What does the upcoming Harry Potter RPG need in order to be a masterpiece?

a hot gay steamy sex scene between dumbledore and voldemort

Disconnect it from the main series, add puzzlesolving

>The winner of the houe cup is Slytherin for general behavior and accomplishments
>Cheers from Slytherin mostly
>Well done Slytherin, well done
>HOWEVER
>Awards Gryffindor bonus points for the main characters
>The winner of the house cup is Gryffindor
>Cheers all around
>Well done Gryffindor, well done
>HOWEVER
>Awards Ravenclaw bonus points because magic final exams are in and Ravenclaw has the highest averages, netting the academic bonus
>The winner of the house cup is Ravenclaw
>Confused cheers from Ravenclaw and upset from others
>Well done Ravenclaw, well done
>HOWEVER
>Awards Hufflepuff bonus points in memoriam because two 7th years were looking for a hidden place to have a shag and got killed and eaten by Fluffy, so a tribute to the dead of 5 points (each)
>The winner of the house cup is Hufflepuff
>Nervous cheers from Hufflepuff and resignation from others
>Well done Hufflepuff, well done
>HOWEVER
>Subtracts points from Hufflepuff for those masturbation orgies they in their dorm room, and Hufflepuff's victory is withdrawn
>The winner of the house cup is actually the faculty in lieu of a proper winner
>Utter defeat from the students, much crying and even some just getting up and leaving the banquet early
>Well done my friends and colleagues, fellow Hogwarts staff members. I make a toast with the house cup itself to your commendable dedication to education and service to this institution, may it stand true for many years to come, well done
>HOWEVER

Just an HD remake of the first three EA games
youtu.be/IwaLGCV58w0

just rip off the bully formula t b h

Let me retcon the books
Let me Romance hermione and cuck ron and harry

FLIIIIIIPENDO

All I've ever wanted is classes that are true length and in-depth and it's never ever going to happen. I enjoy the small ones in the mobile game but the game is shit and doesn't go in depth as much as I'd like

FLIPENDO

someone post the pasta

What do you even get for the house cup? Always seemed like just another trophy you don't get to take with you and then everyone else starts flailing their wrists like faggots

>Romance Hermione
She's gonna be black, dude.

Will she have a cute feminine penis too?

Hermione will literally be a 7'3" black man.

And that's a good thing!

Attached: 1528812012412.jpg (800x800, 97K)

Like the game boy game of the first Harry Potter but with more secrets and alternate routes to the story. Shit was great and collecting cards was fun, had all but one.

I just really want that magical academy atmosphere, not just a third-person action RPG with a Harry Potter coat of paint.

That feeling of exploration and charm that still makes me look back on some of the old movie games with nostalgia, but with the freedom to explore new fantastical scenarios and characters.

Attached: 5464548.jpg (1280x1658, 822K)

tons of romanceable girls to get that prime teen wizard pussy

Since it's confirmed open world, it needs to have all of these
> 1. compelling story
> 2. fully voice dialogue
> 3. tons of side activities
> 4. At least 30-40 hours long for the main storyline
> 5. Multiple endings
> 6. Loveable main Characters
> 7. Tons of customization options
> 8. Ability to create a Male or Female character
> 9. Fleshed out romance

Not a Hogwarts simulator. Between the books, the movies, the theme park and the mobile game shit, Hogwarts itself has become so familiar that a vidya version of it would feel stale.

Will Hagrid be romanceable?

I want something that builds off the set-up that Bully had. Going through classes with friends throughout the year and seeing the seasons and holidays change along with the story.

I know there's probably going to be some big conflict underneath it all, but I still want some of that magical slice-of-life downtime to flesh out the characters more and just have fun exploring the setting.

Attached: hogsmeade__concept_art_for_harry_potter_movies_by_pavasara_dvesma-dab7xn5.jpg (1024x1032, 219K)

>school filled with teenagers
>who can turn your head into the stone
>push each other off flying stairs
>easely be killed while playing brooms-derby
>let's add points system, wich will lead to bullying and violence
ALL THE OTHER KIDS

fuck off bitch hogwarts gta edition is the one thing everyone wants

They should allow bullying depending on your created character. So if you have a large character you would be verbally abused by the girls and if you made your wizard petite then the men would physically use your character.

