Attached: 3x3.jpg (786x788, 253K)
3x3 Thread
Connor Carter
Other urls found in this thread:
youtu.be
mega.nz
twitter.com
Nathaniel Brooks
Dylan Taylor
Those never reflect someone's tastes but are pretty much a compilation of MAL / ANN top 20 anime of all time.
If I made one it would be very similar, but not due to myself having "good tastes" but due to how few anime I've watched and how narrow my view of the medium is.
Christian Rodriguez
>reddit spacing
>doubting the genuine intentions of other users just cause
>newfag
Checks out
Nolan Green
if you don't want to participate then don't post, faggot.
Jeremiah Ramirez
Oh, and forgot to add, these threads lack any purpose besides people patting each other in the back.
It's no different to posting "my favorite _____" on Facebook and waiting for the likes.
Alexander Kelly
9/9 but Liar Game's ending was shit.
Ayden Brown
1/2
Get rid of the western trash.
Evan Peterson
>Get rid of the western trash.
ok
Isaac Campbell
4/5 +Tatami, Mushishi, ghost, LotGH -Utena
3/4 +Kaiji, Hyouka, GLT -Note
4/5 +LotGH, Eva, Millenium, Haruhi -Castle in the sky
5/5 +K-ON!, Haruhi, NHK, F/Z, S;G
Justin Kelly
Well played.
Luis Fisher
There's a few different types: the "I've seen 9 anime" trash grids, the "I have no opinions and I must fit in" trash grids, the "I want attention" trash grids, and the grids people make that actually reflect their taste. The thing is, the first 3 types tend to stick around whereas the 4th type posts their grid once and disappears.
Luke Watson
Explain the two most recently posted grids. They clearly don't belong to either of the 3 groups you've chosen to ridicule.
Michael Gomez
>the "I've seen 9 anime" trash grids,
Josiah Baker
Anime_Emperor is a certified anime expert who has seen 250+ shows. Sounds like you're dissatisfied with your own taste, hence you accuse everybody else to be disingenuous about their picks.
Tyler Hall
I know you're probably serious but can't help but think of
>here's my ebin 3x3.jpg
+++Liar game
+GochiUsa
-DN your enjoyment of chess games is now under intense suspicion
+Visual Novels
+Anime
+The Mirror
+C&C
-Watchmen
Good middle-brow taste
Bastard child
Public meme-spouter
Jonathan Clark
7/7 boring
anime 2/6 -Hyouka, Death Note, Joker Game, Usagi Desuka manga 1/2 seinenfag
anime 5/5 quality grid
2/8 your parents must be disappointed
5.5/8 -Yugioh, LWA ~Trigun, you should replace the kizu image
Juan Cooper
7/7 nostalgic discernment as a 3x3
Parker Roberts
To be completely honest I don't think I've seen enough actually great anime to make a list but I've been watching through some I see here a lot
1/1
2/2
1/1
Watching Sora no Woto right now. Great so far. Also, Pain and Gain is based
3/4 -Love Live
3/3
2/2
Andrew Ward
probably will make a huge grid of "favorites by decade" sometime soon since 2020 is approaching but way too lazy currently.
5/8 I dunno which panpanya book that is but great to see their work featured
3/5 TV
7/7 Movies
moomin, milky holmes, and of course doremi are greatly appreciated~
2/8 you come off as a very delusional and annoying person
4/7
3/5
5/9 genuinely happy to see doremi popping up more now
7/9
Kayden Allen
+porco, +gits, scooter girl
liar game, angels egg, kaji, crab
nice
+nhk, haruhi
++lwa
+kyosogiga, +++effort
not really my cup of tea
++gunbuster, +nhk, +flcl, flippers great taste
Ryder Ramirez
and my manga 3x3
++pdrum, datanimestudioanime
Anthony Kelly
>you come off as a very delusional and annoying person
What makes you think that? is it my 3x3?
Justin Sanders
lol t. tripfag
Brandon Nelson
Kys Twitter Mal tranny
Lincoln Bailey
7/9 nice
You're falling for Yea Forums's bullshit if you think you need a high powerlevel to post in these threads
7/8 what's middle left?
