ITT: Terrible Fan Redesigns

that flashman is perfect though. the original looks like a bald man.

Time, Ring, Tengu, Flash and Solar all look like trash.

Good ones:
Needleman
Ringman
Plantman
Fireman
Crystalman

Bad ones:
Everything else

The only good is flashman

This ain't terrible, it's 30% terrible at most. some of them are alright.

>Characters are already flanderizations
>just pushes it to the next stage where it consumes the design and becomes retarded

>the original looks like a bald man
That's the point though.

Hard Man is good

Is Tails fisting himself?

Maybe you should realize that all these characters/designs are dumb as fuck in the first place.

>magnetman
Original is better
>starman
Redesign doesn't look like some early 80s gimp, more appealing
>gyroman
lmao no
>needleman
Redesign. Covered in needles beats crown
>hardman
Original is a unit. Redesign is an absolute unit
>burstman
Redesign
>timeman
neither
>ringman
gapeman could be fun if your megabuster shots just went through him
>plantman
Redesign with a bit of tweaking to not have such a massive head
>tenguman
YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
>fireman
Redesign looks like a dude with a welding mask, overalls, and big ass boots. So him
>tornadoman
Redesign with some tweaking to not be as top heavy
>flashman
Original
>crystalman
Redesign, actually looks like a typical crystal. Head is bit too big though
>solarman
Original, but have a star floating above the well
>airconman
Redesign because they're both shit but it's funnier

Some of them are pretty good, most of the "their head is just a big thing of their theme is pretty bad"

>lmao change the head into something related to the name lol

I mean, it's better than "he's just a guy with (thing) glued all over him"

Attached: 1477356929077.png (628x350, 432K)

who made this so I can avoid them forever.

>just flanderize everything bro lmao
Great redesigns.

Attached: Sonic Redesign.png (1024x1899, 2.48M)

Looks better than Sonic's "original" saturday morning American cartoon design in the west.

>legwarmers
bold move making sonic a homosexual

The combined autism of Steven universe and sonic

Attached: 1550829344081.jpg (917x1080, 63K)

>gyroman has the back propeller taken off, now wearing an entire fucking helicopter
>tenguman's mask is "subtly" redesigned (see pic related)
>flashman's helmet is a camera
>timeman's face is a big clock
>crystalman's helmet is a big crystal
>starman's helmet
>solarman's head
>magnetman's helmet
>FUCKING RINGMAN

Attached: PleasedWellinformedAdouri-size_restricted.gif (500x288, 2.73M)

Attached: Big D Redesign.jpg (1163x685, 333K)

>THOSE NOSES
god no

Attached: nutty.png (295x404, 119K)

fire man redesign is better, then again guy just ripped off the one from battle network.
The rest are shit and fuck you and your dad if you think otherwise.

About half of these are better.
Actually decent.

Pic related Combee evolution.

Attached: 1502004167236.png (500x357, 227K)

all are shit except for airconman

This looks like it would be worse than boom. Also why does chaos look like one of the good guys now? Metal sonic actually looks pretty cool though to be honest.

i honestly see more in the original, exe was essentially a transformer while the redesign is a guy wearing a helicopter

Attached: classic_styled_sanic_characters_by_karpkang-dbq2u5n.jpg (1600x4907, 1.34M)

all are better except Timeman and Flashman

Solarman looks a bit weird, ideally he'd have angrier eyes

>gyro slapping a fucking helicopter on his head
>ringman becoming a cereal mascot
the only ones that are better are the ones that subtly change the designs like hardman and needleman maybe also crystalman if the crystal on his head was shrunk down.

Attached: Sonic and Friends Redesign.png (828x2610, 624K)

it still baffles me how most of Big's prototype designs were great and yet they chose the fucking worst one. Even that totoro knockoff is better than the official one.

Wasn't he a Tanuki at one point?

I actually really like most of these. Maria gave me a good chuckle.

Agree mostly, the crystal man and flash man redesigns are definitely better though

Right Solarman kinda looks like Spurdo

I actually like hte Rogue and Knuckles here.
Rogue's going full in on the rayman magician but a total cutie angle, and it works.
Knuckles is just professional. It's like he's a hired bodyguard for emeralds. Unless those aren't sunglasses and are his real eyes. It's highly disturbing in that case.

Attached: Img223004_l.png (197x430, 30K)

Attached: 1510357214723.png (1280x1280, 1.28M)

score is 12 - 4 in favor of redesign sorry your opinion is shit

Attached: 1551734842488.png (1280x881, 1002K)

>sonic
looks a bit like boom sonic but alright
>amy
trash
>tails
good
>knuckles
looks like a ben 10 alien
>rouge
looks like a paper mario npc
>shadow
looks like one of ken penders' OCs
>metal sonic
wtf even is that?
>chaos
looks like a good guy and a hollow knight npc but still pretty good
>cream and cheese
don't look like they belong in the same piece of media together
>big
looks a little weird but fine
>sticks
garbage
>charmy
unironically looks like if dreamworks decided to make an animated netflix series based on the bee movie
>vector
slick as fuck
>espio
looks ok but just doesn't click with me somehow

That's not a redesign, it's just fanart in a not pretty art style.