Generic, bland and tasteless. I felt nothing

Generic, bland and tasteless. I felt nothing.

Attached: annoyingMC.jpg (1200x1500, 193K)

Fma>fmab

>generic
>bland
no
>poorly written
yes

The villains exist just to be defeated. It's generic.

What did you expect from a shounen, you should have known what kind of people sing the praises of these.

Shitposting aside, I agree. The original series had a more vibrant/dense color design and general visual direction.

Brotherhood felt very washed out in most aspects.

good taste

based

How is this #1 on MAL?

Attached: 1561501487189.png (254x283, 83K)

There are people who are extremely autistic about it staying number 1, anything that comes close gets spammed with low ratings while it gets constant 10s

03 will always be fanfic garbage

Unironically always a good thread

>when the "real" version is more boring and lifeless than the "fanfic garbage"

ok faggot

Jojo, HxH, SnK

Based

I prefer BH but agree. Ed's hair looks awful compared to '03.

That's retarded.

Based and agreed.

>bro bro muh natural selection and food cycle very profound amirite
Some shit in it was so cringey

Explain why it's bad.
With your words.

reminder that contrarians are always normalfags in denial

That's a bold claim from a shounenshitter

Fpbp

Yea Forums is contrarian to certain things.
The manga is good.

But it's easier to drop something by giving it a lot of 1 than to raise a lot of stuff to its level.

...You could say the same for a lot of series how is this even a criticism

What about Scar or Greed

He means most of them didn't serve any purpose besides being obstacles for the protagonists and the big bad, Father, was only ever the evil guy who must be stopped. He wasn't the evil guy with an interesting worldview or the evil guy who might have a point. He was just the evil guy and everything he does is irredeemable. The one antagonist I suppose none of this really applies to is Bradley.

Scar was an anti hero and Greed made no goddamn sense

>Scar was an anti hero
After being an antagonist for a good chunk of the opening chapters.
He didn't really become an anti-hero until he started associating with Mei.
>and Greed made no goddamn sense
How?

Biggest reason why F.M.A. gets praised so much for having "such a good plot"; it's basically being compared to shit like Naruto and Dragon Ball.

>shounen shit
>popular
>has a dub

great setting but extremely shitty narrative and characterisation
the character design isn't very good either, hiromu arakawa is better making manga about farming

naruto has a better plot than fma, at least through the pain arc before it jumps the shark and gets super shit

Most overrated anime

It's supposed to be light blonde because of his Xerxes lineage.

>naruto has a better plot than fma
lol

>dude Im a contrarian
lmao

desu i prefer hxh
no one can touch that masterpiece

Actual #1 spot belongs to Madoka

Attached: 1528767532178.png (439x400, 171K)

Based

Why did you post a picture of FMA to talk about your first time taking cock up the ass?

Based

Yeah, so what? Why waste a thread on this shit?

Ki mi no na wa and Erased were also No #1 for a while too

Hahahhahahaha, no

It's an actual alchemist cult

stick to "soft-seinen" series.

retard

Attached: bb66c97bd3d3d5bdf9f2ab14fb3bca9a.jpg (436x448, 26K)

that's what she said

he's right tho

Baste Taste

Attached: 1565516920844.jpg (480x360, 20K)

B&R