Is Persona 4 good?

Chie is at least an S

I wanted to put her in S but imposed a "one girl per game in S tier only" rule on myself. Yes, I am autismo.

Attached: 1531103510840.jpg (1024x1024, 653K)

Fuck I hate when they cast adult voice actors as kids and their voice sounds like a literal retard.

What else are they gonna do?

Cast a kid so it sounds like a kid. Its just cringy listening to what is clearly an adult try to sound like an 8 year old.

Mitsuru is overrated as all holy fuck, literally boring as hell, nearly flawless perfect grades rich girl student council president who has no personality other than essentially being the group Manager

You couldnt streamline a character harder than this if you tried, even her aesthetic is trash, how do you make the ojou sama aesthetic that fucking level of cardboard boring?

Can you date the fat ugly girl in the center bottom?
Always liked the idea of having a harem protag go with a legitimately unattractive woman.

No you cannot. Most of these chars are not dateable, for example all of the P1/P2 cast

Attached: 1531105765681.jpg (848x1174, 166K)

it's the cringiest and most lighthearted one. Murders and shit go down on the background while the cast are there making jokes and pretending to be the Scooby-Doo gang.

No, like most fat/ugly characters in japanese media, she has a terrible personality and is played for laughs

Great game, you really get attached to everyone around you.

Except Rise, she's a slut.

Attached: 1531078568739.jpg (1208x2048, 166K)

>Except Chie, she's used goods.
FTFY.

Kids can't act but then again so can't american anime actors so you got me there.

Chie is pure and wears spats. Rise 100% takes fat producer dick between shows and has had at least one orgy.

Attached: 1531098540639.jpg (1000x1166, 172K)

How come 4 fags hate 3?

It's not okay to spread lies around, user. You can see Chie's ex during her social links while Rise basically tells you that she never kissed a man.

Play Persona 1, 2 and 3. The rest is shit.

wheres the hotglue?

I'm a 4fag and I enjoyed the fuck out of P3FES.

Rise is a liar, she's just ashamed to admit that this has happened. Chie is confident in showing her ex because nothing happened between them. She is pure.

Attached: 1531103845059.jpg (1024x1024, 279K)

>Chie is confident in showing her ex because nothing happened between them. She is pure

Save for, you know ; holding her ex's hand.

I don't know anyone that likes one Persona game and hates another.

That's okay, because the real best girl in P4 is Naoto anyway.

Attached: 1537987695914.jpg (894x894, 125K)

Pretty much the rest of the fanbase hates 4 so they hate everyone back.
I actually tried getting into 4 several times. Even pirated the day it came out in english back in the day, but I just can't like it for some reason.

I like the small town setting too. It's unfortunate.

Most people who started with 3 hate 1 and 2.

Now that, I can agree with you.

Attached: ahhhh.jpg (680x383, 29K)

No, but it's otaku wish fulfillment fantasy which is the main selling point of the series.
The only people who like it are losers who didn't have any friends in high school
Any Shin Megami Tensei game is better than Persona

Attached: 1552662976128.gif (193x266, 20K)

Attached: Yukiko.jpg (960x544, 103K)

I've only played 5 and 4 Arena. I hope they release some kind of Persona compilation.

Attached: GET SMOKED Better Sister.png (459x462, 135K)

I'm not trying to shit talk persona 4 by any means, It definitely has its moments. But I'm just baffeld that people can rate 4 so high and yet 3 so low like this dudes post
Also
>Hating Lotus juice and the comfy soundtrack that is 3
But at least you can agree it's one of the best in the persona series.

They won't.
Your best bet is grabbing a vita, hacking it and getting the other four games.

P3's music was really hit or miss for me. A lot of the tracks had parts I just didn't like. However, the "chorus" part of the battle music is the best in the series. But then like the dorm music I just couldn't get into.

Attached: 1531079368158.png (596x600, 346K)

this song makes me so happy my face starts hurting from smiling.
youtube.com/watch?v=y9hucC98P1I

Attached: 1525734037135.jpg (379x379, 34K)

I miss the daily P4 threads.

