2010s

>bunny girl senpai that high
Why do asians like self-insert shit so much?

Kill yourself for two years before posting.

>butthurt isekaifag
how does it feel knowing your genre will die within the next 2 years from oversaturation

There is not a single good anime on this list.

>Shitgatsu
>Anohana
>Bunny Girl
>Slime
>VEG
>Reddit Zero
Jesus Christ, worse taste than Yea Forums.

No, the new art style is cringe, the 2000-2010 period was much better.

Very poor showcase. But what else can you expect from a bunch of thieves?!

>2010
Heartcatch Precure, Saraiya Goyou, Katanagatari, Star Driver; Film: Colorful - runnerup(s): Mai Mai Miracle, Midori-ko, Cheburashka, Omae Umasou - short: Yubi wo Nusunda Onna
>2011
Idolm@ster, Hyouge Mono, Penguindrum; Film: Letter to Momo - runnerup: Sayonara no Tsubasa - short: 663114
>2012
2199, Shimashita; Film: Wolf Children - runnerup Niijiro Hotaru - short: Hi no Youjin; special award for trying: Natsuiro no Kiseki; Mine Fujiko
>2013
Uchouten; Film: Kaguya-hime - short: Shashinkan; "GREAT, but not Takashi Nakumra Level" award: Umi ni Ochita Tsuki no Hanashi, Golden Time, Kick Heart
>2014
Yama no Susume 2, Ping Pong, Zoku Shou 2; Film: Marnie - short: Wonder, 00:08; special "NICE RIDE" award: Cross Ange; special " Thank you Yasuda Akira" award: G no Reconguista
>2015
Fafner Exodus, Go! Princess Precure; Film: Sarusuberi - runnerup: GuP der Film; "Best Girls" award: Rakudai Kishi no Eiyuutan
>2016
Rakugo, Flip Flappers, Occultic9; Film: Kono Sekai - short: Shogi; "Not even Animation" award: Thunderbolt Fantasy
>2017
Tsuki ga Kirei, Houseki no Kuni, (Uchouten 2 & Rakugo 2) - special "disappointment" award: ACCA-13 - special "comfy" awrd: Emiya-san; Film: Otome - short: Matsugae wo Musubi
>2018
Revue Starlight, Hisone to Maso-tan, Happy Sugar Life; Film: Mirai - runnerup: Wakaokami, Maquia, Hi-Evo Anemone; short: Invisible Man, Bai Niao Gu
>2019
Rilakkuma to Kaoru-san; Film: no clue - short: error

TVOD: IM@S
MOD: Kono Sekai
SOD: Wonder

>post garbage
Aren't you the contrarian tho?

>implying

Attached: 1481634352401.webm (1280x720, 1.73M)

You forgot
>AoT
>Dragon maid
>Fateshit
>Made in abyss
>Monogatari
Indeed shit taste

nips taste > chink taste > MAL taste

But only when my shit show is liked ok

Not him but MAL's is by far the worst one, this is not up to discussion. Too much shounen and too much of a recency bias.

Wrong. It's actually

my taste > nips taste > chink taste > MAL taste = reddit taste = Yea Forums taste

Pretending for the latter 3 to be in any way different is intellectually disingenuous. All western anime communities are trash.

Fair enough.

Attached: 1450757973013.png (416x453, 243K)

Get some fucking taste you otaku trash

>old man is still getting the years for MULTIPLE anime wrong
Embarrassment to elitists everywhere.

Colossal shit taste.

Don't use bilibili for chinks rating, it's a streaming site. Use bangumi instead

I am not gonna whitewash my blunders, user! Once you've reached seniority you will understand.

For me, I always think of "what's remembered" as being what's remembered by talented critics and artists instead of the general public, and in that sense I don't feel there's any real difference between East and West.

>Acca 13
>Disappointment
Filtered
Surprised HSL is on there
>Revue starlight
Really?

May I ask who or what exactly decides what a talented critic is?

>Filtered
But I didn't accuse it of being bad. It simply wasn't even remotely as good as it could have been. To be disappointed in something you need to have expecatations, user. You don't expect anything from a shit anime, now do you?

>Film: Mirai
This is just the Hosoda branding talking

I thought it was handled well where it showed us the districts in the first half, then slowly introduced a plot and gave a good ending

I think good criticism is an art in and of itself, so in the same way you'd evaluate an animator or writer or other artist.

