What did Yea Forums think of Red Dead Redemption 2's story? Good or disappointing?

>passe
>amalgam
you use these words as if you understand them. Also user, you do realise the Western Genre is one of the most strict in its form and execution? The themes of man in nature, but at the same time against nature. Man's lust for gold. Enough never being enough. Freedom or death. Each outlaw must fight his own demons. Even the white hat for Micah and the black hat for Arthur that always represented the law and the outlaw. Westerns are like Haiku, they are very strict in their form, so to say its an amalgam of Western is to say it's the best creafted Western in the last 40 years, not that its cliched.

Only zoomers defend this game. No sane adult is in favor of forced walking and pressing RT twice to fire your gun. There's a reason why it didn't win GOTY.

>Call me an idealist, but I don't think that normalizing sex needs to mean we are weakening monogamy
I wish I could agree with you and I used to but the statistics tell a very different story my friend. I was actually swayed to this belief by another poster on Yea Forums a while ago. Used to have your mindset.
Appreciate you being polite and considering. If you want to discuss this further I'm down, if not I'd encourage you to keep this argument in mind and see if its proven or disproven by your own experience and research.

Lmao Iike now you brought it back to that same strawman.
You sure showed him. Can I book you for parties?

>Truly the jewiest cowboy
I knew there was something I couldn't put my finger on about him. Thanks for scratching my itch user.

>Karen
She's a side piece and game for a laugh, for sure. Would not mary though. Lest I was up for the challenge of taming those tittays and getting here to live the good motherly life, that is.

at this point zoomers just do what Yea Forums wants them to do
just like basedboys, cucks, normies, chads, roasties, etc...

It's the only worthwhile thing in this game. It's so good in fact, that it carries the entire game. If only the mission design, gunplay, and basically every other feature wasn't shitty, it would be a game worth remembering.

theres this game called Read Dead Redemption 1

this, autistic people cant into subtext and need everything spelling out apparently
WELL ABIGALE LETS GO HOME, I HAVE DEEP ROOTED FEARS THAT THE MARSHALLS WILL COME FOR US BUT DESPITE THIS I WILL RAISE YOU AS BEST I CAN

agree, immersion falls under story for me, so while i like it as a cowboy sim and its an 8/10 in my book, stomping around and shooting people doesnt carry the game at all. guns are literally tools to be used when needed, i feel no desire to actively try and kill people
i spent my last days in rdr2 just looking for landmarks and cool screenshot locations