Attached: 1558795628.jpg (736x500, 90K)
The Great Debate
Andrew Howard
Cooper Baker
The right because I didn't drop it after chapter 1
Henry Brown
another thread to ignore and hide
Gavin Scott
No point of comparison. Both are different genres. Kaguya is a romcom, 5toubun is a harem. Any answer would be related to how much you prefer a genre over the other.
Lucas Turner
Josiah Johnson
Didn't read or watch either, what do I need to consume?
Joseph Sanders
Neither
Andrew Nguyen
Kaguya didn't have an arc as bad as Kyoto so there's that
Joshua Butler
Both are good manga. Kaguya had a good anime adaptation and 5toubun had nice VAs.
Brody Jenkins
Whoops wrong pic
Jackson Adams
>when someone carries the title of rage manga from SEO
Dominic Sanchez
Jace Gray
Toubun. Kaguya dropped hard after the kiss
Chase Price
Based.
Eli Murphy
Second post best post.
Noah Diaz
>Yea Forums still reads Redditguya
Carter James
both of them are extremely popular on reddit
Joshua Richardson
So you are allowed to like popular things if it is produced by 4channel?
Joseph White
What is this image supposed to prove?
Gabriel Wilson
Kaguya. 5toubun dropped hard in the Kyoto arc.
Easton Murphy
That Mangadex has bad taste.
Grayson Nguyen
>doesn't like harems
>bad taste
Levi Foster
the one that has chika
Eli Torres
Yuragi is better than both of them.
Hudson Kelly
>Chika
Zachary Torres
Before: Kaguya
Now: Quints
Everything after the confession in Kaguya has been flaming garbage. Only reason I'm reading it is sunk-cost fallacy at this point.
Benjamin Campbell
>Everything after the confession in Kaguya
so, 151? This week chapter is 150, user
Cameron Richardson
>completely generic harem vs not completely generic harem
wow what a tough choice
Owen Kelly
He's one of those idiots who thinks the manga should've ended at 136.
Lincoln Clark
Gonna go with kaguya.I think gotoubun peaked earlier and has both higher highs and lower lows.I also gotta give the mangaka credit for all the foreshadowing and callbacks he has made throughout the entire manga, even as early as the first chapter. Quite enjoyed the 7 goodbyes arc more than fireworks, election and festival in kaguya. However, the kyoto arc has left a pretty bad taste in my mouth.
In terms of main characters, kaguya is better developed than the quints while fuuts has had earlier development than prez did but prez has has some interesting parts about him in this latest arc. I find fuut a more interesting character and his subtle changes nice to see but prez can be fairly cool to view even if he was mostly the same character for 100 chapters.
Levi Peterson
Nobody cares about Kaguya anymore while 5toubun is the most talked about manga period.
Waifu war will always be more exciting.
Who > When always
Thomas Lewis
It should've, to be fair.
Owen Davis
kaguya. bought the physical copies. I'm fine with reading the quints on a tablet
Noah Phillips
It really should have. Kaguya is in the process of nisekoi-ing itself.
Thomas Rivera
>"I'll surely manage to force a fanbase war this time!"
Charles White
>left has Nino
>right has Hayasaka
Kind of a tough choice but I'll stick to left since Hayasaka gets way less panels in her manga while Nino gets a lot.
Liam Cook
>gives a shit about what reddit likes
fuck off, kiddo. let the adults post.
Grayson Wilson
If I judge the book by the cover, then the left one looks likes a comfy CGDCT manga while the right looks a NTR horror manga
Evan Brown
Take your trash manga out of here.
Connor Brown
>rental prostitutes
Chase Scott
Kaguya has a 'Who" though with Ishigami
Josiah Lopez
>Everything after the confession in Kaguya has been flaming garbage. Only reason I'm reading it is sunk-cost fallacy at this point.
It's the JUMP effect. It happened to Nisekoi before, and now it's happening to Kaguya and Bokuben.
Jonathan Phillips
redditchika. she is only popular because of the reddit dance
Easton Smith
calling fujiwara "chika" should be a punishable offense. same goes for calling that ED "the chika dance".
Owen Edwards
Based
Tyler Howard
As someone who read both, I actually dropped Kaguya despite having a great comedy only because I dislike Iino.
Luis Cooper
Both of their latest arc sucks dick
Hudson Jones
>shounen vs seinen
The choice is clear unless you're horny teenager.
Also comparing Kaguya to a shitty generic harem is insulting.
Kevin Scott
>I dislike Iino
you should have been dropped as a child instead
Isaiah Wright
Get a load of this reddit
Owen Hall
>a NTR horror manga
Not too far from the truth.
Thomas Brown
Kaguya just feels pointless and the author doesn't know where to go with the story meanwhile toubun is as exciting as ever, also it seems more popular and less likely to get axed.
Jacob Hernandez
t. virgin teenager
Sebastian Perry
Wow, I assume you're a fan of Miko Iino?
Logan Barnes
Based on MAL:
Kaguya manga: 8.85
Kaguya anime: 8.51
Tobun manga: 8.31
Tobun anime: 7.65
So Kaguya win
Nicholas Price
There's no debate you stupid toubunnigger.
5toubun is inferior in both quality and sales.
Ethan Barnes
You have this completely backwards
Jaxon Clark
Fuck off MALfag. I like kaguya more but using MAL is as low as you can get.
Jason Gutierrez
makes me seethe with rage
every single fucking character is a cunt or retarded or both
worst MC and heroine
just absolute trash
Owen Brown
>trying to fit in
Cameron Baker
Ahhh it's a cool thread.
Colton Jenkins
Toubun wins because there are literally no filler chapters unlike Stallguya
Dominic Walker
Tobun is a harem it loose by default unless you're a virgin that like 2d girls more than 3d ones.
Kevin Moore
Quintuplets is enjoyable, but it's pretty generic at the end of the day. Aka's sense of humour really makes Kaguya shine.
Benjamin Rivera
Scrambled eggs was mostly filler, all that development for Miku only for her to regress back to bumbling mess in Kyoto
Adam Green
Toubuen is a lot of prostitutes without ideals that lick one man.
Angel Morgan
Fuck off
Jordan Gray
>MyAnusList scores
Charles Butler
She is shit. Most uninteresting girl in the entire manga with Tsubame a close second.
Isaac Cooper
Josiah Scott
where is the debate in this? they're completely different unless your only basis is they're both extremely popular for whatever reason
Dominic Moore
Yes it is trash, but conflict manga is unique, rare. not cliche like these two pictures of threads.
Jackson Harris
KINOKARI = HxH OF ROMCOM
Gavin Martinez
This.
Lucas Gutierrez
Stop turning this into a fanbase war thread, what the fuck
Matthew Nguyen
It's literally the purpose of these threads: to take two barely related manga and therefore forcing the discussion into a fanbase war.
There is literally no logical reason why they shouldn't be banned on sight.
Carson Bennett
No one will take such a shitty bait no matter how hard you try so quit wastibg your time.
Jace Long
OK
Matthew Morgan
This thread is also licking bait
David Cooper
Elijah Sanchez
Yeah but it's a good one at least.
Andrew Walker
don't be here, you will be destroyed by their hypocritical bait
Noah Wilson
what a shit thread