ITT: Kino Panelling
ITT: Kino Panelling
Logan Hall
Other urls found in this thread:
Jayden Ramirez
I read this series for the art.
Leo Gutierrez
Nicholas Ward
Kino hat atelier always delivers
Lincoln Martinez
>Kino
James Phillips
Togashi frames conversations so well. Every single panel has a flourish that keeps the momentum going. Pic related, Kurapika and Melody leaning on and over the panel border as if it were a rooftop wall for example.
Alexander Clark
looks shit
David Adams
Based and kinopilled.
Lucas Garcia
Thread ruined
Jaxson Evans
Hunterchad thread?
>Left: Natural disasters
>Right: Human disasters
>Morena at the center trying to find a balance.
Kino. It references her mental instability, implies something inhuman about her hatred, and the divider's ALSO really two parallel lines, reminding us of the disfiguring scar she received as a royal bastard. Really damn good composition.
Based
Wyatt Ward
Shit panneling
Ryder Morris
Sebastian Myers
this is the most creative use of empty space of page ever. Chadsuki Fujimoto is literally the best mangaka ever
Dominic Martinez
Why are you cunts so uncreative? Spamming the same fucking shit, every fucking thread.
Andrew Taylor
It was also a play off of the mirroring going on in that chapter. Onior loved human service and excess while Brocco surrounds himself with animals. Their panels mirrored one another, and when we reach Morena she's put in the center and compared to Christ. Jesus was the son of God sent to absolve people of their sins, while Morena is the rejected daughter of a king who wants the world to burn for its innate sin. In that image she is put in the middle with human crimes on the right and crimes of nature to her left, juxtaposing what the two other mafia heads indulge themselves in(human service and nature).
Justin Brown
this is so sad
Bentley White
HAHAHAHA FUCKING AGAIN, YOU LOSERS ARE SO CREATIVELY BANKRUPT, OH NO NO NO NO
Ayden Myers
Pure ToGODashi KINO.
Caleb Richardson
Is this what happens when they don't get any chapters for a year? I'm worried their mental health may never recover from this
Jason Bennett
Why don't you address the content of those pastas? I'll tell you why. Because they are constructed in such an informed and intellectual way, that it is absolutely impossible to refute them unless you are highly educated and learned on the same level of the people who wrote those pastas, who are all Hunterchads.
Jeremiah White
this still hits me hard
Wyatt Ramirez
Why are you shitting up Vinland threads?
Zachary Taylor
god I hate hunterfag so much
Juan Wright
Adam Bailey
Cringed
Based and panelpilled
Jackson Stewart
CRAWLING IN MY SKIN
Caleb Hall
>Hunterchad thread?
Of course, every paneling thread is a Hunterchad thread. I'll contribute one of my favorite underrated pages, from chapter 352 page 19.
>A. The general clutter of the panel and floaty-ness of the character art shows how chaotic the setpiece is, and how Hisoka's mind is narrowing down to focus solely on Chrollo's devious tactics. As if time was slowing down for this train-of-thought.
>B. The white space behind Hisoka's head is used to show how empty of other subjects besides this battle his mind is. Narrowing down to the basics of the fight.
>C. We are then brought back to Hisoka's face, which expresses a mixture of smug surprise, and devilish determination. And swirling in front of him and as well as (seemingly) to his side is a menacing smog. Which has typically been used to communicate blood-lust in this manga.
This sequence is ridiculously good. It is the perfect example of how beautiful paneling can trump overdrawn work.
Daniel Green
Examples of good paneling in manga
Mediocre or bad paneling
With that said, I was rereading through the Chimera Ant arc and noticed that Togashi used Gon's entire body to separate the panels. That's the coolest thing I've ever seen.
Isaac Ortiz
I can do this all day.
Angel Lee
Whoa thats so cool how his body seperates the panels! How can other mangaka even compete?
Kayden Young
Hunterfags in SHAMBLES ITT
Julian Long
we get it. Togashit copies reallife becasue he cant come up with something himself
John Brooks
Is this a running gag or something?
HxH is fucking horrid in all aspects and people are pretending like its some amazing shit.
Samuel Hill
He did it again during Chrollo's fights with Hisoka. It's also one of my favorite examples of Togashi's paneling. The Bungee Gum extending to be a border between the panels is creative as hell, if you know of any other examples just post em
Tyler Mitchell
THIS KILLS THE WHISPERFAG
youtube.com
Nolan Brown
Stop saying "creative as hell" as if it makes it more creative when you repeat it like a fucking retarded dog. ShitXshit is shit and is an insult to art.
