Now that the dust has settled, can we all agree that this would be the best possible realistic Smash roster?
Now that the dust has settled, can we all agree that this would be the best possible realistic Smash roster?
Xavier Flores
Julian Cox
No, because it has characters I don't care about.
Samuel Hill
Nah, that's kinda cringe. Sorry to tell you, bro.
Carter Perez
So what?
Jackson Gray
why the fuck is it 4:3 and why do you cunts keep removing characters?
Ryder Young
I can't find Skull Kid.
Michael Collins
Fuck yes. This actually came out really well. Honestly the only thing I would change is making Dark Pit and Metal Sonic echoes for Pit and Sonic and make Marx a playable character then it’s complete perfection.
Camden Lewis
>realistic
>has banjo
Fuck off
Ryder Diaz
Where's SpongeChad?
Julian Brown
>banjo
Trash list leave boomer go play you 20 year old klepto sim somewhere elder
Julian Wright
Heavens no. King Boo is retarded. Funky doesn't deserve it. Midna as an echo makes no sense. Octolings are pretty much just Inklings and I'm not sure what the point of adding them as a separate character is. Silvally is retarded.
Galacta knight is one of the worst possible echo choices and I have no idea why you fags keep suggesting him; he's literally Metaknight with a different shaped mask, not interesting at all. Shadow as an echo is stupid enough, but thinking that he deserves his own character slot is downright autistic. Big Boss is another retarded echo choice; there's absolutely nothing that he can bring to the table that Snake doesn't, and there's not much to set him apart visually either. Overall terrible.
Noah Brown
Kayden Miller
>Shadow over Eggman
>Silvally and Amaterasu is added out of nowhere (Maybe Banjo too if he isn't DLC at all for Ultimate)
>still too many FEs
Gavin Stewart
no
Alexander Nguyen
clear furfag
Noah Hall
>No Reimu
Nah
William Reyes
4:3 is aesthetic.
Jayden Harris
>it’s better because I took out what I don’t like and added what I do even if it makes no sense
Fuck off
Bentley Peterson
At least it has Big Boss. I even think Raiden should get in too.
Carson Rodriguez
>shadow not an echo
>cutting a bunch of character but keeping isabelle
Adrian Reed
it's okay i guess
Jaxson Lee
Why would Shadow not be an echo?
Easton Perry
Almost as if that's the point of echoes
Colton Wilson
Why would you not remove ZSS?
Parker Scott
>Shadow
>not even an echo
Hahaha, no.
Robert Hall
>Okami
based
Blake Reed
>shadow as his own is autistic
Never played sonic battle huh
Literally no reason shadow has to be an echo
David Edwards
>Octoling
Think about it. Inkling has to have 8 different ink colors to work, and each has to stand out. Now throw Octoling into that mix. Some colors would end up being too similar to Inkling colors. It's messy and confusing.
Alexander Ortiz
>Literally no reason shadow has to be an echo
Literally no reason Shadow has to be a fighter at all. That's why he's not even an echo. Heck he's not even a Mii costume.
Levi Walker
>Shadow
Justin Watson
>Doc as an echo
>Dixie as an echo
>Cut Dark Pit but keep Lucina
>Midna and not Hilda
Gabriel Peterson
>Galacta Knight
Probably the only Kirby option worse than Bandana Dee. The first Kirby newcomer in like 10 years and it's an echo, pass.
Landon Cox
>Silvally
yikes
Kevin Turner
>unironically playing ANY sonic game post-genesis besides mania
Lincoln Ross
>shadow
No
If you have to have 2 sonic reps, eggman is the best choice
Josiah Bell
>Chef Kawasaki
>Marx
Oh wow, this is somehow worse.
Jeremiah Cooper
>King Boo
>Dixie Kong as an echo
>Midna
>Silvally
>Removing Dark Pit for no reason
>Shadow as a unique character
>Big Boss instead of Liquid Snake
>Okami dog
>4:3
Logan Cook
Nah, echoes are interesting ways to put in characters that otherwise wouldn't get in, but these echoes flat out suck
Jackson Ross
>Liking Shadow
>Liking Sonic games at all
That's why he shouldn't be a character or echo. Not because he doesn't have the moveset potential. And that was obvious from the post, but because you're an autistic Sonic fan, you didn't pick up on it I see.
Xavier Ortiz
Silvally, another bayo rep, AND twili midna over normal midna with wolf link. Not gonna get a zozzle from me
Michael Sullivan
>Silvally
Adam Allen
Sorry Primarina, there's only room for one sea creature in the roster.
