Why does it still hurt?

Attached: 1544481861097.gif (540x300, 2.84M)

>Have white Arabian most of the game
>get to the point where you can buy the black Arabian, get it use it for a bit
>do The Veteran and get Buell
>becomes favourite horse and spend hours with my best bro
>then that one two punch at the end
why you gotta do me this way, man

Because that's the way it is

>thank you
I didn't ask for these feels.

Attached: 1541355638136.jpg (700x700, 68K)

Ending made me proud of Dutch desu. He recognized it too late but he ended up doing the right thing, avenging Arthur and trying to protect John.

In that scene I had the horse from the first mission. I miss my nigga Amarillo

Same, I read the spoilers and still wasn't prepared.

Attached: feelsbadman.jpg (102x124, 3K)

>That talk with the nun at the train station

Attached: sad.jpg (728x547, 17K)

I started playing again last night. I just miss Arthur. Why is he so perfect?

Also what was everyone's favorite song? This one is probably mine.
youtu.be/qHer-rGfTco

Where did bad rockstar touch you, lad?

youtube.com/watch?v=tWqHnaWk0f0

Attached: file.png (1381x727, 1.21M)

That is how I played the first time, it took me a month, I filled in the map and his journal too. I think it made me enjoy it a lot more.

>I didn’t lose!
>I stopped you...and I told everyone you were a rat
>THAT’S WINNING ENOUGH FOR ME

Mickey conversation was sadder for me.

The way it is low honor ver.

Was it kino?

Attached: imafraid.jpg (1280x720, 84K)

>still no SP DLC

Why are we still here, cowpokes? Just to suffer?

My Dear Arthur,
You never showed up, and now, after looking at the newspapers I understand why. I don't imagine you will receive this letter but I nonetheless must send it. Arthur, oh, Arthur. I was just starting to dream the silliest and softest of dreams. I miss you, and I will always miss you but I cannot live like that, and it seems you cannot live any other way.

When I am with you, the world makes sense but when we are apart, I see clearly that your world is not a world from which one can escape. I am so sorry, for everything, for everything long ago and for starting up that business again. There's a good man within you, Arthur but he is wrestling with a giant. And the giant, wins, time and again. You've broken my heart, again, and I fear I have broken yours.

For that, I will never forgive myself but you must let me go now. I enclose a ring you gave me many years ago, when we were both young, not because I don't like it, but because I care for it far too much and it reminds me too much of you. I hope, one day you will find some people in love who can use this, for it kept me thinking of you all these years, and I hope by returning to you I can finally be free.

Goodbye,
Mary

Attached: 1547399200952.png (773x397, 325K)

you did your worst you tried your best
now its time to rest

Attached: 1554181012800.png (695x618, 552K)

I wish you could have gotten Buell earlier. My time with him was cut far too short, far too soon.

I was crying so hard when my horse bro died, I was bawling when Arthur finally went, looking off as the sun rose. His last words were just too much.

Undead Nightmare 2 is on its way.

Attached: Red Dead Redemption 2 - Zombie horse.webm (1280x720, 2.53M)

It was. Fags who didn't enjoy it rushed through the game instead of taking their time.

It hits like a train cause he’s joking around with the nun and gets serious all of the sudden

Arthur with beard or without a beard? Or wild choice of stubble?

only if you had the hobo full beard + hair look

Attached: 1546817592050.jpg (1280x712, 96K)

"game" was shit.
zoomers pretend to like it so they can fit in with the original Red Dead audience.

This game is zoomer repellent.

Yea Forums....Yea Forums! LISTEN UP SON, WE JUST NEED ONE MORE THREAD, JUST ONE MORE THREAD AND WE CAN MAKE IT BROS. HAVE SOME GOD DAMN FAITH. JUST ONE FINAL THREAD, ONE FINAL SHITPOST, AND WE'RE GOLDEN!

Attached: 1542526345280.jpg (673x673, 43K)

>original RDR audience
>unironically trying to gatekeep the original RDR of all games
audibly kek'd
thanks

Attached: Dutch's mom blackwater grave.jpg (3840x2160, 1.1M)

With a beard and midlong hair, pushed back for maximum feels.
Arthur is a man shaped by nature but with enough decency to put some pomade every once in a while.

