>Edens Zero by Hiro Mashima, published by Kodansha Comics Rob's pick >BEASTARS by Paru Itagaki, published by VIZMedia Chris' pick >Our Dreams At Dusk: Shimanami Tasogare by Yuhki Kamatani, published by Seven Seas Zac's pick >Samurai 8: The Tale of Hachimaru by Masashi Kishimoto and Akira Ōkubo, published by Viz Media Megan's pick >Witch Hat Atelier by Kamome Shirahama, licensed by Kodansha Comics Deb's pick >That Blue Sky Feeling by Okura & Coma Hashii, published by Viz Media Chris' bonus pick
Best New Manga for Grown-Ups
>O Maidens in Your Savage Season by Mari Okada & Nao Emoto, published by Kodansha Comics Zac's pick >Skull-face Bookseller Honda-san by Honda, published by Yen Press Chris' pick >Blank Canvas: My So-Called Artist’s Journey by Akiko Higashimura, published by Seven Seas Deb's pick >For the Kid I Saw in My Dreams by Kei Sanbe, published by Yen Press Megan's pick >At The Mountains Of Madness by Gou Tanabe, published by Dark Horse Rob's pick
Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens
>JoJo's Bizarre Adventure by Hirohiko Araki, published by Viz Media Zac's pick >Bleach by Tite Kubo, published by Viz Media Rob's pick >Radiant by Tony Valente, published by Viz Media Megan's pick >Ace of Diamond by Yūji Terajima, published by Kodansha Comics Deb's pick >My Hero Academia by Kōhei Horikoshi, published by Viz Media Chris' pick >Ao Haru Ride by Io Sakisaka, published by Viz Media Megan's bonus pick
>Again!! by Mitsurou Kubo, published by Kodansha Comics Deb's pick >To Your Eternity by Yoshitoki Ōima, published by Kodansha Comics Zac's pick >CITY by Keiichi Arawi, published by Vertical Rob's pick >Golden Kamuy by Satoru Noda, published by Viz Media Chris' pick >Chihayafuru by Yuki Suetsugu, published by Kodansha Comics Megan's pick
Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age
>The Rising of the Shield Hero by Aiya Kyu and Aneko Yusagi, published by One Peace Books Zac's pick >Shibuya Goldfish by Hiroumi Aoi, published by Yen Press Deb's pick >Mob Psycho 100 by ONE, published by Dark Horse Comics Rob's pick >The Seven Deadly Sins by Nakaba Suzuki, published by Kodansa Comics Megan's pick >If It's for My Daughter, I'd Even Defeat a Demon Lord by CHIROLU and Hota., published by Seven Seas Deb's bonus pick
Most Anticipated New Manga
>Metamorphose no Engawa by Kaori Tsurutani, published by Seven Seas Chris' pick >Cats of the Louvre by Taiyo Matsumoto, published by Viz Media Rob's pick >ROADQUEEN: Eternal Roadtrip to Love by Mira Ong Chua Zac's pick >Downfall by Inio Asano, published by Viz Media Megan's pick >A Man and His Cat by Umi Sakurai, published by Square Enix Manga Deb's pick >The Poe Clan by Moto Hagio, published by Fantagraphics Books Deb's extra pick
>Maison Ikkoku by Rumiko Takahashi Zac's pick >Lupin III by Monkey Punch Deb's pick >Even If I Can't Use Magic by Kii Kana Chris' pick >March comes in like a lion by Chica Umino Megan's pick >Junji Ito's Museum of Terror by Junji Ito Rob's pick
Underrated but Awesome Manga
>Captain Harlock by Leiji Matsumoto, published by Seven Seas Zac's pick >Girl from the Other Side by Nagabe, published by Seven Seas Rob's pick >My Hero Academia: Vigilantes by Hideyuki Furuhashi and Betten Court, published by Viz Media Megan's pick >Emanon: Memories of Emanon by Shinji Kaijo and Kenji Tsuruta, published by Dark Horse Comcis Deb's pick >The Drifting Classroom by Kazuo Umezu, published by Viz Media Chris' pick
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >Mob Psycho 100 by ONE, published by Dark Horse Comics Rob's pick At least they got one thing right with saying that MHA:V is underrated.
Also
>Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens >>Bleach by Tite Kubo, published by Viz Media Rob's pick Did I miss Kubo announcing Bleach coming back or something?
