1:If it does not follows exact same laws of physics and quantum mechanics in real life, no matter how the scientific is the methodology in manga, can never be scientific. It will be fantasy.
2:The production of nital were totally wrong. No way they would get a ethanol pure enough with those low quality wine with low grapes. They would only get vinegar.
3:Senku should have explain every single detail of why nitric acid were made from bat's shit.
4:The author should have written an entire ark to build up or looking for a laboratory with same quality as current year laboratory. Them he should try for nital to depetrification.
5:He solved the problem of petrification in ep1. Something that should only be solved near THE LAST CHAPTER AS CLIMAX.
6:This petrification shit does not exists in real life. The manga itself should not exist since this and being scientific is the premise. The author should have hired university professors before making the plot itself.
Also all shonen manga is shit because of Friendship, Effort, Victory ideology. This ideology is the reason of why they bend the plot to absurd levels. Betreyal, Talent(with no effort), Defeat makes better works.
You actually put some effort into your bait, nice job!Here´s your (you)
Aiden Murphy
>defies the laws of physics and quantum mechanics Explain >this is fantasy, not science What gave it away? The whole “3700 year petrification” or the “counting for 3700 years”?
Kevin King
>The author should have written an entire ark to build up or looking for a laboratory with same quality as current year laboratory. Them he should try for nital to depetrification. proof you're not even reading
Bentley Edwards
Both of those. The entire premise of the manga is being scientific but the author put petrification in this shit. If petrification is there in manga it's not scientific. Also the cure by depetrification itself is scientifically impossible bullshit.
Blake Bell
it is a educational gag manga >but it is not 100% realistic!!11!!one!!! it is not suposed to, it is meant for teenagers.
Ryan Barnes
>He solved the problem of petrification in ep1. Something that should only be solved near THE LAST CHAPTER AS CLIMAX. This one is actually a pretty interesting one if only as a thought experiment. How would the story have proceeded if Senkuu was the only modern person? Assuming he could somehow ingratiate himself with the villagers, could he have proceeded on his path to South America in the same manner? A lot wouldn't have really changed. Tsubasa's empire as the first antagonists is a role that could have easily filled by some random tribe of grunts. But then again, there are some specialized skills that the modern people have that Senkuu couldn't teach the village because he didn't know himself, e.g., extreme sewing, ship captaining, radar/sonar. Plus, if it's just him, you're getting closer to isekai territory. I know your intentions were inflammatory, OP, but that was an interesting point regardless.
Adrian Harris
Will you fuck off already. Why are you so obsessed?
Jayden Scott
So how long until we see the baaaad man of the hour?
>If petrification is there in the manga it's not scientific No. A part of it is not scientific. It doesn't erase the fact that the whole manga is about real inventions and the intricacies of making them
Stop replying to shitposting threads retards even if you think you have something worthwhile to say. And if you’re going to reply to them at least sage
Dylan Scott
Ep 10 or less
Nolan Davis
>petrification >defying the laws of physics as we know it along with quantum mechanics ???
Christopher Torres
>If it does not follows exact same laws of physics and quantum mechanics in real life, no matter how the scientific is the methodology in manga, can never be scientific. It will be fantasy The only fantastical elements are the superhuman characters, everything else in the series has fallen under science fiction and the genre always bend the laws or skirt on the possibility of what science can do.
Xavier Perez
please stop wasting energy on OP
Matthew Collins
He’s not reading this, he just wants his thread to hit bump limit again. Stop replying
Carter Brown
Nobody cares about the opinions of animeonlys
Ryder Hernandez
Calm down dude, it's just a japanese kids cartoon
Angel Robinson
>4:The author should have written an entire ark to build up or looking for a laboratory with same quality as current year laboratory. Them he should try for nital to depetrification.
except the fact that its 3700 years in the future where nothing is left standing.
Juan Ortiz
nice blog. Where can I subscribe?
Isaiah Turner
this is what happens when a rick & morty fan meet anime
Jaxon Green
Stonefags are rick & morty fans themselves just look at this thread. Tho they are dumb enough to reply to bait.
Hudson Foster
why are people so anti intellectualism here? Does this show threaten your small brain?
Henry Gray
grats user your so fuckin smart
Ryan Gonzalez
Reasons why this post is shit 1.
Matthew Ramirez
>If it does not follows exact same laws of physics and quantum mechanics in real life, no matter how the scientific is the methodology in manga Ok I'll bite, which exact laws of physics are being violated? Could you elaborate on how quantum mechanics is relevant in this discussion at all? Even the hardest science fiction still has some handwaving. >>The production of nital were totally wrong. I'd be more worried about them procuring nitric acid. Nitric acid does not occur in bat caves and especially not at high concentrations. Potassium nitrate does, however they did not process to make nitric acid. You have revealed yourself to be a brainlet.
Camden Diaz
IMBECILE! That's carbonic acid not nitric acid! And of course said carbonic acid is dilute. We should also expect any such nitric acid to be produced to be dilute too.
Jonathan Jackson
Since you can't read and comprehend a four-panel infographic with any amount of competence, your ability to do so with a long-running manga is suspect as well. H2SO4 + 2KNO3 = K2SO4 + 2HNO3
Liam Russell
yeah and japan certainly doesn't have much oil so that's pretty unbelievable. In addition, Cueva de Villa Luz, one of the caves in question has bat populations, but no significant quantities of sulfuric acid have been found. Still we should not expect nitric acid to be produced at significant concentrations.
Asher Collins
And yet it's popular.
Logan Ross
This thread is proof that science simply can't be in anime. You faggots can't handle it without sperging over every tiny thing.
Connor Robinson
It’s just poorly written
Dominic Russell
He never woke up. He counted to a few thousand or so and then started dreaming about how smart he was and other nonsense.
William Collins
>can't take criticism
Evan Cruz
The reason why people are shitting on this show so much is because they think it's supposed to be something that it's not trying to be.
It isn't trying to be some hyper realistic super intelligent science manga about the eccentricities of chemistry and physics. It's just a shounen that has this premise. Humanity was turned to stone for thousands of years and now technology and civilization needs to be rebuilt. If it was realistic, people would nothing but tribes retards and it would focus on the character drama where the physically strong dominate the weak and the breakdown of modern morals. But instead the premise is about getting technology back as fast as possible and watching the progression rather than fucking around in the woods for 100 chapters hoping to maybe to build a farm at most. Senku as a character is there to fit the plot. He's unrealistically smart in order to unrealistically develop technology at an unreasonable pace.
You people are taking the show too seriously.
Thomas White
Hold up. So this isn't meant to be the anime version of Rick and Morty? I've been watching this show wrong all along.
Luis Rodriguez
>*37661 *136161 Jujutsu Kaisen #06 >*28057 **89891 act-age #07 >*24860 **81274 Dr. Stone #11 Here is your aots bro
