Suggested Sumire 16, Gambling Emperor Zero, Legend of Legendary Heroes. At least they don't have a bunch of restrictions on the suggestions like Vertical does.
Dylan Davis
>Will it ever be Sumire 16's time? They've done quirky/weird stuff in the past so it'll likely have a chance. Hopefully enough suggest it that they look into it.
Aaron Torres
Hope so. 5 volumes isn't a big commitment from a publisher. I wonder if they'd rather have a longer running series to pump out over a long time, though.
Robert Scott
Vertical only licenses c-tier manga that are in line for anime adaptation.
>I wonder if they'd rather have a longer running series to pump out over a long time, though.
They don't seem to like long running series. Most stuff they license is 10 volumes or less. The last time they did I believe was 2017's license of To Love Ru.
Some of the later volumes were translated by an ESL nip and badly need a fresh translation.
Dominic Gray
Based on comments they've made, the heavily requested stuff is almost always fully translated or just about there (eg Classroom Of The Elite). But the quality tends to be questionable like mentioned.
JNC owner mentioned he tried to license it. Japan wanted Shoji Gatoh's other works licensed first (Amagi Brilliant Park and Full Metal Panic). It's pretty safe to say JNC will get Cop Craft eventually.
Henry Torres
>Sengoku Komachi >Fujiyama-san >Skip to Loafer >Saotome Senshu >The Violence Action >Melancholia Of those I'd really only assume Saotome, Violence Action, Melancholia and Komachi have a chance of ever getting picked up and Saotome's something I'm surprised isn't actually licensed yet.
Skip to Loafer seems like the kind of thing that Yen Press would go for. I have no hope of ever seeing Fujiyama-san (or any of Ojiro's stuff) picked up but I can dream.
Robert Miller
Getting the Shinmai sex scenes officially translated into English would be nice
>Kadokawa Sneaker Bunko I want it too user, but I doubt anyone but YP is getting a shot at it. Plus I highly doubt they have the patience to see it through to the end, and if they did pick it up people would inevitably ask about Last Embryo.
Jackson Phillips
$10 for an ebook from sse, have you seen the competition? Inb4 shill&buyfag
Jackson Edwards
I'm always begging for the Tsuki ga Michibiku light novel since the web novel is hiatus since forever. I know it's probably to no avail as Alpha Polis seems to hate gaijins and their money.
I always suggesting them in rotation every month. Manga: Seikon no Qwaser, Shinju no Nectar, Pupa Light Novel: Date A Live, Haiyore! Nyaruko-san, Saenai Heroine no Sodatekata, Ro-Kyu-Bu!
Brandon Thompson
>Shinmai sex scenes I hear the last book is a fascinating read.
Blake Sullivan
Fist of the North Star. It's still the greatest manime ever made.
Is the LN ahead of the WN in plot? It seems like it is ending soon already in WN
Ryan Russell
>I know it's probably to no avail as Alpha Polis seems to hate gaijins and their money.
Seven Seas somehow managed to license the Re:Monster manga from them. So they probably have a chance at actually licensing more.
Elijah Morris
The only good licensing company I've ever experienced was Del Rey, cause they actually bothered to use TL notes instead of catering to the flavor of the month crowd
Tyler Harris
Surprisingly Vertical has TL footnotes on pretty much every page of their Katanagatari release
Nolan Butler
I forgot Vertical, they're pretty alright too. But by and large, things getting licensed is always bittersweet for me.
Landon Harris
Why they license such garbage?
Ryan Garcia
What are the chances of Vertical subbing the Katanagatari drama CDs that came with the Japanese Blu-rays which is essentially the Katanagatari Prequel about Shichika's dad?
Mason Price
They touched on it at a con a while back. The light novel was highly requested so they approached Alphapolis but they refused. However they were surprised to be offered the manga. Getting anything from Alphapolis is rare so they went for it hoping they could open the door for more. So far they haven't been able to get them to budge but they keep trying.
