Untitled
>no faces of evil
Cringe and shitpilled
Not even going to pretend that OoT and MM are amazing, they're good but they don't hold up at all.
A perfect bell curve.
This is the closest to correct and still has flaws.
I love Kass!
bretty good
>Gba LTTP in D tier
THEY ARE THE SAME FUCKING GAME
HOLY SHIT
FUCK OFF ZOOMER
I thought that the game just referred to four swords
im pretty sure hes using that for four swords
How can anyone have such shit taste?
Something about this post seems ironic, but I can't put my finger around it.
Wind Waker is a horrible Zelda game
*blocks ur path*
Maybe something like this. Tiers aren't really ordered other than MM being my favorite.
fuck Skyward Sword
fuck Spirit Tracks
and fuck ALBW
This is convincing me to play the Oracle games.
What's wrong with Spirit Tracks? I thought it was a perfectly fine game.
>they're good but they don't hold up at all.
One of you guys posted her tied to a bed post being choked with a belt and fucked by Link a few days ago and I lost my 5 week progress of no fap. Fuck you and your fucking tier list
best one
It's a subpar DS game, and an absolutely horrible sequel to the stellar Wind Waker.
I remember it being alright. haven't played it in a long time though.
That's pretty much the safest Yea Forums parroting one.
its better than phantom hourglass but i really just cannot stand the touch controls of the ds games.
the ds games also just really do not feel like zelda games at all, they just feel like a super watered down adventure game with very little content
says the guy with le open world!!1 Zelda in S and LA and OoT in C, opinion is irrelevant
>stellar Wind Waker
WW is an unfinished, awful Zelda only propped up by cel shading.
it was very boring, specially during the train sections, PH at least had some islands you could explore, in ST you only shoot shit and get rupees while you wait to reach the next dungeon
dungeons are boring, the only good ones are the ones where Zelda helps you
story was boring, Spirit Flute was a shit item and almost impossible to use on OG 3DS thanks to shit microphone
say what you want about PH but that game had fucking Linebeck and he singlehandedly makes a mediocre game into a good game
>It's a subpar DS game
Wrong.
>an absolutely horrible sequel
Tr-
>the stellar Wind Waker.
Wrong.
>AoL in S tier
finally some semblance of taste
>four sword one tier above four sword adventures
????
>no Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland
>no Crossbow Training
shit tier list desu
>nearly all the tier lists ITT are different
>"it's the one Yea Forums parrots"
???
absolutely fucking based. winrar.
The gba version is much lower quality anyway.
I like 3D Zelda much more than 2D
hi, zoomer
cease to exist
suck it, fags.
suck what? i'm glad i'm not as delusional as you. really, just holy fuck.
I've been noticing a lot of differing opinions in threads like these. I think it's because each Zelda game follows a different mindset than the other. Which one do you prefer?
Action >= Puzzles >= Side quests >>> Story >>>>>> """"Exploration""""" >>> Multiplayer
You cannot possibly say with a straight face that Spirit Tracks is better than Wind Waker.
>Majora's Mask is good just because of sidequests.
user, MM is the deepest zelda game by a land-slide. Also the strongest ludonarrative, environmental storytelling, etc.
I don't think there's a zelda game I actually hate.
not even skyward sword
I can and I will. Spirit Tracks has a decent story, great characters, thoughtful dungeons, and an amazing ost. That's a lot more than Wind Waker has going for it.
Spirit Tracks is a finished title that isn’t stretched out the ass to make up for the cut corners as bad as WW. Both are dogturds compared to the real peak of Toon Zelda, Minish Cap.
>the real peak of Toon Zelda, Minish Cap.
>simplistic dungeons
>no difficulty whatsoever
>stupid kinstone bullshit
No.
this is actually the worst thing ive seen in my entire life you should most certainly off yourself with a fucking shotgun faggot
>memorable design
>creative dungeons
>sick ost
>a finished game
Better than WW.
But not ST.