Gameplay-wise, do the same thing as Fire Emblem Three Houses is trying too do. Shouldn't be too difficult considering even Nintendo is doing it.
Multiple campaigns following the same story but from the perspective of different houses could be nice too.

Play Persona if you haven't. What you described it's literally what the newest games are about.

>Soule

I have, and I've enjoyed them, but they're not quite the style of game I'm thinking of.

Bully's environments were much more directly interactive, with mechanics and hidden details that made it worth exploring in different ways. Persona's emphasis was more on playing around with time and stat management in-between sessions of listening to your friends vent.

Attached: 1557101529798.jpg (1600x1042, 153K)

modding support

hot slytherin chicks who will step on the mc

>naked anime chicks in hogwarts

Real Talk: If you were transported to Hogwarts without plot armor, would you be able to survive your first year without dying?

just naked chicks would be enough
let me use diffindo to tear clothes off of girls in the hallways and I'll be happy

A meru

aren't actual deaths a rare occurrence at hogwarts? they can regrow your bones back for fuck's sake
also they made such a big deal out of Myrtle's death that one would imagine it hasn't hapened often, it's not like you see a lot ghost of students wandering around the school
nice trips btw

Assuming i'm the same age & constant center of attention like Harry was? No

With magic...? You're probably good as long as you just hang around the dorm and don't wander off into forbidden areas and play with the murder tree.

>bdsm
>rape
>gore and cannibalism
>zoo
>tentacles
>mindcontrol
>made on Creation Engine

>made on Creation Engine
dude what the fuck is wrong with you

>quidditch
>Nevill's fukups
>Weasley's experiments
>moving fucking stairways

I want to start as an eleven year old and play through all 7 years at Hogwarts with branching storylines.

quidditch world cup is the most underrated game of all time

Being able to shit yourself and magic it away

Yes, very easily. Most students make it through Hogwarts without dying and it took four books before a single student died.

cunny
developer mode, where you get to play as JK Rowling and turn people gay on command

quidditch world cup is the most overrated game by the 200 people that played it

>Artifical Academy: Hogwarts Edition

A faction where you can kill students, harvest their organs or latent magical energy for various purposes. Alchemical, strengthening your own power you name it you can fucking do it.

That depends. Am I going to Hogwarts at the same time as Harry Potter? Then no.

Attached: ilustracoes_harry_potter_mary_grandpre_16-1280x1280-inside.jpg (1280x1022, 253K)

Quidditch. That’s it. QUIDDITCH.

>tfw lots of people tell me academagia hits a lot of the points threads like these want but i'm too stupid to understand raising games

Will they officially announce this game at e3?

>you face all of the same kind of troubles & danger that Harry did
>without plot armor
nigga you crazy

>quidditch
Optional. I'd be a dork on the chess team, not a jock.

>Nevill's fukups
Kid usually blew himself up, not other people.

>Weasley's experiments
Generally harmless pranks. You'd be in more danger just standing too close to Harry Potter then you would be bumping into them.

>moving fucking stairways
Fair enough, but I've used escalators before. Just keep a good grip on the rails and give yourself extra time to get to classes.

>t. never used his broom as a bat to swing at the quaffle into the goal

Why the fuck would I face all that shit if I'm without plot armor? Fuck you, faggot, you just want to get off on someone else's misery and misfortune.

Who /BestHouse/?

Attached: Slytherin_ClearBG.png (350x393, 158K)

>Generally harmless pranks.
>lets feed 1-years some shit with unknown side-effects

I NEED A CUTE SLYTHERIN GIRL THAT YOU CAN ROMANCE

Here.

Not exist

They have a general idea of what they're doing so its not like its completely blind. And anything really bad can be taken care off by the nurse.

>inbreeding

>And anything really bad can be taken care off by the nurse.
Theoretically, if Harry broke his neck on quidditch in 2nd book, can they heal this shit? Brain is still 'alive' for 1-2 mins.