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >>Mob Psycho 100 by ONE, Did they actually bother reading it or did they just drop it chapter 1 cause of the art and say its a bad series
Grayson Kelly
>Mob Psycho 100 Is this dude insane
Luke Price
> By Comic-Con International thx no
Ayden Adams
>Hating on Mob What the fuck
Caleb Perry
>Best New Manga for Kids/Teens >Sam 8 yeah, no get that trash out of here
Eli James
>Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens >Bleach by Tite Kubo, published by Viz Media Rob's pick Were they even trying
They probably thought it was a slightly more mature Zootopia murder mystery in a nifty school before it goes full gay and start talking about how fucked up hybrids are
Josiah Moore
>Mob Psycho 100 HOW? I enjoy the anime much more because of the animation quality but Mob Psycho is average at worst.
>best new manga >Sam8 But there's like, 8 chapters or something. I doubt there's even two volumes out. I know it's best "new" manga, but how new really?
>best ongoing >Bleach >Worst for anyone >that list Yeah forget it
Owen Perry
Beastars is a shounen manga retard
Joshua Walker
>Best New Manga for Kids/Teens >BEASTARS Is this the age of the fur?
The dude on the left and the dude on right look like nice guys. The guy next to the guy on the far right looks like a snobby faggot and or an Yea Forums poster
Jaxon Diaz
Hero Academy sucks
Henry Evans
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >Mob Psycho 100 by ONE, published by Dark Horse Comics Rob's pick
>Comic-con >Shounenshit >ANN Yep, it's a neo Yea Forums thread.
Juan Flores
Get fuck mobtards your series is shit and just a fmotm
Nathan Diaz
My kind of funposters.
Hunter White
>The guy next to the guy on the far right looks like a snobby faggot and or an Yea Forums poster Apparently he's the editorial manager for ANN so you're not far off
Levi Cruz
>yes, i think shield hero sucks. How could you tell?
why should i care what some literal who garbage gaijins think about manga?
Camden Perez
I can honestly see how it went, they really judged by the cover and all >ohh this one had cute animals in it, right? Kids will love it, good. >this one is made by the naruto guy, right? Kids loved that! Good. >isn't bleach thay cartoon kids loved like naruto? Good! >this one is for pedophiles, not good
Daniel Jackson
Beastars is good for kids. Shield hero is bad. Libtarded furfaggots, user, libtarded furfaggots.
Ian Cook
And suddenly i feel like it explained itself.
Hunter Hill
How the fuck is anyone supposed to take the opinions of these people seriously?
Gabriel Price
This post is advertising.
Jack Wilson
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >>Mob Psycho 100 by ONE
>Eden Zero best anything >BEASTARS for kids >Samurai 8 best anything >Sorairo Flutter cos' LGBT REPRESENTATION MATTERS >Gaikotsu Shotenin Honda-san best AND for adults >Bleach is ongoing >Radiant is manga and also best anything > Mob Psycho 100 worst for anyone >All those manga picks on the worst for anyone list, considering the hundreds pieces of shit they published this year >All those 3dip5u/artsy manga that are actually good and absolutely no one (including the judges) read and are on lists just to project fake intelligence and elitist snobbery
Yeah, you are just a fucking circle jerking elitist, they said, you are being a fag gatekeeper they said. Manga going mainstream and getting globalized is great they said, its not a gateway to this kind of fucking cancer they said.
Matthew Gutierrez
Is it time to kick boomers out of this fandom?
Parker King
>Mob Psycho 100 >Worst Y'know what they almost had me, most of the best picks deserved it but this choice fucking sunk the entire list
His face looks maybe 25 years old but his hair is like 60 years old. How?
Julian Rivera
That's just what happen when you drink so much soỵ
William Harris
>Did I miss Kubo announcing Bleach coming back or something?
Last I heard it was still getting some light novels every so often. If one stretches the definition of 'continuing' it could count. Still a weird choice though.
>Best New Manga for Grown-Ups >Blank Canvas: My So-Called Artist’s Journey This finished 4 years ago.
>Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens >Ao Haru Ride This also finished 4 years ago.
>Most Anticipated New Manga >ROADQUEEN: Eternal Roadtrip to Love This isn't even a manga. It's an American graphic novel.
Jeremiah Rivera
You Beastars retards thought your series wasn't shounen or what? Even runs right along the likes of Baki the Grappler. Also what's up with the ANN links, has Yea Forums been trying to become Yea Forums by giving attention to the worst cesspools on the internet?
Jackson Perez
>Beastars retards >not Beastards One job
Cooper Sanchez
>ANN Just nuke this fucking thread.
Robert Williams
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >>If It's for My Daughter, I'd Even Defeat a Demon Lord Such shit taste. >Deb's bonus pick Of course it was a fucking woman.