Luis Perez
Do you have the full Hisoka vs Gotoh fight? HxH's paneling is wonderful.
Xavier Gray
>Do you have the full Hisoka vs Gotoh fight?
Yep, enjoy and everyone else ITT.
I really love Togashi's paneling, the characters are contained within panels when there's not much going on, but when a character steals the focus by stating something important or by doing a cool or threatening pose they instantly break free from the panel and they cover a good portion of the page. Just look at Gotoh breaking free several times in this fight and how Hisoka gum thread goes through the entire page in the last part. Beautiful.
Xavier Hall
>Being this retarded
Is fucking showing it like a film reel. I donät even like FP, but it got some god-tier panel technique.
Gabriel Hill
Looks like shit lmao. Somebody get this nigga to artschool.
Carson Cooper
Thanks and based.
Jackson Hughes
>Newbie mangaka manages to make us of master paneling
How does he do it?
Caleb Reed
>has been drawing manga since 2014
>newbie
do some research before spouting nonsense
Gavin Gomez
Based as fuck. Currently re-reading HxH at chapter 66 and I'm having the best time of my life with this manga. Even fucking Zushi using Ren for the first time gave me shivers. Togashi is ridiculously talented at composition and imparting emotion in everything he draws/writes. Let alone his artsy experimental aesthetic that feels unmatched by anyone else. Even his background characters are full of expression and care.
Here's one of my favorites from the first arc. These panels have a great rhythm. "Who would you like to fight the most?" on the right, "Who would you like to fight the least?" on the left. The pages flow naturally without interruptions.
Aaron Diaz
Based
Isaiah Walker
Hate them because they are among the only ones who deliver on topic material? Poor soul
Carson Williams
Elijah Scott
Thanks user, now I'll have to re-read this kino arc
Jordan Hall
>2014
>Not newbie
You are retarded right?
Lucas Allen
>newbie
>noun [ C ]
>informal uk /ˈnjuː.bi/ us /ˈnuː.bi/
>someone who has just started doing an activity, a job, etc.
Drawing manga for at least 5 years is considered newbie to you? fuck off
Wyatt Ortiz
Excellent post! my follow hunterchad. Sad! See, non of those moeshitters have contributed to the thread yet they want to talk about artistic panels.
William Brooks
Ayden King
>Posting the same pages over and over evert thread with the same pastas talking about them
>Contributing
Chase Campbell
There is absolutely no specimen of this website as deluded and as obnoxious as the "hunterchad".
Their delusion knows no bounds, they unironically defend their shonen as if it was in the level of actual literature or something made for the ages, when it couldn't be further from the truth.
The worst part of it is the intellectual dishonesty of the average hiatusfag.
One might tell him that the "loose, deconstructed structure" of the series is nothing when compared to an average Tezuka manga, which was looser and more unorthodox in its events, it all runs off him.
One could tell him that Togashi's famous stream of consciousness walls of text lack Urasawa's conciseness and good writing, he'll pretend to not hear you.
One could tell him that Oda's worldbuilding absolutely destroys Togashi lazy crap of arranging earth continents in a different way and calling it a day, he'll pretend that you're not there.
One might tell him that Peter Greenaway and Junji Ito make way better integration of classic works of art to the dramatic structure, making those parallels a powerful punctuation for the narrative, he'll pretend Togashi is at the same level.
One could tell him there's more nuance in Tezuka's Crime and Punishment, the hiatusfag will feign ignorance on these subjects.
There is no specimen more disgusting and more intellectually dishonest than your average hiatusfag, if you see one in the wild, it is your obligation, I repeat, your obligation, to mock his ignorance of the medium and tell him to go kill himself.
Adrian Roberts
he was being sarcastic you stupid fuckwit
Austin Parker
>kino
Die.
Josiah Sanders
The art is good, the idea is cool but the end result doesn't really flow that nicely.
Nicholas Parker
We hunterchads can turn the tables
Jack Green
The real kino in chainsaw is in all the little breathers Fujimoto gives the story along the way in pages like these
Nathaniel Morris
You can't refute it.
Aaron Williams
Logan Lewis
The OP page from Witch Hat Atelier reminds me of this one, it's not done as good but I still enjoy it.
Dylan Ramirez
This rather reminds me of this beautiful page right here
Michael Richardson
Magus of the Library
Nolan Reyes
ITT: god paneling = everything I like
Liam Murphy
Michael Johnson
>Magus of the Library
Looks like a good combination of Witch Hat Atelier and Otoyomegatari.Thanks, picked up.
