What are some examples of bad manga to anime adaptations?
One Punch Man
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
uh... most adaptations
Here's the Anime for comparison with the OP Manga image.
name me anime where it better than original source.
i can't even count it in one hand.
How bad can it be when the manga is already a horrible adaptation of the webcomic?
K-On and Lucky Star. I think 4-koma is the manga style that will have better anime unless they completely drop the ball somehow.
FMA b, go figure Bones animated that series too.
both of them barely count as "adaptation". more like loosely inspired.
that seems like a shitty response I could give to most adaptations to completely side an arguement
Garo's theme is great.
Who wins?
Ironic since the manga is a terrible adaptation of webcomic
Yeah but just like Saitama's theme I can already see them overusing it, I started laughing when Saitama's theme once again came up during a flashback with Glasses.
Also JC Staff gloss over Glasses punching Garou, the panel registered for 10 frames total (.4 seconds)
GORO OF COURSE
>atleast this shot looked cool
Glasses is Murata's self-insert that's why he's trying to make him cool
Not really an adaption but the Samurai Champloo manga is always the first one when I think about a manga being worse than the anime. It basically has nothing that people liked about the anime besides the 3 main characters.
This whole scene was pretty good
LOOK HOW THEY MURDERED MY BOY!!!
Well yes I have to give it to this episode, except of the usual 30 seconds of quality we got like 2 minutes this time. Bravo JC
actually good animation comming through
If you get rid of the CGI chains and the weird shaking, look, and sound of Garou holding Wild Horn over the arrows then yeah it would have been great. Maybe change the Shooter body reaction to the rocks thrown at him too.
The list of good ones would be shorter
The whole Superfight arc.
Metal Bat vs Garou
Suiryu vs Saitama
Evangelion, AoT.
Good thing they didnt animate the rock smashing fist, clearly they were running of the budget toward the end of the episode.
Apparently the sound designer for Berserk 2017 is in charge of this season of OPM - the clang man himself. What a joke.
How does he have a job? How can you be this cheap?
How come no one mentioned this page?
Here he looked very angry while in the anime Gatling was portrayed as a complete villain.
Gatling's expressions were fucked.
One S2 ends, the first thing they need to do is fire the sound director.
Maria the Virgin Witch
> Garou keeps shit talking about how S heroes are so much better than them
> Gatling just gets angry about that, he doesn't mention S heroes out of nowhere, just in answer to Garou mentioning them
> Garou then says he's the only one fixated on ranks
Garou is hilariously hypocritical, he's been talking non stop about fighting S heroes since his introduction.
Because they are the strongest you stupid faggot, are you retarded.
Are you? Garou mocks Gatling for mentionning hero ranks, whe he's the first to do that.
All shit, especially tournament.
Because Garou is accurately using it as an indicator of how strong they are, not as being heroic like Gatling.
Also not saying the S class rank on its own can be used as an indicator of strength.
Its like anime was telling you Gatling was the monster the whole time.
>not as being heroic like Gatling.
It's not just about being heroic. Gatling is pissed that him and his below S comrades are being called useless.
more like nonexistent, he looks like a fucking ham
Because they kind of are.
Here is one
They did a fairly good job at fighting Garou. They're not useless tho, just unable to fight the high level threats. S class are limited in numbers, for one thing.
The only bad thing were the sound effects.
>S class are limited in numbers, for one thing.
Whose fault is that?
>high level threats
Which increase every day
I don't see anyone being worthy of the S class popping up.
The series does a good job at making Garou look like the good guy at times. There would have been so many other ways to not have Tareo involved into this, but instead of like telling Tareo to come out and leave, his boner for heroism took over and he "protected" him from a situation he shouldn't have been in, in the first place.
Garou's first real proper act of heroism is protecting Tareo from BG and RR. But here again Tareo got involved because of Garou. Garou attracts bad shit to Tareo and then protects him, it's kind of fucked.
>Whose fault is that?