3/8
Dylan Sanchez
>You're falling for Yea Forums's bullshit if you think you need a high powerlevel to post in these threads
You need to have seen [amount of anime you've seen + 500] before posting.
Bentley Powell
Most boring taste in anime is actually solid
4.5/7 ~Ashizuru, SSR, Chino's anime, Note, Egg
12/17 for anime and manga
2/6
4/6
3/5
6/6 +Alien9
6.5/8 ~Short night -Garbagebuster
I basically like Remi and that's about it
3.5/6 ~Dragon Maid -Agretsuko might be the worst anime I ever watched, Gunbuster
5/6 -Freesia
7/7 +Koji Yamamura
Leo Sanchez
troll grid but still solid
nice taste in both shows and movies, though I really do not care for sora no woto and escaflowne. you must really like moomin
all hail the emperor
average at best, but you got to appreciate the honesty
so in which type do I fall into?
points for the effort. mixed feelings on the show. not sure what actual taste is supposed to mean
I like this one
most of these are good, but if you take your taste from here you are bound to end up with a boring and unoriginal grid
good one, but fuck penguindrum
see above
not sure what I think of this, but I've only seen half of these. what's bottom right?
I only recognize lain and big o. I must say I kinda hate this kind of grids.
Adrian Cook
All of those are not good. Yes, that includes Tomorrow's Joe.
Never read Kaiji but Akagi was a rollercoaster. I learned mahjong so I could follow the games and it was worth it.
17 year old who masturbates too much.
Didn't like Dorohedoro. HxH was bad.
I'm on the fence about Blame because the beginning was very bad, but the last 3rd was great.
Berserk was good if you read Golden Age until Guts leaves Griffith and then pretend there's nothing else. I didn't like the Eclipse. Tower of Conviction was alright but only because Mozgus and his crew are ebin. Falcon of Millennium was bad and I didn't bother reading any of Fantasia.
Christopher Reyes
>not sure what I think of this, but I've only seen half of these. what's bottom right?
It's Yuureisen by Ofuji Noburou
Kevin Reed
>7/8 what's middle left?
not them and i havent seen it but that looks like jewelpet
Caleb Parker
thanks
is there a torrent for Malay Oki Kaisen?
can't seem to find it anywhere
Jackson Torres
>stainless night
classic
William Scott
>I must say I kinda hate this kind of grids.
Pretty sure the only thing this grid ever managed to achieve is that it fucked with people real good, so it was worth making in the end.
Gotta put some more work into this one.
Made my peepee really hard.
Henry Sanders
I'm not aware of a torrent, but you can find it on YouTube
Angel Gray
>17 year old who masturbates too much.
Well you're half right
Ryan Butler
Reminder that i met Bear in college and he was a manlet but also a cool guy.
Daniel Bennett
This is some whack-ass garbage tastes in manga LMAO
Robert Myers
I can't though :(
Oh well
Camden Howard
NPC
LowQ
Lives off pension
Started watching anime recently
Pseud
Homosexual who really loves to suck cock
Jerks off 5 times a day
Tyler Carter
/656006 on new Nya, there is a lot of shit though.
Thanks for the (You)s and all, but why don't I get a mean message? Am I all of the above, perhaps?
Asher Clark
Brandon Brown
You know, all memes aside, I feel sorry for anyone whose taste somewhat resembles this, since
they'll never be able to be taken seriously. I'm sure you could find some common links between everything listed there if you really tried.
Tbf, the threads are best when people have to actually defend their tastes.
3/4 anime
-OG Yamato
3/3 anime movie
4/4 movie
3/3 games
1/1 books
One of these days, I'll make a big list like this, but I don't feel as though I'm quite at that stage yet.
4/4
2/2
4/4
The Book of The Dead was technically impressive and enjoyable, but I can't see why anyone would consider it a favourite personally.
2/2
David Walker
>
>
>
What? What?? I have to know.
Wyatt Thomas
I too have seen “The most boring taste in anime“ by Digibro. Did you think I wasn't autistic enough to instantly recognize that?
Juan Brooks
Noticed that too. This guy thinks he's slick.
