How exactly are female characters in shonen manga particularly bad? People keep parroting this opinion without making an intelligent case for it. Are they just biased?
How exactly are female characters in shonen manga particularly bad...
Because they never contribute to the story in a meaningful way, rarely have any personality development, rarely get into any fights, and only exist for fanservice and a prize for the male characters to win. You could remove them from the story completely and nothing would change.
people that say that don't watch other shounen besides shounen jump shit
Are you describing shonen or real life?
Yes
Quit browsing anime Twitter and save yourself the brain cells. Half the faggots there don't even watch anime and just want something to Grand stand about. And those that do watch it are underage and like 6 months in.
It's pretty great how much Jump has changed recently in that regard these past few years. Neverland and Act-Age have female MC, Dr. Stone has an acoustic MC too busy to fuck with girls, Kimetsu has a female deuteragonists even though it took her a while, and Chainsaw Man seem to be deconstructing having female characters as a prize to the MC
My favorite romances are in things that aren't romances at all. Like initialD of all things.
It depends on if they'd be extremely less interesting if they didn't have boobs.
>a prize for the male characters to win
How rarely this happens in even popular shonenshit. People say this but then shonen lacks romance as well.
not all of them are bad just the main girl love interest. the tomboy is usually best girl and most cumbrains don't even know it
The tomboy normally gets shit on by the story and turned super feminine in a timeskip
Cope roastie
They do contribute to the story in a meaningful way. Twice as many mothers than fathers.
>He doesn't want interesting and likeable women who actually do things in his stories
You sound pretty gay, bro.
I don't know if your parents gave you the talk yet but it takes two to tango. Women don't spontaneously get pregnant. Unless you're saying more women raise their kids than men, in which case, no shit Sherlock. You try being a man and winning a custody battle when the courts are so stacked against you.
I'm saying that on average you have roughly twice as many female ancestors and it wasn't always due to rape.
Controlling who breeds and who doesn't sounds like a meaningful contribution to me.
Women contribute more IRL than men do.
fucking kek
If women could reproduce without men and men never existed we would either be extinct or still in the stone age.
Women make babies, but are otherwise unproductive. Men are very productive, but cannot make babies. It's a mutually beneficial relationship we have.
Not true, men have always hindered women in history that's why we send you off to war so that you can die. You're easily replaceable unlike us.
>always hindered women in history
So? It's just means that women were weak enough to be hindered.
>playing his stupid game
>they never contribute to the story in a meaningful way
What do you mean?
Why do women find themselves incredibly attracted to male media if it's such a horrible place for them?
Because women love to constantly complain, nothing is ever good enough for them.
Because male media makes up 95% of media.
95% of statistics are made up on the spot.
That's actually not true at all.
Women make up the majority of the consumer market, there are hundreds of shows and channels purely dedicated to women.
Shonen, as it's name suggests, is marketed towards boys.
Considering that fifty shades is the best selling book ever, I think it's just a small number of wierdos.
Because they dont actually care about male media and just want to insert themselves into everything men like so they can get attention.
Women should be banned from male hobbies because they always make it shittier for men.
This may sound anecdotal but in my experience, only weird attention whores who hate men complain about hat kind of thing. Women have their own media the same as men. There are plenty of girls who adore the shounen genre the same reason men do. Sexy women, and handsome men. I mean, it goes both ways.
Know what's like real life? How everyone takes notice of any character with a vagina and ignore the countless male characters who are just fodder.
This
No matter what all the robots that bitch and moan about how vile they think women are will immediate bend the knee to any woman if they think they can get into favor with her.
Anime/manga is male media?
But at the end of the day what you want for you tomboy is to fuck the main character so you are a hypocrite.
When there are a female character who has a role in a series that is not to be in love with the main character you don't accept it and you think she has lost or something if she doesn't end with him.
The problem with female characters is in the audience too
I won't pretend I didn't ship Ichigo and Tatsuki, but in the end they were just friends and she was really no closer to him than Orihime.
I just would've preferred she had actual relevance in the story rather than do fucking nothing.
>But at the end of the day what you want for you tomboy is to fuck the main character so you are a hypocrite.
If one self inserts the empathy into the MC to be with the tomboy. I do not see a problem with that.
Shounen characters in general are bad.
>he spends his entire life thinking about pussy and trying to get pussy
>>>>he thinks he's in control
Holy fucking jej.
I think what user meant was that shonen is filled with ten times as many useless male characters.
You remove Renji from the story and what changes? Just like Orihime exits only to have tits on screen, Renji exit solely to be a tier one antagonist whose instantly "befriended" after defeat, a common shone trope of gathering allies. He's a much of a character as someone's body pillow waifu. Ichigo walks around with him and his other "friends" like Chad and Ishida and they never do anything except fight fodder villains that sometime feel like they were invented literally only so they'd have someone to fight. Practically canon filler.
