this guy wanted communism but with extra steps
This guy wanted communism but with extra steps
Pain wanted globalism, which is a component of communism, but I don't remember him having an economic policy.
emotional communism
Continental MAD isn't communism
Its just MAD, with extra steps
Pain watched Itatchi's ark and developed the same views every other 14 year old had
Why did he need the beasts if he could teleport into villages and instantly destroy them all on his own?
Still a better main villain than the masked incel and alien bunny woman.
Communism would work in the world of Naruto because chakra is free. Which means health care is no problem at all, people just wave their hands and you're cured. There's no need to overpay doctors anymore and the population will stay healthy and more active, meaning communism is achievable.
Take that back he was the coolest guy
you'd still have the constraints of labor and the fact that only extremely small amounts of the population can actually use chakra at all, much less in a medical way. also, medicine isn't in the only thing that would need to free and infinite in supply for such a decentralized society to work
we dont talk about that
He just wanted to use the Juubi to fearmonger the big nations into not doing war, don't remember him talking about changing nation's internal policies
>just wave their hands and you're cured
>people had to train for years to become competent medical ninja
No its not. A huge portion of the population can't use chakra let alone have the years of training needed to use it for medical purposes. Their training should not mean their labor is free.
The original Akatsuki objective of creating muh "military industrial complex" to keep shinobi relevant in the world was far cooler and way more evil than what eventually happened.
Literally fucking Metal Gear and what Big Boss wants.
Just ask Naruto to use clones and it's a non problem.
rain city appeared to be a massive industrial complex, as as pain, the governor, presumably owned the city and thus the various refineries and foundries it could be argued he had achieved socialism with ninja characteristics
>this guy wanted communism but with extra steps
not really. he wanted to be God. as in an abrahamic God that made people behave and live in peace out of fear he could destroy them.
I don't even understand what communism has to do with his plan.
>Communism would work in the world of Naruto because chakra is free.
that's mildly retarded. chakra is kinda like a muscle. you still need to train it. as in put in work. work. literally the opposite point of communism
user did you just forget the entire 2-6 tails and Kurama Bijuu Dama clash?
He wanted to give everyone nukes so they be all scared shitless like ww3. He was much an idiot like the 1st hokage who actually did that. 2nd Hokage was great and wanted to consolidate power and keep things in check.
So Pain is just lying to the rest of the members at that moment? I mean he wants "world peace" through fear rather than war profiteering as he said. Not to mention his endgame also doesn't allign with Obito/Madara. I think Pain & Konan are aware of the moon eye plan too, so they think they can somehow outwit/beat Obito?
>inb4 it's all just retcon bro
Anyway, I agree with this user. The war profiteering plan is more interesting.
Pain wanted to abolish the retarded ninja system of their world, which was a right thing to do. The ninja system is barbaric and incompatible with peace, it exists on war economy and employs child soldiers, causing tremendous suffering both to children and their parents. I was actually horrified at all the child deaths in Naruto, it's perceived as normal somewhat, but it's terrifying to think about. Pain's views were completely justified. The whole manga should've ended with the ninja world abandoning ninjutsu completely and striving for coexistence. But it's a retarded piece of shonen, so it didn't do that, instead glorifying the shinobi till the very end.
What are you talking about?
Motherfucker do you really think the Earth and Lightning countries are pansy enough to let something like that happen? Earth and Lightning don't fuck around like the Fire and Wind countries. They're way too militaristic to just let that shit go down. Even the six Pain bodies and Konan wouldn't be able to handle the Lightning country with the Raikage and Bee there. And the Tsuchikage? Nah, man. One fucking Dust style box, it's over.
Their whole village would be destroyed in literally 5 seconds with hundreds of casualties and they wouldn't be able to do anything about it.
I don't think he's lying, it's just that it was just another step in his plan. Tailed Beasts were not the only factor, they spent shit tone of time earning money, getting influence, being hired by other states and etc. They weren't just beast-hunting group
I thought this was literally the whole point of villages in the first place? They're mercenaries too.
That wouldn't happen in any village other than the Leaf village, because the Leaf village is in a precarious situation in terms of defense. While the incredible forest that surrounds them acts as a natural defense against invaders, it's also difficult to effectively patrol (outside of the one special part of the forest that the Nara clan tends). So instead, the Leaf village uses the barrier to protect a certain radius around their village. The other nations do not have this sort of natural defense. They can't rely on a barrier like that and instead rely on actual scouts. Combined with their already militaristic mindset, it seems like a pretty big stretch to think that Pain would be able to replicate that on them. He was in favorable conditions with the Leaf Village because he had intel already from Obito. Plus, the Raikage and Bee could survive that blast anyway. Just the Raikage would solo the pain bodies, and he's definitely durable enough to handle that blast if fucking Tsunade was able to take it while also using her healing jutsu to keep everybody else safe.
Fucking this. Also look at pic related.
Funny how it's Minato who is saying that, one of the system biggest enablers, who feels no empathy for his dead/traumotized students or 1000 men he killed in a battle and also without any necessity put a murderous beast inside his own son despite his wife(who experienced this) begging him not to, simply because of "muh state".
Minato really had basically no fucking character and just said and did what author wanted him to say or do at that moment. You could just break him into 5-6(or idk how many times he appeared) random characters
Nah, they used to be in the warring states era, but currently they're also the regional Government, as the Kage is the Second to the Daimyo.
no, he wanted absolutism, he just wanted to end the wars between all countries by having a weapon that no man could oppose and creatte peace through fear, unironically achieved his goal through sasuke and naruto at the end
Naruto's world is a world of failed adults. You can't prove me wrong
But people hire them to do missions.