Josiah Hughes
4/7 +tatami, porco, yokohama; ~mushishi, gits; -logh, anne
3.5/5 +hyouka, angel's egg; ~last tour, gochiusa, death note
7/11 +laputa, evangelion, actress, bloodlust, kaguya, kiki; ~999, haruhi; -monster, so ra no wo to, escaflowne
4/6 +k-on, nhk, steins; ~haruhi, watamote; -fate
5/8 +flcl, steins, k-on; ~kizumono, little witch, trigun, last tour; -fate
1.5/4 +azumanga; ~kyousougiga; -rahxephone, escaflowne
3.5/4 +azumanga, alien 9, yokohama; ~zetsubou-sensei
9/9 +
2/2 +k-on, night is short
1.5/3 +gunbuster; ~dmc; -dragon maid
1.5/5 ~country doctor, book of the dead, ghost ship; -madoka, malay sea
3.5/5 +lain, whisper of the heart, robot carnival; ~barefoot gen; -read or die
0.5/2 ~sailor moon; -lupin iii
3.5/5 +texhnolyze, patlabor 2; ~gauche, gankutsuou, jinrui
4.5/6 +evangelion, tsuioku-hen, robot carnival, galactic railroad; ~gunsmith cats; -logh
Dylan Bennett
3/7
5/7
4/9
6/9
4/6
6/8
5/5
4/6
1/2
5/5
8/8
Ryder King
I don't really like any of these much except for
Jack Cox
Rewatching Anne right now and it's as fucking terrible as I remember it being. Dropping this garbage soon.
Chino a shit.
>double Moomin
Seems a bit overkill. Hope you're at least Finnish or Swedish.
4.5/8 ~CCS -Yamato, Harlock, Doremi; will like never watch Monster
6.5/9 ~Hijo de Puta -Haruhi, Milk
2/9 +KON ~Love Live, FZ season 1
4/9 +FLCL, KON, LWA ~FZ season 1, Kizu 1; the first movie was extremely obnoxious compared to the other two - jump cut after jump cut, headache inducing
Pretty impressive it fits the filesize limitations, but I guess there's virtually no animation so...
4/9 +Eva knockoff, Eva knockoff 2, Giga ~Figure17, Kaleido
2/9 +YYK, Alien9; consider me unamused
7/9 -Goonbuster, NHK; how do people do it? I hated Yuasa when I started watching anime
7/9 -Kikepets, Doremi
2/9 +Penguindrum ~Sakura Quest, Maid
6/9 -all the yuri shit, especially the cartoon with the evolved strap-on; and no, before you go there: the Ichigos aren't homosexuals. They are pure.
Do you change this grid every day? The hell is mid left? Inb4 the only Gundam I haven't see, aka Victory Gundam.
3.5/4 +Nausicaa, Zamurai, Fishpeople ~Yotsuba
6.5/7 +Gauche, Tex, Gonzo's only good show, Shimashita, Pooplabor2, Midori ~Giant Robo; no clue what the other two are. Probably Sabre Alter honhonhon
>The Book of The Dead was technically impressive
The more western stop motion I watch, the less I agree with this. My appreciation for the film has plummeted over the course of the past 12 or so months. The Japanese are pretty fucking bad at anything but 2D, not gonna lie.
5.5/9 ~Cats -Onireeee, RoV, UtenaTV
6/9 -Karekano, Omoide, 3gatsu
4.5/9 +FLCL, TTGL, Aria, Cosette ~Liz; double Eupho, pretty terrible not gonna lie
Aaron Diaz
still a great take on 3x3s although I feel like the meta has shifted
Ian Rogers
>~gunsmith cats; -logh
But I don't have LOGH on my chart.
Ethan Cook
>Midori
Actually, it's from that Winter Days short isn't it? Forgive my poorly developed brain.
Grayson Moore
How's the current meta?
Andrew Miller
>Inb4 the only Gundam I haven't see, aka Victory Gundam
It's actually G Gundam. Maybe you only watched UC stuff. Check out victory gundam, it's pretty good.
Brandon Price
gotta agree on book of the dead
Jonathan Morales
probably more moe shit and less 80s stuff
Blake Parker
>new Nya
call me a newfag but I have no idea what that means
Lincoln Robinson
Nah, but I dropped G Gundam somewhat early because I hated it. I've seen most of AU as well. Only stuff I haven't bothered with are the GBF sequels, some of the CG OVAs, Victory Gundam and of course summary movies, specials etc. Don't even know why I finished shitty shows like Afterwar X, or most older Gundam, really.