Nathan Clark
Yeah, Inkling.
Kevin Smith
>he fell for the splatoon meme
just take the squarepill, user
Levi Jones
It has Shadow, and is therefore based.
Hunter Kelly
>no isaac
fuck off
Gavin Garcia
Remove Corrin and Palu and its okinstrad of bad.
Ian Wood
>Funky doesn't deserve it.
fuck off
Samuel Miller
>All these DK reps
>Cut Shulk
ok retard
Hunter Brown
*straightens Fall Out Boy shirt*
mm
*tightens Naruto headband*
MM
*pauses My Chemical Romance CD*
*adjusts studded wristbands*
Sooo much this... I f*!@king love Shadow...
*noms Pocky*
mm... He's the coolest...
*cuts self*
Easton Parker
*What even is this thread now? The who can make the shitiest smash roster?
Isaac White
>Being a cutfag
faggot fuck you
Justin Roberts
Great arguments fellas. Really keeping the quality of this board up.
Grayson Anderson
>Reimu
Nah
Christopher Jackson
>Implying S&SASTR isn't the Best party racer game ever created
Carson Cook
Sakurai already did.
Jordan Cox
>I want less characters instead of more
David Ramirez
**AHEM**
Best Roster coming through.
Jayden King
It isn't. Not even the best Sega racing game. But it is pretty good.
>being a rosterfag
Michael Ramirez
Why do you niggers still think Dr. Mario is an echo fighter when they have different movesets?
Zachary Long
AHEM
Nathaniel Morgan
>Big Bob-Omb
Stopped right there. Scrap this roster and try again.
Matthew Mitchell
>Niko
this almost salvaged it
Hunter Miller
>Big Bob-Omb
Based Based Based!
David Bailey
What's up? Need a throat lozenge?
Kevin Bailey
Adeleine would be super based.
Henry Cruz
first of all, not with that aspect ratio
also
>kept the reddit alien AND added a clone
>literal who inbetween simon and banjo
>dumped the miis
>kept ness and lucas (nobody cares and you're not getting mother 3)
>still more FE characters than donkey kong, kirby, star fox, etc...
there's more that's wrong but I don't want to continue
Eli Long
What is Canon doing there
Angel James
>cutting characters
EVERYONE IS HERE is the best possible pre-dlc roster for Smash Bros and yet you faggots still do this shit
Luis Garcia
Who is the reddit alien? perhaps someone who browses it like you could help me out/
Jonathan Martinez
>shadow as the second sonic rep
>over one of the most based vidya villains of all time
Jaxson Reed
>waaaaaaah why don't you want trash included in the game!
Oliver Bennett
Biggest roster in the series yet less replay value than Melee and Brawl. It's almost like rosterfagging is retarded, and it's a lot more important to make lots of challenges and game modes tailored to each character. Spirit battles are a really lazy way of trying to supplement that. Maybe if they add a real Adventure Mode, and a Classic Mode where each character gets a unique map for Board the Platforms and Break the Targets designed specifically to challenge them, then it'll be worth it. Until then it isn't.
Joseph Morgan
why would you fucking cut ness
Caleb Robinson
because either ness or lucas, not both
earthbound really only has a cult following, if you're going to shrink the roster there's no reason to have 2 characters from it
Austin Allen
Fuck Nintendo
Levi Flores
This! So much this! I luv Shadow!
Nobody cares sonic sux
Christian Stewart
The fact that you're avatarfagging with that image unironically is top cringe, my dude.
Carter Murphy
Because 4:3 is objectively superior for video games and only got pushed out by the cinematic focus of the Western market.
Cameron Flores
Autism
Cameron Clark
>please give me less content for the same price
Justin Clark
not an argument
Kevin Jones
>devs should spend resources on garbage instead of good content
that sakurai dick sure must taste good
Caleb Garcia
>silvally
>shadow isn't an echo but midna is for some reason
>no blood falcon echo for falcon
>cutting dark pit but keeping lucina
no
Ryan Nguyen
>Silvally
Daniel Richardson
>porting over pre-existing characters takes up too much resources
Colton Bell
Alright, here's an argument. Both Ness and Lucas have bigger followings as fighters and characters than most of the fighters you say we should keep.
Kevin Jones
I love Dragalia and genuinely want him in but Corrin already fits the "anime boy who turns into a dragon" niche
Colton Campbell
Plus he looks almost the same as Shulk
Ryder Russell
Reminder.