It seems to sell well for them as they openly said volumes 1 & 2 had to be reprinted while Slime was releasing new episodes. Seems like people looking for other reincarnated into monster/object series were picking it up. (Also probably the reason they picked up Tensei Shitara Ken Deshita).
Eli Wright
Even Japan hates alphapolis, they started the trend of telling authors they hire to take down their web novels instead of leaving them up.
Doubt it's about Alphapolis. You see they weren't planning on licensing Mushoku Tensei LN as well but because of the anime adaption announcement were basically forced to.
Adrian Bennett
More like trying to maximize profit nothing strange about it. Everyone on narou knows the only reason to buy an LN which was adapted from a narou WN with little to no changes is to tip the author and maybe grab the illustrations/physical version.
Brayden Green
NO WAY!
Jack Jenkins
Now I want a Fist of the North Star classic collection like Devilman got that would be amazing.
Joseph Allen
Slave Harem seems to have a similar problem, although the LN still gets updates.
I think the LN still hasn't caught up to the WN, although I don't know how much changes. The WN doesn't seem close to ending other than due to the author not writing. I don't think the LN has gotten anything new recently either.
Robert Murphy
Gate still hasn't had a second manga volume in english, maybe that's related to why they don't want to bother.
Tsuki ga has the WN on alphapolis, so maybe they just want control of it? It's still not good if they are adding their own content restrictions, but I don't know if that happens.
Brayden Rivera
Isn't getting translated by SS a death sentence?
Wyatt Wilson
>4 of 5 Popular choices for LNs are shit Sasuga
I just want more enemies of the world. But it seems like we would never get it even if there are a lot of votes.
>Fist of the North Star I thought Viz had access to every non-ecchi Jump series?
Carter Rodriguez
>I just want more enemies of the world. This but add Fortissimo to that for me. I'm optimistic that eventually Boogiepop's time shall come either in relation to the LN or anime.
I'm pretty sure it got published in English a long time ago but I think it went out of print and I have no idea what is currently going on with the license to continue it or who owns it.
Cameron Walker
Someone made files for a bootleg version if it never gets licensed.
I requested Soil and some porn because I have zero expectation anything I like will get licensed.
Have they ever published actual Japanese novels though? I was wondering what kind of publisher would ever do books like Eccentric Family or Run With the Wind if that ever happens. I know Vertical does Japanese books occasionally and Viz tried but fucked up Yukikaze.
Justin Ross
Frenchies get so much good manga it's not even funny. They have such a strong culture of appreciating and creating comics in general that they license constantly and from every genre and demographic.
Tyler Evans
is it just digital? i think the US market is too small to put physical format
Samuel Johnson
NO
Brody Cruz
we just get this one ready for fall and Jujutsu Kaisen for february 2020
I don’t know if they like it or not but some of the series they retitle are pretty damn funny. >50 nuances de Gras >Las vacaciones de Jesús y Buda
Brody Rodriguez
Well, Atsushi Kaneko for example. They've had Matsumoto's Louvre Cats for years and in color too, they got Hiroki Endos vampire series... they've got a a lot of stuff that will never get released in the US.
Chase Jones
Lots of Jiro Taniguchi, gekiga and sports manga would be my guess
Gavin Cox
Quite a bit more of serious shorter works and UG stuff that would be analogous with the western graphic novel format (and not just manga that's licensed in the west and has the "graphic novel" denominator slapped onto it) that are meant for comic enthusiasts. Too niche for most markets.
Landon Cox
>Atsushi Kaneko Bless Hox for finishing the translation of Soil. It’s a shame his stuff never gets published in the US
Bambi has been published in English years and years ago. The license has expired and I don't think they ever even did the entirety of it, but it did happen.
Chase Roberts
Yeah it was only two volumes. The series was licensed by DMG and they are notoriously one of the worst manga publishers in the US. They also licensed a bunch of big titles like Worst and only released one or two volumes, and in the last few years use Kickstarter to fund releases. The only stuff they publish that sells is gay porn
Joshua Adams
His stuff never even gets scanlated despite raws being available. Even Soil sat unfinished for the longest time until Hox saved it.