Nobody. Just shows lower tier heroes are still fairly important to take on the numerous lower tier threats.
Woah... Deep...
He really isn't though.
>lower tier heroes
They are at fault you stupid faggot, they aren't getting stronger
Only till now we've seen heroes actually caring about becoming stronger and it has been a central aspect of the past few arcs in the webcomic.
There is one we've seen that is close to becoming S class if he keeps it up, Glasses. But that's it.
>There is one we've seen that is close to becoming S class if he keeps it up, Glasses.
Dude is still weaker than Eyelashes for now.
Last few seconds were nice but the beginning was shit like always
You mean the boom thing that was straight out of DBS.
ONE tries his hardest to show Garou as a dindu nuffin from the very introduction in the redraw. I think the whole shed drama was kinda predictable and shallow.
I wouldn't be so bothered by it if people weren't such brainlets and immediatly interpreted it as "garou good, heroes bad".
In a way, the way ONE does it is interesting and likely does that on purpose but lots of the readers are too shallow to get it.
Why is this show so good?
I can only imagine what kind of a fat, smelly mouthbreather you most likely are. I can almost smell the cheetos from here
Because you really like generic shounenshit.
JCbros....
>outdone by a gif
What a shitty fucking industry, holy shit.
Anime almost made tournament watchable, that's one hell of a feat.
kill la kill did it pretty good.
On the right an actual character with actual emotions
On the left a bland fucking slice of meat
Golden boy
I thought the anime was the original source
Mob Psycho, SNK, Bobobo, Baccano, HxH, Ping Pong, Kara no Kyoukai(except of part 6) etc. and that's just from the top of my head.
Literally OPM season 1 you giant fucking retard.
Seto No Hanayome
kek
>when playing games is harder than real life
>this season of OPM will have worse animation than fucking One Piece
youtube.com
Can JCfags ever recover from this?
nobody cares serieswarfag, take it to
Was talking about animation not quality of the series faggot.
>Written by the same author expanding on his story but with MUCH better art
Webcomicfags are so fucking retarded, being a contrarian faggot is not cool.
The webcomic is shit and filler. Manga would be so much better as a plain shounen with Saitama not existing and Blast appearing as the ultimate weapon of the heroes.
Why was Garou such an asshole in his introduction? Ripping that hero's arm and mashing Mumen's head ont he pavement, he wasn;t that mich of an asshole even as Monster Garou.
Reread the webcomic, he was always a twat, and he even attacked saitama when he thought he was just a normal pedestrian.
You think it didn't hurt?
Saitama is a selfish prick.
Why do people think he's always right?
might makes right. no one could stop him if they tried. he could punch the earth into tiny pieces, then jump to a new habitable planet and live there.
>provides absolute nothing to back up his claims
The state of opmfags and their tiny brains.
Not really. S1 anime pales if you compare it to the manga.
>Opm brainlets that literally compare Murata's work, slightly modified, with the anime
kek.
yeah the sound effects are literally bollywood/north africa action movie tier
>next episode, garou vs bang!
youtube.com
animation occured too fast, should have been slower as with other pacing issues this season
I'd have to agree.
Agree and animation too
Did they ruin this shot too? They didn't got a single thing right
Most people don't even know that Evangelion had a manga. Although the series' pilot was a TV anime, the manga launched first. It came 2 or 3 months before the TV anime, but ended like 13 years after it.
It was a little better in the anime, because they show Garou's aura and Taero's reaction. The shading was way different, though.
The entire Junji Ito anime.
I want to forget about it.
GURU IN THE DARK
But it was just smoke coming from behind him.
>those derp eyes
the orange hair was fucking stupid
It's a set up to show how retarded his cardboard cosplay looked at the end of the arc.
It will never look like cardboard cosplay in the manga.
Sure garoufag
honestly I was looking forward to this week's episode purely for this moment and it was so fucking poorly done
It's fire red and it's a fucking based color.
Your taste is just shit.