Gavin Martinez
Considering Mashima is in the best new series for teens list, I could only imagine that they just looked at the art and didn't bother reading any of the manga.
Liam Brown
>Best Continuing: Bleach >Continuing >Best: Eden Zero >Worst: Mob
The art of Mob isn't even so bad later on. Yes obviously One got help later on from his assistents when it comes to perspective and anatomy, but he has such a good grasp on displaying emotions and creating interesting atmospheres.
But besides the art this dude completely ignores the story and characters. What a pleb.
Jack Hughes
>itt: people that don't know what shonen means Though the judges don't really either I guess because Maidens of the Savage Season is also a shonen manga.
You made me think Hero Academia got voted worst and I was already really happy Fuck you OP
Alexander Campbell
>BEASTARS >kids
Adrian Brooks
>The Rising of the Shield Hero by Aiya Kyu and Aneko Yusagi, published by One Peace Books Zac's pick feminazis still mad
Brandon Jackson
Mob skizo is overrated trash, finally someone with taste is choosing the winners
Eli Anderson
That's ANN's editor, of course he's hate Shield Hero.
Andrew Cox
>Mob Psycho Bold choice. Never heard of the goldfish one, but a google search tells me it's probably hot garbage.
Brayden Turner
> In the case of Rob picking Mob Psycho 100 as his "Worst", it seems to be that he doesn't think it's bad, per se, but rather is just boring I mean that just seems irresponsible to me. Like does he love every other manga in the world so the one that bored him must be the worst?
Samuel Foster
but, mob is shit, oh...did the choice hurt your feelings?
Alexander Miller
yes, do you consider the most boring one, average at least?
Bentley Torres
The category is for anyone, any age, meaning he can't conceive another taste but theirs.
Jose Nguyen
get fucked hater
Zachary Mitchell
this doesnt answer my question
Kevin Myers
>Edens Zero as Best New Manga for Kids/Teens >Bleach, Radiant as Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens >BnHA Vigilantes as Underrated but Awesome Manga >Mob Psycho 100 as Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age Some of the weirdest/saddest taste I've ever seen.
Jaxon Fisher
This
Hudson Hughes
>Samurai 8: The Tale of Hachimaru How many chapter is this to be considered best new manga?
Andrew Johnson
>No Berserk >No Vinland saga >No Promised Neverland >MOB bad >Nanatsu no Taizai bad >Beastars for kids >Jojo for kids >Bleach ongoing What shit show is this? At least isekai garbage is where it belongs.
Hunter Morris
Mobfags eternally btfo
Nathaniel Ward
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >MP100 stopped reading there.
Isn’t that Zac from ANN? He recently divorced his tranny wife/husband.
Gavin Rodriguez
I've read the whole manga and opm to see if those are worth the chimpout...both are mediocre at best. Can you elaborate why this shitty manga is so beloved?
Jace Bailey
>Worst manga for anyone >Mob Psycho 100 holy fucking based
>Beastars for kids >Jojo for kids Both are shonen manga. Considering it specifies Viz I'm sure he's talking about the stuff before SBR. Likely part 4, which I'm pretty sure is what's being released by Viz right now. Though there are some seinen manga in the "for kids/teens" part (though seinen is older teens I guess for some).
See above. I'm sure he's talking about what's being released by Viz right now, which I think is part 4.
Doesn't seem representative of SDCC overall, it came from a panel run by a bunch of literal whos.
Angel Ortiz
Beastars have explicity sex scenes, and Jojo is hardcore on the violence. First volume already have animal abuse shoved in your face. These people must be idiots to recomend these for kids.
Hunter Roberts
>Ace of Diamond One of the best sport shows, Please read/watch it.
You'd have to be literally retarded(or a teen) to post your picture on Yea Forums because some ugly user(who is probably one of the goblin 5 and OP of this thread) asked you to.
Jayden Hernandez
>and Jojo is hardcore on the violence. Even Shit like My Hero Academia and Naruto can be brutal as hell with gory on page deaths. Fucking even One Piece had a serious on screen kill.
Anyway, Jojo is as shonen as it gets.
Tyler Gomez
WSJ has run plenty of gory scenes, even way more "kid friendly" series on that list like MHA have gore in them.
Alexander Martinez
Jojo's demographic is listed as seinen as well, and it's far more brutal than the average shounen. And Paru never held back on showing the characters having sex or eating each other. Which goes to show how retarded is to list manga in the kids category without reading the full thing. They put Golden Kamuy in the grown up list as well which makes it have even less sense.
