It says a lot about the anime community that this piece of dishonest animation is seen as something to be praised...

anime in general is an insult to the viewer

all while knowing that other fat fucks all around the world will be imitating it on their basements

Are you implying this is rotoscoping? Because I don't believe it is. This looks like a 3d model which they paired with the movements of a live action dancer (motion tracking suit). Which is very much different.

Regardless this is obviously adorable and OP is just a salty neckbeard.

Attached: fq84nn4jwt031.png (960x540, 719K)

Sorry but you don't get to use that picture

Pretty sure the studio said it was fully hand drawn.

Imagine being angry at an ED for no reason.

It's so sad. This animator can reference, can trace and knows how to draw on-model, but they couldn't manage to put it all together. Perhaps the missing skill is knowledge of animation fundamentals, idk

>3d shit

First they came for the mecha, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a mechafag

Then they came for the fx and explosions, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a sakugafag

Then they came for moegirls and there was no one left to speak for them

this 3d shit is cancer

Attached: 1501202306812.png (276x186, 89K)

>anime
>community

What's more insulting is the forgotten in 3 months anime that it came from.

>hating on rotoscoping
faggot

>animation shitter can't even tell the difference between CGI and non-CGI

>Rotoscoping is evil
youtube.com/watch?v=bYCk2udVFvo

Attached: 1545948151150.gif (500x357, 358K)

They are liars then, the hair physics outs it as a cgi model.

Listen, we had to deal with these dumbass threads daily for a month when that show came out and we don't need more

Attached: 1554270069394.jpg (844x840, 68K)

Disgusting, if Miyazaki saw this he would kill himself

B-but user. You're talentless

Attached: 161d215517d8f30afef8d4f633156601.png (702x543, 339K)

Kill yourself

>you have to be able to cook to tell a dish taste like shit

why do you argue like a child?

kek

Yeah, I agree. Maybe aspects were hand drawn or it's a blend, but it's still almost definitely computer aided drawing/cgi modelling. All animation is at this point. It's not like they had someone cell drawing over frames of a film.
It's super fluid and looks great but this isn't Marry Poppins.

Attached: ivl1yf1d3yz21.jpg (640x1138, 127K)

You can be "computer aided" (rotoscoping would be these days) while still being hand drawn.

>Dishonest
Yes, the word that never fails to expose retards that think it's actual criticism and not some forced buzzword

>Gee guys we'll made it as real as possible
>that forced and unrealistic upskirt at 29-30

Ah Japan

>dishonest animation
yet another retarded term Yea Forums invented.

Japs have a different take on rotoscoping, taking the captured footage and using it as a base still counts as rotoscoping.

>This bait still works after the 6th/7th time

Attached: paris-tuileries-garden-facepalm-statue_v2ay.jpg (1024x683, 102K)

Will the term prove to be a time flop?

Why would you need to model CG hair on top of a real performer when the performer's hair already moves 100% realistically?

>almost definitely computer aided drawing/cgi modelling. All animation is at this point.
Most animation in the anime industry is done on paper. In this case they must have used tablets, but that's the best way to rotoscope today. It's not really different from doing it without computers though. You're still just tracing over frames.

If you draw over the frames, it's rotoscoping. Otherwise it's reference.

How's your first month on Yea Forums?

Attached: 1549306762403.jpg (2208x1242, 347K)

I'm just replying ironically

Keep posting it, I'm starting to like it.

Why would people spend time and energy to animate terrible "dancing" like this? This is on the level of that Elaine dance from Seinfeld

>Why would people spend time and energy to animate terrible "dancing" like this?
Why wouldn't they? Why does this ED trigger people so badly?

They adjusted the model position frame-by-frame using the performer video as reference

>dishonest animation
What a dishonest buzzword

Nah, it's praiseworthy for being one of the only good uses of rotoscoping in moe anime history.

>Why does this ED trigger people so badly?
It disrespects the audience

What would be the point of that?

the asian obsession with this kind of old ass dancing is so fucking embarrassing

How?

To make it look more organic

I could tel it was a womanlet because of the short forearms and low knees.

More organic than the real hair of the performer?

By using pretentious cuteness

>dishonest animation
Oh I get it
You mean that it's so good that makes the others series ED looks like shit?
Well, it's the best ending of the year, so there is nothing that can be done

What is pretentious cuteness and how does it manifest in this ED?

It looks good, but it's also rotoscoped.

this style of dance is so awkward. it's like a robot or an alien trying to fit in with humans by dancing but getting it completely wrong

more organic than average cgi

i think the fact that Yea Forums can't talk about anime without falling back on retarded buzzwords like forced animation, native isekai, and time flop tells you a lot more about how braindead the anime community is than anything else

Again, what is the point when the real hair is already there?

