Should analog stick gates be circular, octagonal, or square?

Should analog stick gates be circular, octagonal, or square?

Attached: stick.jpg (220x220, 11K)

Circular.

>square
no.
>circular or octogonal
depends on game

Should be modular so the player can choose which one they want to use and swap between them at will.

If the games are designed for them, octagonal is maximum comfy. If they aren't, then circle.

Square is for literal retards only.

lol consolefags

since you posted the gamecube controller, i began to think of melee
and octagonal is literally perfect for the game. some tech skill requires utilizing the notches in the octagon like shield dropping, or sdi

>square
I'm sorry, what?

circular but octagonal makes sense for the gamecube since its dpad was trash

Suck by dick