Why are P5 casts so boring and unmemorable compared to P3/P4 characters?
I don't think people still talking about them after P6 will come out.
Why are P5 casts so boring and unmemorable compared to P3/P4 characters?
Henry Bailey
William Lopez
They don't behave like actual people and just spew exposition in cutscenes.
>Cutscene in dungeon where they encounter something they openly oppose
>"This is wrong, we can't allow this to continue" repeated 100 times
Mason Lewis
Because you played 3 and/or 4 first.
Matthew Rogers
They're supposed to be outcasts and this does happen, but at some point they just come off as a group of normal students with their own secret club. If anything the focus becomes more 'Phantom Thieves' vs the next big villain
Joshua Reed
my first persona game was P4 but I love p3 guys more
Gavin Carter
Because your nostalgia for those two games is deluding you into think that.
Gavin Ward
how many p5 casts are there?
Josiah Hughes
I dig them more than the 4 cast. Didn't really like the 4 cast outside of Dojima, Nanako, and Kanji.
Asher Sanchez
So I'm a bit confused. During the cutscene when it reveals the leader of the phantom thieves has died, why is everyone acting so shocked? Ryuji's "we got them" makes sense but Haru, Makoto, and Ann kinda freak out like he actually died.
Even if it was "oh shit I don't know if the plan didn't work.", Makoto outright says "It can't be..."
Michael Price
Their identities were known to the Conspiracy thanks to Akechi, which means they had to put up an act in public.