Thoughts?

his giant jew nose doesn’t move, 3/10

smells soi by miles.

We have this thread every two weeks on verage.
12 frames makes me kek, but it's an imprecise representation of the original walk cycle.

I hate it

youtube.com/watch?v=5VuQxoNrwhw

>

Attached: 1538672246302.gif (400x200, 31K)

>floaty and cartoony = good
he watched a lot of Adventure Time and other quirky noodley shit so yeah, he operated a hat before.
don't take that shit seriously. it's a bait thread you dummy. can't you tell?

>left: tiptoe
>right: no tiptoe

Based zoomers putting muh graphics over glorious gameplay

ITS NEW AND LOOKS BETTER MEANING ITS SOULESS HURDERR I HAVE NOSTALGIA

any actual criticism?Besides the shit hat of course.

Attached: 04624DD9-721F-4F16-AE37-97EC89826C53.png (283x178, 24K)

Right looks like an inferior version of the belmont stride.
Get equipped with: Vampire Killer

Why is he leaning to his left?

>Dude what if 8bit games were made in a way that exceeded the technology at the time LMAO

Yeah, its nice, albeit over done animation. But

>left: soul
>right: souless

Attached: 1551480678700.gif (270x188, 1.78M)

That hat flops more than my limp dick and Sekiro

adding shitty frames is not a way to improve sprite animations, sometimes having less images is better to show movement and impacts

>frames where he's literally not touching the ground so he's hopping instead of walking
>stupid hat
>keeps looking to his left because the artist wanted to make his face move while he walked for some reason
This must be the author
youtube.com/watch?v=c8jbSoCbnns

The run is kind of strange but I could get used to it, that fucking hat is retarded though, way too distracting

They fucking butchered it holy shit

There’s a redone Samus sprite out there which actually isn’t half bad since the original was so terrible to begin with. Actually considered rom hacking the key frames into the FDS version of Metroid but lost interest, someone post it.

>operated a hat
>operated
Interesting choice of word.

Hes moving his head to make him look more fluid and more happy
His jumping fits his personality anf attitude

His hat is shit though

Attached: 77E8AF12-8B95-4D26-B4CC-D230DF9C9A53.jpg (125x125, 2K)

>he didn't see the stream
It looks great.

The burden of proving that your dumb fucking gif is good is on you cocksucker.

The left one looks like he's running.
The right one looks like he's on rollerblades.

no it looks nice
the snowflakes here are just terminally contrarian because they are dumb and insignificant and need to feel special

almost none of them have played this game (and frankly how could something like this hold your attention in this day and age unless you were high)

Would be better if the hat didn’t flop around and his head didn’t turn.

>it fits his personality
>it makes him happier
Spoken like a true zoomer
Mario doesn't skip when walking in any other game, including the modern ones.

>Hes moving his head to make him look more fluid and more happy
And yet his head movement is awkwardly stiff and doesn't make him look any happier partially because his facial expression is still an unchanged expressionless robot.

no it doesn't it looks like diamond dozen low efforr indieshit

Mario needs to be ready to jump at any moment when receiving the input, how the fuck is he gonna do that when his feet aren't touching the ground?

Attached: this is you.jpg (1349x530, 145K)

>diamond dozen

Attached: 400[1].jpg (463x400, 199K)

Is there a difference? I can't see it.

>indieshit
this place infests your mind

>Rubies
don't act like the left had any semblance of soul

>head turns while running
"I'M ANIMATING!" God he's trying so fucking hard

new

NINTENDO HIRE THIS MAN!

Italian*

Has the animator ever actually walked or ran in real life?

well we can't use "manned a hat" anymore because it's not inclusive enough

HOLY SHIT, SQUARE ENIX NEEDS TO HIRE THIS GUY!

Yea Forums btfo

Attached: 1538669815850.gif (400x200, 32K)

right is basically Megaman 8.

This actually looks really good.

I unironically like this.

actual improvement here

I would dig new IP with those kind of graphics+animations,
while ninja gaiden, megamen and mario looks a bit to wobly, samus looks actually great

It's still slightly off and doesn't do a good job at understanding the original sprite.

do you understand limited frame animation elegance?

This one is actually decent. The head wobble still kinda bothers me though.

Even Megaman's single frame jump has more immediate action than 8's "I have to sway my arms!" jump animation.

This
Less is more

The original sprite is actually pretty bad though.

Is this dude using the original sprite as keyframes, because it doesn't seem like it

Looks over-animated, especially the hat.

Left looks like she's just doing some zoomer Fartnite dance.