It only made the list because it is good, but it still felt a bit too simplistic. Ironically, you instantly knew Jean and Lotta were of royal blood the moment the royal family got introduced. I am not sure whether that's a positive or a negative quality, given how the shows only pull were mystery and scheming. Made it way too predictable. Jeans attitude also made it very clear that he'd never ascend the throne.

I honestly thought you picked the wrong picture and showed what western people chose. The majority of that is shounen shit.

>MAL taste = reddit taste
Plain wrong. You can go to redditanimelist and check for yourself. Every anime that should be higher is higher and every anime that should be lower is lower (almost), therefore reddit taste > mal taste.

Name them.

I don't even need to go past the top 5 to see how you're trying to bullshit your way out of this.

Attached: 1560580233522.png (822x542, 153K)

And? Look at mal top 4 and tell me it's better. And then top 100.

Wtf. Top 3 is actually decent

everything on there except maybe attack on titan is boring

Stop being underage.

i said except (maybe) attack on titan

Maybe it's better than the west, but it's still pretty gay. Only thing I actually found good is MiA. I guess Monogatari 2nd season, Steins;Gate and AoT are also okay, but nothing really groundbreaking.

Consider the following list:
1. 3月のライオン 第2シリーズ
2. 銀魂'
3. SHIROBAKO
4. 進撃の巨人 Season 3 Part.2
5. 涼宮ハルヒの消失
6. STEINS;GATE
7. ARIA The AVVENIRE
8. 蟲師 続章 第2クール
9. 蟲師 続章
10. ハイキュー!! 烏野高校 VS 白鳥沢学園高校
11. 四畳半神話大系
12. リズと青い鳥
13. 魔法少女まどかマギカ
14. ガールズ&パンツァー 劇場版
15. 昭和元禄落語心中 -助六再び篇-
16. ピンポン THE ANIMATION
17. ジョジョの奇妙な冒険 スターダストクルセイダース エジプト編
18. ハイキュー!! セカンドシーズン
19. ちはやふる2
20. 風が強く吹いている
21. 日常
22. ジョジョの奇妙な冒険
23. 銀魂' 延長戦
24. 蟲師 鈴の雫
25. 宇宙よりも遠い場所

If you'll consider translating that list, I will consider considering that list.

Straight from reddit. Nice.

> 1. 3月のライオン 第2シリーズ
> 5. 涼宮ハルヒの消失
> 11. 四畳半神話大系
> 13. 魔法少女まどかマギカ
> 15. 昭和元禄落語心中 -助六再び篇-
> 16. ピンポン THE ANIMATION
Ain't that bad

Too much mushishi, haikyuu and jojo suck, tatami is overrated and GuP is downright trash.

What shows you actually love that mal hate or dislike?

There can never be too much Mushishi.

How do you determine what MAL hates or dislikes? There are shows with an average of 7, yet the first page of reviews has nothing but 9 or 10 ratings. The website sends mixed signals for a lot of anime.

At least brotherhood was still airing that year

What if tell you that you have a reddit taste (any kind of taste different to mine)? Would that equalize all the tastes?

>FMAshit
>good

yikes fuck off

>rating
MAL as a collective
>reviews
isolated opinions of various people

No, because your opinion doesn't matter. You might very well be a reddit or Yea Forums spy.

>GuP is downright trash
You need to have high IQ to enjoy this show. And the movie was simply amazing. Hands down one of the best anime films ever created

>He doesn't like AoTD for the '00s
Yikes fuck off

>garbage worst shonen in existence
>AoTD

yeah fuck off back to MAL.

200 IQ here, it's trash and your ancestors who fought during WW2 are judging you for watching that wehraboo crap.

As long as 3-gatsu at the top I do not mind. But Gintama is really bad. I really never understood how somebody can enjoy it.

>Asia
You mean seaniggers? Because this list reeks of underage thirdworlders.

So many good things in the 00's and your choice is fucking FMA? really?

Terrible.

Left is Japan right is China

>garbage worst shonen in existence
Not that guy but you've really got it backwards user.

My ancestors would have Yukari as their waifu if they were still alive today

No I don't? I hate FMA with a passion. I will never see the appeal of manlet MC with "im not small!!" jokes. Pure MALshit.

t.manlet

>he doesn't know
Oh you sweet burger boy.