How much do Honhons pay for their tanks? In addition to American publishers only licensing shit that's either on Toonami/Crunchyroll/Netflix or very popular on Reddit and Twitter they also charge like double what a tank costs in Japan. Granted it's still a better deal than paying for an American comic TPB but still, paying $13 for something that costs like $6 in Nipland is dumb.
Gavin Torres
the standard price is 6,99€ but there is some at 7,99€ and it can be more pricey if its a speciale edition
Blake Gutierrez
Peek behind the curtain here. Have to be vague because I like my job and don't want to dox myself. Believe it or not, up to you.
TLDR -> The fan surveys 7S does don't really lead to series getting licensed.
My scanlation team (which I still am a part of despite contracting with 7S) tried getting readers of our series to "survey bomb" so those series would get licensed. However, it wasn't until my point of contact at 7S asked me directly what series I had on my radar that one of those series got picked up. Just as planned, I got that same series to work on officially. So I got to work on it for you nerds and then get paid for it the second time around.
Jeremiah Miller
So about what the Japs pay for their stuff then. Holy fuck do we burgers really get raked over the coals by these shitty publishers. Fucking $20 for the Yen Press version of I Want To Eat Your Pancreas when the Jap manga is like $14 for both volumes.
Easton Barnes
Could be bullshitting but I wouldn't be surprised if the survey was basically just a way to scam people for analytics data/signing them up for their mailing list.
Ryan Clark
How do you get professionally involved with translating manga in work like typesetting/editing? Is it more or less scanlating well enough that they contact you?
Carter Martin
For 7S, I literally just sent them a small portfolio of my scanlation work via their contact form and said "Do you have an opening?" Took a while for them to get back to me and I had to do some test pages but it was that simple. Dunno how it works for other companies.
Lincoln White
Manga I placed in survey: Marielle Clarac no Konyaku
Light Novels I placed in the survey:
1. Ambition Waltz
2. Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu
Carter Robinson
You fade into irrelevancy and nobody talks about you.
Cameron Gray
and you get worst paper quality and no dust cover for alternative cover
Liam Reyes
>Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu you're kidding, they are better LN like this one
Well they did do Little Miss Holmes so I threw Area 88 on there. It's about a third translated already....
Christopher Cook
Thanks for the info.
Dylan Green
Good work, user.
Jaxson Roberts
Still holding out hope that Teito Monogatari will get released in English someday. It's a fool's hope. But it's my fool's hope.
Caleb Wilson
I requested The Sacred Blacksmith light novel. I know they licensed the manga version several years ago, but it would be nice if they licensed the original LN as well. But I know it's probably too late to ever happen..
Isaiah Miller
I don't understand why people don't vote for series that aren't translated yet. It's a wasted opportunity.
Jaxson Mitchell
It would be nice if they licensed Momo the bloodtaker
Nathan Hall
Some of the slayers translations are abolsute ESL trash, and vol 16 is untranslated.
Tyler Russell
Not really, I got Record of Lodoss War, which they went all out with the quality of the book, and the translation is fine as well. Only problem with the True Tenchi novels was a typo or two.
Logan Reyes
That's the way things go for licensing in general. Ultimately, scanlations create a community around a series in a way that a bi-monthly volume release. There's also the fact that they license many titles, the majority of which never had a 'community' to begin with. So you'e looking at a series that was barely discussed that becomes a series nobody talks about.
Owen Scott
I thought this got the axe treatment already just like the author's past work (Black Torch).
Austin Hill
I'm honestly surprised those books have never been translated/released over here. Considering how much influence it's had on pop culture (i.e. a lot of darker supernatural horror anime and shit like Shin Megami Tensei) you think it'd be a no brainer for someone to pick up.