Christopher Morris
Finally a good thread to post this collage
Nathaniel Morales
I flows well if you look at it as a loop.
Michael Garcia
None of this is good.
Its a complete clusterfuck on some and in the others you get absolutely no sense of what motions happened.
Charles Lee
This is some high quality manga.
Jordan Walker
poor hunterfags have to suffer through the hiatuses every couple of months.
Don't be so mean with them dude.
Luke King
Based.
Camden Moore
BLAME has some pretty nice art and paneling in the manga.
Ryan Reed
Based
See
Alexander Barnes
What?
Christopher Thomas
sorry, forgot image
Xavier Davis
Sebastian Price
Why does nobody talk about how sloppy HxH looks now
John Allen
Julian Cruz
is literally shit and it still looks better than HXH
Ethan Barnes
Dylan Price
no
Anthony Foster
Joshua Reyes
and only 10% as good but still got a chuckle out of me
Blake Torres
not the best but certainly works
Nolan Adams
Christian Harris
William Turner
Tsugumomo ha pretty amazing paneling in general
Leo Harris
Each time this series is posted on Yea Forums my interest increases a little
Nicholas Ward
what manga
Logan Kelly
OBSERVE
Lincoln Rodriguez
Landon Garcia
Use Yea Forums's built in imagesearch.
Joshua Sullivan
God, I hate how modern western comics look. Its so stiff and virtually all characters look buff and in their 40s.
Samuel Howard
Lincoln Adams
This one is definitely up there.
>tfw making peace with committing a war crime to save your people and your unborn child
Matthew Stewart
Nen shit is honestly completely out of place in Black Clover.
Carson Russell
Easton Moore
>EHcuck
Jackson Nguyen
Nah, just not a speedreader.
Asher Morales
Benjamin Watson
Some mangas have buff characters in their 40s too, although it's true that they're a minority. It seems the western audience generally likes buff characters and the eastern audience generally prefer youthful characters. It doesn't strictly have to do with artistic skills, just which genre will be more popular.
Ayden Gutierrez
I still can't believe a farmer just fucked historia. Just took her cunny and made it his.
Bentley Long
None of the examples posted are better than Watchmen
sad
Jonathan Moore
Whatever you need to tell yourself, user. Just don't hurt yourself when the "Eren is the papa" reveal occurs.
Christian Bell
The ending of the movie is light years better than the ending of the comic.
Nicholas Bailey
A fucking FARMER!
Carson Peterson
if you're a mental midget, sure
Lucas James
>muh psychological talking
Here you go.
Aaron Jones
These threads are always filled with people who don't know what paneling is and just post their favorite manga.
Brody Cox
>speedreading smoothbrain still thinks I care
This is your last (You) from me. Savor it.
Ethan Peterson
>read from left to right
fuck that
Ayden Cooper
we don't deserve chainsaw man
Dylan Sanders
>giant pretend interdimensional psychic tentacle monsters are better than just making the world believe that Dr. Manhattan lost his mind and went rogue
Kek, imagine unironically believing this.
Dominic Cox
the paneling here is extremely simple though. its still a kino moment for sure.
Evan Rivera
>smug anime girl poster
mental midget, will not waste more time with you.
Aaron Miller
everytime one of you autists posts this image I'm left wondering why Togashi included fetish porn in his montage of natural disasters and human evil
John Reyes
>refuting seething shounentards
Wyatt Davis
>literally no arguments
>just ad hominems
Imagine behaving this way and still having the gall to call anyone else a "mental midget." ZERO self-awareness.
Tyler Stewart
Not one ONE page posted?
Jackson Cooper
Eli Carter
There is sometimes elegance in simplicity.
Alexander Green
it's female objectification
Connor Miller
the entire point of the giant squid in watchmen is that it IS completely unbelievable and comes out of nowhere in-universe, meaning that (from Adrian's point of view) no one would ever suspect that it's fake, whereas Manhattan was still viewed as an agent of the US government so any plan to frame him as the villain would just cause other nations to turn against the US out of fear since they created him. It's also meant to be ironic, because Adrian insists that he's not a "republic serial villain" but he has an evil lair and his secret plan to build world peace is essentially a deranged comic book villain plot, making it a subtle bit of characterization that also ties into the themes of deconstruction, something that the average hunterdrone would never notice because the author doesn't handhold and explain everything in giant, repetitive paragraphs.
Jacob Sanders
>and that's a good thing!
Gabriel Taylor
>basic panel structuring
>hunter cucks cream their pants
I dont know if this says more about the average quality of manga or the average iq of the hunter kid.