>Yea Forums
>anime community
This is more like the mental asylum where the rejects try to form coherent thoughts by mixing words together

don't forget the new "subvert your expectations"

Is not there though.

>rotoscoping
It isn't.

r/anime is unironically the best anime community. That doesn't make it great, it just makes it not as bad as the competition. The thing that pushes Yea Forums over the edge and into the abyss of diarrhea is that the more negative you are, the cooler you are.

>definitions don't change by the country
It's rotoscope.

>Though the execution is nearly flawless, we have to start by thanking choreographer Nagisa Sugao. Not only did she come up with a fun dance full of love for the series, she even acted it out herself, wearing a replica of the school’s uniform and a Chika wig to provide the best reference material possible. Now that’s dedication.

blog.sakugabooru.com/2019/02/12/kaguya-sama-love-is-war-production-notes-01-05/

Do you have some other source saying that they 3D modeled her hair (and at least part of her body since the hair has to interact with it)?

What are you talking about? All I said was that rotoscoping means drawing over the frames, and that in other cases it's referencing. Which is true.

The whole thing is modeled, not just the hair.

Source?

>implying ping pong isn't a fucking masterpiece

>took the 3d video
>use it's frames as a base for their animation
It's dishonest rotoscope.

I disliked it first and foremost because this type of realism in movements does not fit the artstyle and it looks goddamn awful. It feels uncanny valley

>people are still shitposting with this webm I made
Wew

What 3D video? You have no source for any 3D video. And the only way they would be able to make 3D animation look that natural is if they used motion capture... in which case, why would they bother doing the 3D animation in the first place when they can rotoscope or reference the original footage directly?

Rotoscoping may be dishonest when you don't know it's rotoscoping, but rotoscoping sticks out in anime.

Didn't your computer explode due to that shameless display of maladé motion

I've heard those buzzwords used here so many times, and I still can't figure out what they mean.

On the topic of the 3d video, does anyone have the footage of the performer THAT it's said, was rotoscoped?

because the physics look rather different when actual persons dance it

youtube.com/watch?v=-ll7DKLXyEY

>dishonest animation
Congratulations, you've found a thing to complain about even dumber than "forced animation". What the fuck is your problem? "I only want 'honest' animation that wasn't produced using any kind of reference"? You're a fucking moron. There's very little art-wise that doesn't use some kind of reference in its creation.

Rotoscoping doesn't have to be 1:1, they can make changes. They also key framed and then in-betweened it like normal.

here's the quick rundown
>forced animation
animation that looks way too good compared to anything else that came out of the same series
>native isekai
an anime with a fantasy setting
>time flop
shitposter speak for a show that nobody remembers anymore, which is basically 90% of anything to come out of a given season

It doesn't look like skipped frames or small tweaks though

Maybe art is dishonest on itself

bruuuuuuuhh xd

Were you in a coma for months, user-kun?

I-is that why you're being so retarded?

Attached: 1557360244166.png (593x696, 316K)

I don't think so. Art is supposed to represent reality to some degree, so using reality as inspiration is entirely reasonable. If anything can be said to be dishonest about it, it's when art glosses over or downplays the negative aspects of things.

Anonymous never forgets

>put cute extra in the credits because you can
>overseas faggots who watch pirated episodes complain about it
If I ever made an anime I would never listen to Yea Forums's opinion for anything.

In general, it's best to ignore Yea Forums's opinions on everything anyway.

Why in the hell are you in this board then?

is not that common sense?

Maybe he has a thing for getting ignored

If I'm an animator I'd be rolling my eyes at my boss telling me to animate this disaster of a choreography.

For the images and what scraps of information and decent discussion there is to be found. In spite of everything, there is actually some value to this board. And honestly, most of what you need to filter out is just at and near the extremes of "this is unredeemable shit that no-one should like" and "this is awesomely perfect and if you don't like it you're an idiot".

Yeah, but common sense isn't that common.

It's not meant to be Michael Jackson. Why are you taking this so seriously?

The anime community is a shitty because it consists of a lot of trannies and faggots.

Attached: [Mushin] Hajimete no Gal - 11 [OVA] My first school festival (BD 1280x720 x264 AAC).mkv_snapshot_09. (636x720, 616K)

How is this dishonest?

Attached: 1549018270627.webm (850x480, 2.82M)

Please don't mind me, I only opened this thread to have a laugh at your expense.

B-but it's a 3D model! A rotoscoped 3D model!