So this is a question I've really wanted to make ever since Sekiro came out and I played it. I checked and so far i haven't seen a poll with this specific question so far, maybe months ago, but i didn't see one including Sekiro. Sure it's been discussed in the OT, but i really wanted a dedicated thread for everyone to post their favorites From Software games.
I made sure you can vote several times so you can select your top 2 or 3 Souls games if they're tied for you as 1st place.
As much as I liked Sekiro, i still put Demon's Souls as my number 1 Souls games. The art and aesthetics, the sometimes anime look, bosses, weapons, armors, maps. I love everything about it, and i love the NG¨plus of it. Also, being a huge fan of Phantasy Star Online and having put thousands of hours into it, playing Demon's souls felt incredibly familiar.
Based. But as long as we're ramming souls: 2>sekiro>1>3>bb
Adrian Allen
Bloodborne old hunters>Sekiro>Dark souls 3>bloodborne>dark souls 1>demon's soul>dark souls 2
Henry Stewart
>the sometimes anime look What? Have you actually played Demon's Souls?
Adam Martin
BB>DS1>Sekiro>DeS>DS3>DS2
Robert Jones
exactly, demon's souls has the least anime look out of all of them.
Cooper Gomez
Demons>BB>DS2>DS3>DS1>SoTFS
I didn't beat Sekiro as I wanted a stealth game with action elements, but instead got an action game with stealth elements.
Justin Morgan
bb, des, das, sekiro, das3, das2
Luke Thomas
DaS>DeS>DaS2>Snekiro>Das3>>>DaS2 after they nerfed the fun stuff because of fucking PvP faggots Haven't played bloodborne
Thomas Morris
The skeletons in Demon's were pretty fucking anime
Ryder Thomas
For me is DaS3. It just is the game with the best PvP. If I'm going to play a game for years im going to chose the one that has more interesting stuff going on.
Too bad they won't release more dlcs for it. But that goes to all their other games other than Sekiro
Sebastian Young
Bloodborne by far.
Henry Edwards
Demon souls: solid first step into the genre and fun.
dark souls 1: masterpieces and carefully hand crafted
dark souls 2: recycled assets but enjoyable and better than nothing. Enjoyed gear hunting lore.
dark souls 3: good but It seemed like the company was arguing internally about the games accessibility and multiplayer.
Blood born: really good. Not a fan of the combat style but enjoyed everything else.
Sekiro: Good but way too easy since most bosses have a hard counter prosthetic, ability or ninjutsu
forgot to add Bloodborne between Dark Souls 2 and Demon's Souls
Asher Morgan
Bloodborne has the better setting than sekiro, i enjoyed both of them but i couldnt care that much about budhism japs and immortality as i did about a gothic setting and ayy lmaos
Sekiro. I'm a PCboi and never played DeS or BB. I also wouldn't have spent so much time playing Dark Souls hadn't there been online play. Sekiro however keeps my interest even after NG+7. I don't think I ever finished a single NG+ run on Dark Souls games.
I cringe every time someone says Bloodbourne is the best. It's the most obvious try hard shit cuz I bought a PS4 for the damn game and I was embarrassed as fuck for it. It's floaty and gimmicky as fuck. Most of the weapons are useless and same with the guns, and the rolling is so broken it basically trivializes every enemy encounter. The only thing it has is that it has an aesthetic which makes all those Tim Burton and Steampunk and Victorian LARPer losers cream their pants.
Tyler Jenkins
I like DaS1 the best. It has the right mix of
>rpg >action >worthy loot >good exploration >interesting designs >fun setting >creative ost >thoughtful lore >meaningful and unique npcs and quests
I feel like the other games excel it in certain aspects, but as a package i just prefer DaS1.
>Gameplay Sekiro >Aesthetics and mood Bloodborne >World design Dark Souls >Story-telling Sekiro >Online Dark Souls 3 (but only because I like killing gank squads more than bullying loners or dueling) >Music Dark Souls
This. I was absolute shit at Dark Souls my first play through. Just so many deaths to bosses that are "easy".
I'm actually not very good at these games, despite loving them and getting them all on release day. Bloodborne was easily my best game, with the most first-try-boss-kills and least missed secrets. For that reason I think I'm also biased in its favor a bit.
Felt very hollow playing through the game again, even with a new ending cutscene and bonus fight. The same build, same everything, no reason to explore, no real reason to fight anything that isn't mandatory. It's pretty poorly thought out so NG+ for me was just a few good bossfights and 90% filler.
I think they are all great but BB is my personal favorite
Nolan Russell
This is the only correct ranking to be honest
Brody Walker
Note this is also just for the boards that have search enabled on archived.moe. This doesn't even begin to show just how popular the ayy lmao meme was on Yea Forums. Yeah the meme started on tumblr in 2013 but Yea Forums took it and ran with it in 2014. >given rock solid evidence that you're wrong >still argues I loathe newfags so fucking much.
>Very very safe game They released a 20$ DLC in which the first boss filter'd lots of people
Nolan Martinez
Dark Souls is the best, period. Anyone who thinks otherwise simply has a low IQ. Demon Souls and Bloodborne are close so if it's your favorite is alright as long as you admit DaS is the best. DS3 is trash, Sekiro is isn't really a Souls game, it's more similar to DMC than DS honestly (for me that sucks but at least it's a pretty good action game). Da2 is by far the worse, I don't even like to acknowledge it's existence, same with Da3, for me everything there's to DaS is Da1