No beard/low beard till Guarma
After that never shave

Stubble on the chin and cheeks, but longer mustache

Dutchposting was the most fun 2 weeks I've ever had on Yea Forums/nel

>tfw all the pieces fall in to place and you just realize Tilly stole the money in the end

Fuck, dude. I finished my second playthrough and just picked up on this, Jesus Christ. She's the only one who gets away with any success, everyone else became bounty hunters and shitty general store owners.

Cruel, cruel world...

Attached: RDR2 100%.jpg (1920x1072, 303K)

Give me all your Dutch memes, Yea Forums.

Attached: Tahiti.jpg (599x755, 108K)

>Just you left, is it?
>YEAH, JUST ME
>Red Dead Redemption theme starts playing
I didn't even like RDR1 that much but holy fuck that was masterfully pulled off. Absolute 10/10 kino.

Attached: 1984946541.png (1507x632, 245K)

Also, fatten yourself up until Gaurma, so the TB weightloss is more contrasted

You got it

Attached: 1541883904565.jpg (570x664, 303K)

Full beard was shit. Light stubble is the most kino.

it never stops

Attached: I'm afraid.jpg (1920x1080, 213K)

Attached: 0yjzfl15ahc21.jpg (1881x991, 69K)

Attached: 1541881945552.jpg (1100x1196, 238K)

THERES ALWAYS A GODDAMN THREAD

She does mention she won’t die poor lmao.
I like to believe she shared some with Abbey and John and that’s how they got by for a decade

Attached: 1547009154812.jpg (1024x775, 49K)

Attached: 1542069697592.png (244x349, 103K)

Attached: 6F9016F1-5190-49DF-A87E-D45D39727FF4.jpg (712x888, 126K)

Attached: Red-Dead-Redemption-2_20190316162910.png (2560x1440, 2.62M)

kek

Attached: 0_36.jpg (3840x2160, 328K)

INSIST-MIND

I wonder how much time was spent on facial hair in this game, 'cause it looks crazy good.

Attached: dw4188wtzcb21.jpg (1240x1078, 97K)

Attached: 1542046050796.jpg (751x656, 132K)

it was

Attached: 1554740272699.jpg (480x360, 14K)

Everything in this game looks good. Can't wait for the inevitable PC port, so we can see it in all its glory.

Attached: RDR2 Kino.jpg (1920x1080, 86K)

>Ctrl+F "lumbago"
>No results
I'm dissapointed

Who was your favorite chapter baddie?
Pic related is mine, he’s sort of who Dutch wishes he was.

Attached: 7C9906F7-C2FA-4902-8734-BE23B69437AB.jpg (770x350, 34K)

He is in a better place. One where he isnt scared

Attached: 1542398381666.jpg (3840x2160, 877K)

INSIST? YOU INSIST?

HAVE SOME GOD DAM PHFAITH

Yes. Chapter 6 is probably one of the most depressing story arcs in a game, but it was amazing.

>inevitable
Just like RDR1?
Is it actually coming for Epic or not?

Uncle has two voice actors in RDR2 because the first and original one died while the game was in development. They kept his lines, and it's why one of the songs makes a reference to New Bordeaux instead of St. Denis - the actor was dead when they made the change.

Attached: 0_22.jpg (1920x1072, 221K)

Why is Dutch posting the best?

Why did he leave Arthur in that factory?

>Is it actually coming for Epic or not?
Why would it be an exclusive? Rockstar already has their own store. If it was an exclusive, it'd be a Rockstar Social Club exclusive, and Rockstar doesn't care about $5 million Epic might throw at them.

That's the way it is

**AHEM!!**

I wish you could buy a physical copy of Arthurs journal.

Attached: 1541984236902.jpg (446x598, 20K)

He suspected Arthur was the rat and letting him get killed by getting away was killing two birds with one stone

R* would be dumb not to port it to PC and 9th gen consoles to get people to double dip, similar to what they did with GTAV. This game printed them money on just the PS4 and Xbox One alone.

Literal brain damage.

