Was he right, Yea Forums?
Also SMT thread
Was he right, Yea Forums?
Ryan Baker
Xavier Gonzalez
Persona 3 being under 4 and 5 makes this list instantly fucking retarded.
Christian Gutierrez
You literally made the same thread again, it’ll die the same way as before.
David Russell
Why put in the shitty Persona and spinoff games? This is retarded.
Benjamin Howard
Persona makes a fair amount of sense at least, Catherine is the real head scratcher
Andrew Perry
If Persona is removed then everything that isn't Mainline SMT would have to be removed as well, otherwise you're just being inconsistent
Aaron Sullivan
no
next thread
Jack Perez
>right opinions
Makes me just wonder why:
>DDS2 dropped 2 ranks
>IVA dropped three ranks - I guess anime plot would warrant it, but not with P4 as a first place
Logan Taylor
>4 better than Apocalypse
Joseph Price
>Nocturne not in a tier of its own
>Persona 4 anywhere above 3 when it was a step down in every aspect other than level design
>P3P not even on the tier list because he's a salty vanilla 4 fag
>Devil Survivor 2 over 1 while both being lower than Persona games
>Strange Journey being lower than Persona games
>Persona spinoffs anywhere above garbage despite being trash tier in their respective genres
>>>>>>>>>>Catherine
This man doesn't love SMT. Fuck this nigga, I'm mad.
Austin Martinez
No.
But I am.
Aaron Barnes
>Persona 4 and 5 above 5
>Nocturne behind Catherine
Yikes!
Cameron Brooks
>FES better than P3P
Away with you, shitter.
Jaxon Smith
Where they are on the rank doesn't mean anything, the letters are the only thing that matters.
>he likes P3 but gimped in every way simply because he can play as a girl
Samuel Thompson
The girl had much better social links than the guy.
Eli Wilson
Switch SJ for DESU and EP for P3 and youll have a decent list
Cameron Thompson
>SOUL Hackers first
G O D L Y T A S T E
Ayden Howard
It's better in nearly every way that isn't gameplay
Jayden Wright
That doesn't excuse it being a butchered demake
Hudson Kelly
>P4 and P5 on top
Wyatt Roberts
>Unironically thinking Nocturne is the end all be off of the franchise
>P4 is a step down when it actively improved the gameplay or at least returned to form after P3's bizarre choices
>hating on Catherine
Jose Brown
the true patrician list
Bentley Cox
and gameplay is the most important part of any game
Jace Jones
I feel like I'm the only person who actually played the snes games. The first one is very lonely.
Owen Jackson
What version of Strange Journey should I play?
Tyler Jackson
>Persona 4 had the best characters and music
>Persona 5 had the best aesthetic and gameplay
>Persona 3 had.... ???????
Asher Smith
I personally like raidou 1 more but this pretty based
Adam Powell
Persona 3 had best characters, music, aesthetic and gameplay
Austin Young
>P4
>best characters
Brody Howard
But the gameplay in P2 sucks
Ryan Scott
>Gimped in ever
>Direct Control is completely optional
>knockdown changes ended up not changing shit because it's a boss heavy game
>added gameplay content that wasn't complete garbage along with another superboss
>VN style also changed nothing because P3 is practically a visual novel outside tartarus to begin with
>NG+ doesn't force the player with Aigis in the ending
You didn't even play the game.
Kevin Richardson
SMT 1 is great. The atmosphere is top notch and the characters are great as well. Its less accessible since there aren't many official English versions but and there are no press turns but it deserves more love
Jack Evans
>best combat
>best S-Links
>best characters
>best story
>best Reaper
>by far the best music
If Tartarus looked and sounded nicer before hitting the fifth block, then it would've been hailed as the best of the three by far.
John Carter
>can't control party members
>dungeons are all procgen bullshit
>actively cut down elements from previous games
You have to be real deluded to think the dogshit P3 offers is the best gameplay
Hunter White
>Any Persoyna game anywhere above C
No, he is not.
Chase Bell
>SMT IV that high
>P4 vanilla over golden
Yikes and nopilled
Nicholas Rodriguez
>VN style also changed nothing because P3 is practically a visual novel outside tartarus to begin with
Now I know you haven’t played the original, just compare any important story scene from the original to p3p and in every single occasion p3p is much worse, like look at the persona awakening, p3p has none of the impact
Elijah Rogers
Persona 4 and 5 would have better combat if they didn't have full party control. 4 and 5 fags insist that they're balanced for it unlike P3P, but the reality is those games get facerolled just as hard because the game simply cannot handle multiple playable characters.
This is the defining factor that separates nu-sona from SMT.
Robert Murphy
here, I put Raidou 2 on B but it's one of the most disappointing games I've played. While the combat's improved significantly, everything else felt either the same or worse. I expected so much more coming off of Raidou 1. At least totally-not-Lucifer was nice.
I really tried to play SMT1 but got hopelessly lost pretty early until I gave up. I want to go back to it and actually go through it, use a guide if I have to.
SJR has no real downsides and has improvements along with added content so if you're not an autist about the original sprites and ingame achievements, that one.
I did play it but I dropped it after the train boss because I really couldn't stand how worse it felt to play than the original.
Luis Jackson
P3P has the awakening cutscene, retard.
Oh, and thanks for outing yourself as a subhuman that needs an abundant amount of cutscenes to enjoy a game. I hear Resetera has a nice God of War 4 thread going. You should check it out.
Xavier Cox
>persona 3 being under 4
>DeSu 2 above 1
>he’s the biggest persona and smt e celeb
Christian Nguyen
It’s a story driven game, the presentation is one of the things it lives and dies on and p3p misses the mark
Chase Lopez
It's obvious you're taking the piss because you can choose to go full ai control in the games of you so desire.
Isaiah Rogers
Had trouble with if I was gonna put 1 or 2 in S. Probably should have done both.
Carson Sanchez
>he doesn't know the AI took a nosedive in 4
Playing 4 and 5 with the AI is borderline unplayable. You can thank ATLUS for completely gutted the HP thresholds for healing. You think Marin Karin was bad? You obviously haven't tried playing 4 or 5.
Nolan Gutierrez
Can someone explain to my why people don’t like persona q I thought the game was comfy
Angel Wilson
>SMT2
>D
Jeremiah James
>rated the dancing games
for what purpose