Attached: 1461010848340.jpg (1000x1000, 118K)

Power by Google Translate:
1. March Lion 2nd Series
2. Gintama '
3. SHIROBAKO
4. Attack on Titan Season 3 Part.2
5. Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya
6. STEINS; GATE
7. ARIA The AVVENIRE
8. Acupuncturist continued chapter 2nd Cour
9. Acupuncturist continued chapter
10. Haikyu !! Kanno High School vs Shiratorizawa Gakuen High School
11. Four tatami half mythology
12. Liz and the blue bird
13. Puella Magi Madoka Magica
14. Girls & Panzer Movie version
15. Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinkan -Sukeroku again-
16. Ping Pong THE ANIMATION
17. JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Stardust Crusaders Egypt
18. Haikyu !! Second Season
19. Chihayafuru 2
20. The wind is blowing strongly
21. Nichijou
22. JoJo's Bizarre Adventure
23. Gintama 'extra time
24. Acupuncturist Suzu no Uta
25. A place farther than the universe

that's the shitty MC you're shilling for though?

>manlet MC
Mustang is not a manlet

>Acupuncturist
Kek.

I never knew Shitward Shitric isn't the MC. If there's a season without him I'd gladly watch.

>Getting this mad about a child in an anime
Chill out man put some fma on

Some major recency bias with some of that list and there's not much from the earlier half of the decade but it's still better than shounen shit.

Attached: icw9al7uj7tz.jpg (676x484, 52K)

> start with first episode
It was his mistake. 1st episode is objective not good and 3d is jarring at the start

Was there even any tanks in first half of garupan's first episode?

He was a protagonist but was not a hero of the story. At least not in the Brotherhood. I was watching it mainly for Mustang at the start and I never had a feeling that he was sidelined really hard

Opening scene shows part of the St. Gloriana match before flashing back to the day Miho met Hana and Saori. I think the Panzer IV was also shown in the garage in the last scene, right before it zooms out to show the aircraft carrier.

Is Mushishi acupuncturist? Also surprised to see Aria the Avvenire up there of all Aria shows. Not great, but better than OP's list for sure.

>Is Mushishi acupuncturist?
Google Translate say so
>Also surprised to see Aria the Avvenire up there of all Aria shows.
Aren't all the other Aria shows before 2010?

>Aren't all the other Aria shows before 2010?
Oh right, I forgot this thread was about 2010s for a second.

you either dont remember or didnt experience how much more shit there was in the 2000s compared to how much good there was

GoPrincess Precure is overrated.

This. Look past the seasonal isekai garbage and you can find some real gems in the 2010s, it's really not that fucking hard.

>1. 3月のライオン 第2シリーズ
based

Might be, but not only was 2015 an abysmal year in general, Go! is also still better than Hugtto and Futari. It's the prettiest precure and the CGI short film specials look really good, too.

>the only anime literally everyone had fun with is Oreimo
We have a winner already.

Attached: 1419567383517.gif (640x348, 1.73M)

So how is life being a scumbag contrarian just for the sake of being a snowflake?

I did not watch it. What did I miss?

Good taste. It's one of my favorite anime but fuck me is the first episode crap.

If an anime is genuinely good it usually has a high score on MAL while it would most likely get shit-talked by a few very vocal snowflakes of Yea Forums. Yea Forums taste should be absolute bottom of the barrel

>If an anime is genuinely good it usually has a high score on MAL
Good luck finding a SOL with good ratings there

The greatest love story ever told.

Attached: 1421550795494.gif (500x281, 1003K)

>Kekkai Sensen
>Gakkou Gurashi
>Punch Line
>OPM
>Cinderella Girls
>Osomatsu-san
>ConRevo
>Lupin
Tell me about fun. Why do you hate it?

>that image
Anime is dead.

Texhnolyze rated 7.76, while crap like FMA:B gets 9:23. I mean, I can't find any good shows rated 5 or less, for example, but as long as we are talking about 7-10, there is no telling which shows are actually good and which ones are utter crap.

>Tell me about fun. Why do you hate it?
Not that user, but did it ever occur to you that fun might be subjective?

>muh ratings
>brings up texnodogshit

Well basically everything that scores above 8 is genuinely good but that doesn't mean that stuff under 8 is automatically bad. Rankings are always flawed as fuck and MAL certainly is no exception. Only snowflakes don't like FMA:B, it's one of the very few masterpieces of the last decade.

aniDB taste

1. Steins;Gate
2. Disappearance of Haruhi
3. Gintama
4. Usagi Drop
5. Hunter x Hunter
6. Mushishi Zoku Shou
7. Owarimonogatari
8. Koe no Katachi
9. 3gatsu no Lion
10. Made in Abyss

MAL hardly has anything rated less than 5. There's tons of amazing stuff rated below 7 though. Also
>Texhnolyze
>good

That simply cannot be.

