time that Eggman somehow never thought to get rid of since he had the teleporter anyway
>people mistaking sonic for shadow at all
>the whole prison island sequence being laughably inconsistent about where Shadow is
>He doesn't just immediately Chaos Control to where Rouge is trapped
>Master Emerald shards somehow exploded across the entire world and into space from Knuckles punching it once
>Why didn't they just make 7 artificial emeralds and go super sonic the whole trip
etc etc etc

Even as a kid I was scratching my head over some of this stuff

Because Sega isn't in the console market anymore so they stopped trying.

Sonic Heroes was better.

Attached: Amy gay 1558540843282.png (600x600, 517K)

>It would be hard to get rid of a rocket, especially when GUN wasn't far off from where Eggman's secret base was.
>A 3'3 super fast hedgehog known to change colors and forms has stolen a chaos emerald. Who else could it be?
>Emeralds are known to scatter often, like the chaos emeralds did in Sonic 1, it's not far off to assume a similar thing could happen to the Master Emerald shards
>Artifical emeralds are not powerful enough to turn sonic super

It did a long time ago with this gem.

Attached: 220px-Sonic_unleashed_boxart.jpg (220x275, 23K)

>To get into space, Sonic and co for some reason break into Eggman's base and use a rocket that was there the whole time that Eggman somehow never thought to get rid of since he had the teleporter anyway
Rockets are pretty universal.
>people mistaking sonic for shadow at all
It was dark.
>the whole prison island sequence being laughably inconsistent about where Shadow is
This game hides time skips. This is why there are such gems like "You will tell me where Sonic and Tails are!" and one second later Tails is in the room.
>He doesn't just immediately Chaos Control to where Rouge is trapped
No Chaos Emeralds nearby.
>Master Emerald shards somehow exploded across the entire world and into space from Knuckles punching it once
They didn't. They ended up on ARK because Knuckles can't drive shuttle, shuttle opened and Master Emerald pieces fell off.
>Why didn't they just make 7 artificial emeralds and go super sonic the whole trip
Tails had only yellow Chaos Emerald and he made a yellow copy. Maybe he needs all 7 to make all 7 fakes.

Attached: hqdefault.jpg (480x360, 20K)

>>people mistaking sonic for shadow at all
He looks a lot like Super Sonic which everybody saw, only his palette is different and Sonic might as well be a chameleon anyways

>>Master Emerald shards somehow exploded across the entire world and into space from Knuckles punching it once
The shards only got into space because Sonic dumped them from the rocket's cargo hold like a dumbass

>>Why didn't they just make 7 artificial emeralds and go super sonic the whole trip
Because the artificial emeralds are clearly inferior. Eggman wanted nothing to do with the artificial one and Sonic didn't think he could use it to chaos control, why would he be able to use artificial emeralds to go super sonic?

Don't remember the rest of what you posted

Attached: tierlist3.png (596x496, 500K)

Google "Sonic the Sissyhog"

Still need some ideas

>people mistaking sonic for shadow at all
maybe GUN didnt mistake shadow for sonic. Remember that they knew exactly who shadow was (they had him captive). They may have said to the media that it was sonic because they wanted to cover up shadows existence.
this is a gud vid: youtube.com/watch?v=1ZJuLcakn3Y

Attached: dress up.jpg (680x499, 69K)

>Not including the Master System/Game Gear games
Other than that, move Advance 2 and Heroes up to C and it's good.

Attached: 88763-Sonic_The_Hedgehog_-_Triple_Trouble_(USA,_Europe)-6.png (394x283, 27K)

Obviously.
youtube.com/watch?v=PVv-5Y3jZmI

Say what you want about it's many, many flaws, but it's got the best opening level in video game history.

Attached: 6hetn9id4ad01 (2).gif (800x600, 144K)

what

>lagunitas ipa
What?

awful, awful list. you're a fucking idiot and should feel ashamed of yourself

Fuck off zoomer, Heroes sucks

Attached: 1496732059782.png (648x1231, 555K)

I honestly hate our timeline.

thats not sonic cd

thiswasn't meant for you but the other guy

colors and generations was a better game, but I will admit sa2 sonic still controls the best and has the best levels

>peak of Sonic's coolness
I guess I agree. Every other game felt too childish/cartoony or edgy/serious

I rate sonic games by music and level ambiance

whatever game you'll try to pull up will be automatically inferior

>I rate sonic games by music and level ambiance

Attached: 1499153776402.jpg (2000x1333, 348K)

>sonic cd
>good

>music
Not him, but you're lying if you don't think City Escape was fucking awesome when Adventure 2 was released.

