Attached: 1559118830265.png (424x324, 347K)
The Great Debate
Jacob Ward
Other urls found in this thread:
desuarchive.org
thelibraryofohara.com
khooz.com
twitter.com
Ethan Carter
"In a debate, opposing arguments are put forward to argue for opposing viewpoints."
They're both trash though.
Bentley Martinez
Once an OP virgin, now a titan chad, anyone else?
Camden Campbell
I don't see a debate.
Isaac Jones
They're both trash though.
Kevin Martin
Angel Anderson
Both are cancerous shits.
Adrian Cooper
One Piece has better word building ad art, SnK has better storytelling and characters
Dominic Wilson
t. contrarians
Benjamin Gonzalez
They don't seem similar at all.
It isn't like we live in a meritocracy where things are judged and ranked. AoT has some fun things in it and OP has many great things in it. Im sure if AoT was as long as OP it would have just as many moments, but I doubt it will have the longevity of OP.
Aaron Myers
T. People who refuse to read SnK manga and pretend to have the right to judge it
Justin Allen
>T. People who refuse to read SnK manga and pretend to have the right to judge it
t. fucking retard who think someone who bashe AoT only bashing the manga.
Worry not faggot, I read the manga and it's as cancerous as a story can get.
Brody Allen
Good goy, keep shilling literal government-mandated propaganda. I bet you loved Franxx too.
Jonathan Lopez
The one that's ending soon. One Piece has been ongoing for twice as long and still nowhere near its goddamn end.
Jackson Moore
One Piece is not trash,I've realized that people in this thread only want to see tits and butts.But every fucking series in this thread is called trash,fuck u all dude
Adrian Johnson
This.
Kevin Roberts
I still like One Piece but I think SnK is more interesting these days.
Leo Ramirez
No contest :^)
Easton Walker
>a story about war,gray morals,nationalism,racial hatred,sufference,cycle of hatred,fatherhood and pass of the burden.
>bhuuuu just a shitty manga with breading morale!!!!!!!
Liam Russell
SnK died after the reveal, all the mystery and potential wasted on a shitty political drama.
>but muh filter
Being a contrarian doesn't make you an unique special snowflake grow up
Grayson Butler
What is cancerous in SnK?!
The characters are well written (most of them), the morals are interesting, the story was mostly planned since the first chapter and the twist are foreshadowed and well written.Also the story got a big inprouve after the timeskip and right now is the best ongoing shonen manga.
Your hateboner is literally pathetic, why you can't just accept that someone you used to call shit actually became good?
Charles Lewis
peak OP > SnK
Jose Walker
It's literally a story about muh nazis and muh jews where Marleyans are obviously the bad guys since modern Eldians literally did nothing wrong and don't deserve their fate.
Kill yourself if you think this is deep.
Hunter Torres
>people used to insult this manga because it used to look like the usual "horror survival shonen"
> now people insult this manga because it became a " deep and political war story" like the author alwais planned it to be
You are just hypocrite.
Brandon Rivera
>the story was mostly planned since the first chapter
David Jackson
Naruto is "about" those things too. What matters is execution. And SnK turned out to be another breeding propaganda piece by Shinzo Abe. Expect more platitudes about muh next generation as the story ends.
SnK is not well written. See Armin stating the obvious that Eren was co-erced by Yelena through the wine plot and how he's obviously not on Zeke's side. Not to mention nonsense of Ymir committing essentially committing suicide because it would be too early to reveal the outside world make it abundantly clear that Isayama sees this series as a milking cow. He is far too willing to suspend logic to create false tension and forced mystery.
The end was spelled when he admitted to changed the ending midway through to appeal to fans after the series exploded in popularity.
Zachary Myers
You are wrong, the marleyans are just normal people who live in their world, in the good and in the bad, while eldians are just people who want to survive , and even them are both good and bad.
Eren literally started an attack on liberio's ghetto, killing thousands of innocent people who had nothing to do with the war between paradis and marley.
Asher Lopez
>deep and political war story
There's nothing deep about it you mong, go read a book and stop being such a dumb nigger.