I can't find the "This post gave me tuberculosis" meme

I know why he did it. I just wish he didn't go crazy after Hosea died. The weaker Arthur got the stronger and more influence Micah got.

>UNCLE, JACK, COME OUT HERE
>It's over, Abigail. It's finally over.
>that hug
>that fucking song

youtube.com/watch?v=dPjhnuCNsD8

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH ROCKSTAR WHY WOULD YOU DO THIS TO ME I KNOW IT WON'T END WELL FOR THEM

Attached: 1456534037296.jpg (393x325, 83K)

>Expecting the game to explain why Dutch went from a philosophical revolutionary to a madman
>In game explanation: "I bonked ma head Orther"

m.youtube.com/watch?v=j8068ZrwicQ For me I enjoy a happy song

IM GONNA TAKE MY HORSE TO THE OLD TOWN ROAD

Is Arthur one of the most attractive characters in games?
It makes me sad whenever he calls himself ugly.

Ok guys time to make some smoke to escape.

Shoot literally everyone on sight

Attached: Robot-in-Red-Dead-Redemption-2.jpg (1920x1080, 528K)

When he does that?

Someone on plebbit theorized that Arthur has low self esteem about his looks cause the gang bantzed him on it, even tho he's a ram ranch Chad

The game actually never explains it. It gives the players multiple interpretations of the reasoning behind Dutch's character change, which is good writing.
It's kinda funny because it goes against the mission gameplay design - where the gameplay is fairly restricted, the narrative and characters are left fairly open to interpretation and the game really doesn't spoonfeed you.

Rent a room and interact with the mirror. He gets pretty depressing after a while.

Go to any mirror in a room you can rent and hold L2.

no one can hear you escape if there's gunshot sounds everywhere

Attached: arthur-mary.png (569x650, 654K)

It might have some to do with him being dumped all those times too. And just low self esteam in general. He probably honestly thinks he is dumb as well. His writing tells a different story though.

>PC port still decades away

Attached: 1515019682381.png (500x500, 170K)

youtube.com/watch?v=YDkLIvbOeEc

Attached: Try not to cry.jpg (1049x550, 120K)

>the actions of one j*w
Yeah it was a real dick move getting beaten up by thug enforcing the literal jewry of his moneylender boss.

He looks more attractive when he is older. Which is kinda odd. His scruff helps.

Why did this give me feels?

Attached: maxresdefault.jpg (1280x720, 108K)

>Gameplay is restrictive
Yeah, I never bought that E-celeb NakeyJakey's video and will never watch it despite youtube shilling it to me endlessly since november
It's a narrative driven game and has as much freedom in missions as GTA 4, 5, and RDR1

Will someone find her in 11 years after multiple hidden events trigger correctly?

She HAS to be somewhere, it makes no sense Rockstar would include this for no reason.

Unless she’s in RDR3.

Attached: 634B1F21-FD03-44AF-AF9A-4C1405377A26.png (930x1250, 965K)

MAY I

what's
>all those times
he only had 2 women that we know of - a young one before Mary Beth with whom he had a son with and Mary-Beth herself. I guess the Mary-Beth shitshow might've done a number on his self esteem, but women seem to jump at his dick, including the whores at the saloon. only reason he doesn't get action is because he's rude and autistic in the first words he blurts out and they run away.

Oh, you haven't played the first game...

>E-celebs
There's your problem.

This big ol world has got me runnin round

He looks so fucking young man. Mary is qt, too. Our boah deserved so much better.

she's dead user

Don't get me wrong user, I'm not saying it's a bad thing. I've watched the Naked dude's video and it's mostly ridiculous comparisons and a guy that doesn't seem to grasp that Rockstar doesn't make RPGs.
I was just stating a fact - RDR2's missions are restrictive, and yes, just like GTA4, GTA5, RDR1's.

Maybe it was part of some cut content.

>TFW RDR3 is at least five years away

I guess I meant more Mary. It seems like it was super on and off and it probably ended very poorly everytime.

I did though.

That was some cute shit and showed Arthur would have been great husband material.