Attached: [HorribleSubs] Amazing Stranger - 12 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_03.27.883.jpg (328x492, 40K)

It wasn't me who brought up MAL ratings in the first place. Texh is one of the shows I consider perfect in both audiovisual and literary aspect, but it's rated even below the usual flavor of the month shows.

I don't consider it exactly bad, but it doesn't excel in anything either. Not in the story istself, not in music, not in visuals, not in humor, not in romance... It's above average within it's genre, but I don't understand why exactly is it supposed to be a masterpiece.

This might surprise you, but people rating anime on a normalfag site probably don't think some pretentious shite is any good.

>No Natsume Yujinchou on any list
Sad

Of course it does not surprise me, that's why I talked about the ratings not being reliable in the first place. You also don't know the meaning of pretentious. There is nothing pretentious about Texh, it doesn't try to namedrop literature, doesn't go out of its way to impress you. A typical normalfag with low attention span finds it boring.

>if you don't like my dogshit taste you're a normalfag!
Wow, what a truly convincing argument.

That's not what I'm saying, I'm saying the average, "normal" person will find it boring, because it requires you to pay attention. It doesn't hold your hand, you are supposed to analyze what you saw and draw your own conclusions. It's not a matter of taste. If it was indeed pretentious, the normalfags would flock to it, because they would be easily tricked into thinking they saw something profound.
How about instead of misinterpreting my words you try to tell me why exactly do you consider it to be pretentious.

>everything that scores above 8 is genuinely good
Ouch.

>the average, "normal" person will find it boring, because it requires you to pay attention
Stopped reading right there, I guarantee you look like pic related.

Attached: tips.png (463x469, 92K)

Don't bother debating with him, everyone that uses pretentious to disregard a show is a buzzword spouting idiot.

>muh Yea Forums debate
Are you 12?

Natsume's just Mushishi without good art, atmosphere and endearing acoustics. If you remove the fujo bait, what's left?

Don't you realize you are confirming what I'm saying to every last word? You just confirmed you don't even posess the attention span to read text longer than an average twitter post.

didn't read lol

Why do you even come to Yea Forums if you don't like debating?

Wow, I didn't know there were people that unironically took this site seriously.

Debating, arguing, talking, shitposting, whatever. It doesn't matter, you don't give a shit about this site and what remains of its community.

>Yea Forums and Yea Forums of all boards
>debating
You don't appear to be much smarter than him.

Attached: 1565630364393.png (2518x1024, 436K)

Pretty sure all 3 seasons of Aria are above 8.

It's always so obvious when you're dealing with a newfag larping as some wise oldfag because they take everything far too seriously.
Also, none of the words you listed mean the same thing.

So, you pick the Japanese equivalent of MAL and try to depict that site as the general "Asian taste" consensus? Really?

Yeah, I naïvely keep thinking that one day I will finally learn why some people find Texh pretentious, but it looks like it's not happening today. My bad, should have realized it sooner.

>debating

Attached: 1314906132371.jpg (478x380, 44K)

What was he supposed to pick if not the most popular site?

You raise a good point.

SakuhinDB's taste

1. Madoka
2. Steins;Gate
3. Hyouka
4. Disappearance
5. Ika Musume
6. Go Princess Precure
7. Chihayafuru
8. Hibike
9. Usagi Drop
10. Ano Hana

Notable that AnoHana is #187 overall. Compare MAL where 23 of the top 30 are from this decade, and two of those that aren't are LOGH and FMAB which barely count

>What was he supposed to pick if not the most popular site?
2ch.
Where people actually have an opinion of their own and don't only follow whichever opinion becomes mainstream.
And you know what that would show? Not a toplist, but a multitude of opinions and tastes. Just like Yea Forums does.
And you know why that is? Because fans of anime are no monolith.

And let me tell you another "secret": If you start breaking that down into smaller fandoms of genres, authors, directors and so on, those probably won't remember those "least common denominator" things, but some more specific stuff that hit their specific "collective taste" better.

>so you pick the big websites to gauge the general consensus
Yeah, that's kinda how it work, retard.

