whos read this?
gimme yo thoughts on it
Vagabond
It's shit. Don't read it. There is literally nothing good about it.The story is bland and generic. It is hard to follow. And nothing interesting happens. Dropped it after 2 chapters. desu I wonder why all the fags that like it rave on about it so much?
that muh aeshtethic samurai nujabes bebop look man...
SHIT
Its cool, I liked it.
Sorry it isn't ADHD rasengan shadow clone spammy enough for you. Some manga are just too high brow for you.
It's on my backlog and I'll probably never get to it
I read the first three volumes, the arts nice too early to judge the story yet but it seems promising.
When I'm not so poor I'll buy the rest.
It's amazing, but the lack of a proper ending really hurts it.
Also the Eastern philosophy stuff can be a bit too much at times.
>t. Takehiko Inoue
It is pretty much directly stolen from Eiji Yoshikawa's novel "Musashi". You might even call it cartoon adaptation of the novel.
I'd recommend you read the novel itself. It's better than the comic. It explains more about the characters, their motivations, the world around them and everything in general.
It's actually fairly easy to read (depending on the translation version) and a bit more realistic than the comic.
Great art. It's my fourth favorite samurai manga in story, second favorite in art.
yeah and the novel actually fucking ends
Yeah. The comic veers off the storyline at one point and does shit that doesn't take place in the book.
Unironically a masterpiece.
>There is literally nothing good about it.The story is bland and generic. It is hard to follow. And nothing interesting happens.
>Dropped it after 2 chapters
Holy fucking kek
best manga ever made and whoever says otherwise is a moefaggot speedreading chimp
literally the only good manga
it's literally an adaptation of the novel. It is listed as such and Inoue does not pretend like it isn't.
Are you going to criticise lord of the rings next for being a ripoff of Tolkiens novel?
Wasn't exactly criticism. I just wasn't sure if it was a direct adaptation or "loosely based upon" or "shameless ripoff".
And I was too lazy to check it out.
So if the author says it out loud that it's direct adaptation, then that's ok. He's allowed to draw such an adaptation. Nothing wrong with that.
Still doesn't alter my point which was "read the book, it's better than the comic."
I personally haven't read the novel but the manga is already a masterpiece imo.
Even if the novel is better, Inoue's composition, layout and art add immensely to an already strong character story.
I might actually read the novel though since it is one of my favorite manga.
Are the translations any good? Cause I hate reading a good book that's reduced in quality because of shitty translations like what happened with the legend of the galactic heroes novels.
I loved it, one of my favorites.
I think one would enjoy the story more if one likes samurai themes and knows a bit about the period and Musashi himself - but not a requirement.
Great art.
Kojiro is not deaf in the novel.
so? Adaptations change things.
It's based on the novel. I didn't say it was a direct translation to manga. There are a lot of other things that are different.
good but the plot is a bit of a mess
Can't really say anything about English translations.
I read mine in Finnish.
Finnish translations are generally very good quality. Due to flexibility of our language to convey complex expressions in multiple ways and because the translator/language education in your universities is generally top notch.
Example: I heard that the witcher books got some international reward for "being superbly good translations" because they translated directly from Polish into Finnish. The end result is considered to be better than the English translations.
Musashi book might have got the same treatment.
>our language to convey complex expressions in multiple ways
Finnish is indeed literally the only language in the world able to convey a complex expression in more than one way.
This, just finished reading it and it was great.
Wait a second when did this finish? I put it on hold during the farming arc. Guess I'll reread it.
It did finish, not in manga form though. Inoue did a museum exhibit containing the ending as a series of portraits.
Good, but ending never ever
You're joking, right?
hiatus retard
can you please list the other favs on your list? both story and art wise.
No he is Fucking not newfagg, didnt you see his trips of truth nigga?
SSS Tier manga
Is this still being published? I stopped at potato farming Musashi long ago
SSS Tier manga which got axed
The farming arc was the best in the series and then it just 'ended'. At least I guess you can say it went out on a high point.
You can google what that user is referring to
Good shit, shame it'll never be complete village sage (Namek) killed it basically
Inoue's art will always be godtier
I love it but the fact that Musashi for literaly no reason remains an eternal virgin despite being in a quest of self discovery and introspection is full retarded.
Sex is essential to understand other and one's self.
The manga medium would be fucked if this was really the best it had to offer.
then what is better ? tell me