Call the cops, I don't give a fuck.
>But not ST.
MC doesn’t focus entirely on a handheld gimmick like ST and the stylus.
Pad > stylus
If you really think ST is nothing more than a single gimmick, you either played it once as a child or haven't played it at all. Regardless, you're full of shit.
>Regardless, you're full of shit.
No I just recognize that MC is better than ST. Nobody would remember ST had it not been for Zelda, meanwhile MC actually looks good and wasn’t a hassle to play.
this is bait or bad taste
WW sucks mate regardless of ST.
>mass replier
>calling other posts bait
Not that user but ST has the best dungeons of any Zelda in the last decade. Unfortunately, the train is also the WOAT mainline Zelda gimmick and, by extension, overworld. Real diamond in the rough, that one. Simultaneously one of the best and straight up the worst, depending on which part you look at.
>Nobody would remember ST had it not been for Zelda
Confirmed never played it, take your feces ridden opinion and shove it back up your ass.
>Seething this hard
Sad as fuck desu. I was going ask you to be my girlfriend and everything. :(
>Spirit Flute was a shit item and almost impossible to use on OG 3DS thanks to shit microphone
Fuck I forgot all about that item, how the fuck did I 100% that game. I remember now getting stuck for like a few days on a plot-required flute section. Fuck Phantom Hourglass, what a piece of shit game. I had a lot of fun with it, 5/10.
Link to the Past + Four Sword > Four Swords Adventure
>outright admitting it by using retarded buzzwords instead of any form of a counterargument
Every time.
Wasn’t lying about the MC being better than ST, that was a fact.
so the opinion of some user speaks for every other user?
Yes.
And the CD-i games are the pinnacle of the franchise, whatever you say.
>t. born in the late 90s
Btw I'm not shiina I was making fun of him
0 interest in the DS games and havent gotten to try four swords adventures yet
Don't bully, I'm old
something like this for me
How shit is my taste
>rating Spirit Tracks and the Oracle games above Link's Awakening, SS, and Zelda 1
>shitting on the Oracles
Nope, can't be doin' with this.
You were born in 1998.
All of you have bad taste.
>puts a proof of concept as S rank
>says others have shit taste
BotW is a nice skeleton of a true masterpiece but not the real McCoy, too many elements feel like a first draft effort with only the physics engine and weather systems properly pulling their weight. I'm waiting for the actual masterpiece that will inevitably be made with this foundation, BotW is little more than a glorified playground with halfhearted attempts at meaningful content as is.
bait image
>Zelda II at D tier
There is no saving you.
Strange how the GBA port of Link to the ass is a seperate game here
All I want is BotW with Twilight Princess combat but with enemy encounters to actually accomodate for all the techniques you learn
3D was the worst thing to happen to the series.
Gimme rebalanced cooking to not be so exploitable and a Hyrule Castle tier structure in every subregion and I'm in.
it's because the "port" has multiplayer you retard. you rank the multiplayer levels separately from the original/main game
The health system in general needs a rework, armor adding a flat amount of damage resistance is stupid since it completely trivializes everything
Then again, in the current format its probably for the best because I honestly don't enjoy the combat in BotW at all
>with only the physics engine and weather systems properly pulling their weight
Except for the part where the bulk of the entire game is built around the physics, weather and climate systems. BotW's best sidequests, best puzzles, best overworld secrets, its best towns and its best enemies are better than anything any previous Zelda game has had to offer. It has the most traversal methods of any Zelda game, its topography and verticality with a variety of new and interesting environmental puzzles easily gives it the best overworld in the series, and it encourages experimentation more than any previous title from the durability system to the cooking system right down to the combat mechanics. There isn't a single older Zelda game that doesn't instantly feel like a regression unless you're blinded by nostalgia.
Stay upset.
If you disagree you're wrong
Midna aside I just really dislike TP. Also the gameboy attlp is worse because it adds annoying sound effects.
