So now that the dust has settled, how was it?

its my favorite game i dont understand the how someone could dislike it

Attached: 1552669154057.png (1526x935, 1.54M)

I fucking love Arthur Morgan

Great everything, except gameplay. I'm hoping PC fixes that.

And fuck you

good fuck rdr2

I loved the story and the characters, which is the only reason to play rockstar games anymore despite the amount of "realism" they cram into them.

If you wanted a truly open world western sandbox with a non-linear story and missions system then tame a horse im minecraft and knock yourself out.

game of the decade

Incredible, an experience more than anything else

From the combat, riding around, minigames, music, storyline, missions, all the way to the atmosphere it's an achievement

Incredibly immersive and fun as fuck

Attached: IMG_1115724d-f960-49b4-b149-87c9e2c019aa.png (1920x1080, 850K)

>combat
>fun

Hunting is fun. Can dress up your cowboy, then get sad.

Could have been good if they focused as much on gameplay and mission design as they did on all that other shit that ultimately doesn't matter. Shit like the camp system felt like wasted potential, how giving Pearson food does nothing, the wanted/witness system feeling half baked and broken at times, bandanna's working retardedly (whole point is that nobody recognizes you when you use one but Law always recognize you), how you can never rob a train without getting caught, felt like you were suppose to have fewer rations and such so you'd be required to hunt/forage for food if you were away from any towns or outposts for a long period but was changed last minute so you never have to worry about cores and properly some other shit I'm forgetting about.

>1 hour
I'm not watching all that /pol/, just give us the quick rundown.

Online was the worst garbage i've ever seen. Brings the games rating down to a 7/10.

Ragdolls, gore and weapons all feel satisfying.

fuck off falseflagging tranny
Rockstar games are pretty neutral when it comes to politics

Basically, rockstar has always acted to be edgy and cool so they can pretend to wax poetically about "what it means to be an american" while promoting degeneracy. I would recommend giving this guys videos a watch though. He isn't really /pol/.

better than any nip shit in years

Attached: Red Dead Souls.png (882x863, 339K)

Watch the video faggot.

Cool characters apart from Sadie in the mid game I liked her much better During John's segment. The rest was meh. I've had a bit of a buyers remorse after purchasing the game at full price.

Attached: 1553417469144.jpg (1036x696, 78K)

kino

Unironically a 10/10

Most beautiful open world ever realized
So dedicated to realism and immersion it could almost qualify as a sim
Top tier writing. Morgan is one of the best protags ever
So much content, even after hundreds of hours still finding things i hadnt seen before

Ive literally had sessions where I just spent hours traveling the world, taking in the atmosphere, hunting and just stumbling on things I haven't before.

It's a masterpiece.

Rockstar shills in force itt. Game is boring shit, only redeeming value is graphics and shooting. That shotgun goddamn

>IF YOU LIKE IT YOU'RE A SHILL
>IF YOU DISAGREE WITH MY YOU CAN'T HANDLE CRITICISM

yawn

It makes me feel like a cowboy

To be honest, its way inferior to Breath of the Wild

>Implying R* shills aren't the only people play this
>R* shills are als scientifically proven to at least be 90% of the males in the world
>Be based
Fuck rockstar and fuck you

based schizo

nope its shit.
youtube.com/watch?v=fM6L3-5tQug

Attached: 1550836954693.jpg (1920x640, 331K)

Already postedObjectively it isn't shit but has hamfisted politics.

>dust
haha good one

>watching 1 hour long /pol/tard videos on youtube instead of actually playing the game
Yeah you're nu-Yea Forums alright.

we really need to rise up over this already

>How dare rockstar portray white people in a negative light it's a regular white genocide!!!

have sex

Find Love Emcel

Shilled to all fuck and back and I didn't buy it anyway.
Victory:
Me 1
Poorly paid team of viral marketers 0

What the fuck does that even mean?

Americans did do shitty things. It's not so much political in any real sense to portray pseudo historical events that were mostly based on real world events.

at least meme adequately

Game of the gen my man.

Attached: a_rdr2_thumbs up.webm (640x360, 2.76M)

Attached: 1553990744497.gif (460x359, 77K)

I just watched and I agree that some of this shit is obnoxious like the whole Sadie character, but it's not that big part of the game. I just hope that Rockstar goes back to being more centrist with the next GTA game.

They won't bigot. And that is a good thing.

I'll probably never play it again. Story was kind of cool at first but it just got stupid when Dutch kept not explaining anything or did shit for no real reason. I was just rushing to finish it halfway through.

>And yet, I still loved it because i'm a total fucking cuck for Westerns
Probably helps that the amount of good western videogames you can count on a single hand

it's forgettable. maybe even the most forgettable game in R* history. The ping pong game gives me more feels than this.

this. on top of the looting i just lost interest and waited for rdr2 online. but that has its own problems too so i just stopped caring.
mission structure too go too predictable
>ride horse to here meet up with guy
>okay ride with your posse to do some gay shit like steal money
>go on shoot out
>return back to camp
>repeat

hunting was fun though

I miss Arthur.

The game was a lot of fun though. You do need to take your time with it and explore and all that. I understand that isn't for everyone though. I really loved exploring the map though. Finding little things and watching Arthur scribble them on the map and then in his journal was great. All the weird people he ran into as well, their conversations you got to hear as you ran into them again later. The mad preacher, the guy in the cave, the king in the tree, the blind prophet. Stuff like that was a lot of fun and fulfilling to me.

Attached: Dutchs_gang.jpg_large.jpg (2048x1576, 414K)

Most of these points and the general direction of the video is accurate but there's a bit of paranoid reaching in here that liberals will use to discredit the whole thing. decent vid tho

That's because the whole video is a paranoid reach.

>game rated 18+
>everything pandering to 10 years old
>can kill every innocent people
>no prostitutes
>ugly women
>black cowboys
>can't ride with rifles on back (still a fucking mistery)
>online xd

Anyway still a 9/10 for graphic, openworld, hunting and just riding around this huge ass map

well you're kinda proving my point. missions like the black doctor loses his cart one felt completely out of place even within the context of the rest of the game, where later on Arthur literally tells the Indian chief that he doesn't care about helping them and only does help because Charles almost begs him

No, you are reaching. Arthur has orders from Dutch to not interfer in the Indians business as it would mess with his scheme. The doctor is just a stranger mission earlyish in the game. Both of these are also optional and you don't have to do either.

Arthur is suspiciously modern in his worldview, but the game is fun regardless.

Attached: Baithammer.png (860x860, 157K)

Arthur was basically raised by Dutch who is very modern and tries to be ahead of society which he considers to be trash.