Why does Dutch walk away at the end and let john keep the Blackwater money...

Attached: 1547942771517.jpg (683x1024, 157K)

They needed Dutch to live obviously but they also wanted to have that retarded Mexican standoff. It's overall just a cringe story.

He no longer needed the money, he lost everyone

RDR2 makes seeing Dutch in RDR1 a lot more tragic and gives him so much more backstory. Also explains why he got together with a band of natives.

I still don't understand why Dutch was up on the mountain with Micah. It would have made infinitely more sense if he didn't show up again after Arthur died.

same reason as you more or less

Looks pretty but probably the worst mission in the game.
I don't want to go clearing out rdr1 gang hideouts again thank you very much the game had enough mandatory shooty filler as is.

>he was there to kill Micah.
This is false. He was bros with Micah and would have immediately shot him instead of point the gun at John if that were true. FALSE NARRATIVE.

He would have done it(and probably also kill Micah) if John didn't appear with absolute lust for revenge
Seeing John made him change his plan to "KILL MICAH" and leave
Remember, it has been seven years since that fateful day

>shooty filler
As opposed to what, more cutscene watching? The gunfights are the meat of the game and sadly there barely was gameplay content with satisfying mechanics aside from the shooty pooty.

Attached: 1548277028931.jpg (1920x1080, 376K)

>steal the dude's fancy hat with the plume
>it's temporary

You shot me

I want to marry Mary Beth!
I want Sadie to rape me!
I want to fuck Karen!
I want to give Jack headpats!
I want to comfort Molly and drink with Sean!
I want to go fishing with Kieran!
I want to party with Lenny and sing with Javier!
I want to hug Tilly and help Susan with chores!
I want to help cook with Pearson!
I want to bully Bill with John!
I want to look at the stars with Charles!
I want to listen to Uncles conversations about lumbago!
I want to hear Revs sermons!
I want Hosea to teach me how to read!
I want to kill Micah and tell Dutch to grow up!

a bigger offense than only modelling El Presidio at Nuevo Paraiso
which is possible to visit via a Glitch

I want to live in the Horseshoe Overlook camp.

I want to kiss Abigail and watch her strip but then realize my best friend is plowing that and stop and tell her that he’ll come back!

Seeing Micah trying to trick John was what did it. All the years after the gang fell out, Dutch probably got to thinking he'd made a mistake doubting Arthur and John. Letting go of the idea that Micah, and by extension he himself, was ever a 'good' individual was the last bit of his ego being let go. I believe this was the moment where Dutch no longer could pretend he was being a hero the whole time.

It was his way of apologizing to John and ending a chapter. When Arthur is dying Dutch's face screams guilt, shock and regret. When Micah mentions "Arthur is dead", Dutch immediately looks at him in a "oh no you didn't" sort of way.

Dutch was there to kill MIcah but Micah mocking Arthur probably made Dutch attempt to give John a life (which, btw, is what Arthur wanted) and disappear.

My name's John Marston, you killed my brother prepare to die.
>Seven Years Later
My name's Jack Marston, you killed my father prepare to die.
I love how the story has two seven year timeskips.
Also Ross telling young Jack "enjoy your fishing day while you can" ends as pure karmic justic