Cringe

Somebody thinks of himself as pretty smart even though he's triggered by the most popular sites being used to list popular things that'll be remembered.

Attached: 1492430363652.png (450x449, 171K)

Ah, so there is a consensus in the west that FMA Brotherhood is the best anime of all time, right! We all agree on that, don't we?
Or is that not how it actually work, retard?

Well, if you love "popular" sites so much, why are you still here on Yea Forums instead? Come on, fuck of to MAL.

Good luck finding good SoL

Attached: 1368741790197.jpg (640x480, 47K)

Yes, we all agree that FMA is the best anime of all time, and you are mentally ill so your opinion doesn't count

>Yes, we all agree that FMA is the best anime of all time
Sure you "all" do.

There is. That's what the majority decided. Your opinion is irrelevant since you're nothing but a shitposter who's desperately trying to appear as important as millions of other people combined. Your opinion is not of equal value. You're an irrelevant outlier. The general population decided that FMAB is the greatest anime ever. Therefore that's the general consensus.

No, Natsume is Mushishi with equally good art and atmosphere.

> TVOD: IM@S
Seriously? If you had to pick any idol anime at all, Precure and Love Live! had a much bigger impact on Japan overall

The western fandom says it is just as the japanese fandom says Sora Yori is the best. You don't have to agree as an individual but the masses have spoken.

>The general population decided that FMAB is the greatest anime ever. Therefore that's the general consensus.
No, it isn't. Majority opinion does not equal a consensus. But, hey, call it what you will: FMA being at the top just shows how worthless that kind of "consensus" is worthless.

>Majority opinion does not equal a consensus
You're right. It's a GENERAL consensus. Seriously hope you're not a native English speaker.

Oh and I'd like to add that you can argue that some shows have a lot more votes/members than others and thus the lists for each fandom can be rearranged based on that.
Which as far as this conversation and this thread go means FMA remains West's #1, S;G becomes Japan's #1 for this decade and VEG becomes China's #1 for this decade.

I've watched and enjoyed everything here, but fuck gintama.

I think people get to obssessed with anime score 9/10, 10/10 blah blah.
But these sites are actually useful, if anything is rated a 9/10 it will 100% have some entertainment value for you, doesn't mean it's actually a 9/10 for you, but it got the rating for a reason.

Actually S;G becomes Japan's number 1 of all time and VEG China's number 1 of all time.

>if anything is rated a 9/10 it will 100% have some entertainment value for you
That is evidently false.

Hugtto had Emiru so it's better than GoPri

>It's a GENERAL consensus.
No, it isn't. General consensus would imply that it's a generally shared opinion or shared knowledge. And that's not the case for something that gets voted first on average by a majority.
At best you could say it's an approximation of the average taste of MAL users.

Really? are you being honest with yourself?
for me, everything i've seen with at least an 8 on MAL, has been worth the watch, or entertaining, or just good on some objective level, that i can't deny with all my contrarianism.

Hugtto had Hana in the lead, so it's worse than virtually all other Precure's by proxy. Homare is the only character that saves it.

>consensus
>noun [ S or U ]
>uk /kənˈsen.səs/ us /kənˈsen.səs/
>a generally accepted opinion or decision among a group of people:
>The general consensus in the office is that he can't do his job.
>Could we reach a consensus on this matter? Let's take a vote.

Stop being retarded. MAL is by far the most used western site for keeping track of anime and manga, therefore its consensus is the general consensus.

>FMA:B, it's one of the very few masterpieces of the last decade.
It's from 2009 and not even the best anime of that year, much less that decade
It amplifies all the problems the manga had and was mostly bolstered by 03's worldwide popularity, especially considering the criticism commonly made that it "rushed" the early content when it's practically a constant 1.5 chapters per episode adaptation

>all these anti FMAB contrarians
Yikes, with a capital Y.

>a generally accepted opinion
Yes. I don't accept that FMA is the best anime ever, nor do lots of other people. Thus it's not GENERAL consensus.

>therefore its consensus is the general consensus.
Wrong. There are more more people who don't use MAL than there are MAL users. Even if we count sock-puppet accounts as real people.

In which aspect does FMA:B stand above all the other shows (story, audio, animation, backgrounds, humor, romance, any other quality?). In my opinion, there isn't any aspect it excels in enough to make it a masterpiece, let alone a great show.

>general
>adjective
> 1Affecting or concerning all or most people or things; widespread.
> ‘books of general interest’
> ‘the general opinion was that prices would fall’

Get out retard.