Christian Morgan
t. zoomer
Josiah Taylor
>He thinks weak minded american kids can compare to japanese
Ayden Turner
You can tell it's the same guy because he thinks blotches of blood in My Baby Academia are comparable to actual gore.
Connor Roberts
Let's not forget that this and Kimetsu are running in Jump right now and are very gory. Also To Love Ru ran in Jump
To be fair, Golden Kamuy is serialized in Young Jump
the last few chapters of MHA have shown someone's hand getting ripped apart, and a women getting shredded into pieces. It's not Jojo tier but it's still gore
Lincoln Flores
I have to give them credit for unknowingly creating the best bait possible. It has something to confuse and or piss everyone off.
No, it isn't. There's no viscera or exposed organs in those chapters. Chunks of blood flying like tomato sauce is cartoon violence, not gore. An example of actual gore in Shonen manga is pic related from HxH.
>Jojo's demographic is listed as seinen as well Only SBR after chapter 25 and JJL. Everything before is shonen. Not arguing that the lists don't make much sense, since you're right, there are seinen mixed in and also shonen in the "for adults" categories. But people are specifically picking out Beastars despite it definitely being aimed at kids and teens by virtue of the magazine it's running in.
Carter Gonzalez
It's barely gore, we haven't seen any organs or dilacerated people, just some blood and a few cuts. The wildest Hori has ever been was this.
Cultures cultures. If they label beastars as "for kids", for example, some dumbass might buy it for their 5 years old. While shounen actually means 12 and up.
Interesting I thought shonen was meant for a little younger than twelve and could go higher Never knew it wasn't actually intended for below 12
Ryan Clark
>Comic-Con >ANN >shit opinions Why even make a thread of these irrelevant faggots? Kill yourself.
Dylan Walker
If we went by what the US considers for kids and not then nothing would be for kids. Even stuff for little kids in Japan have had to be censored for airing on American TV and manga is generally more explicit even with stuff aimed at kids.
I don't know if there's any actual cutoff. It's pretty variable I imagine. Though the category this thread is about is "kids/teens" which covers pretty much whatever the entire range of shonen is.
Jordan Cook
not on the same level
shounen is not a genre. I'm amazed how a fucking anime board doesn't get this and perpetrates this fucking retard fallacy.
Attack on Titan is shounen. JoJo is published on a seinen magazine btw. Hokuto no Ken was published in shounen but was reprinted or changed to seinen too.
They are demographics, you goddamn imbeciles.
Angel Flores
Unh why is bleach there when it ended years ago
Nathan Brown
12 and up means cutoff so not meant for 11 or 10 year olds.
Matthew Reed
>JoJo is published on a seinen magazine btw Now it is, but not the stuff currently being released by Viz in the US, which is what that guy is talking about.
Lucas Rivera
Its both. Genre's can be more than one thing Shonen is a genre named after its target demographic Like Horror is a genre named after the feeling So if you say >horror is not a genre. I'm amazed how a fucking board doesn't get this and perpetrates this fucking retard fallacy. >its a feeling, you goddamn imbeciles Then you are a huge fucking retard.
Christopher Stewart
They are all too fat to matter.
Gabriel Bennett
>>Lupin III by Monkey Punch Deb's pick
You know what. Deb's alright.
Gabriel Rivera
>Even stuff for little kids in Japan have had to be censored for airing on American TV Meanwhile, Jojo's domestic airing is entirely blacked out.
Kayden Parker
Cuck Clover & Shit Piece not even mentioned. Kek.
Aaron Bell
Stuff like Pokemon, yokai watch and yugioh is what's actually intended for really young kids.
Zac is a man, but it’s easy to mistake such a whiny personality for being a woman’s.
Nathaniel Myers
Based
Aaron Campbell
So what is that called?
Justin Lee
Kodomomuke.
But, Yu-Gi-Oh! was published in a shounen magazine and it's regarded as such, that poster is retarded.
Pokemon and Yokai Watch I can see being aimed for children from the start
Ryan Brown
Actually, Kodomomuke seems more directed to younger children and teaching them stuff.
As I said, it's not a genre. If it's an anime original, it was not published in any magazine.
That's EXACTLY what I was talking about. This board keeps talking about shounen, seinen, etc as if they genres, and the majority of you retards think that.
It's not a fucking genre. Yeah, i know, mind blown. Now go along.
Blake Diaz
I guess the next sensible and rational course of action to take is to buy and own furries.
