So was it just plain bad or mediocre?
So was it just plain bad or mediocre?
Angel Smith
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Kevin Gonzalez
The first 13 episodes were pretty good and had a good direction, everything else was pretty fucking bad and as a love story is just fucking bad, can't believe people unironically consider it the greatest love story in anime.
Ian Gray
Because it's a story, that has love in it and most "love stories" people are used to are bereft of story. It's usually just self-insert romance porn.
So if that be all one has ever seen, then this appears outstanding by comparison, just as Madoka appears outstanding just for being compared to "magical girl".
Jaxon Phillips
It's objectively the most overated anime ever. it's a solid 4.5/10
Jason Gray
Dude, Dragon Ball exists.
Even if Dragon Ball were averages rated 3/10; it would still be the most overrated thing in existence. Dagon Ball's glorying in it's own terribleness and how much it contradicts itself five episodes later merits a negative rating.
Joshua Powell
Forced drama is always bad.
Grayson Parker
Don't care about the actual anime, but the OST is god tier.
youtube.com
Isaac Reyes
More like Shitgatsu wa Jimi no Kuso lmao
Jason Adams
based
Andrew Ward
It was okay. Despite consuming
melodrama like hotcakes Yea Forums dislikes it solely because it got somewhat popular with normalfags.
Jose Russell
It's one of the best anime out there. Fite me
It's a show about how music changes people's lives. The romance comes second.
True. Yea Forums will never enjoy something in the top 25.
Ayden Green
Garbage telenovela for mexican grandmas.
Ian Campbell
based
Kevin James
It's shit and you're shit. Fuck melodrama when it's related to love stories, although the deal breaker was the random comedy skits. Absolutely awful.
Aaron Rivera
lol
Brody Garcia
They are fucking teens. One heartbreak isn't the end of the world. This is why I hate teenager drama. Otherwise the music part is great.
David Cooper
It was okay and very forgettable. It's probably my fault for getting spoiled early on but none of romance felt impactful and Kaori or whatever the main girl's name was is completely retarded and just should've told Piano the situation. Basketball's drama felt like such a waste of screentime considering it's blatantly obvious she had no chances of winning. The performance scenes were nice though.
Emi deserved to win.
Parker Fisher
Everytime people preaching this, I cringe of how shallow they are knowing how service-level this was.
Anthony Johnson
Aggressively mediocre for the most part. But there was real care and consideration given to the choices made for the OST, which bumps it up to half decent.
John Rivera
Give me a better show about how music influences people's lives. I've yet to see something that comes close to this show.
Camden Hill
it's surprisingly popular with Normalfag in here
Joshua Morris
Sora no Woto, kinda.
Ayden Rodriguez
S2 never ;_;
Christopher Kelly
Perhaps didn't even close, but this is a good one.
Jace Campbell
>Lie in April
>lie was basically "I was pretending to cuck you with you bff"
story could go just full romance and tragedy, and at the end MC is learning to move on with his girl-bff
It was a wasted potential
Samuel Moore
Seen it, impressively boring.
Gonna move it up a few places in my plan to watch queue.
Asher Young
Kaori was a whore and im glad mc got the real ending
Tyler Phillips
This anime IS just self-insert romance porn. Main character with zero personality or... well... dialogue has three 10/10 girls after him simply for existing. Doesn't help he also has black hair and glasses like 99% of Jap males.
Tyler Bell
neither
Jordan Long
>heartbreak
It was more the fact that she died young without ever giving the final duo performance. It's not like she just moved to another country.
Bentley Howard