Nigga, if every single person on earth had to agree to something in order for it to be a general consensus, there wouldn't exist any general consensus at all. I can't believe you've already spent so much time arguing some stupid semantics.

>moeshit
>haremshit
>haremshit
>i dont even know what that is
>moeshit
>haremshit
>shonenshit
>moeshit
>shonenshit(+haremshit)
>shonenshit
>moeshit
>moeshit

Good god.

>Really? are you being honest with yourself?
Yes, I am.
From its top 10 alone, FMA and Steins Gate had no entertainment value to me whatsoever. SnK, Gintama and Kimi no na wa had very little. I haven't seen Sangatsu no Lion.
That leaves HxH 2011, which I found entertaining, but ultimately subpar to both the 1999 anime and the source manga.

>if every single person on earth had to agree to something in order for it to be a general consensus
Not every single person. But a few more than one shitty site's userbase, maybe? How about that?

I find your post extremely moeshit.

>when you're such a contrarian you refuse to acknowledge dictionary definitions and lack basic understanding of statistics
Oof..

Not that user, but I'd say I am honest by agreeing with him. Everything with score 8 and higher
>has been worth the watch
definitely not
>entertaining
definitely not
>or just good on some objective level
It's hard to define objective, most of the shows have at least something good going for them. If I was to cherrypick, how about some of the recent isekai like Shield Hero or Slime? I can't think of any level on which those shows aren't utter crap. Lazy, uninspired template writing, animation or sound isn't anything noteworthy, there is no encompassing idea behind the show, no direction where it's going, no message to convey, no gripping plot, nothing.

>The contrarian that hates fma and S;G is a HxHfag

Attached: 1517230468537.png (446x426, 134K)

Because I said that I enjoyed it? Grow up, MALtard, there's more than just black and white.

Speak up son

Attached: huntermumblers.png (262x241, 69K)

It's as good a sample as any other. Of course it would be better to pick people from different communities, but it seems nobody wants to be bothered by doing that. I believe the consensus of the entire western fanbase combined would look a bit different than that of MAL, but it's highly impropable the results would get completely turned on their head.

>FMA and Steins Gate had no entertainment value to me whatsoever.
REALLY? lol I woulnd't say either FMA or steins gate are great, but i was always compelled to keep watching.

I'm not trying to do a "gotcha" or anything, just honestly curious, what are 3 shows you do like?

>It's as good a sample as any other.
True. Sampling any random small (not statistically relevant) group of anime viewers and then taking an average over their ratings is neither scientific nor worthwhile. That was the point all along, and that's why MAL ratings are shit.
It's shocking how many idiots hold that stuff in such a high regard.

>it seems nobody wants to be bothered by doing that.
Also true. Most reasonable people don't care much for ratings in the first place.

Attached: fuckin japs.png (468x414, 92K)

I'm not a part of this conversation, but out of curiosity how different do you really think a statistically relevant sample would be from MAL's user base?

Haibane Renmei, Aria, Mushishi, Kino... From the more recent and popular ones, I guess Houseki no Kuni, Girls' Last Tour, even Made in Abyss was pretty good in my opinion. It's hard to decide on just three. I'm not necessarily saying everything I enjoy is objectively good in every aspect, but I know exactly what I like and tend to be picky about my entertainment.

>how different do you really think a statistically relevant sample would be from MAL's user base?
I can't possibly tell, of course, but I assume that it would be all over the place, just like Yea Forums's taste is pretty much all over the place.
MAL's userbase seem to have an overrepresentation of "battle shounen" fans, so I'd say that anything that speaks to them would fare worse. Older things tend to do excaptionally badly on MAL, so one would assume that pre-2000s stuff would largely do better.

You see the same with other ranking sites, including Japanese ones: They do not have a diverse userbase, thus they get heavily skewed results.
The idea alone that those who would go online and rate something of their own volition could ever represent the general public is crazy.

>Older things tend to do excaptionally badly on MAL,
>7th place is a series from 1988
Okay user

Go through the list as a whole. Don't just look at the first "old" thing you see. 1988 isn't that old anyway.

oh look, a semanticfag being contrarian for the sake of it

>1988 isn't that old anyway.
Okay grandpa, whatever you say.

Things up to December 1999 with a rating of 8 or 9: little more than one page (60 to 70 results)
Things from January 2000 onwards with a rating of 8 or 9: nearly 12 pages (600 results)

The further you go back, the bleaker it looks.