Anyone who spouts soul and soulless when it comes to Sonic needs to be gassed desu

Lizuka puts his soul into everything

Attached: 1506773929039.jpg (900x1200, 138K)

No, I agree, SA2 has great music. Better than Heroes that's for sure. I mean Heroes has good music, I don't hate it or anything, but it's far from the best in the franchise.

SA2 level design is very straight forward compared to SA1.

>Lizuka
*raughs in japanese*

Attached: Untitled.jpg (334x404, 43K)

>people mistaking sonic for shadow at all
The only explanation for this is that Shadow's original design was supposed to be closer to Sonic's. When they finalized Shadow's design they didn't bother changing that aspect of the story.

I find it amusing when people come up with these elaborate headcanons to explain holes in a plot that clearly didn't have a whole lot of thought put into it in the first place. Kinda wish the Sonic fanbase was more like the Resident Evil one where they're openly aware of how dumb most of the writing is and instead enjoy it for its schlockiness.

Attached: 1529096301446.png (1130x667, 774K)

Oh, definitely, SA2 is the definition of nostalgia. SA2 is not a good game, half of it is pretty damn bad. Chao and the Sonic stages are the only reason people like it.

you wanna fight fag?

youtube.com/watch?v=QHfRLg_JDsc
youtube.com/watch?v=j5Sj7lwwDAM

youtube.com/watch?v=6zYH0dlRcVk
youtube.com/watch?v=gZXjeLE7cFg

youtube.com/watch?v=pj0JwHQer_c
youtube.com/watch?v=E9B9Fvr1ehw

>Gravure Idol who likes Sonic and Undertale
>Doesn't get involved with Fandom Drama

>tfw I loved the Mech stages as well as the hunti ng and racing ones

SA2 is one of my favorite games ever

Sorry but SA2 just has the better OST. Live and Learn is better than Sonic Heroes. Supporting Me is better than What I'm Made Of.

Sonic 2 has the best cover art prove me wrong.

I like it but it made me think Robotnik had a beard and black eyes as a kid

youtube.com/watch?v=VRUdjM6-iR8
youtube.com/watch?v=yGNygDghZAI
youtube.com/watch?v=evtQMowXsUY

youtube.com/watch?v=KbAhyOWRCqw
youtube.com/watch?v=BCs5SGdfbH0
youtube.com/watch?v=tfIVPnbcDtg

Attached: 1516316212969.jpg (623x414, 133K)

why is there no part 2 wtf

Colors
Generations
SA
SA2
Unleashed day time

Don't @ me, top 5 3d games, including shadow, heroes etc

>Concept Shadow is literally just black Sonic
>Real Shadow is literally just black Super Sonic
Gee I wonder how people in universe could ever mistake shadow for sonic

>tfw I love everything about Heroes' presentation, music, and environments, but absolutely hate the gameplay, level design, and in-level chatter
I kinda feel the same way about Colors, except I can stomach the gameplay and level design and Eggman's PA announcements are great.

Attached: 1543209568577.jpg (162x164, 4K)

and the peak of the series' kino

Attached: not - 1539913585628 - shadow.png (687x1800, 1.72M)

Attached: 1506580016111.jpg (1920x1080, 432K)

Sonic Battle was better

tfw no adventure 3 or "sonic journey"

it's funny how the characters had to talk over each other only because of localization constraints, but that actually kind of made the dialogue feel more organic. You know, since people talk over each other in real life too

damn she cute

user we've been over this a hundred times. Sonic Adventure 2 is a horrible game. It's fucking shit. It was never a good game, you're just nostalgic for it. Stop with this shit. It's one of the worst games ever made.

Sonic 06 could've surpassed it if it was finished.

wtf what's wrong with marvel u wanna square up

this

Those are Disney movies made for children. Are you a child, user? Do you enjoy your pretend fantasies of beating up the bully, having everyone love you and getting the damsel in distress?

That can apply to any old game