Elijah Cox
Seems like that's the only thing about Yea Forums that has improved :^)
Jayden Fisher
If you make the middle image smaller, it will resemble a hakenkreuz.
Chase Rivera
>Don't even know why I finished shitty shows like Afterwar X
Because of your cute daughter Tiffa obviously.
Leo Baker
>unrecgonisable moeshit
would be a good amendment to the bingo 3x3
Easton Walker
More likely for Witz and Roy to have been the reason. Their little vacation was probably the only part I genuinely enjoyed. Tifa and Jamil were almost too autistic for me to swallow.
Levi Peterson
>Anne of Green Gables
Are you fucking with me OP
Andrew Campbell
Read the thread. He is fucking with you.
Christopher Wood
Your 3x3 is sooo boring OP
Jaxson Campbell
I like comfy shit
Camden Thompson
I came across another autistic girl who likes to paint in a show I'm currently watching, what do you think of her?
Also, do you know where the Hesse quote in this from episode 2/3 comes from? Google was no help so I assume it might be one of his works not in English.
Gavin Powell
Is the tile in the center supposed to be your favourite?
Evan Perez
No, the whole chart is your favourite
Nicholas Mitchell
It's in any order you want.
I put my favourite in the top left.
Carter Allen
5/7
Much better than that guy's "actual" 3x3.
2/4
Manga: 2/4
Anime: 6/7
0/5
3/8
2/3 (for the "real taste")
Characters: 4/6
Anime: 4/6
5/8
>I've been watching through some I see here a lot
That shows. You really should be watching things you DON'T see here a lot.
4/7
3/5
1/3
2/3
6/7
3/4
1/1
4/5
2/5
2/6
3/4
>I don't really like any of these much
Please rate anyway.
5/7
2/6
Much worse than that guy's "meme" 3x3. And just as boring/entrylevel/meme-worthy.
0/2
>I like comfy shit
I like when you rate others.
Sebastian King
All I am gonna say is that Helga is pure. It's not her fault. Everything else would spoil the show.
>Hesse
It's "Irgendwo". Short poem of his
>Durch des Lebens Wüste irr ich glühend Und erstöhne unter meiner Last, Aber irgendwo, vergessen fast, Weiß ich schattige Gärten, kühl und blühend. Aber irgendwo in Traumesferne Weiß ich warten eine Ruhestatt, Wo die Seele wieder Heimat hat, Weiß ich Schlummer warten, Nacht und Sterne.
It's gonna make more sense to once you've reached the midpoint of the show. That's when various plot-elements are being revealed to the viewer. Or rather, they are confirmed to match what the viewer likely anticipated.
Gabriel Flores
... and manga
>Is the tile in the center supposed to be your favourite?
Not necessarily. But often. It's the one that stands out the most, thus many people naturally put their favourite there. It's a sensible thing to do.
The other two panels that stand out (a bit less than the center though) are top-left and top-center.
In my case, my anime 3x3 has my favourite in the center, my manga grid has my favourite in the top-center position.
Jose Adams
Much appreciated. I'm in the flashback part right now.
>Or rather, they are confirmed to match what the viewer likely anticipated.
I wasn't sure what to think with how much information it hands you right off the bat, there's pretty much everything you need to figure out the Befort kids' general circumstances as early as episode 2.
James Lee
Too much modern rubbish in here.
Luke Phillips
I wasn't much of a fan myself until the second half finally started to connect all the plot strings. Though I am a sucker for anything Nakamura has touched, so that probably doesn't say much. The limited animation is a bit of a bummer, though. Okiura is a fucking faggot for not having worked on it.
Kevin Anderson
What does '~' mean?
Average?
Nathaniel Gomez
It means ~
Ian Ortiz
3/3
7/7
We share a similar taste in anime
4/6
1/2
2/8, too boring
You should watch more anime
I should watch more anime
3/3
3/5
1/2
I enjoyed OPM as a manga more than an anime
William Thomas
Forgot to add my 3x3
Grayson Collins
>I enjoyed OPM as a manga more than an anime
So did I. But I do find that it is a very strong adaptation. That being said, it's at the bottom of my top-9 and thus the next to go once I find something I like more.
