So Yea Forums has Yea Forumscore albums, Yea Forums should have 20 or so games considered true Yea Forumscore I'll make a collage in a bit once new ideas popped up, but right now I'm thinking >Deus Ex >Fallout New Vegas >Metal Gear Solid 3 >Super Smash Bros Melee >Metroid Prime >Castlevania Symphony Of The Night >Ghost Trick >Halo 3 >Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas >Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney >Bloodborne >Dark Souls >Final Fantasy 7 >Persona 3 FES
True Yea Forumscore is fapping to the terabytes of hentai that comes out of Japanese mobile gambling games.
Logan Brooks
Yea Forumscore isn't a thing because each X amount of years a new wave of zoomers that are more tryhard than the ones before them hops on and they start shitting on every single "respected classic" to have contrarian internet nerd cred. This process is repeating itself over and over again until Yea Forums considers every game ever made pretty much shit. Yea Forums gets a lot of shit for being hipsters but even they aren't as hipster as Yea Forums. Yea Forums is by far the most insecure and hipster board of them all.
>bloodborne Nah, DS1 is the only soulsborne game that deserves to be on that list
>FF7 casual fag shit. Swap it out for Dragon Quest 8
Austin Taylor
user, she has a dick
Connor Morales
>Halo 3 >Not Halo 2 What about clans
Leo Cox
>Jak 2 TPL is a better platformer though I know
Owen Lee
True, however there are certain games that people who arent contrarian for the sake of being contrarian all come together on I like MGS 2 more too, but MGS 3 is way more praised on Yea Forums. Remember, it's to represent Yea Forums, not what is a subjectively better game based for games retard not soundtracks Ill take a look at this too, should we move it up to 50 essentials? I would argue about bloodborne, i see it praised a lot more than dark souls, and the imagery in bloodborne is typically better than dark souls >FF7 It's way more popular than DQ, but if theres enough demand, DQ can get a rep too
Also thinking of adding RE:Make, Resident Evil 4, and Super Mario Galaxy, 64, or Odyssey. Which out of the SM games should be on?
Charles Russell
Hard to find good thing these days OP. Vidya composers with creativity and education seem to have died out. Prince of Persia and Homeworld are my often go-to soundtracks.
As for contemporary stuff. The 40k Mechanicus soundtrack is good shit. Domina and bignic. nu-Doom soundtrack was good i suppose. Mother Russia Bleeds, can't think of many.
You can add or distract from the list as you want. There might already be a newer version somewhere, it was just the one I had saved.
Sebastian Evans
This is painfully true. People were complaining about that massive 100 title list from 2012 or something and called it ''Reddit tier'' when it was brought up. There is no saving this place.
This is an alright list. However >Drop Halo 3, replace with ODST >Add Starcraft >Add Ace of Space >Add Team Fortress 2 >Add SS13 >Drop Bloodborne, replace with Demon Souls
I love Trent but quake is pretty mediocre for ambient music.
Thomas Carter
You argued that a lootbox infested shitpile should be in any list except the list of dogshit. Go hang yourself garbage. Lootbox trash is automatically disqualified.
we can't have a Yea Forumscore list of games because:
>board is to heavy on shitposting, decreasing considerabily the amount of actual discussions about videogames >a lot of younger virgins won't care about videogames and only want muh graphix experience >a lot of depressed people won't pay attention or enjoy videogames >the amount of awfully retarded people makes any type of online playing impossible
Nathan Anderson
Okay anons here's the list so far 1.Deus Ex 2.Fallout New Vegas 3.Metal Gear Solid 4.Metal Gear Solid 3 5.Super Smash Bros Melee 6.Metroid Prime 7.Super Metroid 8.Castlevania Symphony Of The Night 9.Ghost Trick 10.Halo 3 11.Halo Reach 12.Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines 13.Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas 14.Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney 15.Bloodborne 16.Dark Souls 17.Final Fantasy 7 18.Persona 3 FES 19.Devil May Cry 3 20.Silent Hill 2 21.Morrowind 22.KOTOR 2 23.God Hand 24.RE:Make 25.Resident Evil 4 26.Super Mario, let's go with 64
Okay, new ones to be debated are >System Shock 2 >Team Fortress 2 >Ace Attorney 3 >Ocarina Of Time >Majora's Mask >Banjo-Kazooie >Paper Mario TTYD >Mother 3 >Pokemon HG/SS >Doom >Portal >F-Zero GX
Any objections or new ideas?
Jackson Hernandez
It's impossible to do an essential lists in a medium with exclusives. Not because of the locked aspect but because of the fanboyism and brand loyalty some retards have.
Luke Powell
Yeah, if it has lootboxes it is to be removed from the list. No exceptions.
Blake Murphy
So Team Fortress 2 should be removed?
Brayden Thompson
Anything which has them. Gotta separate feelings from lists that should be representative of sought-after standards.
Brandon Wright
Fair enough
Any other objections from anyone?