>1988 isn't that old anyway
It's 13 years after anime started being worth watching. Anything before 1975 was irredeemable trash.

Why is 1975 your cutoff?

>Anything before 1975 was irredeemable trash.
Well, that's what MALtards like you seem to thing.

>Astro Boy is actually great!!!!1111one
Ah yes, boomer begone.

Steins gate was good. The rest are mostly shit

A strong 4/10 can have entertainment value, some redeeming qualities, but still not be good. Kimi no na Wa would be a 2/10 if not for the pretty( but somewhat sterile looking) backgrounds and good ( though not notable from a creative standpoint) animation, but MAL has it marked over 9.

In a sense the movie is objectively good, it successfully peddles lowest common denominator sentimentalism and utilizes a generic formula with its audio-visual presentation that will make most people feel like crying if they aren't that privy to the formula. And it does it do a degree that people never really stop to think critically about the plot or look for some sort of interesting artistic innovation or creativity on any front, and just get sucked in to the cry porn bait. I'm sure that it wasn't meant to do much more than this, and it succeeded. Achieving your artistic goal is the only real objective measure, since what counts as a meritorious feature in itself is subjective. But it couldn't be more distinct from what I consider a fulfilling film.

Belladonna of Sadness, Ashita no Joe, Horus, Ace wo Nerae?

He's trolling

>porn, battle shounen, Disney without animation, battle shoujo
Why do you list garbage?

LOGH was only subbed recently though

You’ve never seen any of those I see.

>subbed recently
Yet the oldest available torrent on AB is from 2009, so basically since the website started to exist. Showing us that the subs are likley way older. What's recent to you? 20 years?

>never seen
Wasn't aware I was talking to a Madotard lmao

aniDB says Central Anime didn't finish until 2011, which is also what I remember

Well I mean, you got the genres wrong on two of the shows and stated something objectively false about one of the other.

He's TROLLING

Not him but more anime was being produced in 2000s and 10s than say 90s or 80s so ofcours you will get more anime shows with high ratings in post 2000 than 90s anime.

I think the reason is a lot more likely that people generally tend to watch and talk about newer things than older.

Sorry, pal. Asshitter yes Joe and Queen of Tennis are battle [demographic].

Also this ofcours.

Not this much more anime. We're talking factors of 10 here. That might work out if you compare pre-1970 stuff to the post-2000s.

Very much so. MAL users tend to be very young as well.

It’s also a matter of what kind of fans watch older anime. When you are just starting out you watch all the new popular stuff and the odd classic and everything is good because of the novelty. Once you’ve been into it for a while you get more critical and start exploring more.People who watch both old and new tend to have plenty of high and low scores for stuff from all decades, but have a medium level average. People who just watch newer stuff tend to have a really high average.

Most old anime is shit anyway, just like most new anime. Nothing changed.

>no madoka
Based

I don't know what's worse: MALtards or ironic weebs?

On the good taste one (SakuhinDB) has it in its top ten

>On the good taste one (SakuhinDB)
Meme websites. Almost all my favourites have a very good rating despite being memed by western communities. Looking at this is extremely awkwards.

Chances are your favorites are shit.

That's why I am calling it a meme website.

Okay dumbass. I guarantee you more people will talk about gridman in 10 years than overlord.

>Oreimo not on the list
Shit taste

Aside from Hyouka, the shows in that list are nowhere near the best shows of the decade

But Violet Evergarden is unironically one of the best anime ever made period.

It seems that left has much better taste than right

Look fake since it is missing Madoka and GuP

This shit is actually good? Really?

I mean, this MC looks like a pathetic waste of a human being. You're saying its worth watching? Am I being baited like with Honey & Clover(which was shit)?

Where is Non Non Biyori?