There's actually a good chance Zombie Land Saga will replace it if its second season delivers!
Tyler Roberts
is season two worth watching? heard mixed opinions
Dylan Brooks
It's not as good as season 1, but also not as bad as shitposters pretend it is. The main criticism is the animation qulality, compared to season 1, and it is valid, but season 2 had less of a budget and less ideal conditions. And it's not as if season 1 was perfect; it doesn't compare to the manga.
I'd say it's worth watching, if only to see those parts of the manga animated, but you'll have to decide that for yourself.
Henry Parker
I know people will say that this is basic taste but i've seen over 400 Anime and these are still the ones i like the most. Don't need to look cool here.
Good taste sir. Mushishi made me almost in my Manga list
Liar Game and Kaiji are great. I lost interest in Liar Game after a while though. Still a good list and balanced taste.
I like your Manga list. Also balanced taste, minus points for Berserk.
The Yugioh movie was meh. K-On, Monogatari, Trigun are good - Steins Gate and Fate Zero(?) not so much. Its okay.
This is one of the best so far. Your taste is diverse and overall good picks.
A bit too much girly stuff but i like K-On, Shrobako ofc. If the middle one, bottom row is Heidi, then thats also a plus.
I can't hate on anyone that puts School Rumble and Gunbuster in his list.
9/10 taste.
This one is really good. Heidi, Zeta, Lupin, HnK. Elite tier stuff
Summit of the gods almost made it
into my 3x3. Children of The Sea, Jojolion, Yotsuba+++ This is like 10/10 taste. I should read more Taniguchi.
7/8
Diverse taste and Slam Dunk is my favourite Manga and K-On my favourite Anime, so i can forgive your for this one show in the bottom row i forgot the name of and i dropped after one episode.
Thomas Cox
This is my Manga 3x3. Kinda had a hard time making this but i just went with what i had the most personal attachment to. So Manga like Phoenix, Summit of the Gods, Ito or Kakukaku Shikajika didn't make the cut.
Nathaniel Gutierrez
Plebian filters, or those anime that immediately skim Art Connoisseurs from ignorant peasants with shallow taste and poor sensitivity.
Good taste OP
Jordan Lopez
it can't be helped
Alexander Taylor
Jayden Sanchez
Guess what, a random-picks-grid! 9 random grids, one random panel each.
I'm not including and for obvious reasons.
Raw data:
>192739338+(3), 192754651+(7), 192746938+(8), 192746042+(8), 192747198+(2), 192742721+(1), 192752189+(6), 192754839+(2), 192748792+(6)
Archive:
>mega.nz
I could include one of these 2. Which one are your actual favourites, if any?
Fun fact: Hesse wasn't actually Hessian, but Goethe was.
Adrian Wilson
5/6
Never liked "Baikingu Bikke".
(There wasn't even any biking in there, if I recall correctly!)
Also, please rate others.
2/6
5/7
4/6
4/5
4/7
4/7
Jason Sullivan
Whenever people agree with my 3x3 I always feel I must have shit taste.
Landon Morgan
Why?
Joseph Flores
Because everyone in these threads except me are stupid
Joseph King
>everyone are stupid
IS, user. Everyone IS stupid.
Are you sure you aren't?
Benjamin King
Heh, you've fallen for my trap. I was merely pretending to be ESL. Only a low IQ dumbo would point out obvious grammar mistakes. English is a language that places emphasis on meaning and feeling over mechanical precision.
Brayden Taylor
>English is a language that places emphasis on meaning and feeling over mechanical precision.
Well, if you say so. (It doesn't, but who cares?)
Let's talk 3x3 instead. Which one even is yours?
Owen Sullivan
I don't have one. I just like to post in these threads.
Easton Allen
Why did you write
>Whenever people agree with my 3x3 I always feel I must have shit taste.
then? Surely, that line implies that you do have a 3x3.
Nathaniel Powell
Oh, I didn't write that. I was just replying to someone else.
Kevin Powell
>English is a language that places emphasis on meaning and feeling over mechanical precision.
Are there any languages (besides Lojban) that are not like that?