Attached: Red-Dead-Redemption-2_20190419145646.png (2560x1440, 3.47M)

Got this game spoiled for me which sucks but loving the shit out of it so far. Just got forced to do the debt collection mission with the coughing guy. Arthur is such a fantastic character, an actual man of grey moral fibre whereas John always felt more law abiding in RDR1

more like 10, won't get another GTA for at least 3 years. Gta V is gonna be 6 years old here in a few months, fuck

it's probably some inside joke user
also why 11 years?

arthur looks so weird in all these young pictures 'cause they didn't adjust his frame. 20 year old face on a 35+ year old body.

Where are the bones.

Goddamn I wish I could just fuck off to a mountain top or something when I need to be alone

So we can all agree that, at this point, GTA is their cashcow, while Red Dead Redemption is their passion project, right?

Attached: file.png (2000x1886, 149K)

I didn’t even try V, the setting is so boring.

Just wait for the Bully sequel user, then you'll see a passion project
R-right guys?

Oh shit. I hope this is true, it's a fair trade off imo

The beards all look like shit. Why cover Arthurs handsome face?

The first statement is true, I wouldn’t go that far with the second tho.

The actual soul behind RDR.

Attached: file.png (1200x633, 931K)

Not sure desu. When I think cash cow I think one game every year Ass creed style. GTA’s last game was in 2013 and they refuse to release anything modern during the trump administration. Expect a retro throwback like Vice City that disconnects itself from everything

GTAV is the single most profitable piece of entertainment ever made across any medium. If that's not a cash cow, nothing is.

Woody Jackson, god bless this man

>GTA: [VI]ce City
I would be happy desu.

Attached: 0_0.jpg (1920x1072, 244K)

2019. I am forgotten.

RDR & MDE never dies

youtube.com/watch?v=XiQYRXyz7vw

Attached: 1543637396404.png (1000x1000, 965K)

I'll remember you user

>Frequent threads that still reach bump limit
>Forgotten

When he's overweight his face looks like trash.

Attached: Red Dead Redemption 2_20181228000002.png (1856x1556, 3.76M)

>no wonder they all leave you

Attached: 1542314820639.jpg (1452x1180, 401K)

Damn it Arthur...

Why do you have to be like this?

I imagine overweight Arthur heavy bearthing during important conversations and everyone just has to deal with it

I haven't played since November. Did they ever find Gavin?

Christ I didn't even know he could look like this

How many Arthur wojak edits are there?

>Not keeping Arthurs chad body in perfect shape.

>he doesn't know

>Getting old and kinda sad
Stop

Heavy breathing between TB coughing fits. Mid convo Arthur Smokes a cigar and eats a can of salted offal

GTA is where Rockstar does satire and comedy while RDR is where they do something more serious.

Satire is gay

kino?

>RDR is serious

Attached: red-dead-redemption-2-ufo.png (1818x1023, 1.05M)

The only actual flaw in the game's writing is the scene where sadie, wounded with a stab wound in the gut, somehow climbs the frozen mountains and shows up behind micah without anyone ever realising. Not to mention that it's absurd she got there in the first place, but it was literally impossible to get to that spot she showed up in without micah seeing her.

How did Dan houser, Michael unsworth or Rupert humphries not catch that

kino

Attached: kino.jpg (780x440, 92K)

Kino

Attached: Mission_3_Ending.jpg (1280x720, 83K)

Weird West is still a valid part of the Western genre.

The only flaw is Arthur not fucking her calm when she mouths off to Pearson in Chapter 3. No, you don't get to wear guy clothes or go robbing

>GET DOWN HERE NOW!
>YOU INBRED TRASH!

Attached: 1537381340826.png (1089x776, 1.26M)

CLASSIC

>RDR is serious

Attached: red-dead-redemption-2-mutant.jpg.optimal.jpg (1080x600, 106K)

There is plenty of satire on Red Dead, tho there was way more in 1 than 2.

Sadie is a ridiculous character made for captain Marvel audience.

That whole scene was kino as fuck. It made you understand why so many people followed Dutch.

>Sadie is a ridiculous character made for captain Marvel audience
Have sex

I thought it was odd that is the place Micah knows and goes to meet Arthur out of there.

Have sex.