Gabriel Rogers
>no cloud
>no squall
> no mega man x
>no arthur from ghosts n goblins
>but most importantly no cloud
You need to be culled from the gene pool
Xavier Cooper
>Midna echo for Zelda
never even thought about that
Christopher Sanders
>Banjoke
In the trash it goes.
Jordan Ortiz
>Kawasaki over Adeleine, Bandanadee, or Daroach
Jace Morris
Chef Kawasaki is a better pick than Marx.
Brayden Allen
No roster can beat this
Benjamin Ortiz
Kawasaki is a random mook helper/miniboss. And if you're going to put a random mook helper/miniboss in you might as well pick someone better like Bugzzy.
Jeremiah Reyes
>Remove Jigglypuff
>Add Edgy the Hedgey
Special place in hell for you my friend.
Jose Green
Late reply, but VS puzzle games like Puyo benefit from 16:9 since it allows for more room to display information between the boards.
Landon Rodriguez
you mean this one +sheik
Lincoln James
>Kawasaki is a random mook helper/miniboss
In non-autismo speak we call that miniboss a "character"
Noah Jones
>King Boo
>Character that is always lloating doing jumps and falling to his death
>A character who nobody even cares about besides being the best in double dash
Yeah that won't look retarded at all.
Nathan Barnes
Where is Alex yiik though?
Isaac Reyes
>Gardevoir
>Decidueye
full retard
Evan Nelson
Retard
Hudson Reed
Chef Kawasaki is the best Kirby character.
Eli Russell
>>Character that is always floating doing jumps and falling to his death
>>A character who nobody even cares about
Perfectly describes Bowser Jr in the baby clown car but Sakurai put him in anyway. Probably just because Miyamoto begged him though.
Elijah Adams
I agree bowser jr is fucking stupid but even he's more important and has a more cohesive moveset than fucking King Boo.
Benjamin Hill
People actually care about Bowser Jr. And he could even bring along the Koopalings.
Cooper Powell
If having some dialogue in a non-canon spinoff is enough to quantify something as a "character" then so is Broom Hatter.
Christopher Martin
Yeah of course he is. Everyone in Dream Land is a character.
James Moore
Why have Bayo when her debut didn’t even began with Nintendo. At least the Final Fantasy series started with Nintendo.
Alexander Scott
She's cool
Landon Russell
The point I'm making is that Kawasaki isn't important enough to be in Smash. You can like him but he's on the level of every other helper/miniboss. Marx might have been a one-off but he was the final boss and antagonist of Super Star, which automatically makes him more important and thus more relevant than Kawasaki. Although Bandana Dee, Daroach, Adeleine, Taranza, and Susie are better picks and more relevant than Marx, people latched on to Marx because of Sakurai's Super Star bias making him seem more feasible.
Luis Baker
>saying this when Sonic, Snake, and Pac-Man are there
Having your first game originate on a Nintendo system has never been a requirement.
Luke Green
>Amaterasu instead of Dante
Jonathan Stewart
Are you fucking retarded? fuck off
Charles Smith
Take out the Pokemon and the ghost and put in Geno and Skull Kid and a decloned Ganon and it's perfect.
Dominic Myers
Truly the ultimate showdown.
Jason Hughes
Consider your roster shit if
>it has Corrin
>it lacks Banjo, Geno and Isaac
Gabriel Lopez
The point I'm making is that your perameters don't matter. The one you guys tout as "next in line" and " next most important" didn't even get an assist trophy nor a spirit battle. If a character is good, or has potential, they should be used.
Noah Baker
>assist trophy playable
Luis Peterson
eveeything after cloud is a fucking nightmare, holy shit
also
>cutting fire emblem just to add EVEN MORE fire emblem
Andrew Morris
Little Mac was an assist trophy too.
Nathan Baker
>Shadow isn't an echo
I'm down for this
Grayson Barnes
>Toon Shit over based Young Link
"No!"
Dylan Walker
not in the same game brother
Dylan Fisher
And made-up dream rosters aren't games. What was your point?
Joshua Miller
Based
Ryan Brown
Well why did the other third party jrpg fags didn’t make the cut. I love them.
Luis Gomez
Cloud is more iconic. Bayo is a literal who to most people.
Benjamin Flores
Rosterfags are a fucking tumor. Imagine if people were asking for half the weapons to be cut in Splatoon 3. Imagine if people were asking to have Super mario bros 3 and new super mario bros removed from Mario Maker
Christopher Cooper
DW guys I'll cancel this guy out by considering your roster good if it meets those criteria.