Compare that to Kurapika or Killua from hxh.
All I'm saying is shit shonen is shit on every level, not just with the girls.
Shounen anime/manga is male media.
>never contribute to the story in a meaningful way, rarely have any personality development
You could say that about half of the cast of any given series
The female characters who aren't love interests are fine.
The shitty characters come when you've got a man in is 30s trying to write a teenage girl in love, a la Sakura or Orihime.
>when you've got a man in is 30s trying to write a teenage girl in love
While being harem manga protagonist levels of oblivious to the already existing sexual tensions between already exiting characters that he wrote into the story completely unintentionally and only for some sort of Freudian reason.
No since the moment the editorials themselves tell their shonen magazines (Weekly Shonen Jump for example) are read in a 50% by females.
That changes nothing.
But if the character is not in the series to be a romantic interest you should to accept it and enjoy the female character without this aspect.
>compare that to who and who from hiatusxhiatus
cringe
Some shonen shows have better female designs than harem series when it comes to hairstyle and outfits.
>ichiruki/narusakufags are still mad
>That changes nothing.
Except many things, like making bishies immortal "or else."
I said it before Ill say it again, y'all nigga need to read Flame of Recca.
Maybe because they're attracted to male characters' interactions?
Or else what?
If shonen series are read by both males and females of course the way to do the series is going to change. They are already changing, even though slowly
Shonen series will survive with or without female readers.
So it's not so bad after all.
They were in their 20s when they their manga and started to write their love
But women reading shonen exist and if they are so many you can assure they are going to have a very important influence in the way to do shonen. And this is a trend that just started, we haven't still seen the full effects of it. Hopefully this will bring better roles for the female characters.
>People say this but then shonen lacks romance as well.
Not anymore seeing that the Japanese birth rate is decreasing more and more. Some battle shounen do have important romantic subplots and it depends on the writer's skill. Most just take knowledge from media instead of real life.
I haven't kept up with a lot of modern ones, but I remember romance always been around if not a major plot at least an important sub one. Shows like Rurouni Kenshin were even as much a romance as they were an action show
>why do women
How about stop using the loud voices of a few to form your opinion of all. Men complain just as much about either their own or media not meant for them but instead of blanketing "all men" people divide them up into "fags" "man children" "niggers" "boomers" etc forgetting or not wanting to admit that they too are all men as well. This generation and the last one are just spoiled crybabies, both genders.
Seething this much
Most have been useless trophies but shounen and alot of seinen just have bad writing in general. Same power fantasy and power level bullshit across the lot of it and weebs buy into it.
>he thinks he's in control
I never said or implied that.
>Not anymore seeing that the Japanese birth rate is decreasing more and more
This meme again.
Where is the significant statistical change in shone romance? BNHA, becasue Hori is a westaboo enough that he wrote Uraraka to be a semi-competent character? There's always one exception like FMA.
Shonen romance in general hasn't advanced since Chi-Ch and Chi-Chi was shit.
Explains why fujo is degenerative.
>implying fujo wallets aren't doing most of the funding for shounen so they can support their ships
>implying male wallets aren't going toward idol bullshit and games.
Trend started two decades ago, women don't want to read about women they want to read about hot guys.
Where do you think fujos get their material from? BL is a shitty genre, shounen is prime real estate of twinks bonding more with each other than the female love interests.
One of the great things about fiction is that you can improve on real life.
>that the Japanese birth rate is decreasing more and more
Every modern country has declining birth rates, the xenophobic ones just don't offset it with immigration.
>Where is the significant statistical change in shone romance? BNHA, becasue Hori is a westaboo enough that he wrote Uraraka to be a semi-competent character?
Are you really saying the romance in MHA is differnt and Ochako is a good main female character? The romance is very minimal, it's Ochako being in love with Deku mainly, so the same as other many series, and Ochako has little protagonism in the series for being the main female.
I was hoping the bottle was gonna say bleach
No. She has SLIGHTLY more character and agency than other shonen heroines, and tends to get more badass moments.
She's ultimately still whipped by the plot for being female because this is Japanese media.
Same reason men like CGDCT. Most don't really give a shit and just want to watch people they think are cute for half an hour, while those who bitch constantly hate seeing others enjoy themselves so they try to explain why those around them should also hate everything.
Not the percentage being 50% . This is recently, and the editorial themselves were surprised.
In my opinion in the future the magazines are going to be advertised and made for both genders.
Nah, Rukia is way better main female than her
For me, it's still Tier mommy Harribel.