>Anyone who dislikes Sadie is an incel

Sadie was pretty good. Sometimes she pushed it but she was looking to die and out for revenge. Hunting O'Driscall scum with her was fun.

I said have sex first, retard
Now, slide me a (you) and an upboat, and we'll call it even

It was shit and you should have spent the money on diapers for your biological children fucking snoys

>poor choice of attire.

Attached: I'm afraid.jpg (360x1008, 142K)

Kek

That is the pattern I have observed. There's nothing wrong with sadie's character. Besides she's arthur's most loyal friend.

yes

Attached: rdr2 you can pinpoint the exact moment Arthur finally finds some god damn faith.webm (640x546, 2.19M)

Attached: hqdefault (1).jpg (480x360, 17K)

>eccentric recluse does crazy shit away from civilization
More news at 11

Get your own damn drank!

>she's arthur's most loyal friend.

Attached: JohnMarston-Redemption2.jpg (513x513, 44K)

>There's nothing wrong with sadie's character.
Except she's the most annoying character in the game by a large margin.

>arthur's most loyal friend
Who is Jim Milton, for 500

Shut up Micah you goddam rat.

>starter horse
Thats gonna be a based from me

can she be romanced?

Attached: hmmm.jpg (321x322, 25K)

>arthur's most loyal friend.
Did you mean Charles Smith?

Go back to Yea Forums, R9K is a nsfw board

That's not the suffragette in Saint Denis square.

Did he even know arthur had tb? John never did anything for arthur. It was always arthur saving his ass.

I like Sadie, but that is John or Charles as his closest friend.

user, your incel is showing.
The most annoying character in the game is that fucker looking for Gavin.

This.

Attached: RDR2-Arthur-and-John.jpg (1915x809, 103K)

Just gonna leave this here for my cowbros
rave.dj/J4bnfnnuFq_1Cw

Im familiar with the vengeful widow thing but feels there’s some gaps in her character that seems that are left there deliberately so there can be a totally badass female gunslinger. Like filling a quota.

>annoying
>is super friendly and is just a sick man
The woman on the other hand will literally never shut up, is always screaming the same fucking 3 lines, and acts like a cunt towards arthur.

I wish Charlotte's missions were available earlier & Arthur would go for her instead of bitch ass Mary Linton so he would at least have a smidge of happiness

It is less jarring if you don't fuck up that one quest in chapter 2 that removes her from the camp.

Alright, I got chills. This is my last (you) for the month, user. Be more considerate next time you drop a fire link like that next time

YOU SHOULDVD MARRIED MARY BETH

Redroof me on the details of this glitch pls

0-1 hours - woah cool
1-2 hours - hmm
2-3 hours - jesus christ hurry up
3-5 hours - what is even happening, what am i supposed to do in this world
5-6 hours - aye this is quite good
6-10 hours - damn this is great
10-20 hours - holy fuck this is incredible
20+ - pic related

Attached: 1445988595452.jpg (520x638, 218K)

I never noticed her at all in Saint Dennis after that quest. Meanwhile you hear him yelling for Gavin in every town basically for the whole rest of the game.

Didnt she liked Kieran?

>for the whole rest of the game
Complete his quest dumbass

Well. He died.

Single player dlc when?

Attached: 20190418_095718.png (939x720, 601K)

It happens if you mess up the Uncle mission in chapter 2. She, Jack and Abigail go missing from the camp for the rest of chapter 2. She comes back in Rhodes.

No she liked Sean, they fuck during one of the camp parties

What quest are you talking about? The screaming woman has no quest.

Attached: B605D668F3F541E784C0B5DE64AAD7E1.png (537x585, 118K)

That's the fat drunk one.

>Mess up
Clarify, nigger

Karen.

If you have to restart at all. I did it my first play through when I didn't get to slut in time when I had never been to Valentine before and got lost...

So did Arthur ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Charles is one of the biggest bros is vidya
I hope he's happy in Canada with a caring wife

Attached: charles.jpg (1280x720, 85K)

:(

CharlottexArthur is better.
Mary BethxArthur is second.
Dutch taking advantage of Arthur for sex is third.