Connor Morris
Honestly, I'm kinda stunned that with all the Lupin stuff coming out lately that absolutely nobody has thought to get the license to reprint the manga.
Brandon Reed
Japanese kids love this shit
Jacob Ward
>Maison Ikkoku by Rumiko Takahashi Zac's pick Surprised that's not licensed when pretty much every other Rumiko manga is. I thought it was pretty well known?
Jason King
>Best Continuing Series for Kids/Teens >JoJo's Bizarre Adventure by Hirohiko Araki, published by Viz Media Zac's pick It makes sense, almost all of the jojofags on Yea Forums are underage and have only ever touched 3 series.
Blake Brown
>this fanbase I don't like doesn't even read manga and is made up of little kids That's only the animeonlies.
Noah Mitchell
I don’t like Jojo as a series and it’s fanbase. The only part I was actually interested in was the second half of Part 7. The rest seems redundant and repeated because Araki can only write the same character but give them different clothes.
Christian Howard
oh so you haven't read any of it. good to know
Jace Hernandez
What? When did I say that I didn’t read any of it? I’ve read up all the way up to part 7. I just said that I was more invested in the second half of part 7 because it was the most interesting and characters had actual development. Sorry if I didn’t make that clear enough to you.
Elijah Robinson
>By Comic-Con International And I'm supposed to care because?
Cooper Rogers
You entered a thread about something you dont care about because?
Kevin Diaz
> animenewsnetwork
right, the sjw website that smeared the shit outta Vic with fake lies. Why the fuck would you link to this cancer site?
Alexander Ross
They're advertising their shit opinion and click bait article on Yea Forums. I'm surprised the thread hasn't been pruned
Cameron Russell
This.
Charles Hall
>trying too hard
Aaron Sanders
Why do amerisharts have manga awards when only 20% of it gets translated?
William Thompson
because he isnt in middle school
Luis Morris
boring is the worst thing a piece of entertainment could be
Colton Gutierrez
he looks like someone who likes middle schoolers
James Phillips
Viz published Maison Ikkoku back in the early 2000s. Chances are they probably actually still have the license or will reacquire it eventually in order to do a re-release like with Ranma 1/2 and Urusei Yatsura.
Hunter Mitchell
This. Beastars will never be shounen no matter what bullshit you tell me
Jordan Sanders
We don't know if he's got any copies of Rurouni Kenshin, user.
Kayden Gomez
>a series in a shonen magazine isn't shonen Are you a hunterfag too?
Leo Roberts
>Worst Manga for Anyone, Any Age >Mob Psycho 100 by ONE, published by Dark Horse Comics Rob's pick Was any justification given?
Joshua Smith
I didn't know kids liked interspecies sex that much.
>In the case of Rob picking Mob Psycho 100 as his "Worst", it seems to be that he doesn't think it's bad, per se, but rather is just boring
Easton Morris
Wait, Beastars actually talks about how fucked up hybrid kids are?
Anthony Perez
Most of the shit that gets licensed overseas is shonenshit.
Matthew Anderson
On paper is all that matters. The magazine's target audience is kids and young to mid teens. There's no unifying content measure that separates shonen and seinen as there are plenty of seinen that are more family friendly reads than some shonen series, though it has a higher ceiling for content that will fly.
Levi Walker
It's not a poll. It's 5 obese retards who are egotistical enough to think they can make such grand claims based on their own shit taste.
OP is either one of them or the ANN article author fishing for clicks. >The worst manga part may shock you.
Next we'll be discussing youtubers like in Yea Forums.
>They're still seething about the slavery and rape accousation That must be it, typical SJW bullshit by a bunch of fags coopting the manga scene. I mean, i despise all isekai but it's not the worst one out there.
Easton Hill
Ugly people truly are worthless inside and out.
Adrian Walker
Oh yeah, it's pretty redpilled if you take certain liberties with the context. But don't forget, it's written by a woman so eventually inter racial relationships win every time. Gotta stop feeling guilty for lusting after the BWC.
Sebastian Miller
>those Worst Manga >Most Anticipated: A Man and his Cat, Cats of the Louvre, Roadqueen Yeah, the "jury" are women.
Connor Cruz
Big spoilers. Current damage: >1) severe mental retardation, shameless lolicon, criminally delinquent >2) extreme mental illness, culminating in suicide >3) serial killer, vile sexual inclinations, prone to acts of physical and emotional violence, and guilty of crimes against all forms of life (pictured)
Dunno what everyone's so surprised about. Basically everybody that got into anime and manga when they were in college back in the 80s and 90s looks like this. Sometimes worse.