Owen Hall
Portal and Doom should definitely make the list
Michael Diaz
why is fallout new vegas in the list? I don't want to start a discussion here, I just found it to be very empty with wannabe philosophical fedora NPCs some of the aspects of the game are really cool but the NPCs and the roleplay however..
Aaron Sullivan
>Doom 1 >half-life >age of empires II >Thief The dark project
Yea Forums is the hivemind mentality to the extreme. Yea Forums still has a bit of individuality even if most people here are braindead. Making a chart of Yea Forums core games is guaranteed to kill that
Juan Brooks
Most of what is on the list is already hiveminded and paraded around as infallible
>Deus Ex >Fallout New Vegas >Bloodborne >Morrowind
Luis Morales
Because of how popular it is on here. If you look at a 3x3 thread chances are it'll appear almost everywhere Agreed, what do we think of Portal 2 and Doom 2016
Nolan Murphy
At least they don't take up the bulk of the conversation here
Dominic Sanchez
>Because of how popular it is on here. If you look at a 3x3 thread chances are it'll appear almost everywhere yeah I still don't understand it I'll have to replay it again and see if I'm missing something
All I can think about is how much I want to fucking beat you up for posting faggy the frog so much. If you post Juan next, I swear to fucking God, OP.
Lincoln Johnson
this right here is the perfect v-core list. Don't let any nintoodlers tell you otherwise.
Landon Barnes
obviously I meant to type Yea Forums-core
Dominic Ortiz
pretty tame list.
Nathaniel Allen
>Rhythm Heaven made it Based.
Isaiah Jackson
Nothing from the past 10 years or so should be on the list. Not because they aren't good, but because they haven't been tested by time yet. The list should only include indisputable classics. Shit like Bloodborne and REmake are too new to really tell if they will belong on the list 10 years from now. The list is meant to be permanent, so it can't include shit that's too new and untested.
Also, I think it'd be best to come up with some criteria for the list before trying to fill it out. In my opinion a game on this list should be:
>Widely acclaimed by Yea Forums users - the game has a substantial fanbase on Yea Forums. A game shouldn't make the list just because it's generally popular or because critics liked it >Timeless - the game's appeal has withstood the test of time for at least 10 years, and continues to be enjoyed to this day. All things considered, if the list were made a decade from now, the game would still be on it >Influential - the game had a significant and powerful influence on Yea Forums for its time. This criterion should be allowed to override the previous one in notable cases, or cases where the game cannot be enjoyed anymore. Tribes: Ascend is an example of this. Dark Souls is also slightly too new by the previous standard, but it is undeniably hugely influential on Yea Forums and vidya in general, so it belongs on the list. >Distinct from other entries - to avoid cluttering the list. There's no need to have both Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask, or every installment of Halo, or the Elder Scrolls, or every GTA, or your favorite JRPG panty quest. Directing people reading the list to one will lead them to the others if they want. Only in exceptional cases where each title truly is incredibly influential on its own, such as Metal Gear, should warrant more than one entry per series.
Alexander Howard
>no cuphead One job.
Justin Bailey
With all that in mind, I would cut: >Bloodborne (too new and similar to DS) >Halo Reach or 3 (just pick one Halo entry) >Ghost Trick (not enough fans, not influential enough, not notable enough) >RE:Make (too new)
I agree with most of the list to add, but I would suggest you pick a single Ace Attorney entry and add it, and do the same for OoT/MM.
Also, one last thing: don't number them or people will think it's a power ranking or something
Landon Stewart
Something that doesn't shit the bed
Dominic Roberts
Kirby 64, we have Kirby threads daily and 64 is the most replayable and memorable of the bunch
>Castlevania: Symphony of the Night >Alundra >Deus Ex >Super Street Fighter 2 turbo >The Guardian Legend >Thief: The Dark Project >Dark Souls >Doom >Fallout >Devil May Cry 3 >System Shock >Snatcher >Shin Megami Tensei III: Noctrune this is the true ludo connoisseur taste
>I would add: Mount & Blade STALKER (series) EYE: Divine Cybermancy Risk of Rain Dawn of War: Dark Crusade Also Pathologic, LISA and Deadly Premonition are mentioned often, but I wouldn't consider them Yea Forumscore. >I would drop Everything Pokemon, they have their own board
Isaiah Flores
>smelee
Lmao go home
Bentley Watson
i figured he meant the remake of Resident Evil 2, the currently popular one
William Johnson
>No Mario Galaxy or Xenoblade >Persona
It's shit, but Yea Forums loves garbage like rap i guess so it's expected.
when i said remake i meant the original one, not 2 I like adding Thief
Cut Bloodborne for dark souls instead, and halo 3 for reach 1.Deus Ex 2.Fallout New Vegas 3.Metal Gear Solid 4.Metal Gear Solid 3 5.Super Smash Bros Melee 6.Metroid Prime 7.Super Metroid 8.Castlevania Symphony Of The Night 9.Ghost Trick 10.System Shock 2 11.Halo Reach 12.Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines 13.Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas 14.Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney 15.Thief 16.Dark Souls 17.Final Fantasy 7 18.Persona 3 FES 19.Devil May Cry 3 20.Silent Hill 2 21.Morrowind 22.KOTOR 2 23.God Hand 24.RE:Make 25.Resident Evil 4 26.Super Mario 64 27.Ace Attorney 3 28.The Legend Of Zelda Majora's Mask (Or Ocarina of time but thats a bit basic) 29.Banjo-Kazooie 30.Paper Mario TTYD 31.Mother 3 32.Pokemon HG/SS 33.Doom 34.Portal 35.F-Zero GX 36.999 37.Deadly Premonition 38.Killer 7 39.E.Y.E.