>people shouldn't be held accountable for the actions of their ancestors
BRO WTF THIS IS SO DEEP I'M LITERALLY SHAKING MIND BLOWN LMAO HUMANITY WAS A MISTAKE
Brody Garcia
You completely missed the point you dumb fuck.
No Eldian is bad when considering why they are treated like second class citizens, literally none of them are responsible for what their ancestors did. The Marleyans responsible for the treatment of Eldians in Marley are obviously bad guys, and the average Marleyan that knows how Eldians are treated but does nothing about it also shares some of the guilt.
This is how retarded SnK faggots are
Robert Gonzalez
-Naruto did one of the shittiest work the explore those themes, while SnK succeded in that.
-ymir death was because she wanted help BR since she felt guilty for what she did to them 5 years ago (and also due Marcel's memories influences). Porco did some similar to save reiner like the last chapter, so is also the nature of the jaw titan be a selfless person (just like the attacker alwais seek the fredom)
Juan Gomez
Your hate boner is literally pathetic, i have never seen people so closed mind like you. Enjoy your shitty series but stop saying SnK is trash while it objectly isn't.
Levi Lewis
stop comparing the greatest manga of all time, SnK, to kid shit like wan piss.
Jackson Phillips
>get absolutely BTFO
>no arguments
STOP HATING MUH OBJECTIVELY GOOD ANIMU NOOOOO
What a fucking brainlet, lmao. SnK fags, everyone.
Zachary Thomas
This, stop making fun of SnK! How will we get those goddamned otaku to breed if you keep doing that?
Luis Thomas
It's literally the most deepest and intellectually stimulating shonen and you can't prove me wrong.
Stop the hate and go away please.
Jacob Gomez
So explein me YOUR argoument to say that SnK is shit!
Explein it way if you have an actual motivation to said it outside "POPULAR MEAN SHIT1111".
Luis Reyes
SnK is garbage as it's already explained in this thread and can't even come close to matching One Piece in themes or storytelling. All of your shitty series don't even add up to 5% of the geopolitics, history, connections, sociopolitical exploration and themes of One Piece.
Hunter Murphy
>The characters are well written
0/10 bait, didn't even read the rest of your post.
Luis Gutierrez
Multiple people have told you over and over the writing flaws of SnK and you just dismiss them with "durr u dun like cuz it popular" and baselessly asserting that the series is good because it tries to address the same themes as Naruto. Honestly you fags are pathetic and it's telling that most of your fanbase are shipperfaggots.
Jaxon Sanders
even bnha is better than snk
Daniel Baker
Are you drunk? There is literally no consistency in OP, the mangaka is just milking that manga for like 20 years without a proper plannification.
Ryan Ortiz
Holy shit, I really hope you're just joking with this post.
Henry Carter
Why are ESLs so attached to comicbook storytelling being deep and better than other comics? Is it because they can't read anything else?
Connor Nguyen
Are kidding right?!
It was kinda good until ALLMIGHT retire, after that it went down to the 7 Quirk bs
Benjamin Parker
Can you blame him? He has lost so much because of marleyans and their hate toward the Eldians. It is only justice to fight back. Using the wepons that they are using themselves against you. They could have used the Titans to instill fear in the Eldians.. but that wasnt enough. They wanted to exterminate them. Sending the Colosal Titan, The Armored titan, Female titan. You would probably do the same. Surounded on all sides by giant titans that eat you, just because...And an enemy on the other side of the sea that plots your destruction. In the safety of their homes. You would want to use whatever you have to destroy them... Because justice.
Aiden Perry
Pic related, than add zeke,erwin,Rod,Kenny,pixis,zackery and Jean.
They are all realistic and human characters, while the secoundary are still interesting and entertaining.
Christian Johnson
AOT is edgelord shit for chuunis
Carter Scott
>SNK is my first manga/anime
Spotted
Jaxon Cook
>antagonist is a watered down JRPG villain that wants to castrate his own race to end their suffering
Angel Carter
SnK have literally nothing to do with Naruto outside the 9 titans/9 beasts (eccept that the 9 titans are well explored and balanced with their own weaknes and advantage, and not OP like the 9 beasts).
