Now that the set has dustled, can we all agree that this would be the perfect Smash roster?

>cuts a huge chunk of the roster
>the Faggy Fox Clone Trio somehow get to stay in
Why do autists always do this? Why not at least cut Falco, the one who was never supposed to be in the game and makes the least sense to be outside of his ship, to save roster space?

Cutting characters is stupid.

Why cut anyone? The more characters the better.

>Silvally

What the fuck. It has one of the worst designs in its generation.

>No Young Link
>No Roy
>No Chrom
>No Dark Pit
Throw it in the trash.

I just noticed you also got rid of Cloud. Man, this shit is straight trash.

Replace Shadow with Eggman and I'll be fine with it

Sakurai agrees with you, and so do I.

The only character that I’m okay with being cut is ZSS. Anyone else is pushing it

What's stupid is bloating the roster with characters that are unnecessary because they either overlap too much, because their series doesn't need more fighters, because their series isn't storied enough with Nintendo, or because they've overstayed their welcome.

A concise roster is the best kind of roster.

No this one

Attached: 245766457457.png (963x978, 1.52M)

Please find a better way to format this

>no porky
dropped

Bitch please. (1/2)

Attached: Omega 1.png (724x8269, 2.5M)

Shadowfags are fucking pathetic

(2/2)

Attached: Omega 2.png (827x7246, 2.4M)

>Only gen 1 Pokemon

What the fuck is wrong with you? Are you dense?

Rudy would fit a lot better as a Classic Mode boss.
>removing all the non-genwun Pokémon (not that I'd miss Incineroar) and adding even more genwun
Stop

>more Gen 1 pokemon

Attached: 1478821053057.jpg (300x300, 15K)

>All these characters and no Erdrick
This will be a disaster.

>that Etch-a-Sketch line below the dickbutt
just zoom in you lazy bastard. That or use the curve tool.

>Louie alt

Into the trash it goes

>keep and even add Echos
>remove Dork Pit
For what purpose.

Do cutfags cut themselves?

How the fuck would Midna be a echo of Zelda? That doesn't make any sense at all.

No, this is

Attached: deviantartroster.jpg (800x425, 108K)

no you retard
cutting characters is never a good idea
the perfect roster would be whatever roster we'll end up with after all the dlc characters come out
now if only they would add spring man ;__;

>Sylvally
>No Rayman
>Shadow not a Sonic echo
>Keep ZSS but cut DS
>No more F-Zero rep
>Keeping Shulk
>Keeping Duck hunt
>Okami as a capcom rep

Autism and you probably also love to suck dicks

Stop putting more Sonic characters in the game. Your series is gay and hasn't had a good game in 20 years, and it's really autistic to see you guys holding on so hard. That is all, thanks.

This is actually fucking perfect
if it had dante of course. 9.9/10 aint bad

Attached: 51 veterans, 8 newcomers, 6 DLC, 10 semiclones remix roster.png (720x550, 515K)

>No Blood Falcon as Captain Falcon echo
>Shadow as his own character instead of Sonic's echo
>No Ms. Pac-Man echo
>No Medusa echo for Palu
>Silvally instead of Giovanni
>No Birdo echo for Yoshi
>Amaterasu instead of Wonder Red

7/10

>grovyle
>meta knight clone
>tetris
>other ganon
>midna
>two sonic more sonic reps
>several literal who's
>another DK rep

also
>thinking PL will get in
>think PW will get in, no less Edgeworth
i wish bro, i wish

Fuck rosters, post movesets.

Attached: TETRISmovesetv2.png (1000x2800, 475K)

not a moveset, but I may as well post it here
this was made literally the night before Joker was announced.

Attached: what was not meant to be.png (812x818, 44K)

tiermaker.com/create/my-smash-roster

Make your own roster here

Are you the guy that started it? Are you taking suggestions still?

9-Volt. All of his attacks are either Nintendo peripherals or old toys they made.

>Neutral Special: Punch Buoy - old toy where two players had to keep sending a ball on some strings back and forth. Just imagine Ganon's Death Volley and you have a good idea what the attack would be like.
>Side Special: Mach Rider/Chiritori - remote-controlled vehicle. Mach Rider explodes, Chiritori sends enemies to 9-Volt.
>Up Special: Space Ball. Shoots 9V out like a spinning top.
>Down Special: Love Tester. Like C4, but power is based on how close the enemy is to you.
>Grabs are Ultra-Hand
>Final Smash is Master Hand's Hanafuda move in 4

WHY ARE YOU PIECES OF SHIT KEEPING TOON LINK AND REMOVING YOUNG LINK!
There should only be one Link, to be completely honest. But I'd rather have a young link that had a mask gimmick

would main Strong bad

Only easy ones right now, if I dont have an image of cant easily make one I wont do it.

Could you do pic related?

Attached: 20A4841C-0205-4B71-A8E4-75F081837721.png (330x287, 29K)

Toon Link represents a whole line of Zelda games. Wind Waker, Minish Cap, Four Swords Adventures, Phantom Hourglass, Spirit Tracks. Young Link only represents Majora's Mask.

this is.

Attached: slimmed down roster.png (720x550, 685K)

friendly reminder that the plant should be replaced by Naval Piranha.

Attached: Naval Piranha Height Example.jpg (1242x546, 162K)

dude what if we remove like half of the unique characters and replace them with echos

pretty soulless.