Christian Long
No. This is like judging japanese comics based entirely on what gets published in jump.
Austin Allen
you fags with a hateboner for hxh are ten times more obnoxious than the average oc producing hunterfag, fuck off or try to make arguments you annoying brat
Grayson Adams
Literally post 1 good looking american comic that came out this year.
Michael Murphy
That's right. It's about her finding that existence in itself is nothing but unending suffering and meaninglessness, probably due to her horrible circumstances. And this was made clear when she mentioned that she found her balance perched atop "the razor's edge", searching for meaning but feeling pain and agony the longer you persist. This reminded me of a very similar quote from Apocalypse Now, as Kurtz describes his dream of being a snail slithering along the edge of a straight razor.
Josiah Scott
I have no idea what you're trying to say "no" to.
Hunter Baker
You clearly havnt spent enough time on this board if you think that. Nice try though.
Wyatt Martinez
Give a few minutes im phone posting in the john
Hunter Evans
1) Veidt spent literal years perfecting the tech to perfectly reproduce Dr. Manhattan's unique, one-of-a-kind energy signature. Kissinger explicitly tells Nixon that the energy signature of the attacks is a perfect match for Dr. Manhattan, and this occurs shortly after DM freaked out violently on live TV in front of millions of viewers. Almost no one in-universe would doubt the cover story without Rorschach's journal surviving and reaching the press.
2) I don't give a fuck about HxH. Never read it, never will.
Kayden Taylor
Post dong
Gabriel Carter
Your myopic view of western comics
Noah Cox
Based. Morena's character introduction made the strongest impression on me out of any manga this decade.
Nathaniel Wood
Not him, but mainstream American comics are a fucking dumpster fire right now.
Henry Foster
So are mainstream Japanese comics.
Nicholas Nguyen
Explain
Dominic Campbell
What's there to explain?
Andrew Cox
How manga suck right now.
Ian Martin
That's not what I said.
Joshua Flores
>It seems the western audience generally likes buff characters and the eastern audience generally prefer youthful characters
Is it this sentence that you want to say "no" to? Have you perhaps misread the word "generally"? It's a sentence about tendencies, there is nothing extremist about it. Or are you willing to claim that you think the tendency is the opposite? That the tendency leans toward very buff muscular characters in japan and effeminate youthful characters in the west?
Noah Brown
Does this seem kino to you?
Tyler Sanders
Here, sorry it took a minute.
Jaxson Hall
This is either bait or hxh really is the most overrated manga
Isaiah Diaz
Cool composition and color but I still hate the realistic facial design.
James Collins
>clarifies as talking in generalities
>can only pose two possibilities
Bit of a wew lad from me. I'm your understanding of western comics is surface level at best. Even a comic with the most buffed out person on the cover, the moment you actually pick it up and read a few pages in you'll realize that the cover does not represent the norm. So like I said, surface level.
Adrian King
Regardless, you asked for 1 and you got 2.
Benjamin Howard
Well I like to read their opinions of why they like the paneling on those particular pages.
Actually, I do enjoy those who state their impressions, better than haters and those who merely post a well-drawn page with >3 panels.
Sebastian Turner
>but I still hate the realistic facial design.
That's just because they're black
Carson Rivera
They aren't even remotely comparable atm.
Parker Bennett
>seething shounentards
So hiatusfags?
Elijah Gonzalez
Aja is an american comic book illustrator but he dies some really neat stuff by putting panels inside of panels.
Noah Stewart
They are, and I feel qualified to say that as someone who follows both Japanese and American comics.
Without fail, anyone who says shit like "American comics are so much worse" just don't know what they are talking about. And think that having a pop culture level knowledge of American comics is even remotely comparable to being a basket weaving forum user level weeb.
Dylan Rodriguez
Yeah now post your comics from decades ago as proof while ignoring the modern ones.
Henry Taylor
Cooper Hughes
Are you srs?
Justin Morgan
Literally post the SNK equivalent of a western comic that's being published right now.
Henry Young
lol
Ethan Nelson
the drawing in the middle isn't pointless, it's showing a pose in time. Gon is thinking before talking, making his word resonate more as an important word for the end of the page.
Parker Torres
A discussion about tendencies is not an assertion of extremist point of views. Nobody in this conversation expressed the opinion "all manga characters are such" or "all western comic book characters are such". I understand that you dislike extremist claims. It is a fine thing to dislike extremist claims. You should be careful that you don't see them where they aren't.