She's more rabid than badass

>just one more wojak

Attached: dutch wojak.jpg (920x863, 130K)

I remember how much he triggered Yea Forums when he first showed up.

Fuck sake im gonna ask... there are RDR doujins?

>*heavy nostril breathing*
>OOOHH

Attached: arthur oof Marron.png (538x493, 422K)

Don't compare MDE to this soi filth game.

Dutch was right.

RDR2 is söy repellent, partner.

Be honest, how hard did this scene hit you?

Attached: 2DBAEF79-C9A0-42B4-9B8A-70E224392C22.jpg (1280x720, 64K)

>RDR Online will never be good
>RDR2 will never get single player DLC just like GTA V
Why does Rockstar insist on ignoring their fans at every interval after making such fun single player campaigns? It really hurts knowing how long we'll have to wait for another game by them just to get cucked by these awful multiplayer modes.

Attached: image.jpg (944x703, 279K)

Charls likes RDR2

How?

youtube.com/watch?v=fM6L3-5tQug

There was a /y/ thread around for a while. A good amount of stuff on AO3. Too much of Arthur not being a botton though. How anyone sees him as a top is a mystery to me.

Attached: IMG_20190127_152145.jpg (1332x1207, 174K)

oh god

Attached: 1542160045796.jpg (422x433, 26K)

I went back for the money the first time.
I just wanted to give John enough money to start his ranch :-(

>RDR2 is feminis-

Attached: RDR2 feminism.webm (520x292, 2.66M)

You seem lost

very

Attached: Red Dead Redemption 2_20181104203119.jpg (1920x1080, 106K)

I cried for an hour.

Don't treasure hunt with Arthur and save the maps so John can get the gold bars.

Jesus mode avant-garde

Attached: Rdr2 Arthur Jesus.webm (1094x504, 601K)

>Why does it still hurt?
because you're a dildo?

arthur was a fucking joke and the gangs donkey/beast of burden. one sorry son of a bitch. he was designed solely to exploit sadness, he was hyper pathetic and a hyper loser who's only purpose was to evoke irrational emotion.

lame character.

1. I watched that video last night
2. I'm paypigging Sam $5/mo on gumroad (you probably aren't)
3. RDR2 raises your test and blocks estrogen production

kurt russell?

Everything about chapter 6 spiked my depression like a motherfucker
I didn't play the epilogue for quite a bit, because it just felt wrong the way it jumps right in

WELL LET ME HAVE A RULE AND A SAW AND A BOARD AND I'LL CUT IT

Attached: Comfy_blanket.jpg (600x579, 42K)

you dumbass

Have sex maybe it will cure your autism and lack or empathy you incel.

When I play a cool historical game, I don't want boring neoliberal values for pussies.
The world is pure trash, worse than Ubisoft tier.

>the fucking bluebird right there the whole time

Attached: 1463791554783.jpg (1080x1028, 146K)

The epilogue is good, it really is. But I just missed Arthur the whole time. John is great and all, but not hearing Arthur anymore sucked. They got 8 years to get over his death some but I was still recovering.

>a cool historical game
That's a rather interesting generalization of RDR2. I wouldn't call it historical at all considering murderous cowboys weren't really a thing.

Shure

Attached: 1541569548674.jpg (751x389, 65K)

>Murdering cowboys
They're called shootists you fucking non american. No one in the gang has herded cattle before the games events

>That echo of Arthur telling John to be one thing or another.

>tsck, ye know john? im a fat bastard. so fat maybe even, that i could eat my own journal. could you even inagine being so fat that you look at a journal and see food?
>no arthur, i can't quite imagine
>come to think of it, ain't so bad. fits with my hot air ballooning fetish.
>excuse me?
>ive decided to identify as a blue bear, john.
>that consumption done got to your brain. i think you need to lie down.
>i reckon id rather practice some awesome rhetorical judo
>you.... damn, your ass is big, arthur
>thanks john.

Attached: 1541625926415.png (1920x1080, 1.88M)

Oh Dutch... he’s a rat

Attached: 1494514745384.jpg (611x716, 98K)

This is cut content

God I can hear the voices

Why couldn’t we have a native in the gang tho?