I honestly thought Hero Mode in SS/WWHD/TPHD finally fixed the health systems in Zelda as it was busted before, but in comes BotW and there went that.
>best sidequests
stopped reading there, I bet you think Tarrey Town was good
I don't know why they always have to backpedal so much, it's not like SS was bad because of its combat system
>BotW's best
I can agree with it, in its best moments it shows what this kind of game can be and it excites me to see how much of that potential comes to fruition. I do not think that holds true of the majority of the game, though. Like I said, it's a nice skeleton of a true masterpiece, definitely a direction Zelda should explore but BotW is far from perfecting. Many of the things you praise felt like first draft takes on god tier ideas to me. Durability, cooking and combat are all things I believe need further fine tuning.
check 'em
If you disliked SS for the controls, you are officially mentally challenged
Stolen Heirloom alone is better than anything MM has ever produced.
okay Payafag
I LIKED SS's controls and would still put it in the lowest tier, what the fuck are you smoking placing it that high?
>2 of the best games in series in D tier
go fuck yourself
Me except bumb TP up one and switch z1&2
Sounds like Zelda 2 in 3D.
Want. That would entail the best magic system this series has ever seen making a comeback, not to mention dungeons just being massive labyrinthine gauntlets to explore.
>putting majoras mask anywhere but top
yeah fuck you bud
Video games are fun.
Holy fucking Zoomer
Absolute top-tier taste.
Yes, I do have an IQ of 168, not even memeing
I appreciate the others and enjoy them to some extent but OoT will be the Zelda game for me. None have come close, even BoTW which was an unfinished game due to lack of dungeons.
Objectively correct list.
Here you go nigga, r8/h8/b8
LoZ 1 is between B and C
>Links awakening above the oracles
awful
Haven't played any of the handhelds sadly, what should I start with judging by taste?
seasons for gameplay, awakening for story
Awful taste.
Not an official zelda game.
Here's mine. I tried to be as fair as possible to the ones I didn't personally like.
R8/H8
this is pretty much the best
>TP on S
Opinion discarded
>WW on S
Opinion regained
>BotW that low
Opinion ABSOLUTELY discarded.
Objective opinion coming through.
Ok, zoomers, step aside
>botw s tier
what's beyond zoomer? zygote?
OLD GAME GOOD
NEW GAME BAAAAD
BOTW is an empty game that has one of the most retarded payoffs for actually doing the dungeons
>But Muh Choice
Fuck off. Shaving half the hp of a final boss instead of buffing you or debuffing the boss is a sin. Also no fun items makes it a fuckin bore.
>Closest game progression and exploration to the original TLoZ
>No Bullshit 2 hour boring cutscene and text-heavy tutorial
>Tutorial is fun as fuck to try and do faster on subsequent playtroughs
>Can challenge the game most difficult areas from the get go
I don't know, you tell me, TP fag.
>No fun items
>In a game where people can experiment with them enough that they created (A slow as fuck) airplane and ways to sequence break by just using items and game physics, no bullshit glitches
>Majoras mask below Ocarina of Time
Youve just made an enemy, pal
no one asked for dumb sandbox shit in zelda
the dungeons were trash
Physics engine sandbox tools != fun items.
Half life 2 had an entire gravity gun, but you still had other guns and grenades to use, not just that. Simply imagine if you had the hookshot to use in tandem with these mechanics to be fucking spider man, like it feels so wasted.
Good. They're the most solid all round games in the series and remain perpetual underdogs.
Nah, it feels right, they can expand on it on the next game and let's be honest, Hoolshot in 3D Zelda was stale after OoT, did not receive a good twist until TP, and then again is slow paced as fuck to use compared to the runes, and let's not discuss those "items used only in a dungeon and a couple locations to get some rupees" bullshit TP and SS werw guilty of, the Spinner IS wasted potential.
I feel like the only thing that holds Majora's Mask below Ocarina of Time is the reuse of assets. Had it had its own, that shit would easily be held in the same regard. Although I'm sure most people are too pussy about the time system.