Luke Brown
Bentley Brooks
>SNK equivilent
Now, I say this as a fan of SNK. But do you mean an overrated dark thriller with a fan base that only peeks its head out when hype shit happens? Because if so, then fucking batman is enough.
James Campbell
also the right arm is what leads to the right panel because it has blood fucking dripping on it. Should be so obvious.
Grayson Hernandez
no, wan pissers and narutards.
Joshua Bennett
this is another interesting one, the entire issue has no speech bubbles to show the reader that clint has been deafened and make us struggle to understand the other characters intent just like our main character.
Brayden Stewart
>I understand
No you fucking don't, because I never said anything to even indicate I thought you were talking in terms of extremes. Nice straw man though. At least have the decency to address the actual fucking substance of my post, until then you won't be getting another you.
Jaxson Barnes
You stupid fuck
Hudson Diaz
Nolan Roberts
There is nothing in the US mainstream that is even close to SnK right now. Maybe something on the Indy scene, but certainly nothing in the current Marvel/DC catalog.
Samuel Ward
In terms of what?
Nolan Foster
if you honestly think that Snk isany better than comics like SAGA, locke and key or Chew then i dont know what to tell you.
William Lee
This is high quality bait.
Camden Rivera
This
Andrew Wilson
>SAGA, locke and key or Chew
Who?
Jayden Green
saying only marvel and dc count as mainstream is an unfair comparison since the Japanese equivalent would be shonen jump and snk does not run in that.
it would be more fair to compare to image or darkhorse.
Charles Wood
>muh popularity
Brody Roberts
Hiatusfag
Aiden Mitchell
Thats what I was asking for. A popular, mainstream graphic novel that is not fucking capeshit.
Kayden Collins
Literally baby's first panel-breaking
Hunter Cox
>That's what I was asking for
No it wasn't. In fact you never fucking clarified what you were asking for. Literally all you did was say "like SNK". Did you not realize how fucking vague that is?
Chase Davis
So nice that you actually know to reverse the order you normally view manga in as you follow it.
Carson Turner
>opt and panel threads filled with HxShit spam
Summer is already over, when are they gonna leave anons.
Matthew Powell
These are your words about my post.
>can only pose two possibilities
The word extremism comes from the same root as extremity, the end of something. Offering only two choices is the most literal definition of extremism. I am not attempting any straw man. I am only trying to clear confusion because we seem to agree. I posted where I reminded someone that manga characters can also be buff. You have quoted that post and said no.
Thomas Harris
>all that intricate hatching on arms
>face, hands and clothes completely white
What kind of fucking hack is Togashi really
Thomas Hughes
Only a retard wouldn't be able to decipher what I meant by "like SNK".
Henry Butler
Jason Nelson
>Only a retard wouldn't be able to read my mind
Is what you meant to say, I know because I now know you need people to read your mind in order to understand you.
Leo Adams
They've always been here, tourist
David James
>Tourist
More of a sporadic lurker, so I know for a fact they haven't always been this widespread. They tended to stay in their generals and the shill threads that we obviously filter. Maybe I just got lucky with my timing before?
Samuel Lee
>the more she drank the more she shat
Landon Jackson
>Almost no one in-universe would doubt the cover story without Rorschach's journal surviving and reaching the press.
The point is that an unknown alien entity that comes out of nowhere (which Adrian prepared for by spending years brainwashing New York in advance) makes for a much better unifying scapegoat than Manhattan. And you missed the second explanation for the squid, which is that Ozy is a republic serial villain who doesn't realize that he's a republic serial villain
Jaxon Robinson
He can’t because there isn’t any, they’re lucky to sell 10k.
Eli Collins
>muh popularity
You don't belong in a thread about artistic quality
Caleb Baker
shounenfag
Robert Nelson
Boichi really draws the most giga of chads
Hunter Nguyen
Based.
Evan Rogers
>says this while being a hxhfag
hxh is as shonen as it gets
Owen Turner
not his fault if an artlet such as yourself can't appreciate unconventional shading methods and practices
Zachary Martin
they can probably hide a railgun in their chin alone
Jace Hall
Cooper Rivera
man berserk looks like THAT?
Zachary Johnson
>artlet
Fuck, I'm stealing this
Lincoln Smith
>bad and inconsistent shading
>I-It's just unconventional
You people have been riding this mans dick for over a decade, let that sink in.