Yes, and unlike a typical mercenary it's sanctioned and insured by the Government.
No. This guy just wanted to create our post ww2 world. Was beaten by the power of shounen, unfortunately
Naruto is effectively carrying out his exact plan.
No. Nukes/tailed beasts are eternal. Naruto will die like a bitch pretty soon and shit will go down again
Supposedly they were loyal to their respective countries, I really don't understand how kishi thought that dumb mercenary-hokage-daimyo system was better or simpler to do than just have the Hokage be the Emperor of the Fire country, the village be the capital and jonin/chunin/genin being their military ranks. After the first arc it practically turned into that anyways
>Nukes/tailed beasts are eternal.
They're really not.
jesus, the plot could have been based.
Man, can't wait for that Boruto timeskip. Probably gonna be as you say, Naruto (and possibly also Sasuke) die, and war almost immediately breaks out. I'm sure they'll have it be Kara's fault, cause I don't think they've got the balls to just have the countries go to war naturally. I also really hope that Himawari gets the Nine Tails after Naruto kicks the bucket.
shutup moooorty *BUURP*
They lived for thousands of years. If killed, they are revived again. Compare that to Naruto
Pfff, mangaka won't have enough balls or intelligence for that. There is no foreshadowing for villages' conflict, everyone will be cooperating and loving each other because of some 3 minute speech about "muh naruto"
All of Naruto's history is like a century or two.
Its tied the theme of ninja being tool/weapon
Minato is fully aware of what he is while naruto refused to be one
user, tailed beasts are thousands years old
They're irrelevant to the discussion unless shoved into people.
Lol what? Pain wanted to invent the nuke and stop major wars which (news flash for you retards) actually worked IRL. Countries are so scared of mutual destruction that WW3 was avoided until now and it won't happen as countermeasures to nukes don't become effective. Pain's idea was unironically much better than Naruto's retardism and would have stopped major wars after 2-3 cities get wiped from the face of the Earth. Naruto's idea only worked temporarily because Lolmadara was a common enemy and the next few generations will remember fighting together against him.
We don't have WWIII because;
1. There is nothing important to fight over. WWI and WWII were literally because of imperialism and butthurt
2. War has become costly and thus no longer generate the profit they used to/there is no real glory in fighting in them anymore.
Once technology reachers a certain point including mass-messaging shit becomes pointless.
>nothing important to fight over
>what is the cold war
>what is ideology
You are literally too retarded to talk basic history with. The only reason the cold war didn't develop into an actual war is because nukes were a major deterrent. Go read a book for once in your life you brain dead monkey. Absolute state of this board.
So did old man Sage of Six Paths with his Ninshuu bullshit.
But it failed.
>Muh nukes
>Muh ideaology
>Muh Cold War
Literally retarded. Russia couldn't do shit to the US and knew it. They would lose more starting a war in Europe than the US which is why a war never broke out.
Literally everyone's plan was better than Naruto's. You know why?
Because Naruto never had a plan to begin with. He himself literally never gave an actual answer and shit just worked out because of other people. I highly doubt he himself realises that
This, Shikimaru is the real Hokage
You are the biggest brainlet I've seen here in a while. I'm done responding to your idiocy, pick up a book so you can stop embarrassing yourself every time you say something.
>shikimaru is the danzo of boruto
Literally no one think that. Not even Shikamaru himself
Though Naruto does seem more like an English Queen sometimes
That was so much cooler than the moon eye plan, and kaguya. Why Kishimoto couldn't just follow what he initially planed?
He thought he needed to continue escalating the scope of his plot.
>military industry complex
>forcing piece between the nations through the use of the bijuus
>putting the entire world in a perfect illusion
>harvesting humans to fight in galactic warfare
Kishi going from semi-realist to more and more esoteric ruined Naruto
Why couldn't we just let Madara to build the ninja Matrix?
*without "to"
True.
Kojima confirmed narutard
I mean, doesn’t it go in line with peace trough bijuu nukes plan?
Reminder that DarkRuto was right
>communist is free healthcare
why are americans this dumb?
>mass murder
ok but what are the extra steps?
Naruto forgave them though , so it's all good.
The whole point was to create Bijuu Nukes and hand them out to every single country, not for Pain to do the destruction himself
>Communism
I fucking wish.
Decades of brainwashing and propaganda by corporations has resulted in the entire US population being subservient drones. There’s literally no difference between Americans and the Chinese when you switch them.
>work. literally the opposite point of communism
A basic tenet of many forms of communism (notably Marxist-Lenism) is that you have to work. Like, they put prostitutes in work camps because they didn't consider them as workers otherwise.
>A basic tenet of many forms of communism (notably Marxist-Lenism) is that you have to work
This , from each according to his ability , to each according to his needs.
Basically everyone has to work as hard they can.
>from each according to his ability
That's where it fails
>I'll fix your teeth if you give me some food
>same amount of food as the janitor gets since we both have similar requirements
Makes no sense to waste years in education if you receive the same from your community as an unqualified worker. But if you receive more that creates disparity in the community.
Well undwr communism , you're only supposed to study/do stuff that actually interest or that you have a passion for.
Your life shouldn't be guided strictly by the hopes of monetary gain.
>you're only supposed to study/do stuff that actually interest or that you have a passion for.
This works in fucking Star Trek because they can print anything out of thin air
This doesn't work in reality
Society requires menial labor performed by people to run. Everybody can't just chase their own passions.
Not him, but that's a separate argument.
Tiger mizuki