Hot, isn't it?

Even though it'd probably be a lot of extra work I'd love if you could choose your house and it actually had a major impact on how all NPCs interact with you. People from your own house would obviously be much friendlier, people from other houses would be less so. Since this takes place pre-Voldemort, lets assume that Slytherins aren't just universally hated by everyone but themselves so it's not a playthrough death sentence to choose to be one.

MERULA
E
R
U
L
A

>It hasn't been posted yet
this site is fucking dead

Yes, Internet would be my plot armor so there's nothing i couldn't solve without using the magical equivelent of google

jesus what is going on with hufflepuff

can they both be girls who both love me so much they agree to a love triangle and i can marry both of them?

ye

Attached: aNYm9L3_460s.jpg (460x833, 86K)

then she's gonna get bleached

Yes

>only purebloods
No one here could get in. Mght as well join the other good house, the pissbros.

Attached: Huffles.png (614x682, 451K)

>imagine being a jannitor

Lots of interesting creatures, classes where you learn and practice spells (and have to learn them, you don't get given them purely for attending), hopefully few references to the main characters in the books (other than the teachers), and choice of house which actually affects shit. It'd be great if it had a persona system for spending time with others/solving mysteries balanced with practicing your spells. You'd get fucked up in combat or be unable to unlock a door for example if you didn't take school seriously. Maybe you can go all-in on a few spells like Harry and get stronger versions of them.

elves, man

People forget how much the Habsburgs practiced marrying in the family. This wasn't first or even second generation incest, this has gone for a long time.

THE, janitor. Because the entire school seemingly only had 1. Who couldn't even use magic, what a fucking nightmare.

I know its a meme at this point but rip off bully. House approval system like the cliques, learning magic and potions from attending classes, no romance beyond kissin

Emphasize the atmosphere and exploration. have some "forbidden spells" you have to work to unlock.

plot that doesn't go beyond, like, slice of life stakes

Filch would get kids to do the cleaning for him, and chain them up by their thumbs if they talked shit. He may be a squib but he got the job done.

Yeah, there are shitloads of wizards standing by that can intervene if something too dangerous happens, and apparently maagic is canonically able to heal any nonmagical wounds.

Norf QC vs Souf QC rivlary

same shit applies to the 'purebloods'
iirc everyone were somehow related to everyone for several generations already

>have some "forbidden spells" you have to work to unlock
>"Biggus dickus!"

>sneaking out to hogsmead for postgame hooliganism

>upcoming Harry Potter RPG
No thanks, HM is the only Harry Potter game that matters.

Better question: Knowing that you could be expelled, would you try to use your magic to get Hermione & other girls to have sex with you against their will?

Were they? Besides Blacks, I can't remember anyone outright marrying each other's cousins.

Yes

You'll get Azkaban'd.

It'd be cool if you have multiple ways to progress in certain situations too, depending on how you spent your time in classes. You could focus on charms and use levitation to reach a high platform, or use herbology to grow a climbable vine. Maybe you could spend a ton of time like you said on becoming an animagus and get up that way. It'd be a bit like an immersive sim. Also, a real Hogwarts RPG would have there be some serious shit happening, but it's completely missable if you don't investigate. There was crazy shit going down pretty much every year the main cast were there, and the majority of the school was unaware. Maybe if you focus on classes/social interactions instead of the overarching mystery (think Persona), at the end of the year someone else solves the issue and the player never hears about it. It doesn't have to be incredibly deep, maybe an endgame dungeon like the first book with certain skillchecks or challenges to progress for a "true" ending.

Funny thing is, I am eligible for the title of "Baron" since 7/8 of great-grandparents were nobles
But it costs too much for a vanity title so whatever

Academagia: The Making of Mages already exists

The Weasleys and the Malfoys both appear on the Black family tree. What they were trying to say was that basically every pureblood family in any given country are all probably like 3rd or 4th cousins with each other.