>all these people linking Zelda II low
I guarantee you either
1. haven't played it at all, or
2. thought it was too hard and gave up
Oh shit you raise a good point
>BotW's best sidequests, best puzzles, best overworld secrets, its best towns and its best enemies are better than anything any previous Zelda game has had to offer.
Absolutely not true. The best it has to offer is excellent, and sometimes on par with much of the series' best, but Eventide island is the only point where it reaches a genuine series apex. It has no town as good as Windfall for instance.
> its topography and verticality with a variety of new and interesting environmental puzzles
But its exactly the physics that make this moot by allowing you to brute force your way around almost every obstacle.
> to the cooking system
Again, awful system that just encourages the player to horse and brute force their way through shit that otherwise could have been clever or challenging.
The handful of times the game restricts you enough that you actually have to be clever are excellent, but most of the content has no drive behind.
For me is that the story feels "Less important" or less Epic (For lack of a better word, than OoT, and since the Zelda book reveales it was all a dream then... why? It had some cool mechanics that took a while to return ( Villagers having their own dily routine returned properly in BotW) or were never used again (Transformations, Wolf Link is a very poor attempt at it).
>Expanded on in the next game
Spinner might have been a prototype idea for the shield riding thinking about it further.
>Hookshot is slowpaced
There's a bow in this game, you know that right? It's pretty much the same shit. You could have used the weird magical bullshit that's all around to make the hookshot not need to retract and just instant back to you. You seem to just want to defend this game cause you enjoyed it, and that's fine, but lets not get confused and think it's a good game, let alone a good Zelda game.
What is a "Good Zelda game", BotW is the closest to the original.
you really don't need to play that much of it to get the gist
you either like that castlevania type combat or you don't
since we're ranking zeldas, most people probably like the standard top down ones and the 3D
With the dream knowledge, I get you, without that, I feel like the moon falling into the earth is much more significant then Ganondorf being classically evil.
To be fair, Zelda II id hard as shit at first (compares to other Zelda games) but becomes waaay easier later on, it also has a lot of cryptic bullshit conpared to the others.
The original Zelda isn't that good to begin with. Yeah it starts everything, but at the same time, the series evolved since then to have so much more. It's like trying to herald Devil May Cry is one of the best DMC games when its a solid game that doesn't really compare to some of it's sequels. A good Zelda game would be something that follows the set formula the best and has the most meaningful story, the formula being used, being the dungeon crawling, item obtaining, focus it's been for most of the series life.
Your tier list is fucking upside down you basic little faggot
Fuck you zelda 2 was good
But they have sadly sacrificed freedom and gameplay, SS was so full of linearity, cutscenes and simon says shit that I had no hope for the next game, boy, am I glad BotW did a 180 from that shit.
Already know whats coming, bring on the hate
How the fuck do i use the tierlist maker on mobile? Im fuckin retarded
Hey, just cause SS was shit, doesn't mean BOTW gets off clean. While better then SS that's a low bar to compare to. BOTW had far too much freedom to the point where it felt as though the dungeons weren't as impactful to the story as they should be and the payoff for them is ridiculous. I don't think it's a good game by open world standards, it's far too empty. I don't think it's a good game by Zelda standards, using other weapons could have just been Items that were otherwise more useful or interesting, or even just having passive items like titans gloves and allowing that to open up more. I'm not saying that linearly chaining the dungeons together is the only way,but having them be optional is a stupid idea. Have it like Zelda 1 and just have them mandatory but with different tiers of accessibility and have items that increase you quality of life or whatsohaveyou other then just having food and a bunch of weapons who just equate to different numbers or physics tools.
Nvm i got it
Im the worst zelda fanboy ever, i havent even played half the games
Nigga you can emulate almost all of them shits, wtf
Bold of you to assume i can be bothered and/or not be too autistic to find a trustworthy downloader
eh