Left with the armor design of right and a bit more fluid but not as much as the right would be perfect.

>upgrade
>changes the entire animation
>makes it cringe worthy and bouncy for no reason
fucking gross.

Fix the head keep the body

very nice

reddit/10

for all intensive purposes, he's right

Whoever remade it failed to notice that in the original sprite, she runs with her arms swinging in front of her body, which is why the right arm disappears during one of the frame. In the upgrade she runs with her arms parallel to her body.

that's more of the case of the original sprite being shit

you know how it'll be good? use the 12 frames as base and cut it

Attached: lemmings-animated.gif (256x256, 5K)

Attached: 1505968330388.gif (878x438, 110K)

heinously overanimated
too many frames makes it look too slow for a run cycle
actually good

It's like these are someone's first, second and third ever sprite animations. But they actually learned how to animate from doing them.

They should've left the head alone. The body animation is fantastic but the shaking head and floppy hat are terrible.

This one is good. Would be neat to see a fangame in that style if the rest looked that good.

It doesn't look that much better is the thing. The floppy hat looks a bit too goofy and it will look even worse when he's running since it'll pretty much just vibrate.

This one is actually good, but the original sprite was pretty bad
Head turn is still bad

you can't remake SOUL

He's doing a moonwalk

NINTENDO

HIRE
I
R
E

THIS

MAN
A
N

This actually looks better. You seriously can not argue that the left is superior here.

I wasn't necessarily disagreeing with you, but that information is poorly conveyed in the original. Maybe the dude who remade it couldn't figure out how to make it look better so he decided to go for something different.

THAT IS NOT EVEN THE ORIGINAL ANIMATION! THE ORIGINAL ANIMATION HAS THREE FRAMES RESULTING IN A MORE FLUID MOTION AS THEY LOOP 1-2-3 INSTEAD OF 1-2-3-2! THIS FUCKING HACK CAN'T EVEN GET THAT RIGHT

This, mario is a grimdark character with a depressing backstory, and a wicked sense of humor

It's a fucking video game, user. Mario doesn't need to get a running start to jump fucking 10 meters into the air either.

>Putting words in his mouth just so you can attempt to argue against something
Why do you people do this?

You are retarded.
This series has always been proud about their consistent animations and tight controls, whoever made that gif literally made it worse and called it an improvement.

I agree. The Samus one has more detail put into the suit to actually show the red torso armour she wears and more segmenting to the rest to show it's a suit of armour and not some spandex onesy.

Nice

Im not argueing though?
>Mario was almost abducted as a child and doesnt know his family
>always smiling when killing
Mario isnt a happy character

>Forced animation

Mario's nose literally does bounce exactly like that in Mario Odyssey. The point of the remade sprites is to make them ''feel'' modern while adhering to the same model and level of detail.
But, tell me why realism should apply only in that one specific instance you mention when my example isn't valid.

>Putting words in his mouth just so you can attempt to argue against something also im gay btw
Why do YOU do this?

Didn't Lemmings have 12 frames? That's what immediately came to mine when I saw the Mario one.

What does Mario's nose bouncing have to do with him literally being able to jump from thin air in the gif we are discussing?

Why does he look slower

>Consistent animations
>It actually isn't consistent at all
Mario has been able to jump mid-skip since technology allowed for more animation frames.
But, why is realism important in this instance? You skipped that part.

the main appeal of these games for me is nostalgia, i have way better modern choices if I want a more polished game. it's pointless in my eyes

Can I get a hat wobble?

NiNtEnDo HiRe ThIs MaN

Lose the floppy fat and it would be better

What's with these filenames popping up all of a sudden in this place?

Attached: a.png (414x164, 11K)

It annoys me for some reason, it makes me think of soibois

ResetEra.

Unironically true

Some kind of unique ID from a single site not sure where though

Stupid zoomer "quirky" animation

fuck no

It's the eyes. Left's eyes are showing that he's looking at something, giving him a sense of life whereas right's eyes are looking off in different directions giving him a sense of lifelessness. Right basically looks like an offline animatronic.

right is better
left is limited to keygframes because of the weak hardware. Only nostalgia soul hipsterfags think left is better.

Mario bros was also my first game ever so no I'm not a zoomer, im 30

NINTENDO!!!!!
HIRE
THIS
MAN!

Attached: DFADBC60-8EB5-4AED-9A0C-1F7AB3A881AD.png (458x480, 163K)

If right was the original and left a remaster came you'd say "are dumb devs even trying anymore these day?"

Go on tell me Im wrong

No it doesnt, you're supposed to be contrarian despite being true

overdesigned