I have had a Hori Rap V (Xbone version) for about 2 years and I have no complaints except that maybe the buttons can be too sensitive sometimes. I don't have an Xbone I just got it for PC since it was the only one I could find at the time, and it works fine on PC in 360 mode. I have thumb issues so I can't use a regular controller for too long meaning I use it for everything and it's still kicking today despite almost daily use. Works great on shmups, fighters, platformers, pretty much anything that doesn't rely on analog input. I cleared Hollow Knight on it and it felt great. It's a great solid stick and I'd definitely recommend it, especially since it's professional quality at a decently affordable price. It's been out for a while now so you could probably get it used for under $150.
Before that I used a Hori Mini just to get my feet wet, and while I enjoyed it for a while eventually the stick started consistently dropping back inputs until they pretty much stopped working at all so I can't recommend it. The stick resistance was very high which you might enjoy if you don't like accidental inputs, and even though the buttons were tiny I didn't really find it that uncomfortable. Honestly for $50 if the stick never broke I'd definitely recommend it as a starter stick, but it's just not worth it if it's going to crap out on you in under a year. I didn't even use it all that much at the time either.