Evan Fisher
Seriously, what caused HxHfags to go insane and start shitposting everywhere? It wasn't like this a few months ago, every goddamn thread about any kind of manga has someone shitposting about how HxH is so superior
Robert Ortiz
They didn't get their annual chapter
Brody Miller
Whenever there is a topic used for shitposting everywhere it's never actually fans of the series. It is either a singular dedicated autist who doesn't care about antying or some discord grouop trying to further ruin the quality of the site
Andrew Howard
>unconventional shading methods
The shading is just one of many problems Togashi has as an artist, fucked up anatomy, horrible sense of solid drawing (just look at Hisoka's shirt, the sleeves are all kinds of wrong, card symbols aren't even close to being symmetrically placed) with the cards sort of just existing on a separate 2d plane, shifting from non-shaded white blobs to hugely intricate overcomplicated messes of lines and shapes on a whim.
Togashi was a good artist once upon a time but he's just so unfathomably inconsistent that it's impossible to defend him nowadays
Brandon Parker
>NOOOOO DON’T USE SALES
If the art is so kino it would sell, there are millions of artists that can draw well and detailed.
Austin Young
Jace Garcia
>Y-you can't say that word wtf
Bentley Smith
Based
Togashi is a true master
Liam Peterson
>phoneposting a panel from squirrel girl
I know, but I still like this
Xavier Hall
Based Kenganchad
Oliver Rodriguez
Kaguya sama. Page is a big spoiler though.
Camden Sanders
based
Isaac Adams
It's not an idea that is easy to pull and the execution is pretty good. I only read the "ciao" after reading backward.
Jose Cook
Cameron Anderson
I'm looking forward to this scene being adapted. It's a cool power.
Charles Watson
Tsutomu Nihei's mangas have interesting two-pages layouts.
Brody Roberts
Tsukushi's paneling is usually pretty normal once you get past the somewhat odd style, but it's great for the big action scenes when it really counts
Isaiah Richardson
>entire thread is about paneling
>nobody mentions the girl is looking over the wrong shoulder
You guys disappoint me.
Hudson Sanders
Dominic Jackson
Based, this is the first time I see someone draws a scene INSIDE the sound effect.
Juan Carter
>not even ten posts in
>huntertards already shit up the thread
Is there a more fucking annoying group on Yea Forums? All it takes is one of them to post a retarded psuedo-intellectual paragraph and then a dozen more will pop up to circle jerk.
Aaron Sanders
Wtf is going on here?
Jacob Howard
Ryder Reyes
It's a punch. The sound effect for the punch is ゴン (gon), and the artist drew the various close-ups of the punch inside each stroke of the sound effect
Parker Young
I'm pretty sure its just one person talking to himself.
Dylan Rivera
Easton Anderson
Sauce?
Jacob Scott
Hunterfag at it again
Jaxon Wilson
so like did frieza and cell have a baby and it somehow ended up in hxh or something?
Angel Campbell
ITT: hunterfags derailing a thread yet again.
Angel Anderson
Yes
Adam Stewart
that panel on the bottom right is uncanny valley levels of cringe. idgaf who you are.
Alexander Butler
Chase Barnes
Parker Howard
this honestly made me tear up, Agni deserved better
Parker Lewis
Jaxson Stewart
85% of this thread is about art inside the panel and has nothing to do with the arrangement of panels lol
Benjamin Ortiz
Here’s your ONE posting
Ayden Garcia
Aiden Adams
Noah Young
Ayden King
Gavin Jenkins
Andrew Morales
fuck self flaging discord trannys
Owen Carter
Honestly i think ONE draws bad on purpose
Zachary Fisher
gluttony and lust
Adrian King
it doesn't have to be hyper detailed to be good. This is why Murata's work is inferior
Dylan Roberts
200IQ panelling.
Austin Miller
Fujimoto's art kinda bugs me because his gestures are so bad sometimes. Top right panel as an example. Just ridiculously stiff. Overall I do really like his art though.
Henry Butler
James Lewis
Elijah Rogers
Not that user and I generalle prefer manga but your argument is objectively retarded and redditier.
Owen Moore
SOUL, when the super detailed art fails to surpass this you know the artist is a hack and is missing that special thing.
Jordan Kelly
Ichikawa's paneling is always great
Liam Lee
Late reply but this is embarassing.
When in doubt follow the text and the borders. Obviously the eye will be drawn to the subject of any panel but the bubbles and sfx lead to each other and lend to the overall flow. The splayed fingers act in place of traditional borders and the eye actually follows the arm twice. Once when moving toward the top left panel and again moving down to the following panel thus simulating both him reaching toward the non existent camera (Deku's POV) as well as the movement of his arm extending during the second pass (from his POV). I do agree that popping out of frame is both jarring and unnatural (even moreso when physically flipping to these pages on the physical version) but it aids in expressing his desperation to go so far as to cross panel borders and leap out of frame, grasping, ending up going across multiple pages in his attempt to grab Eri.