Attached: 372.jpg (1920x1080, 277K)

We doing one of these bad boys?
OFFICIAL BEST ANIME OF THE 10'S BY YEAR LIST
>2010
Youjouhan Shinwa Taikei, K-ON!!, Panty and Stocking, Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsuu, Redline
>2011
Idolm@ster, Madoka Magica, Steins;Gate, Kore wa Zombie desu ka?, Nichijou
>2012
Nisemonogatari, Kore wa Zombie desu ka? Of the Dead, AKB0048, High School DxD, Psycho Pass
>2013
Monogatari Second Season, Kill la Kill, NouCome, AKB0048 Next Stage, Tamako Market
>2014
Shirobako, Space Dandy, Selector Infected Wixoss, Hanamonogatari, Ore, Twintails ni Narimasu
>2015
One Punch Man, Durarara x2 Shou, Kekkai Sensen, Punch Line, High School DxD 3
>2016
Kimi no na wa, Koe no Katachi, Heybot, Kono Sekai no Katatsumi ni, New Game!
>2017
Garo Vanishing Line, 18if, Akiba's Trip, New Game!!, Kobayashi
>2018
Pop Team Epic, Asagao to Kase-san, Wotakoi, Zombieland Saga, Violet Evergarden

>re:zero

Attached: puke.png (432x415, 177K)

Reddit detected

Was anime really this bad this decade?

Please return to r/anime before I request a warrant for brain cell assassination.

Whenever someone uses the word pretentious it's always 110% guaranteed they don't know what they're talking about. If you want to be entertained ask someone who uses that word why x show is pretentious and grab some nice popcorn while you're at it

>Isekai and sol garbage
>No madoka or Space Dandy

Translation have already been posted for you.

Nope Aria the animation is below..MAL ratings are for dudu brains

Everyone who's watched 2 anime agrees

>or look for some interesting artistic innovation or creativity on any front
I don't disagree with you honestly and I know what you're saying applies to most people but I feel like a little added perspective may be in order for certain sweeping statements.
Though few, there are people who find some intrinsic value in something like Kimi no na wa
For example, youtu.be/iY6XMBRM6A4 (at 6:56)

While I don't personally relate to his point of view, I now find it a bit disingenuous to say there's no artistic value to be found in certain anime for everyone as much as they appeal to the LCD

>Everyone who's only watched 2 anime agrees
Ftfy.

i want to have a lot of sex with kurisu

>Konosuba
>Fateshit
>AoT
>all that isekai shit
>Made in Abyss that high

Attached: aa6.jpg (600x465, 30K)

3-gatsu has been the best thing in recent years.

Attached: ba25862d830cd9abc3366e5ef9a93009.webm (854x480, 1.56M)

I'm not saying that it lacks artistic value, all art has some value insofar as someone values it. My point is just that it gets away with being very generic and not innovating in any way. Which you would kind of expect from something considered the absolute best of all time by so many people.

>This shit is actually good
It is good. The first couple of episodes can feel a bit slow though
>I mean, this MC looks like a pathetic waste of a human being.
He goes through some nice character development. For me it was quite pleasant to watch how basically he made his own happiness with his own hands.
> Honey & Clover
From what I've heard it is quite different from that. Simply because romance is not the central part of the story.

It is hard for me to judge if it the best or not because I only watched it 4 days ago. But damn, I do not remember when was the last time that anime made such a strong impact on me.

>YoriMoi higher than VEG yet again.
Somethings just never change.

>mfw FMA:B will always live rent free in anons head because of some site

Attached: 1469120266596.jpg (1065x722, 191K)

Exquisite taste user

Attached: manofinegrity.png (640x478, 286K)

FMAfaggots are shitposters. Who'd have thought?

Glad I never watched this dubshit garbage.
Glad Dick McFaggot is getting arrested as soon as he loses his case.

>all these normalfaggots thinking "M-MAL TOLD ME ITS GOOD SO IT-S GOOD ALSO I ONLY WATCHED THE DUB!!!""

back to your hole burgers

RE:zero is shit so now I cant trust the rest of the list

Attached: 1565045284926.jpg (908x720, 294K)

If you look into the history of cinema, the most popular picks of each year are rarely remembered after a few years. These lists mean nothing.

Attached: yawn.jpg (500x491, 55K)

I just cheked anicore and you just put whatever you wanted on that list faggot.

What do you mean? Black Panther is movie of the decade.

Thank you.
Didn't add 2019 before because it isn't done yet, but so far I have a rough top 5:
Pop Team Epic Special (nothing will top this)
Sarazanmai
Saiki K. Kanketsu-hen
Mob Psycho 100 II
Fate/stay night Heaven's Feel II

>the new art style
Ah yes, I forgot that "new art style" that every anime adopted.

10s made anime super mainstream, i hate this shit

You are an actual newfag, you just did a good job with pretending and reverse trolling, and now you are own this shitty site with your ironic weeb shit

t.faggot

Thanks for calling op out on his faggotry.
/thread.