Attached: 1542845290422.png (897x900, 873K)

>you.... damn, your ass is big, arthur
>thanks john.

Attached: spitting laugh.gif (400x225, 1.75M)

Good thing they are outlaws and not cowboys.

Me too. They stick with you for far too long and are unique.

What did Guarma served in the story? It looked like the devs reused contents from a past game they wanted to do and just put it there for some reasons.

>empathy for a fictional character, designed to be a hyper loser
you're making a mockery out of real tragic characters, you fucking infant. he's not real. he's purposely designed to be that pathetic and yet you insist on being a sucker for it.

arthur is unrealistic and a ridiculous exploitation of 'that type' of character.

Attached: tf.gif (236x224, 1.89M)

It was the tropical getaway dutch dreamed about.

Tries to explain no matter how far they go, even a tropical paradise, they will be caught up with eventually. And even tropical paradises have their own issues.

It's definitely not very well handled though if you ask me.

Imagine hating Arthur.
I mean, just imagine being that guy.

Attached: 1436987961502.jpg (494x366, 43K)

Please enlighten us on those true tragic characters

On the wiki it's mentioned that they cut 5 hours of missions from the game and a love interest for Arthur, I'm guessing the 5 hours of missions came from Gaurma

Time skip after St Dennis bank robbery, to show law and rich men influence can reach even supposed tropical paradises and to worsen Arthurs TB by having him dicking around in a very humid place.

That even when Dutch gets his goal it isn't really what he wants. He got his tropical paradise. They could have stayed and been out of it for good. But Dutch never wanted that.

>unrealistic
this is a board about video games

>want to replay RDR 2
>remember there's no new game plus
>remember Chapter 6 and the epilogue
>remember the choices not mattering in the slightest
>remember the postmodern revisionism
>remember the downgraded graphics post launch
>game remains on the shelf collecting dust

Attached: 1554262757080.png (740x537, 783K)

I hope the love interest was Mary Beth or Charlotte. Sadie would be a good wingman for Arthur or help him clean up and cheer up for his dates.

Attached: Dy7zZ8PVsAAEZQDorig.jpg (2942x2778, 1.19M)

I forgot they downgraded the graphics. I was wondering why it didn't look as good. Just play to chapter 3 and goof off with the gang before things go bad.

Attached: Dutchs_gang.jpg_large.jpg (2048x1576, 414K)

Attached: john annoyed.png (491x544, 329K)

The cutscene at the end of Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow got me right in the feels

It was almost certainly Charlotte

fuck him, fuck him as a character. fuck whatever writer that even tried to lay it on that thick. he (arthur) was a exploitation device.

honestly, all they had to do was have micah kill him. the whole addition of making him have a bad cold to top it off, as you watch him fucking die slowly was just ridiculous.

not only that, how are you supposed to believe he can be that sick and still have legendary hunting that has to be accomplished?

it was fucking stupid. unless you're irrational and capable of suspending belief even further than you already have to...which, kids are capable of. so i get it from that point, but fuck....talk about corny character, arthur the sick donkey morgan lol. it's hilarious at how thick they tried to lay it on you when it came to that lame character.

Attached: a man arthur will never defeat.jpg (500x374, 34K)

I beat the game a few days ago (well ch. 6)

I cried when Arthur rode back to the camp with that absolutely KINO song

Absolutely GOAT game

Ok Micah. You won the Dutchbowl over Arthur. You don't need to rub it in.

I remember thinking about me having not enough goddamn faith after shooting Micah despite telling you he was there for the same reason as you.

I can just imagine all the guilt he was feeling after watching Arthur die. It is no wonder John after all his disenchantment with Dutch still can't bring himself to kill him.

He looks absolutely miserable in the epilogue, it surprises he goes back to the “freedom fighter” shtick

I hate the look Dutch gives John after shooting Micah

this guy was moron btw

Based slav

>but I can’t fight my own nature. That’s the paradox, don’t you see?

Attached: 174B794A-84CA-4356-B236-C42E4DAD68F2.jpg (1280x720, 72K)

Because we were stupid enough to believe that anything could live up to RDR1 without relying exclusively on its success

I didn’t like they reused that speech in RDR2 since it takes away some impact of his realization.
Then again he was BSing the soldiers then but ended up believing that same speech.