COOME ON NORF SCORE SUM FUCKING RINGS

it's the patrician fetish, even GoTards agree

Time to give birth to magitech. I'm going to magically hijack internet connection to some shack just outside Hogwarts perimeter.
I wonder if wireless network signals can be teleported?

>tfw too brainlet for raising sim games

Based, i wonder what /pol/ would be like if it existed in the Harry Potter universe

Death Eaters

>Spoiler
Sorry user but the upcoming game is set in the 18th century or something.

>replying to muttbloods

So her great great grandmother then, that's fine too.

Ideally you'd be able to choose your own house, and that'd act as the game's form of replayability by having each house work with its own cast of characters (plus interactions amongst the residents of the other houses), and sub plots.

youtube.com/watch?v=k5hY6JFrqbo
youtube.com/watch?v=kYNsCh96-m0
Goddammit this ost is pure nostalgia

Attached: 1554096167716.jpg (1920x1080, 163K)

>What does the upcoming Harry Potter RPG need in order to be a masterpiece?
WAIFUS.
YOUNG waifus.
Young SEXY waifus
Young sexy waifus who are CUTE and HUMOROUS.

If Sony allows it, they aren't cute or humorous enough!

> Forgetting that every time you get detention you are sent to the Dark Forest with literal monsters in it

why are you in a thread for a harry potter game? go play some mobile gacha game, it's right up your alley

Based

Actually I just looked it up and I was a century off. It's 19th century.
What year did that toilet ghost die? Maybe she will be in the game still alive.

>Basedny
>allows waifus

This

>It'd be great if it had a persona system
Why on earth would anyone want this to be like Persona?

Attached: 121020233424.jpg (2000x1176, 555K)

>Character creation
>Not letting JK touch it
>Open world hogwarts roaming
The 3 important pillars.

Because Harry Potter is a franchise popular among late adolescent and early adult women.
Having them exposed to the glory of young cute and funny characters will humble them, and those age brackets could use some humility.
Or maybe they could be lesbos and they'd enjoy the waifus, that'd be cool too.

Chamber Of Secrets was the only good game

I think that happens only if your a 5th year and the headmaster is not grooming you to be a hero and die. Plus we see Denton only twice if I recall and one was torture. Must not tell lies.

Why does everybody want character creation?
What's wrong with playing as an established character?

They allow them if they're 3d, look at Miley Cyrus before she got trafficked and replaced with a body double.
And to be honest, 2d waifus are easier to traffick.
... wait, I guess that's why Disney doesn't want them. We might make unauthorized copies of their waifus.
I get your point now.

Myrtle died in 1943.

Lot of people want to experience a magic academy setting as themselves or as an OC. I suspect that is why that Witchbrook game by Chucklefish is going to enjoy some early success, since it is supposed to be exactly that.

>Why does everybody want character creation?
>What's wrong with playing as an established character?

Because it's an RPG, a genre that is founded on the idea of creating and role-playing your own character?

Attached: 1552492955801.png (621x702, 56K)

People want to be themselves in the fictional world. Not be someone else.

>here's a universe people were always interested in almost entirely because they wanted to imagine themselves in it.
>What? no, you can't make your own character.
>No, you can't play as any of the characters people did care about
>No, you can't even play as the main character

Its impossible without actual GM.
Prove me wrong.

>What's wrong with playing as an established character?
Because I don't want to play as a poorly written shitter from a kids book.

Shame, a century too late. I suppose there is a possibility the leak was a case of Chinese whispers and it was actually 19 hundreds rather than 19th century but I doubt it

Honestly I'd be okay if it was just cosmetics and choosing from a short list of preset mannerisms like Shy Wallflower, Country Bumpkin, Posh & Elegant, Explosively Energetic etc.

No, if you wander the castle at night you are sent to the woods regardless of your year

I think they want to make sure no book characters are in this game. So 1800s, but I have no idea how old Dumbledore is. He was like 100 in the 40s but it gets retconned every 3 seconds.

Attached: 1525847580429.jpg (500x432, 27K)

This, every western RPG should have character creation at some point. JRPGs got away with it solely because they used to have memorable or loveable characters.

