Is it good

HOpefully when Kaguya ends Aka will now no longer divide his attention between two mangos and will actually put some brains into this.

kaguya was very very good for most of its run though

this

It took a nosedive after volume 4, it's pretty clear Aka used vols 5,6 and 7 as filler to give himself time to plan the rest of the plot

>kaguya was very very good for most of its run though

Attached: 1635907144031.png (628x387, 238.24K)

Yeah it's good until you get to the eternal Tokyo Blade arc

it's at least better than the faggy series summary that's used everywhere

it's bad until you get to the eternal Tokyo Blade arc

It was good but the last arc which is also the longest arc in the series by far was garbage. I temporarily dropped it but might pick it up again in the future.

whats wrong with the Tokyo Blade arc

Kanawank

That's the only good part

Not enough Kana

idols must have been dicked by their managers since early teen ages

>n-no u
>no argument

Attached: 1559166064904.gif (500x455, 496.38K)

Yes, when Kana isn't on the page.

unironically this, it's still bad but not that bad

Too long, all over the place and the play itself was nothing special after all that buildup. And yes, way too much Kanawank.

Yes. Worth it for Kanacute.

Attached: 1613341288367.png (1300x1920, 613.41K)

never heard of it but the grill on the cover is cute

Wait, this is written by the same author as Kaguya-sama? Christ, that explains why people are still following this shit.

Kana spin off when

>going from dead body reveal to kiss in one chapter
What is Aka thinking?

essentially this OnK was good before stage act arc like most people said but it got boring after that and the unironic Kana shilling is making it worse
Now it's just boring. Being better than the utterly dumpshit that is Kaguya is not something to be proud of

It is obvious that Aka just make shit up as he go
It is like he didn't learn anything from his failure with Kaguya.

Story is pretty aimless. I have no idea what Aka is trying to go for.

It's the opposite. Kaguya was good up until OnK was published. It's not that Aka didn't learn from the failure of Kaguya because Kaguya failed only after OnK started.
OnK is like the accumulation of things he wanted to write while Kaguya is something that he needed to write. Kaguya failed because Aka lost time to properly think of something good to write about when he's also writing OnK.
OnK was good at first because it's interesting but he essentially doesn't plan any shit and just write what he wanted to write. That's why there's a lot of plot holes in the manga despite still having around 80 chapters. Ruby also doesn't have much appearances despite being the other protagonist of the story.

tldr, the reasons for Kaguya and OnK failing is different. Kaguya failed because Aka didn't have time to think about what to write (and probably because of divorce) and OnK failed because Aka is just writing whatever he likes, just like you said

This and also it's way too long and boring

Huh, that is also when I dropped it. I didn't even stop reading intentionally, I thought I liked it, but then I just kinda... stopped. Guess I should catch up

I wonder if anyone here is reading this manga for this manga and not for their obsession with Kaguya specifically and Aka in general.

I read it for Kana

This. The obsession with Kaguya is insane. A lot of anons read OnK because they either like or hate Kaguya.

You're just a mikofag or their descendants. Both you kanafags and kanahaters are the biggest reasons why we can't have a good OnK discussion

It is fucking annoying how Mikofags kept associating her with Kana and now those mentally ill faggots latch onto her with their cancer waifufaggotry

I haven't read Kaguya at all but I did read IB, at this point I only keep reading this for Kana, Aka hasn't improved at writing edge at all, Aqua is supposed to be over 30yo when he died but sounds 12 when he goes edgy, this manga would be much better if it focused on the showbiz side

It's got interesting insights into the japanese entertainment industry, with an interesting murder mystery-revenge plot combo

Kana is Maki, not Miko

Too much kino.

Attached: 1631986204816.png (1264x506, 685.72K)

I started reading it because Kaguya was my favorite series and I assumed Aka's other work would be just as good. It is.

It's pretty mediocre but the waifus make up for it. Pretty par for the course for most idol shit.

Read it and decide for yourself. What a sheep you are.

What's wrong with sex?

no

it sends you to hell

if I can't have it NOBODY WILL!!!

Attached: ss (2017-03-06 at 12.55.50).jpg (743x403, 119.39K)

leaks doko

It's good because I want to fuck Kana.

Attached: 0076-015.png (1082x760, 1000.79K)

No payoff. Between Aka and Mengo they just weren't able to portray how X acting was better than Y acting and the character who got the most development was someone who was previously a one-off that doesn't even count as side cast until he returns and we see something come of it. Maybe the worst part of Oshi no Ko is the exposition too, and we spent an obscene amount of chapters on that.

The denouement was alright but it felt like we jumped through tons of unnecessary hoops to get to Aqua finding out about his father, except every reader knew that it was a misdirection and we didn't even get an arc before they came clean about it being a mistake.

Kana is my favourite character but Kanawank is right too. As mentioned, the team couldn't portray what was special about different acts so people were just saying Kana was great without any clear reason. Her plot in the arc is discovering that it's okay for her to stand out on stage but we just had the idol arc shortly before that where she decided with way less trouble that she would stand out on stage so like what the fuck.

A LOT of the problem with the stage arc is the fact that the manga became close to a fucking monthly manga during it because Aka was constantly on breaks. In a binge it's not actually very noticeable that it's super long, it's a 'major arc' but not at all over-long for what it is.
Kanawank was bad during it because having Akane turn into a rabid Kanafag did nothing for either Kana's character nor Akane's character, and it also had this weird effect of retroactively making Kana as good as or better of an actress than Akane when it had already been established the latter was significantly better in the present. Kana's baggage was that she had to find ways to deal with her insecurities and the truth that her prime in acting passed years ago, the play arc flipped that on its head and makes you wonder why she'd even bother being an idol at this point if she can start acting again.

It falls off hard after that girl almost gets bullied to suicide. Like it deviates too much from what made it interesting from that point and focuses too much on the boring shit.

Bunch of literally who drama that I don't care about
Also the same face problem become much worse when everyone put on wigs

Based fuck whores.