Eli Myers
but it began on April this year and we have it because Black Torch sell really well in France
Ryder Edwards
On the other hand I wish there was actual physical releases for shit like Kenrantaru and Arte as opposed to having to buy shitty digital versions. It's far easier to convince someone to read something when you can lend them a copy than directing them to Mangadex or something I've found.
Kayden Jones
I imagine it's just old, which makes it a harder pickup. Gotta focus on translating those isekais that kids these days want.
Adam Brown
Hey man, Crest of the Stars/Banner of the Stars light novel got licensed again even when TokyoPop died and despite like a 12 fucking year hiatus from the author.
Seven Seas sometimes licenses random stuff.
Sacred Blacksmith might be cheaper to license since it is completed rather than ongoing
Nolan Cruz
How good are Seven Seas translation? I remember people complained about their Monster Musume manga translation.
Does it just depend on the translator they hire?
Bentley Perry
Everything is cheaper in Japan like manga.
However, I heard compute parts are more expensive in Japan than in America since Japan's PC market isn't that big.
Austin Sanchez
I want someone to license Ashita no Joe for fuck's sake. The scanslations on Mangadex go to shit a couple dozen chapters in. It'd be perfect for their Classic Collections.
Elijah Flores
I definitely agree, I was mostly talking about internet discussion.
Isaac Roberts
Because it's a series of books from the 80s. Not even LN, just a serialized novel, and very niche for a western audience on top of being rather old and obscure. Doomed Megalopolis was published officially in English but shit's been out of circulation for years and years and casual, i.e. the profitable and largest, audience will know of it as often as casual audience will know who Rintaro is, so not very often. If there's any hope you'd have to hope for actual literature publishers who'd be doing significant cultural work by translating it, and not manga/ln publishers. It's not unheard of of publishers picking stuff up based on well constructed arguments.
Thomas Morris
I want someone to pick up Owari no Chronicle so I can have it on my shelf but no publisher is gonna go out of their way to deal with it when it barely has any western fans
It's really a wonder why Joe hasn't been published in English. Literally one of the most influential and important series ever. Why doesn't Vertical do it? They're having a grand old time publishing all sorts of Tezuka titles, specifically the heavy shit like MW, Ayako or Adolf.
Robert Diaz
Hueland also get some stuff not available in english, nothing on frog level but still something.
Easton Thomas
Man every time it's a write in I always blank. There's a lot of series Id like to see but I can never think of them on the spot.
I want Owari to be left alone honestly. Any licensed translation for any of his works would be trash, the only way you'd get a good one is either with an already dedicated fan of the kawakamiverse, or have the man himself learn English fluently.
Brody Cook
Also true, yeah. There was some thing not too long ago where he supposedly asked for native japanese to english and japanese to german translators to get in touch with him on his fanbox but god knows what the point of that was.
Christopher Edwards
Tezuka is more well known in the west than Kajiwari and Chiba. You'd think when Megalo Box was new they would've done it since that seems to be one of the criteria these publishers use when deciding what to license and release (why do you think we suddenly got an explosion of Go Nagai stuff or the Space Battleship Yamato manga getting collected). The only other hope is to turn it into a meme like what vaporwavefags did with Urusei Yatsura since that's pretty clearly the only reason the series is getting published over here now.
Eli Bell
>what vaporwavefags did with Urusei Yatsura since that's pretty clearly the only reason the series is getting published over here now. Excuse me?
Daniel Thompson
Seven Seas translations are okay. Even their in house LN translations okay (their Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e TL is great - it has literally everthing done right without garbage burgerization which is rather very uncommon).
Parker Hill
>Urusei Yatsura its more the fact that Rumiko Takahashi is already well known
Joshua Nguyen
>okay "Okay" does not cut it. Why do you think the only studio to rise to the occasion of the "unadaptable" story was Sunrise? And even then, they had to cut content and limit themselves to two cours. Have you seen the encyclopedia? You are severely underestimating the challenge here.
Easton Evans
How long ago was that?