Considering now Cuphead, Shovel Knight, Kirby 64
Colton Moore
Like the other user said, cut some of the newer entries, and add in games like system shock 2 and doom as they are massively influential and genuinely great games.
Dylan Gutierrez
Xenoblade 2 is pretty big here
Easton Perez
>Barkley: Shut Up and Jam - Gaiden Great list
Jack Moore
>GUN based
David Miller
Shovel Knight and Cuphead are too new. We don't know if they will become part of Yea Forums culture yet.
Levi Jones
1 is better though
Carson Lopez
BB is still consistently relevant, 4 years straight. Not sure why it doesn't deserve a spot.
Landon Howard
>Jak II uuuuh, no
Kayden Sanders
>Make List >Claim it's Yea Forums's list Instant (You)s everyone.
Elijah Brown
I'd merge OoT and Majora's Mask since they've got the same following, with MM's being a bit more dedicated, they do have the exact same engine
Cooper Cox
>consistently relevant No? Its only relevance is as a console war meme. As a game it's just a souls clone with a different setting. No one makes bloodborne discussion threads, no one plays the game anymore, it didn't affect other games that came after it, it isn't getting sequels or spinoffs, and it doesn't even have its own distinct fanbase. It's just a clone of Dark Souls so Dark Souls should be on the list instead. You might as well list Red Dead Redemption 2 because you think cowboy games are good and GTA 3 was influential. >4 years straight not even a long time so this means nothing
Thomas Roberts
>Sonic one over Sonic 3 or SA2 >Celeste >Classic Mega Man over X series Cringe
Jaxon Price
Why would you want (you)s anyways? I honestly don't understand.
Leo Martin
>resident evil 4 >apex legends
Done, that's Yea Forumscore
Alexander Ward
This one seems a little more Yea Forums-core in the sense that there are some games here that Yea Forums introduced me to and I didn't see anyone else talking about at the time. For instance: LSD, Barkley: Shut up and Jam Gaiden, The Longest Journey, Pathologic, Rez, Yume Nikki
Blake Fisher
cut melee, that's entirely /vg/ if you looked, Yea Forums follows whatever the new smash is and dismisses the old
Josiah Martin
>Its only relevance is as a console war meme Based retard. The majority of the threads are discussions on weapons and lore. Just today we had a thread reach almost 300 replies. Keep deluding yourself though.
>hack and slash >diablo and its clones Who the fuck made this?
Robert Rivera
in my opinion Wii is easily the best one. someone else mentioned DS, also not a bad option.
Jayden Lewis
The darkness Silent hill 2 Ninja gaiden 2 The darkness Resident evil remake Silent hill 2 Shadow complex The darkness Dantes Inferno The darkness Silent hill 2 Final fantasy 7 Resident evil remake The darkness The darkness Silent hill 2 Resident evil remake The darkness Alan wake The darkness
You cant make a better top 20 games list
Carter Adams
Add antibirth ost and we be square.
Andrew Lewis
I see Xenogears more desu Majora is more Yea Forums Yeah id say so Oh i forgot about Pathologic and Yume Nikki No but ill add NieR Automata
Should we add STALKER?
Christopher Robinson
>Kek you outed yourself too Redditard go back with them >>/r/eddit
One has to wonder how klong you retards try to keep it up, pretending to not be as green as you really are, for everyone but your own dimwitted minds to see.
Poratl 2 was fun and had definitve improvments over the first one but dragged in the end. Doom '16 plays ok but feels more as if they tried to make a painkiller sequel then Doom, and be it simply becasue you have for the most part walled off arenas/rooms to shoot demons up and not the whole open level. Doom, the first one, should be by itself for the series.
Jack Young
OP here
Ill be gone for a bit, respond to this post with suggestions
Justin Turner
Then I'll replace it with DS tough my personal favorite is DD.
Jacob Taylor
deus ex aged like milk why melee when you can play ultimate and have a better experience ?
Nicholas Jackson
Yea Forums doesn’t play video games though
Aaron Baker
Replace Persona 3 with Persona 5. Only contrarian boomers pretend that P3 is the best.
Nathan Mitchell
We need a Pikmin game on there, it's a small franchise but it's entire fanbase seems to be here with the nightly bulborb thread
Nathan Hill
Because i see melee get more praise here which pikmin game
Jordan Morales
>why melee when you can play ultimate and have a better experience ? because ultimate is FOTM and melee is timeless
Jeremiah Carter
I'd say 2 as it has the best bosses and treasure hunting