Samuel Baker
>being so smug over such entry level taste
Liam Campbell
If you count Latin then yeah, but it's probably the only example I can think of.
Zachary Perry
Ancient Greek is much worse than Latin when it comes to "grammatical exactness". But both are far more flexible and elegant than English.
If you want a horribly static and rigid language, well, there's French.
Logan Bennett
-Mushishi, Joe, LOGH, Porco
--Fate, Steins, Monogatari, LWA, GLT, Trigun
-K-On
--Azumanga
-Hidamari, Boogiepop, SZS
--NHK, Flip Flappers, Gunbuster
-Hyouka, Night is Short
--Shirobako, Precure
-Night is Short, Penguindrum, K-On
--Madoka, Marimite, Ichigo
-Joe
--FOTN, Zeta
-SM, Lupin
-Jiro, Jojo
--Katanagatari, Gunsmith
-LOGH
--3gatsu, In This Corner
-Kiki, K-On
--Redline
-Nichijou
--In This Corner
-Leiji
--Shirobako, Chuu2, Champloo
-Perfect Blue, K-On, Laputa
-Metropolis, Honneamise, Lupin
Nathaniel Smith
Nicholas Perez
Its not Chuunibyou, you pretentious fuck
Cameron Wilson
cute
Hunter Murphy
Update:
>192739338+(3), 192754651+(7), 192759566+(8), 192746042+(8), 192747198+(2), 192742721+(1), 192752189+(6), 192754839+(2), 192748792+(6)
William Edwards
w i d e
Caleb Ross
Elijah James
my grid is cuter and funnier
Brayden Wilson
What are top left, bottom left and center?
Nathan Kelly
Damn dude even I've heard of Milky Holmes
Hudson Sullivan
I recognize the name but I never really knew what it looked like
Adam Harris
ojamajo doremi, tantei oper milky holmes, boku no pico
Jacob Hill
What a boring taste
Andrew Davis
>-Leiji
Still not Leiji ye dumb fuqq
5/8 +Wanwa, Cloud, Wonder ~Iblard, Cyclone, Ghost, Mitsumeru -Thunder
Imagine unironically picking THE WORST Murata short. Even Wolf in Snowy forest is superior to this. Shayou is so bad it's not even available anywhere. Imagine that!
Anthony Jones
I’ve been thinking of doing a 4x4 for these threads, just to include other shows that I like a lot and a few films
Is this the 3x3 Digibro mentioned in his video about 3x3 collages?
Excellent anime and anime movie choices
Not a fan of your chart, 2/9. You might like Aria
Lots of comfy anime and Monogatari! Nice. You might like Noein.
Based Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou, really relaxing OVAs. But yeah it pales in comparison to the manga. Also great Boogiepop
+NHK, Gunbuster, Bebop, FLCL, Lain and Yuasa.
Mawaru Penguindrum is as based as always
They really did an anime adaptation of Blacked huh
I’m going to guess there’s Princess Mononoke and Lain
>RETRO ALWAYS WINS!
>Utena
>Evangelion
The ultimate heavenly combination
>Mind Game
Best anime movie of all time right here
Yours is also not very interesting and could be Digibro’s chart
Brilliant image choices for Baccano and Haruhi
>Chihiro
No
The rest, yes
Very solid picks
>LWA
>Kill la Kill
>Cowboy Bebop
>Samurai Champloo
>Tatami Galaxy
That’s a BEST ITT award
Tyler Anderson
>I’ve been thinking of doing a 4x4 for these threads
Don't
They are annoying and given your taste it would probably be filled with other uninteresting picks
Isaac Sanchez
rikafag please stop posting your shit here
Blake Hughes
What is top right?
Parker Reed
>no clue what the other two are
I doubt anybody will be able to recognize these, so I will give away the names — it's Interstella and Bio Hunter.
I like Midori way more, so let's pretend it is.
On .si domain, I bet it on Pantsu too.
>Princess Mononoke
No, and I need to rewatch that movie. Middle is Whisper of the Heart.
Parker Sullivan
>Bio Hunter
Top meme.