I don't watch much shonen but shit female characters in Naruto pissed me off because their entire characters revolved around their crushes and they always play second fiddle to the male characters in every way they can even if it makes no logical sense and even if it makes them annoying/useless by proxy, even Tsunade, who is probably one of the most accomplished of the female Naruto characters ends up spending most of her tenure as kage being Naruto's bitch and getting shat on by him after Jiraiya's death and she was only chosen because Jiraiya didn't want it and because Orochimaru was too busy being evil. Not to mention that her backstory revolves mostly around Dan.
Sakura's character after becoming briefly cool after the Sasori fight (which is undercut because she needed Chiyo to win it anyways) is ruined again to make her have her crush on Sasuke regardless of how retarded it is, Hinata is bland as batshit because she revolves around Naruto so much, Konan becomes completely aimless once she loses Yahiko and Nagato and then gets killed off by Obito in about 30 seconds flat, etc.,
I'd have said Black Clover if I had to mention a modern shonen with a non-retarded female love interest. Ochaco hasn't been good since her fight with Bakugou.
>revolves around men
Naruto is probably the closest shonen to write actual woman instead of sues.
this is kubo bias
Honestly, a world without women would be terrible. Men (are):
>loud
>smell like shit
>unhygienic
>hairy, rough, and ugly
>autistic and obsessed with ideas and tools
>violent
>couldn't even care for a fucking pet hamster
>too tribal
>cannot reproduce
>do not have vaginas or boobs
>completely out of touch with their emotions and feelings. They become repressed and eventually release themselves in sporadic and dangerous ways
>lack grace, subtlety, prose, and restraint
>devoid of culture, devoid of purpose, and devoid of passion without women
Is this really that hard of a concept for incels to understand? Both genders do different things, and both genders are essential for the other's; they complete each other, like the yin and the yang.
>a-anime without wo-
It would be fucking shit. Just a giant autistic faggy sausagefest with no break in tension, pace, or action. Everything would be like those shitty indie action movies or action video games from the 90's.
Rei is cute! CUTE!
we're talking about shounen manga not manga in general
there's plenty of great female characters and representation in manga
just, you know, not in the ones specifically targeted to boys (and even then it's really only just battle shounen).
>gold digger
HxH has no women in the main cast and it's the best battle shounen
>HxH has no women in the main cast
Kurupika
>it's the best battle shounen
Lmao
Kurupika is a man
a manly man
oh yeah I forgot HxH is a seinen, sorry about that
Pika is either male or a tranny. I'm inclined to the latter since Togashi love them.
>sees one person saying this
>hmm...
>sees more people saying it
>do i ask them to explain their opinion?
>no, fuck that, i need to make a thread
Kubo should have gone into porn
Would have probably ended up better than Bleach even if he tried to give it a story.
Jesus christ your a fucking faggot
They still somehow get the best porn artists.
Shonen teachs boys that women are just cheerleaders and cum dumpsters which is based and redpilled.
>wasnt always due to rape
Lol wut consentful sex was an alien concept to men before the iron age.
Men are sent to war because only their sex can handle warfare, women are weak and useless so have to stay behind and get raped by the invading army. Look at Africa the men always fight in tribal wars the women do nothing on the otherhand. Chimps are different both sexes fight in wars.
Because they rarely do anything of note that gets readers excited.
Like Sakura got the 100 Seal, that's nice but Tsundade already had that and she got destroyed by base Madara along with 3 other Ninjas better than both of them, what the fuck is Sakura going to do against Six Paths Madara?
Rukia got her Bankai? Congrats you're one of the 30+ characters who do.
Orihime can undo anything even things determined by God? Does nothing with it, especially against Ywach who thinks he is God
And as much as I praise One Piece girls for actually more solo victories than the above, they still don't really make you shout 'FUCK YEAH'.
Or you get the opposite end of the spectrum of characters like Erza and Erina who just win despite all adversity put against often with minimal difficulty. That's boring regardless of gender if played straight.
Then there's the fact they're usually drama magnet and the drama usually turns them into love sick puppies or quivering does in headlights, undermining any attempt to make them seem impressive.
And that's just the tip of the iceburg.
I would rape the lesbian out of Suì-Fēng
They do?
Shonen would not survive if women stopped buying the magazines. A medium cannot survive losing half of its consumers.
Shonen manga hasn't been a 'male media' for 30 years my guy. Shonen as a tag is a meaningless hold over from the 70s.
For not liking men?
I think it teaches boys that when girls are watching magical things happen inside of you.
This, if shounen manga/anime had female characters worth half a shit and actual romance fujos wouldn't be such a boogeyman.