Adrian Rogers
February this year >Regardless, Kawakami posted on his Fanbox that he's looking for translators that might be interested in working with him. Specifically Japanese to English, and Japanese to German. Preferably those that are located in Japan, but native English and German speakers are what's most important to him. If you're interested, he asks to reach out through Pixiv or Twitter.
Ryder White
There's no perfect TL and there will never be (even SS/Eclipse subs weren't perfect too despite the fact that they were close). Seven Seas is probably the best official publishers for LNs and second best for manga after Yen Press (yeah, they sucks really bad for LNs, but that's different department of them). Everthing other is nothing but piece of garbage (especially Viz and vertical).
Gabriel Reed
Have you even read any Kawakami
Jack Stewart
It disgusts me to see something as trash as sister new devil placed alongside dxd in any context
Hunter James
Yet it was never published in English until this year conveniently after vaporwavefags started using it/Lum in their shit. It gets popular, Viz sees there's money to be made now and capitalizes on it.
If they wanted to capitalize on Takahashi's name they would've done it when Ranma was popular in the early/mid '90s or when Inuyasha was big 15+ years ago. That they didn't until now says a lot about what the reasoning was.
Kevin Young
but she gained fame in your country only after Inuyasha came out
Oliver Baker
For smaller creators stuff like this is honestly a great way for them to spread their name and works. There's a few series like Skinny Girl and Chubby Boy and I Can't Tell What My Little Sister's Friend is Thinking that are translated and put on Mangadex with the author's permission and all it does is basically work as free advertising.
Jonathan Clark
Ranma 1/2 was one of the most popular series of the pre-Toonami anime fandom. Inuyasha was incredibly popular in the early 2000s. People knew who Takashi was yet there was in interest in publishing Urusei Yatsura until the series blew up on the internet over the last year thanks to vaporwafefags using it in their stuff and giving it attention.
I don't know what's offensive about the idea. A publisher isn't going to see any value in spending money on licensing, translating and releasing an old work unless they feel there's a market for it and getting very popular on social media/youtube means that the publisher thinks they might be able to capitalize on that newfound interest.
Joseph Cruz
they should try crowfunding if they have some fanbase but the downside is it'll come only digital
Gavin Phillips
Samefagging but for the record I hate vaporwave and A E S T H E T I C S nonsense but that shit definitely is influential. I've been listening to city pop and old '80s j-pop for like 10 years but it wasn't until vaporwave came around that it blew up and now you're seeing western labels starting to put out shit like city pop compliations.
Jonathan Morgan
anime and manga is not the same market, anime viewer are essentially young kid without lot of cash to spend on pricy manga
Juan Evans
Maybe they don't want to get mogged. Joe is far above any 70s-80s shit, ahead of it's time.
Lincoln Foster
Got a comprehensive list of those? Is there a tag for it?
Aaron Howard
Well, remember Viz dropped Gintama manga because they just felt like it even though Gintama is a big property.
No one really knows how Viz thinks.
David Sanchez
maybe no one bought it, you overestimate a bit the US market
Camden Price
I'm still fucking pissed at Vertical for dropping Ninja Slayer
Cameron Allen
why'd they do that?
Angel Myers
Low sales I'd assume but I have no idea. I emailed them about it at one point to ask if they would publish the remaining volumes but they never responded.
Kevin Long
Vertical is incredibly overrated
Lucas Lee
>giving a fuck about licencing
Carson Price
Seven Seas is good though. I couldn't care less about Viz and other similar burger trash though.
Logan Kelly
>Have they ever published actual Japanese novels though?
Kinda. Wicked City, I Want To Eat Your Pancreas, Perfect Blue and At Night, I Become a Monster were all originally released as regular novels. They all had new editions released under a LN imprint which is the edition Seven Seas licensed. Generally the only difference is new cover art.
Aaron Adams
This. They license weird stuff and don't go after scanlators. They also actually communicate on social media instead of being superior fucks. Viz and Yen Press are the worst.
Mason Robinson
Speaking of Yugami, I hope TL user comes back soon. I need my weekly Yugami fix.