Jose Reed
Hey Kenji you are a faggot
Dominic Wilson
6/8
3/3
6/7
3/6
6/6
5/7
William Foster
Zachary Reyes
top middle? 3/5
Jaxson Baker
Birth
Carson Hall
1/1
Characters: 7/7
Anime/manga: 5/6
Still 4/7
1/4
Please rate others.
3/4
Please rate others.
5/7
4/4
3/7
Please rate others.
Charles Hill
Dominic Hall
6/9 Lots of fun shows.
4/9
3/9
I'm on the same boat as you bud 7/9
5/9
6/9
Bottom right and top left shows?
4/9
2/9
6/9
2/9
4/9
Julian Green
Leo Bennett
Something about that screencap is wrong. It feels very wrong. I stared at it for a while and couldn't quite place it, then I just tried to copy the pose with my own hand. And it's actually pretty obvious where the error is: The thumb!
The thumb could never comfortably bend in an angle that would allow the viewer to see it head-on. It would naturally bend upwards instead and be viewable from the side.
What the screencap shows would only be possible if the thumb is broken are forcefully put into that position. Anyway, I tried to redline it.
Anthony Edwards
Are you, by chance, autistic?
Ian Mitchell
In the Yea Forums sense, yes, clearly. Not according to the medical definition.
That means that I'm just very pedantic. And in this case, well, I think I know a bit too much about anatomy for my own good. But I think those 10 minutes it took me were well wasted.
Wyatt Lopez
>What the screencap shows would only be possible if the thumb is broken are forcefully put into that position.
or if you lowered your middle, ring and pinkie fingers
Henry Ramirez
>or if you lowered your middle, ring and pinkie fingers
No. It's about the thumb. It's bent in a nearly 90-degree-angle directly at its root and turned to face the viewer (upper side with the nail fully visible). You can put your thumb in that position, but no matter what the other fingers do, it will feel uncomfortable and thus not be a natural resting pose for it.
I admit that it's not a huge anatomical error, but it did seem strange to me.
Aiden Garcia
what made you pick Niea over any other slice of life or ABe?
Zachary Gray
my thumb finds the depicted position rather comfortable, but I'm also left handed and find doing the same with my right hand difficult. perhaps you just have a poorly acclimated left thumb?
James Williams
Literally who?
Jeremiah Hernandez
No, it's the same for both hands for me. Maybe we have different definitions of "comfortable"? Or maybe you're not turning your thumb towards yourself hard enough? To replicate that pose, it can't even have the sligtest angle when you view your hand going up straight.
Trying without any definitions of comfort: In the end, it does come down to what position it would naturally be in when you try to do a pose like this, and that would be taking the path of least resistance.
Noah Kelly
Update:
>192739338+(3), 192754651+(7), 192759566+(8), 192746042+(8), 192747198+(2), 192777970+(2), 192752189+(6), 192754839+(2), 192748792+(6)
Juan Anderson
more reasonably, everything about that hand gesture is uncomfortable to a certain degree. keeping your index finger perfectly straight like that takes a conscious effort, so one can assume that they aren't following the path of least resistance. the gesture is strained and over exaggerated. being that you admitted to its anatomical possibility, I think this is a very necessary point to address before considering comfort.
Asher Jenkins
I like how the bottom middle, bottom right, middle left and middle right (sort of) tiles all include characters which are facing the center.
Cameron Brown
>everything about that hand gesture is uncomfortable to a certain degree
It is. And it isn't the natural position for any of the fingers. That can be excused for the index finger more easily though, as stretching it seems to be the main goal of that pose.
The thumb is more critical because its position puts a lot of strain on the abductor/extensor pollicis brevis.
Funnily, looking for that exact scene, I've found another Lupin scene that does the same pose more correctly, but totally fucks up the length and perspective of the index fingers.
I also feel I have to note that those are all very minor issues that would have gone unnoticed in the few seconds they can be seen on-screen. Examining those things in detail on a still is quite unfair towards the artists.
Ethan Fisher
Yea Forums - Anatomy & Hand Gestures
Samuel Phillips
in conclusion, animators do a very good job, but occasionally make small anatomical errors which can be overlooked due to their irrelevance.
Anthony Taylor
Yes. But being pedantic is fun!
Cameron Johnson
6/12
I'm not sure whether you know how the ratings in here work.
5/9
Please rate others.
4/8