No microtransactions
Ability to just completely ignore the houses

Dumbledore was born in 1881.

Ok, who is this bitch and why are people always losing their minds over her?

>This, every western RPG should have character creation at some point. JRPGs got away with it solely because they used to have memorable or loveable characters.
Uh-huh.

Attached: 1203032023233.jpg (2000x1952, 735K)

I stand corrected. I havent read the books in years so I'm not sharp as I used to be.

Based

Thank you.

Fuck off WRPG-Kun, everyone hates your guts & has for years. Get a trip code so we can ban you

what would the magical equivalent of a school shooting at hogwartz be

You have to describe the characters on the left because nobody remembers them or has ever heard of them at all. They don't even know their names, whereas most gamers recognize all of the ones on the right except the Suikoden kid

I mean the basilisk was basically that if it weren't for all the asspulls keeping people from dying when they saw it.

there used to be this shitty mobile game that Yea Forums had a boner for for a while

>POPULAR GAME GOOD
>LESS POPULAR GAME BAD
Brilliant argument. By this logic, Twilight and Harry Potter are some of the world's greatest literature ever created, with some of the most complex and multi-faceted genre to ever grace a novel.

You're basically saying that jrpgs have such shitty characters that you can't even find any positive traits to defend them with and instead you can only make a mindless appeal to popularity.

Attached: 1551017810907.png (558x614, 29K)

harry blasting draco with that sweet sword spell that easy outclasses "instakill lol" but is never used again

>used to be

>only one person has been posting these images for over a decade

Issac isn't a mute you retard

I like how you didn't include FF in there at all

Some edgy slytherin bullied for being a pale twink hearing about the killing curse from his family and using it to get revenge on the chad gryffindors who kept bullying him. Probably wouldn't get very far, maybe kills one student before the teacher disarms them, maybe a few more students if they kill the teacher first before they wise up and knock them on their ass with like 50 wand shots.

Why should he? "hur durr tormented by my past uggghhghgh i'm so amnesiac I've lived a life full of regret at the ripe age of 19"

>BAN ASSAULT WANDS

Yeah give some coffee baby

It doesn't matter if you're bullied as long as someone will stick up for you.
Promoting inter-house conflict prevents in-house bullying.

Nice job outing yourself as a blind contrarian WRPG-Kun
Sadly yes
Nice samefag, it's because any FF protagonist is more memorable than anyone you named. The reason Mass Effect became such a cultural icon was because it was the first WRPG with memorable characters.

Attached: Potter the antichrist.png (639x1001, 1.18M)

I think you might be a newfag

Attached: embarrassing.png (355x136, 6K)

>Explosively energetic
Bonus points if you play as a petite asian named Megan Umin

>Promoting inter-house conflict prevents in-house bullying.
It's actually the opposite.
Imagine how hard was Nevill bullied for losing points.

>Explorable castle in an out, all the areas from the movies, diagon alley, dark forest, etc etc
>good gameplay, different kinds of wizards, summoners, casters, defenders, healers, illusionist all with a unique sense of gameplay
>good sense of immersion and adventure
>mini games that relate to the movie and books, ie: discovering new spells, mystical beast discovery, defeating bosses, quidditch, goblet games

They can really do this game well. I only worry about sustainability. How long can they keep the game intresting before it gets boring like wow. You can only do the same stuff over and over before it gets so awful.

It's gonna suck, right?

Anyone have that post with Dumbledore throwing Slytherin into a gas chamber?

Less white wizards. It's disgusting.

T.domestic elf

Modern electronics tech doesn't work around hogwarts you wouldn't be able to get a signal off. It's directly stated in Goblet of Fire when Hermione and Harry are discussing Rita Skeeter.

That's why you go far enough from Hogwarts.

Sup mate.

You can be bad or good and you get the ability to kill students and teachers and people important to the story, but when you do so the game will tell you your actions will have a huge impact on the story like in morrowind

gnome kissing

>modern
That's 80's tech. Maybe actual robust military tech could work

You're A Wizard Harry!

Attached: 31173978.jpg (1280x1816, 570K)