Attached: 1517925126520.png (568x602, 645K)

>Recommending the worst version of p3
here's your you

Better than getting a ps2 and paying for one game.

Aww you didnt like the trumpets?

No, the story is too slow and uninteresting because you know that you won’t catch the killer until the end of the game. And that fucking period where the characters think they caught the killer and the game just keeps going, so bad

I didn't like deep voice guy, more like

Attached: 128973198713.png (953x1970, 732K)

Do you think Dojima would let Yu go naked in the house like the OPs pic?

Nanako seen Yu's dick

Yeah that was lotus juice, It doesnt bother me one bit. I sign along to it constantly. But i understand how it can take you out.

Does the bear shit in the woods?

Why did you put the (S)hit-list above (A)-list?

S is better than A you silly biscuit

Attached: 1545940853485.jpg (607x850, 71K)

no

No, they shit in the forest.

Yes, all of the games are good.

Nog, who the fuck doesn’t have a ps2? You have to be 18 to post here

Attached: 458B1960-77F6-4B32-9780-52C93655D001.jpg (296x394, 13K)

Not him but my controller is broken and I have an unplayed Persona 3(not FES) waiting for me for like a year already, I hate being poor.

So why did you put (S)hit characters in the (S) category?

Imagine having taste this bad.

Attached: 12837981739.png (914x1157, 545K)

So who did you choose on your very first playthrough, before the waifu threads, before knowing anything whether it was 4 or golden. Even if you changed your mind or picked the wrong bitch by accident, who was it? I chose chie

Attached: UnsightlyHappygoluckyApatosaur-size_restricted.gif (500x281, 1.3M)

I chose Chie as well. I wanted to pick Naoto but she's the only party member whose S-Link isn't unlocked naturally, which I expected it to be. Then I did the last dungeon early and lost like 1 month worth of social link days so I got cucked.

Attached: 23156128712.png (512x512, 106K)

>dream of butt fly
what did they mean by this?

youtube.com/watch?v=y65oKsRJth8

P3 has the worst base game in the series. Not being able to control your party members is shit.

Why is he naked?

>Persona 4
The christmas cake is treated like a joke on the same level as the fat walrus woman despite being attractive, you can't romance her
>Persona 5
Multiple christmas cakes, you are able to romance them and they give some of the best social link bonuses.

Did Atlus hire a person into milfs in between 4 and 5 or something?

Attached: 1510893658266.jpg (725x1024, 106K)

No, shit sucks. Can't even romance best girl.

It's better than P3
>M-MUH SCOOBY DOO
>When it has vastly more similarities to DiU
Hey reddit.

Most of this is excusable, but
>3 not being #1 for music
You're burning my bread right now, nigga

>shitty dungeon crawler and average VN duct taped together
It's bad

i initially chose yukiko assuming nobody better would come along and then i cheated on her for naoto. after multiple playthroughs i am enlightened and know that rise and ai are top tier, every other girl is a one note cardboard cutout.

jojo is the epitome of reddit.

youtu.be/C4PqshRBjuY

Attached: 1424544566104.png (640x475, 404K)

Best girl in her game.

Attached: 24767.png (1906x576, 407K)

>Everything I don't like is Reddit

Attached: 1459219040427.gif (400x225, 1.84M)

>yet he says scooby doo is bad and therefore reddit
humorously i didnt say anything bad about jojo, just that its reddit

>Then I did the last dungeon early and lost like 1 month worth of social link days so I got cucked.
That doesn't happen in P5, right? It's only December 1st and I'm about to get the last introduction letter on the ship.

No because you still have to wait for the calling card and all that crap. You should be fine.

Better than P3, worse than P5

>>When it has vastly more similarities to DiU
Notice how people only say this now after part 4 got an anime.

Easily the least interesting game in all departments except for music. Shame about that, since it takes inspiration from one of the best Jojo arcs.

