Best games by combined Critic/User Scores & Best Game Lists

Do you agree with this Yea Forums?

Attached: AD927692-2FA1-418C-ADB6-92B32DC2D0B0.jpg (1200x1200, 654K)

Out of all of the open world games why is BOTW the one that people obsess over the most?

Because it's a Zelda game. Remember how Skyward Sword got rave reviews despite being flawed at best, downright shit at worst?

Lttp > Oot

Because it’s what everyone dreamed Twilight Princess was going to be, except without good dungeons or music but amazing everything else

most would rather fit better in a "most influential" game list than "best game" list

but they're all very, very good, except BOTW which is just decent

Where’s SoTN?

Nintendo Bonus, Zelda is the worst offender.

>OoT
Shit combat and visuals aside it's a decent game
>CT
Good
>BotW
Good
>SM64
Camera has aged like shit and these daus the levels haven't held up but the basic controls/movement are still top in class for 3d platformers
>ALttP
It's okay I guess
>SM
Bad like all 2D metroids are
>SMW
Solid 2D platformer but not a fan of the physocs
>FFVII
Shitty TL and 3d models aside it's fine
>FF3
Very boring combat and a bloated cast that gets in the way of the main storyline hold it back, okay at best
>RE4
it was shit then and it's shit now
>SM3
Okay platformer but kinda janky feeling with the physics
>MGS
It's braindead easy with shallow mechanics but it's got a lot of heart and some cool gimmicks, good
>SF2
Well the SNES version sucks but it's okay otherwise
>MP
Auto aim aside the atmosphere/level design makes it good
>Goldeneye
Garbage then and still is now
>HL2
Garbage then and still is now

Nowhere near what I'd pick for a top 16 (either for quality or importance at the time) but decent enough any way.

Nintendo bonus doesn’t exist since everyone has always loved their games, bonus only exists for Rockstar since Critics give then high reviews but will award GOTY’s to something else & gamers themselves usually hate them. Nintendo has a penalty, since Bayonetta 2 was utterly screwed out of GoTY despite 2014 being the worst year ever

>Bayonetta 2 was utterly screwed out of GoTY despite 2014 being the worst year ever
Bayo 2 was a 6.5/10 at best and the likes of Endless Legend, Shovel Knight, Rune Factory 4, Transistor, and The Talos Principle all dunked on it hard.

>Nintendo bonus doesn’t exist

>Skyward Sword 93
>Wind Waker 96
>Twilight Princess 96
>Breath of the Wild 97

GTA games never score below 95, Nintendo games constantly get sub 80 Scores. If Bonus existed then a 90 Billion dollar franchise like Pokemon would have as many 97’s as Mario & GTA

I’ll take the bait. Leave my beloved SM out of it

Remove GoldenEye, HL2 & BOTW. Add Shadow Of The Colossus, Castlevania: SOTN & SoulCalibur

None of it's bait, it's all honest opinions.

I don't think any 2D Metroid game has managed to have good feeling combat or decent enemy design, and that ruins most of them on its own for me. M and M2 also had shit map design in my opinion.

>GTA games never score below 95
Rockstar Bonus is also a thing.

>Nintendo games constantly get sub 80 Scores
Nintendo games with 80 scores are actually 65 or do you really believe Metroid: Other M is a 79 game?

Yeah, this is pretty much correct.

By this logic then every AAA company gets a bias & therefore it’s entirely unbiased Since reviewers are equally biased towards every AAA developer

Unironically this except GoldenEye is insultingly bad & shouldn’t be on any best game list when Perfect Dark is better in every way

>By this logic then every AAA company gets a bias

Yes, it's called "Big Publisher Bonus", but the Nintendo Bonus is the most offensive one because of the overall laziness.

Why is Alyx on the Boxart when she isn’t even the main character?