He needed Arthur to help hold hin together. Knowing what he gave up for what he got and Arthur's last words to him would have been soul crushing. I think with his freedom fighter gig he was trying to kinda recreate the gang the only way he could.

What look?

Just looked at this webm and said outloud "god he's so attractive"
how did rockstar do it

That is his sick look too. Take a look at healthy Arthur.

He looks at John, not saying a word after John finishes off Micah. It's like dutch is saying that John should feel bad for questioning him, when It's him that should've told John he's sorry for betraying the gang

A bastion of husbando-ism

Attached: Red-Dead-Redemption-2_20190310140452.png (2560x1440, 2.95M)

I miss you, bro.

After RDR2 this scene is so much sadder. I feel like after Arthur's death and the gang falling apart Dutch loses hope and goes through a depressive phase. Then in RDR1 he's just fighting because it's all he knows how to do even though he really has nothing left to fight for. It hit me hard too that when he adds "Our time is passed, John" he's echoing what Arthur had been saying all throughout RDR2 but that he didn't want to believe.

I was throwing the glowing eyes on characters. I was so fucking happy seeing them turn up on other sites.

Attached: MANGOMAN.png (572x572, 336K)

>Dutch (con fe)

Based Dutchposting historian user. A lot of people have your OC saved on their pc/phone

John even yells at him in RDR1 saying “YOU DON’T EVEN KNKW WHAT YOU’RE KILLING FOR!”

*know

Absolutely based. Dutchposting is peak Yea Forums.

I never liked him with a beard. I forgot to shave for a few days or a week Arthur is best.

I liked letting his beard grow out after Guarma to illustrate how much time had passed and the idea of Arthur letting the hair cover up how gaunt his face was becoming.

But Maximum Beard always makes me laugh.

Attached: just one more score.jpg (1455x818, 141K)

That fucking moustache.
Reminds me of Ricketts

Drawing a picture for Arthur. Just need some help with this letter.

What would Dutch say to Arthur if the plan actually worked?

Attached: Tahiti.jpg (3000x4325, 2.46M)

Should have had faith.
Then a ps saying from Micah calling him black lung or something.

Dear Tacitus Kilgore
I INSIST that you hop on the next boat to Tahiti Arthur STOP
The mangoes are juicy and more than enough to go round STOP
Me an Micah are cooking up a little plan STOP
We just need some money, a little smoke, and We'll leave the pinkertons in Tahiti STOP
We'll go to the one place they wouldn't expect us. Gaurma STOP
Sincerely, Aiden O' Malley

These are good, gonna go see if there's a cursive converter.

Eighteen naked cowboys in the showers at Ram Ranch
Big hard throbbing cocks wanting to be sucked
Eighteen naked cowboys wanting to be fucked
Cowboys in the showers at Ram Ranch
On their knees wanting to suck cowboy cocks
Ram Ranch really rocks
Hot hard buff cowboys, their cocks throbbing hard
Eighteen more wild cowboys out in the yard
Big bulging cocks ever so hard
Orgy in the showers at Ram Ranch
Big hard throbbing cocks ramming cowboy butt
Like a breeding ram wanting to rut
Big hard throbbing cocks getting sucked real deep
Cowboys even getting fucked in their sleep
Ram Ranch, it rocks
Cowboys love big hard throbbing cocks

Gavin died user.

I liked this but I really enjoyed when Milton just strolls the fuck into camp/

youtube.com/watch?v=0fwwvGiSCDs

been replaying rdr 1 to try and get my fix (already played rdr 2 twice)
The last third of the game is fucking kino. I love how the game doesnt end once Dutch dies and you get to do things around your farm. Man, they really nailed this part in rdr 2 too.

Sadie was one of the best characters towards the end

Attached: sadieslay.png (3136x1444, 2.7M)

Yeah it's from the epilogue but hearing this shit again during Jim Milton rides again and american venom made me have the will to finish the epilogue.

youtube.com/watch?v=-MK5ChLJTAk