And to nitpick some more the "useless rubbish" shows that Deku sees the platform (following up from the preceeding panels) is already weak and crumbling and the additional force of the leaping grab shatters it. In fact it is shown exactly in the proceeding panel where the makeshift platform breaks, so yea the result does "flow here".
I actually agree with the other people in that it flows more natural as a clockwise loop, and if the whole spread was flipped so that it starts from the top right (along with some panels rearranged to compensate for the timeline) and goes counter clockwise that the overall composition would be better off. As it is now it's just normal paneling and flow with somewhat unique application of panel breaking that leads to crossing over the physical gutter/gap of a 2 page spread. Although I will admit the panels of Deku finally catching Eri juxtaposed against his empty hand to show her slipping out of his grasp is quite clever.
I wouldn't expect a shitposting huntard to be able to read a 2 page spread though.
Jace Garcia
When going from right to left it looks better for me. Anyone else?
Isaiah Barnes
Austin Perry
David Brooks
these are spreads not panels
Kayden Powell
man, i want to watch the watchmen comics again
The voice-acting was unique.
Easton Harris
This is actually a very interesting manga.
Bentley Sanchez
holy SHIT lol
Jayden Brooks
that's good shit
Levi Hill
fuck i like this shit
Carter James
is this the guy who did that one hawkeye comic from the dog's perspective or something?
Josiah Hill
i.e., 90% of this thread
Hudson Young
>Hunterchads
Nolan Clark
Nathaniel Lewis
What manner of pseudo-intellectual bullshit did I just read? That panel is a complete clusterfuck plain and simple. The eye is immediately drawn to the masked man and has no idea where to go after that. No sane person would look at the top right first with the masked man taking up half the page. You have to backtrack through the entire page just to figure out what happened and when it happened. The masked man breaking through panels is real fuckin' neato but it's completely obstructive to what is actually happening. There is no logical flow as to where the eye should go on that page.
>the eye actually follows the arm twice
Only because it has no choice but to do so. This is not logical or advantageous in any way and not to mention, this is only your interpretation of where the eye goes. Ask someone else and you'd get a different answer. With actual good panelling, you'd get the same, consistent answer from multiple people (yes, even for 2 page spreads). Not that you'd know anything about good panelling though, seeing as how you called this "normal panelling".
Logan Edwards
Isaac Carter
Jonathan Cruz
the qt cyborgs all died :(
Anthony Lopez
Still the best manga page of the past 6 years.
Joshua Peterson
Do you smoke crack? This is a thread for good paneling and that page is literally just 3 simple panels. There is nothing interesting at all about it visually regardless of the quality of the scene.
Jeremiah Nguyen
>paneling thread
>no adachi
Elijah Bennett
Dylan Garcia
Nathaniel Diaz
one shouldn't conflate unconventional or unique paneling with just "good" paneling
some artists can do both flawlessly like you can see in chainsawman ITT, and very often unique is good, but there's a simple and pure artistry in framing a "scene" correctly that feels underappreciated
Benjamin Hughes
Every time I remember this, I get sad.
Kevin Lewis
Samuel Gonzalez
William Gonzalez
Noah Perez
Bentley Wright
Justin Gutierrez
some artists are just magical
Isaac Ortiz
>laius throwing a lasso as shit goes down south
Nicholas Carter
Prepare for some hot opinions
God Tier:
>Witch Hat Atelier
GreatTier:
>Chainsawman
>HxH
Good tier:
>Dungeon Mesh
>Kengan Ashura Though the scalanters typersetter puts is really good so maybe that warps my view
>One Punch Man (One)
>Naruto
Meh:
>Berserk
>Boku no Hero
>Black Clover
>Houseki no Kuni It's my favourite manga, but the amazing compositions don't make up for the borderline incomprehensible action
Caleb Bell
this is the worst panelling ever, terrible sense of flow
Jaxson Perry
Zachary Taylor
Ryder Gray
Justin Bennett
Blake Hall
Just started reading this, TLs when?
Michael Cook
>but the amazing compositions don't make up for the borderline incomprehensible action
this, action scenes are probably Ichikawa's biggest flaw but with the exception of last chapter I feel she's improved throughout the run of Houseki
Isaiah Moore
forgot pic
Liam Howard
People not getting the chisaki page makes me kinda upset. Seeing as how they make up some elaborate explanation to how it shit or is supposed be viewed while the answer is extremely simple.