Stop comparing it with that shit, SnK did good with his own themes because the manga planned it (at least like the 80% of the story)
Austin Mitchell
Madara?
Luke Campbell
Both series are examples of an author planning things out instead of just making shit up from chapter-to-chapter.
Hudson Wilson
>Historia
Literally a baby-making factory. Plot device tier.
>Shitren
His "development" is off screen during a timeskip. That's peak hack writing.
>Reiner
Flashbacks, flashbacks, and more flashbacks. Split personality is treated as a gimmick. Naruto tier.
Not going to bother demantling the other garbage characters you unironically listed like fucking Jean and the bootleg JRPG villain.
Nathaniel Cruz
OP is a grand long adventure and SnK is short
Aiden Turner
no faggit you just have zero objections to them being good characters.
Easton Perez
I don't blame eren, i just pointed the fact that both marleyans and eldians are not good and bad at all. The only evil one are the politician and militaries who , drunk of the potential of the titan powers (first the eldian rulers and later the marleyan superiors) and used it to obtain power over the world.
Michael Diaz
>Founding Titan/Ymir -> Kaguya
>9 Bijuus -> 9 Titans
>overcome cycle of hatred and tyranny (totally different than Nardo!)
>muh breeding propaganda "importance of the next generation"
>both MCs have their titan/bijuu thrust upon them by their fathers
>both end on a war arc
The only major difference is that SnK has a more gritty/realistic setting which fools teenagers into thinking it's more mature. If anything, Naruto did a better job elucidating the nature of cyclical conflict.
Robert Hernandez
Ahahahhaha sorry fag but NO.
I have read a lot of them in my life,some bad (like TG) amd others good (assasination classroom, berserk, kimi no knife,JoJo,kenshin etc....)
Oliver Bailey
>storytelling
The protagonists meet opponents a little bit stronger than them, but not enough so they can win and fight the next bad guy.
Kek is this even storytelling or a shitty video game plot? Please kys.
Angel Myers
ITT: everyone laugh at SnKfags
Joshua Sanders
EH is cute and canon btw
Jordan Garcia
Based
Aaron Martin
>Sabaody
>Impel Down
>Jaya
>Marineford
>Zou
>Whole Cake Island
>Reverie
Now shitpost more because your manga got BTFO, SnK babby.
Based
Christopher Garcia
Historia: a normal girl who just want to live her life as she alwais wanted, but had to became queen for the sake of her country.
Eren: a boy who wanted to be free and avenge his mother only to find out how weak and miserable he alwais was, and after have find out the truth of his world he understood that he have no other way to save the people he love eccept became a monster.
Reiner: a boy who wanted to became an hero and be loved by his dad, but he ended up being a killer and shorten his life just because their world is cruel
Luis Moore
This post has to be fake lmao, SnKfags have zero self-awareness
Oliver Parker
>eren self inserters
Nathan Ward
What debate? One piece is a poorly drawn, poorly written, overmilked cow shit that will never end
Jace Roberts
Let me ask you something
What big and rich jew did hitler persecute? I mean the ones of the big capital like the rothschild
Why were almost all the big companies owners that hitler had friendship with, and used for the reconstruction of germany plan, jews?
You are so fucking ignorant and yet you idolize a cryptojew and zionist
Julian Edwards
>The characters are well written (most of them)
Aaron Moore
*titanemo
Angel Sullivan
One Piece is for little babies
Shingeki is for us middle ages people in their 90's
Kayden Collins
true, let virgins seethe
James Morgan
>SNK's world is literally just alternate historical earth
>another timeskip after the basement reveal for muh mystery with why Eren changed so much
Great worldbuilding
Aiden Bailey
Colton Bell
>Copying land borders from a popular novel to further reinforce that muh marlehuan ebil nazi
Adam Edwards
>shingeki no chuuni
>stimulating
Alexander Foster
dude I would also discriminate the fuck out of eldians knowing that if they drink or inhale titan jizz they become mindless monsters, and that if the 9 aren't kept at bay they could manifest in any random eldian baby giving them essentially a nuke from birth
marley did nothing wrong
Benjamin Nguyen
>shounentards uniting against kino
lmao