Attached: 1550204604656.png (868x1224, 225K)

As wack as 5 was compared to the others, I'll give them credit for acquiring good taste

Attached: 1544974142766.jpg (801x1200, 340K)

3>4>5
3's characters are better written but 4's have better interactions
5 is just terrible all around
I'll never understand people who rate 5's bland music higher than 3 or 4 and I think such people are legitimately deficient

Attached: 1528806759761.png (680x950, 733K)

I can understand rating 3's music above 5's, but 4 being better than 5? No way.

>smt threads
>in depth discussion of demon designs and philosophy
>genuinely humorous memes and OC
>appreciation of stellar atmosphere and gameplay

>persona threads
>I WANT TO FUCK X-CHAN WHY CAN'T SHE BE REAL
>here are my game rankings that nobody asked for or wanted, now lets debate which of these 3 identical games is the best one
>same 5 faggots announcing their arrival every thread like fuukafag, tierlistfag, saefag since they have nothing better to do with their lives
>no discussion of gameplay, all waifu wars

Attached: 1501469622059.jpg (1025x600, 112K)

I love the music from P4 and P5, does this artist make more albums or something? I just want more of this type of music.

Attached: 1544403008209.png (2039x2700, 2.8M)

Every single song in 3 and 4 is memorable, catchy, or at least atnospheric
None of 5's are. Even the endding song, which are historically amazing and emotional, pales in comparison to even some of the BGM in 3 and 4, let alone Kimi no Kioku or Never More.

Life Will Change isn't memorable?
Neither is Whims of Fate? Not even Last Surprise?
Come on.

>None of P5 song are memorable
I can understand you thinking the others are better in things like story but now you are being a shit taste retard

Life Will Change is pretty good, but the other two are total snoozefests

Absolutely based tier list.

You fucking weebs are fucking obnoxious. I’m sick of seeing you fetishist, pedophillic bullshit. Like, how fucking pathetic can you fucking be?
Just fuck off already. Your kind isn’t welcome here anymore.

Literally one of the best social links with the best payoff

I chose Rise and i regret nothing

I fucking hate everyone on Yea Forums so much. Literally all you faggots do is argue over stupid shit, and somehow boths sides are always fucking wrong. Did you really think this user was saying that scooby-doo is reddit, or were you just trying to make your point look better? I'll never fucking understand you retards. Must be a virgin thing I guess.

>tfw there was a time when we all thought the world of persona 4 was gonna last forever

Attached: laughing death.gif (360x270, 1.63M)

It depends on what your priorities are. The P4 cast is a lot better than P3, more grounded in some ways, and generally easier to relate to. So if you're someone that puts a heavy weight on the cast when forming an overall opinion you're going to lean toward P4.

Then there's these assholes. >Not being able to control your party members is shit.

No

Yeah it's a good JRPG.

Worse than p3 story and narrative wise. Has too many happy go lucky anime shit. P4 has slightly better gameplay without the party hack.

Based Japs, sounds pretty realistic to me

>tfw you will never be left to take care of your cute cousin everyday

And I had this really cute cousin loli too that asked me to play NDS with her.

Yes, best one IMO.

P3's story is trash besides near the end.
It's a snoozefest most of time. I can't even remember most of it.
It's antagonists are cookie cutter as fuck, none of them come close to coming to Adachi.

Chie is SSS tier.

based and greenpilled

Attached: chie adachi.gif (410x311, 1.99M)

I'm so mad you can't date her

its more that 4 and 3 fags hate each other more than any others

Chie was the first girl i dated but I chose Naoto for the christmas event.

>Literal angry Yea Forums-irgin
Bad bait

This

>but I chose Naoto for the christmas event.
You heartless fuck.
Anyone have the image that compiled all of the Valentine's Day rejection scenes?

Naoto wore a skirt for me. I regret nothing.

Not every fucking character in a game needs to have someone close to them die like in 3.
Like jesus christ I know the game is about death but it's a little ridiculous how many people in that game go through that.

How can he stop him without the naked teen screaming rape and attracting a lot of attention?

Ya know there is a TV right there dojima sempai.... it wouldn't take much to be rid of the little bastard.