Liam Evans
Adrian Cox
Love this page
Thomas Sullivan
Clovercucks are retarded
Josiah Richardson
how do you read it then?
Gabriel Flores
shit adaptation of a shit isekai but this page is really cool
Daniel Jenkins
Never read that but that panel is fantastic.
Josiah Howard
Bentley Lewis
@192986114
cringed
Ayden Edwards
This manga doesn't really hesitate to kill characters it seems.
Connor Murphy
Jayden Bailey
this isn't OPT, stop posting spreads
Daniel Diaz
Spreads can be kino
Nolan Bennett
but they arent panels
Mason Gray
Not him but
Isaac Parker
It's not godlike or anything but I like how it looks
James Gonzalez
Man this would be so much more kino if Tatara's coat was actually ripped like the hair-transition makes it look like
Cooper Scott
>it's messy and chaotic
that's the point
Jonathan Powell
the ones that are just one panel for a whole page, not the spreads with actual panelling
Noah Jackson
A spread is just a big panel deal w/it
Levi Sanders
man
I remember reading this
I remember when tg was actually good
Nathaniel Price
Noah Flores
Owen James
Creative paneling in a 4koma of all things.
Carter Garcia
how is that good panelling though? just one panel might have good art or a good plot impact or whatever, but that doesn't make it have good panelling
Joshua Gutierrez
kino
Josiah Ward
Didn't know Grrm did manga, so that's what delaying his fucking book.
Brandon Bailey
posting Mignola is cheating he is the cream of the crop
John Powell
The kakin game of thrones and this edgy bitch are so fucking unimportant holy shit, can't wait until this fucking whale hits a fucking iceberg and kills 90% of the fuckers inside it.
Dylan White
Not paneling.
Hudson Lopez
>normal paneling
Kayden Hughes
I don’t know why this fight has ONE’s best panelling. Probably because it doesn’t speed by as much as the rest of the comic.
He’s got pretty good comedic panelling tho
>the entire King vs Apple segment
>Saitama closing the door on Flashy Flash
Murata’s also pretty good, but it doesn’t stand out with his art taking the spotlight. I just hope ”You can never defeat me” remains basically unchanged.
Juan Sullivan
Here’s my favorites from the newest chapter. Pretty good, not outstanding.
Juan Powell
>being unable to distinguish between unique paneling and effective paneling
die
Anthony Rivera
Jose Powell
ITT: Spreads, 3-panels and the same shounenshit posted as per usual
Hunter Taylor
>The eye is immediately drawn to the masked man
Yes that is the most eye catching part.
>have to backtrack through the entire page
>There is no logical flow as to where the eye should go
In a 2 page spread where space is at a premium any bubbles or kana are placed so that they also will lead the eye toward the next panel. Along with the borders that are not obstructed by the villain you can make out what the author intended. The pink lines aren't highlighting the flow that your eye naturally follows instead they show the progression of text you will end up reading and subsequently the chronological order of the panels. I do agree it is not very logical and clashes with the visuals.
>this is only your interpretation of where
There's no other order to read these 7 panels without the events being out of order.
>called this "normal panelling"
It is the bread and butter basics. In the intended reading order you don't cross any T's and the bubbles/kana all lead to the next panel, even if the actual art doesn't. Sure the mangaka sacrificied the visual integrity of the entire spread with a broken flow but the paneling itself is a pretty normal layout. I don't see anyone in this thread saying that the spread is anything but bad execution. Maybe if you reread the post you would see that I mostly agree with the hxh poster but his analysis of the page was what I had issues with.
Hudson Perry
Itoh sei does some interesting stuff
Dylan Butler
Maybe not the best flow but it feels very dynamic
Gavin Bailey
Thomas Richardson
Jace James
Grayson Myers
Its because the eye naturally goes to the bigger shapes first, then the smaller ones. The author is using that to his advantage
Wyatt Smith
simple but effective, i like it
Sebastian Smith
actual kino, shame that ishida lost his edgy style halfway through :re
Isaac Barnes
No, you are just a contrarian.
Thomas Miller
Adam Jackson
Not the best example but this manga has some extraordinary panelling.
Henry Nguyen
My King~
Anthony King
Is way fucking better done than
Jacob Foster
That’s not paneling.
Oliver Hall
only good ones
Jace Sanchez
innocent is really fucking pretty but I'd say it's better in the two page single panel spreads or just really well executed standard boxes than anything that stands out as being exotic in terms of panelling