Added

no it shouldn't. PP was chosen because it was a simple mario enemy yet was so recognizable by everyone. some boss version of the character from yoshi's island doesn't bring the same thing and is removed from the point entirely

>two new wario reps
>two new mother reps
>two new f-zsero reps
>but yet no new pikmin reps
jesus christ. the bias is cringeworthy. You could at least at a fucking louie echo.

> Silvally
> No Bandanna Dee
> Corrin
> No GBA era rep for FE
> Isabelle
> no Cloud

So close, yet so far away. Quite frankly it's disgusting you felt the need to remove Cloud but kept Corrin and Isabelle

Toon link is shitty and most of the games he is in, are shitty. There's no reason to promote those shitty games.

That's just your opinion bro.

this is actually pretty great. Dante and Amaterasu would be cool too, but not necessary

Based

Young link promotes oot and mm. Oot is a backbone of the Zelda series, none of the toon link games are.

then it should at least be added as a semi-clone of PP. Naval is definitely recognizable, seeing as it's the most reoccurring boss in all of the yoshi games behind bowser himself.

It would also bring a lot to the table, being primarily a new yoshi rep, as well as being easy to implement, another heavyweight, another villain, and of course a lot of soul.

Attached: Naval-Piranha.jpg (286x284, 26K)

do you guys still do Yea Forumseekend Smash? I've been away for a while.
I've seen this pic before...

>banjofag

Attached: REDDIT.jpg (566x363, 29K)

Pic related?

Attached: AD55640B-0475-414E-95F8-909C1A3DCCE8.png (638x845, 342K)

OoT already has Ganondorf and Sheik. There's no reason to put even more eggs in its basket when Toon Link has so many games to represent.

>Their series doesn't need more fighters
>"overstayed their welcome"

Based on what criteria?

A Shadow echo of Sonic is the only thing gayer than playing Sonic.

could you add one for my boy Naval Piranha?

Attached: Naval_Piranha_Artwork_-_Super_Mario_World_2.png (640x593, 352K)

>roster with even less characters
>fucking buff ike
>corrin still
>midna echo
Nope, this is shit, extremely shit.

>not wanting to recreate pic related in squad strike

Attached: B37BBADD-88CB-4C52-82D4-A1E8DE69F6CA.png (1024x721, 261K)

>Ganondorf doesn't have a single one of his moves from oot
>Shiek only has one move from it
Nah. It needs an actual rep.

>my favorite pokemon is in
based roster desu

You sound like an extremely nitpicky and whiny little bitch.

They're never going to drastically rework Dorf/Shiek and OOT doesn't have anyone else important.

>Kumatora
>No Masked Man/Claus
Get your priorities straight.

>Toon Link represents a whole line of Zelda games
>The only unique thing he brings from those games is the artstyle

I fixed it

Attached: roster.png (897x164, 308K)

based and porkypilled

seething

you still adding characters?

If so, how about some Plasm Wraith action.

Attached: Plasm_wraith.png (329x500, 644K)

mind doing the cropping for me

Mind doing the cropping for me?

>cutting Ice Climbers AGAIN
Tell me where you fucking live user I'll have my dad beat up your dad

Attached: 1475522195213.jpg (300x222, 9K)

Attached: D98684DD-1663-46A2-B7C5-E86CDCC65EAF.jpg (220x208, 19K)

Attached: 821D2678-4E42-4232-8B75-2858375D3F4D.jpg (209x208, 19K)

2001 called. It wants its Nintendo Not All Star crossover game back.

There's your contradiction right there. If they are not going to rework character. Just take out every link that isn't normal link.

Silvally has a lot of potential with a neutral b that changes its type.

Why? The Links are similar enough they don't take much effort and some people have a favorite among them.

Give Ganondorf's old moveset to Black Shadow then. Or give Sheik's to Impa.

This. There was so much potential with going with him over Incineroar. Too bad Silvally’s design probably didn’t even exist at the time the project plan was started.

Missing someone but otherwise pretty good. Only if that Big Boss echo is a more melee-oriented Snake, though.

Attached: 1549236470400.png (524x524, 254K)

>can we all agree that this would be the perfect Smash roster?
No. When will rosterfags understand that there's no such thing as the "perfect roster"? No matter what roster you r/smashbros dickheads shit out, you will never please everybody, especially anybody on Yea Forums.

Attached: Eggman.gif (312x390, 1.87M)

Any roster that adds another Sonic character is instantly shit

>Jill
Shiieeet, that makes up for the other trash picks

Shitting on the Sonic franchise is low-hanging fruit now we've moved onto shit get with the times.

Okay, then. It's settled. Young link is in too. Thank you for your contradictory ass debate.

Pedo.

Since the Plasm Wraith one was already made, here's one for Naval as well.

Attached: naval piranha icon.png (349x349, 180K)

>Shadow not an echo
>Sonic but with witch time and projectiles
imagine

He’s fine by himself

Shadow would be an echo, use that spot for someone else.

Attached: steven.png (630x758, 11K)

It's already better than what we have just for the fact they're properly grouped together

>Jill
>No Geno
Based af

He doesn't have to be an echo, y'know. There's plenty of moves he has that Sonic doesn't, like Chaos Spear.

I don't agree with the guy you're replying too but at least he took the time to actually make OC instead of just using a wojak.

where's goku

>implying he's worth more than a wojak

removing cloud looks like the best thing they could do to improve the roster