Attached: bd0d03494831482d903d521c259e4d38b1d380e8_hq.jpg (600x338, 29K)

Was gonna pick Yukiko in the original but then Rise came along. When Golden came out though I picked Yukiko.
In the end though neither of them came out of top.

Attached: 7b71c892.jpg (494x630, 67K)

Animefags ruined the JoJo fanbase

Cant you date multiple girls in this game?

You can date multiple girls in all Persona games except for Persona 1 and Eternal Punishment

P4G was fun.

So whats the problem then in picking, when you can date them all? Or is there a special event where you can pick only one girl?

Oh user.....

Attached: 5830DDF5-E677-4E3B-901A-FE57A2981F1C.jpg (2110x4779, 1.38M)

Well damn, guess ill have to be faithful, cant disappoint my waifu

Oh shit.
Thats not in vanilla p4

fuck....

Choosing ai though

It's even better voiced
youtube.com/watch?v=09DDYlYJw-0

What, it can't be both?

did they deserve it?

Fuck no, they’re all best girl in their own ways

In P3 there’s a jealousy mechanic where the girls get mad if and impede your progress with them if you hang out with other girls too much. In P4 and P5 there’s a Valentine’s Day scene where you break their hearts. Have you never played a Persona?

Kanji was always best girl.

Attached: Kanji.gif (325x150, 493K)

Nanako chan is not for lewd!

Attached: 30-P4-00197(2).jpg (640x450, 43K)

Nope. Started playing P4 a few days ago

Child actors are expensive, only Hollywood can do it.

Anyone who think the social links in 3 are good is delusional. The only good ones are Sun and Hermit, the rest are trash. The worst part being to max ANY of the girl social links you HAVE to date them, which is retarded.

Yukiko is the worst by virtue of being annoying as fuck and even she doesn't deserve anything like that
eh, P5 technically has a scene like that, but it's basically played for laughs

These threads are notorious for a certain big spoiler, you should probably leave now

Watched the anime when it came out, so im pretty much spoiled on all the major plot points. Had nothing better to do, so i finally decided to give the game a spin after all this time.

Attached: 2015-07-15-114311[1].jpg (960x544, 135K)

to be honest, for a first persona game start on 3.

Only persona 4 fans prefer persona 4

NANAKO
FOR
P6
PROTAG

Attached: D7865235-94A9-4646-9E86-8FF6CCC3A16B.png (1500x2499, 912K)

They are A at LEAST!

Attached: its loli time.jpg (489x653, 88K)

it should be illegal to have a list this based

People are glad cakes got love in 5 but the fact that a top tier cake didn't receive her happy ending in 3 is a crime upon the land

Fuck no

Gameplay: 5 > 3 > 2 > 1 > 4
Story: 3 > 2 > 5 > 1 > 4
Characters: 3 > 5 > 2 > 1 > 4
Dungeons: 5 > 2 > 1 = 3 > 4
Music: 5 > 3> 2 > 1 > 4
Final boss: 1 = 3 > 5 > 2 > 4
Waifus: 5 = 3 > 2 > 1 > 4
Overall: 3 > 5 > 2 > 1 > 4

Why are you guys responding to bait? He posts this in every persona thread

Attached: 1432161164060.jpg (2110x4779, 3.86M)

Attached: 1432405003912.jpg (960x1308, 333K)

Attached: 1474264056877.jpg (679x1382, 394K)

Yukiko --> Naoto --> Ai (Golden)

Attached: 1553054777915.png (800x1132, 1.11M)

Aigis, Chie, Kawakami. I like robot girls, tomboys and cakes.

What is the meaning of this

I'm a virgin and I don't get it either, user.

Makoto is on a tier of her own

Yeah SS+ tier

Stupid Slut Tier

Attached: makoto.png (702x416, 185K)

I agree. Z-tier. Easily the worst girl in Persona. Maybe all of fiction.

Well, I'm taking care of my younger sister almost everyday due to both parents working, she's the cutest thing ever but is really scary how much of a sponge little kids are, she quickly developed the same taste as me for vidya and anime and some times she behaves exactly like I would, crazy, considering we aren't blood related, I'll make sure to spoil her rotten!